Arizona Condo Governance | Open Meetings | Direct Claims
This page organizes the uploaded Superior Court record in Marx v. Tara, including the June 2025 preliminary-injunction and derivative-claim rulings and Tara’s May 2026 motion over whether later claims are direct or derivative.
Last updated May 31, 2026. Case: Lisa Marx v. Tara Condominiums Association, Inc., Maricopa County Superior Court No. CV2025-012980; Hon. Randall H. Warner and Hon. Adele Ponce.
Posture note: This is a pending Superior Court record guide, not a final merits summary. The uploaded packet includes important interim rulings, but it does not include a final judgment resolving every claim.
The posture in one sentence
Marx v. Tara is a pending Arizona condominium governance case where the central practical question is whether alleged open-meeting, records, insurance, voting, and declaration violations are enforceable as a member’s direct rights or must be handled as derivative association claims.
Case snapshot
A Tara condominium owner alleges the association acted without proper board votes, notice, records access, statutory compliance, and member approval.
The court denied a preliminary injunction, denied Tara’s first derivative-claim dismissal motion against the association, and dismissed individual board members.
Tara’s May 27, 2026 Rule 12(c) motion renews the derivative-claim issue after newer appellate authority; the public court-source packet does not include a filed opposition.
The public source set preserves 163 uploaded PDFs; the generated index deduplicates them to 159 public PDF entries plus a normalized filing roadmap.
What the record shows
The Second Amended Complaint frames the case as breach of contract, Arizona Condominium Act, corporate-records, and declaratory-judgment claims against Tara Condominiums Association. Marx alleges that board actions were taken without proper notice, agenda, discussion, vote, or approval and that she was denied statutory inspection rights.
The early motion practice produced several important but limited rulings. The court denied preliminary injunctive relief in June 2025 because the record did not show irreparable harm requiring immediate intervention, even while noting that some board actions allegedly should have been voted on in an open meeting.
The court then denied Tara’s first partial motion to dismiss claims as derivative, treating the claims against the association as attempts to enforce Marx’s own membership rights under the declaration, bylaws, and law. A later ruling dismissed individual board members Mark Gottmann and Dennis Anderson from the case.
What the court has already done
The June 2025 preliminary-injunction ruling did not give emergency relief on insurance, meeting, or records issues because the court did not find irreparable harm on that record.
The June 26, 2025 minute entry denied Tara’s first partial motion to dismiss, explaining that member-right claims against the association were not derivative as framed.
The July 31, 2025 ruling dismissed Mark Gottmann and Dennis Anderson, distinguishing association obligations from personal liability claims against board members.
Tara’s May 2026 Rule 12(c) motion asks the court to revisit parts of the direct-versus-derivative dispute after Iqtunheimr and related appellate authority.
The May 2026 direct-versus-derivative motion
Tara’s May 27, 2026 motion for judgment on the pleadings argues that community-wide claims over common property, association funds, insurance, and governance belong to the association and must satisfy derivative-action requirements.
The public source packet does not include a filed response to that motion. This page therefore treats Tara’s motion as pending rather than presenting an unfiled draft as a court source.
Because the uploaded public court-source record stops with Tara’s motion, this page does not treat the May 2026 arguments as decided. The next important update would be a filed response, the court’s ruling on the Rule 12(c) motion, or any final judgment.
Timeline highlights
| Date | Event | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| April 2025 | Original complaint packet begins the CV2025-012980 record. | The initial claims focused heavily on open meetings, board authority, records, committee action, and association governance. |
| June 23, 2025 | The court held an evidentiary hearing on preliminary injunctive relief. | The hearing created the record for the June 2025 emergency-relief ruling. |
| June 25, 2025 | The court denied the motion for preliminary injunction. | The ruling matters because it separates alleged procedural defects from the emergency showing needed for immediate injunctive relief. |
| June 26, 2025 | The court denied Tara’s partial motion to dismiss association claims as derivative. | This is the key early ruling treating the claims against the association as member-right claims rather than derivative claims, at least for that motion. |
| July 31, 2025 | The court dismissed Mark Gottmann and Dennis Anderson. | The ruling draws a line between claims against the association and personal liability theories against individual directors. |
| October 2025 | The record includes emergency TRO filings over master insurance, amendments, and owner insurance obligations. | The case expanded from meeting and records issues into insurance/amendment governance disputes. |
| March 2026 | The uploaded record indicates related insurance/amendment litigation was treated as a supplemental pleading in this case. | That procedural move matters because later Rule 12(c) briefing addresses both the original and supplemental dispute. |
| May 27, 2026 | Tara filed a motion for judgment on the pleadings. | The motion asks the court to treat many community-wide claims as derivative after newer Arizona appellate authority. |
Curated document roadmap
After comparing the page against the AI-agent CSV, the missing piece was not the raw source coverage; it was a document-by-document narrative roadmap. The generated source index below already lists the public files, but the table here preserves the CSV’s chronology, document type, and stated case relevance so readers can understand how each filed or public-source item fits into the dispute.
This roadmap intentionally excludes unfiled draft materials that have not been confirmed as part of the court record.
The source-reference numbers in the final column are the CSV’s own reference numbers. They are not separate legal findings by this site, and the underlying PDFs remain the controlling source record.
Document roadmap from uploaded AI CSV
| Date | Document | Type | How it fits the case | CSV refs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| February 19, 1970 | Declaration of Restrictions, Establishment of Board of Management and Lien Rights | CC&Rs | Foundational governing document defining common elements, board authority, maintenance, lien, and insurance duties. Marx uses it as the contract source for alleged breaches involving board authority, maintenance, and building-structure insurance. | 1-7 |
| March 29, 2022 | CC&R Amendment Update from the Arizona Supreme Court – CHDB Law | Article / news | Kalway-related legal analysis used by Marx to argue that the 2025 insurance amendments were not reasonable or foreseeable enough to bind owners. | 8 |
| July 31, 2023 | Homeowner Tara COA July 2023 Financials | Financial statement | Historical association financial record used as a comparison point for later disputed budget, insurance, and expense decisions. | 7 |
| January 11, 2024 | Organizational Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Board organizational minutes. Marx cites them to show board-position decisions, knowledge of meeting requirements, and alleged inaccuracies about leadership and procedure. | 9, 10 |
| January 20, 2024 | January 20, 2024 Board Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Documents committee-volunteer discussion and the Landscaping Committee, which Marx later uses to challenge the committee’s dissolution and her removal. | 7, 9 |
| January 30, 2024 | Trench on Newcastle done by Mark and Dennis | Evidence / report | Maintenance-work documentation used to support claims that individual board members acted unilaterally or performed unauthorized maintenance work. | 7 |
| February 1, 2024 | Email removing Lisa from committees and dissolving them | Evidence that Marx was removed from the Landscaping Committee and committees were dissolved, supporting alleged open-meeting violations and selective targeting. | 7, 10 | |
| February 5, 2024 | Email announcing new board member | Announcement of a new board member without a recorded open board vote, supporting the A.R.S. § 33-1248 board-action theory. | 7, 11 | |
| February 5, 2024 | Gmail – Claim Message from USAA – 13601 N Newcastle Drive | Insurance-claim correspondence used to support allegations about improper insurance handling and board-member maintenance involvement. | 7 | |
| February 17, 2024 | February 17, 2024 Board Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Minutes reflecting discussion and speaking limits. Marx alleges those rules were used selectively and that board-membership status was misdocumented. | 7, 9 |
| March 16, 2024 | March 16, 2024 Board Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Minutes referencing a workers-comp policy and Bermuda-grass plan, cited as examples of alleged unilateral chair action without open meeting votes. | 7, 9 |
| March 17, 2024 | Spring newsletter 3-17-24 | Newsletter | Association communication to residents, used as evidence of public board statements and owner-facing messaging. | 7 |
| May 27, 2024 | Dennis working on the shutters | Evidence / report | Documentation of Dennis Anderson performing maintenance work, supporting allegations that board members acted outside authorized roles. | 7 |
| June 15, 2024 | June 15, 2024 Tara Board Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Procedural record of board actions during summer 2024. | 7 |
| July 2, 2024 | DAnderson 07 02 24 Expense Voucher | Expense voucher | Financial record used to test whether board-member reimbursement and expenditures were properly authorized. | 7 |
| July 16, 2024 | 07 16 24 Letter to Lisa Marx re Petition Response | Letter | Association correspondence to Marx about a petition, part of the pre-litigation governance-dispute history. | 7 |
| July 23, 2024 | American Family Master Insurance Policy Invoice Voucher 2024 2025 | Financial document | Shows prior master-insurance cost and coverage before the disputed 2025 insurance amendments and policy changes. | 7 |
| July 27, 2024 | July 27 2024 Tara Board Meeting Minutes | Meeting minutes | Procedural record of board actions and decisions. | 7 |
| July 31, 2024 | Travis Law Firm July Inv Voucher | Invoice voucher | Legal-fee invoice used to support claims about association legal spending and approval procedure. | 7 |
| August 29, 2024 | Travis Law Firm August 2024 Invoice Voucher | Invoice voucher | Additional legal-fee record used in the unauthorized-expenditure and approval-procedure theory. | 7 |
| November 1, 2024 | 2025 Tara Condominiums Budget Letter | Budget letter | Board letter recommending a $50 assessment increase due to insurance, sewer, and legal-fee increases; part of the financial buildup to the insurance dispute. | 12 |
| November 3, 2024 | Issues regarding the 2025 Budget Vote | Marx email arguing that the budget-vote process violated statute, used to show an earlier voting-procedure objection. | 13 | |
| April 11, 2025 | Civil Complaint for Breach of Contract | Complaint | Original filing against the association and individual board members, opening the litigation and asserting governance and CC&R breach theories. | 14-16 |
| April 14, 2025 | Minute Entry Denying TRO | Court order | Early ruling denying temporary restraining relief because emergency TRO requirements were not met. | 17 |
| April 16, 2025 | Amended Emergency Orders: TRO and Temporary Injunctive Relief | Motion for injunctive relief | Request to preserve declaration and insurance status quo while the case proceeded. | 18, 19 |
| May 28, 2025 | Association’s Partial Motion to Dismiss | Motion | Association argued many claims were derivative and Marx lacked individual standing to pursue community-wide harms. | 20 |
| June 4, 2025 | Responsive Memorandum to Association’s Partial Motion to Dismiss | Responsive memorandum | Marx opposed dismissal by arguing the claims asserted direct individual harms and member-right violations. | 14-16 |
| June 6, 2025 | Reply to Response to Request for TRO and Injunctive Relief | Reply memorandum | Reply supporting emergency relief and addressing alleged service-delay and response-timing issues. | 18 |
| June 26, 2025 | Minute Entry – Claim not Derivative | Court order | Key early ruling treating Marx’s claims against the association as direct member-right claims rather than derivative claims for that motion. | 21, 22 |
| July 15, 2025 | Motion to Dismiss Defendants Mark Gottmann and Dennis Anderson | Motion | Individual board members sought dismissal based on director protections and lack of personal liability. | 23 |
| July 20, 2025 | Response Memorandum to Motion to Dismiss Individual Defendants | Responsive memorandum | Marx opposed dismissal by arguing Gottmann and Anderson acted in bad faith and outside their authority. | 14, 24, 25 |
| July 25, 2025 | Minute entry order to file amended complaint | Court order | Order requiring a more definite statement, leading to amended pleadings. | 26 |
| July 31, 2025 | Ruling dismissing Mark and Dennis | Court order | Dismissed individual defendants, creating a major procedural setback for the personal-liability claims. | 27, 28 |
| August 6, 2025 | Travis Law Firm Budget Letter / Proposing Amendments | Budget letter / letter | Counsel letter explaining proposed amendments to shift insurance responsibilities to owners, initiating the core insurance-amendment dispute. | 4-6, 29-31 |
| August 10, 2025 | Motion for Partial Reconsideration of July 31, 2025 Ruling | Motion | Marx sought reconsideration of the dismissal of the individual board members. | 32 |
| August 11, 2025 | Exhibit N Cert of Ins for 25 26 | Certificate of liability insurance | Insurance certificate showing property coverage effective August 1, 2025 to August 1, 2026, used to contrast later claimed coverage changes. | 6, 33 |
| August 12, 2025 | Order Denying Motion for reconsideration | Court order | Maintained dismissal of Gottmann and Anderson. | 34 |
| August 15, 2025 | First Amended Complaint (FAC) | Amended complaint | Updated pleading reasserting claims and refining the legal counts against the association and directors. | 2, 14 |
| September 6, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Initial Rule 26.1 Disclosure Statement | Discovery disclosure | Mandatory disclosure identifying factual bases, witnesses, and evidence Marx expected to use. | 35, 36 |
| September 11, 2025 | Stipulation for Extension of Time | Legal stipulation | Agreement extending Marx’s deadline to respond to fee applications; later relevant to arguments about premature fee rulings. | 28, 37 |
| September 15, 2025 | Order Denying Motion to Strike Reply | Court order | Denied Marx’s request to strike Tara’s reply regarding the amended complaint. | 38 |
| September 15, 2025 | Second Amended Complaint (SAC) | Amended complaint | Operative complaint against the association after dismissal of the individual defendants. | 28, 39-41 |
| September 15, 2025 | Order on Stipulation to Extend Time | Court order | Granted an extension to respond to attorney-fee requests. | 42 |
| September 20, 2025 | Minutes for a Board Meeting of the Tara Condominiums Association | Meeting minutes | Board minutes covering approval of the plan to present CC&R amendments for owner vote. | 43 |
| September 22, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to File Third Amended Complaint | Motion | Marx sought to reinstate direct claims against individual board members and add alleged post-filing violations. | 14, 44, 45 |
| September 24, 2025 | Urgent Concerns on Proposed CC&R Amendments | Email / letter | Marx letter to owners identifying claimed risks of the proposed amendments, including costs, title, loan, and insurance issues. | 4, 46 |
| September 25, 2025 | Meeting needs to be called to turn in ballots | Marx demanded an open meeting for the amendment vote, preserving her objection to the voting process. | 6, 47 | |
| September 27, 2025 | Proposed Insurance amendments (Board/Owner Emails) | Correspondence framing the association’s justification for the insurance shift and Marx’s objections under statutory and declaration duties. | 5, 6, 30, 48 | |
| September 30, 2025 | Minute Entry Denying Motion to Vacate | Court order | Denied Marx’s request to vacate a fee-related order before the fee award was entered. | 49 |
| October 1, 2025 | Order Granting Application for Attorney’s Fees | Court order | Awarded individual defendants $5,957.70 in fees after dismissal; Marx contends the award was premature. | 28, 49, 50 |
| October 5, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary and Permanent Injunction | Motion | Attempt to block implementation of proposed amendments based on alleged statutory and declaration violations. | 6, 51 |
| October 9, 2025 | Motion for Expedited Hearing | Motion | Request for a hearing within five days before the amendment-vote deadline. | 31, 52, 53 |
| October 14, 2025 | Scheduling Order | Court order | Set discovery tiers, litigation deadlines, and a September 14, 2026 trial date. | 54 |
| October 15, 2025 | Action by Written Consent | Voting form | Owner written-consent form used for three proposed declaration amendments. | 55 |
| October 17, 2025 | Amendment to Declaration of Restrictions | Recorded amendment | Recorded amendment No. 2025-0605584 shifting insurance responsibility to owners; Marx challenges its validity. | 31, 56, 57 |
| October 18, 2025 | Results of Tara CC&R amendment vote | Announcement that amendments passed and owners had to obtain insurance by November 15, 2025. | 58, 59 | |
| October 22, 2025 | Stipulation to Continue Case Deadlines | Legal stipulation | Joint extension of deadlines due to Marx’s medical hospitalization. | 60 |
| October 26, 2025 | Meeting to view ballots (Transcript) | Transcript | Transcript in which Gottmann allegedly refused to show owner signatures or vote choices, supporting A.R.S. § 33-1258 inspection-right claims. | 61, 62 |
| October 29, 2025 | Emergency Motion for Temporary Restraining Order | Motion | Emergency request to stop cancellation of master insurance and implementation of recorded amendments. | 31, 63 |
| October 30, 2025 | 2025 Budget | Financial document | Association budget showing a $50 assessment increase for insurance premiums, part of the financial basis for the amendment dispute. | 64 |
| October 30, 2025 | Order Granting Leave to File Reply Out of Time | Court order | Procedural relief allowing Marx to file a late reply related to the third amended complaint. | 65 |
| November 6, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Amended Motion to Set Evidentiary Hearing | Motion | Request for an evidentiary hearing on the voting process and alleged harm from insurance lapse. | 66, 67 |
| November 10, 2025 | Reminder to obtain homeowner insurance | Board email setting a December 1, 2025 proof-of-structural-insurance deadline. | 68 | |
| November 12, 2025 | Notice of Appeal | Legal notice | Notice concerning dismissal of individual defendants and cost/fee issues. | 69, 70 |
| November 13, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Reply to Defendant’s Consolidated Response | Motion / reply | Reply supporting preliminary-injunction relief based on claimed individualized harm and flawed amendment process. | 71 |
| November 17, 2025 | Minute Entry (Dismissing TAC and Injunction) | Court order | Denied leave to file the Third Amended Complaint and denied injunction relief, prompting later judge-change efforts. | 70, 72 |
| November 21, 2025 | Official Ballot 2026 Budget Ratification | Ballot | Budget ballot showing a proposed $15 assessment decrease after removing association insurance duties. | 73, 74 |
| November 21, 2025 | Civil Complaint for Declaratory Judgment | Complaint | New action CV2025-062973 challenging the October 2025 amendments and potential master-policy cancellation. | 75 |
| November 23, 2025 | Motion for Change of Judge for Cause | Motion | Marx sought to remove Judge Warner, leading to reassignment to Judge Adele Ponce. | 72, 76 |
| November 24, 2025 | Request for Answers to Interrogatories | Discovery request | Interrogatories targeting board decisions and maintenance work to develop the ultra vires theory. | 11 |
| November 25, 2025 | Case Reassignment / First Amended Civil Complaint | Court order / complaint | Case reassignment to Judge Ponce and amended pleading in the second insurance-shift action. | 70, 75, 77-79 |
| December 1, 2025 | Motion for Reconsideration of Nov 17 Minute Entry | Motion | Marx asked Judge Ponce to reconsider denial of the third amended complaint and injunction relief. | 70, 80 |
| December 3, 2025 | Minute Entry Case Consolidation | Court order | Consolidated CV2025-062973 with CV2025-012980, folding the insurance-amendment dispute into the main litigation path. | 81 |
| December 3, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Motion for Reconsideration of Consolidation | Motion | Marx opposed consolidation, arguing the actions involved distinct facts and emergency concerns. | 82 |
| December 4, 2025 | Plaintiff’s Motion for Clarification and Expedited Hearing | Motion | Challenge to characterization of the complaint and request for expedited hearing on insurance risk. | 75 |
| December 5, 2025 | Joint Notice of Outstanding Motions and Hearings | Legal notice | Catalog of pending matters for Judge Ponce after reassignment. | 70 |
| January 4, 2026 | Plaintiff’s Response in Opposition to Motion to Dismiss | Response memorandum | Opposition to dismissal of the second action, arguing insurance termination was a new occurrence requiring separate attention. | 19 |
| January 20, 2026 | Certificate of Liability Insurance (Master Policy 2025-2026) | Insurance certificate | Certificate showing liability and D&O coverage but no building property insurance, used as key evidence that buildings became uninsured. | 83, 84 |
| January 20, 2026 | Notice of Intent to Serve Amended Subpoena | Discovery notice | Notice for records subpoena to Colby Management, part of the discovery fight over association records. | 85 |
| January 30, 2026 | Supplemental Memorandum in Support of Reconsideration | Legal memorandum | Filing using the January 20 insurance certificate as new evidence of claimed statutory insurance violations. | 83 |
| February 26, 2026 | Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Compel | Legal notice | Procedural withdrawal of a discovery motion. | 86 |
| March 16, 2026 | Minute Entry (Oral Argument and Rule 15d conversion) | Court order | Converted the second lawsuit into a Rule 15(d) supplemental-pleading path in the main case. | 41, 87 |
| May 27, 2026 | Defendant’s Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings | Motion | Tara’s attempt to dismiss asserted community-wide claims as derivative after newer appellate authority. | 88 |
| Not dated in CSV | Plaintiff’s First Requests for Production of Documents | Discovery request | Formal request for insurance, financial, and related records, aimed at evidence about the 2024 insurance claim and policy-rate increases. | 90 |
| September 10, 2020 | Marx Warranty Deed | Deed | Warranty deed conveying Unit 5 to Lisa Marx, establishing her standing as unit owner and association member. | 2, 91, 92 |
How to read this case without overclaiming it
- Treat interim rulings as interim rulings. The June and July 2025 orders are important, but they do not equal a final merits judgment on every later claim.
- Separate association claims from individual-director claims. The uploaded record shows the court was willing to let some claims proceed against the association while dismissing individual board members.
- Track the exact injury theory. The direct-versus-derivative question turns on whether the claim seeks to remedy a member’s individual statutory/contractual injury or a generalized association injury.
- Do not skip the procedural posture. Preliminary injunction, motion to dismiss, judgment on the pleadings, and final judgment apply different standards.
- Use the source index. The upload is large. The normalized roadmap and complete source-document index are the safest way to follow the record in order.
Practical lessons for condo disputes
- Tie each claim to the specific statute, declaration section, bylaw, vote, notice, record request, or personal harm.
- Preserve agendas, minutes, emails, insurance notices, amendment materials, ballots, and records-request correspondence.
- Do not assume that proving a board process defect automatically proves irreparable harm.
- Keep direct personal injury theories separate from generalized association harm.
- Document board authorization, open-meeting votes, executive-session limits, and ratification steps.
- Handle records requests with clear statutory deadlines, production logs, and written explanations.
- Treat insurance and amendment changes as high-risk governance events requiring clean notices, votes, and member communications.
- Do not rely on derivative-action arguments without addressing member-right statutes and declaration enforcement language.
Complete source set
Download the filing roadmap
The source files were normalized into the standard court-case download layout. Use the roadmap CSV to cross-check original filenames against public filenames, then use the generated source-document index below for direct downloads.
FAQ
Is this case finally decided?
No. The uploaded packet includes important interim rulings and May 2026 briefing, but it does not include a final judgment resolving the full case.
Did the court say all of Marx’s claims are direct claims?
No. The June 26, 2025 minute entry denied Tara’s first partial derivative-claims motion as to the association and described the claims as member-right claims as framed. Later May 2026 briefing asks the court to revisit direct-versus-derivative treatment for asserted community-wide claims.
Were the individual board members kept in the case?
No. The uploaded July 31, 2025 ruling dismissed Mark Gottmann and Dennis Anderson, while distinguishing those personal-liability theories from claims against the association.
Why does insurance appear in an open-meeting case?
The record expanded beyond early open-meeting and records allegations. Later filings challenged master-insurance changes, declaration amendments, owner insurance obligations, and related voting/notice procedures.
What should be added next?
The next high-value update would be the court’s ruling on Tara’s May 27, 2026 motion for judgment on the pleadings, any hearing minute entry, final judgment, or appeal docket.
Complete uploaded source-document index
This index is generated from every public-facing source file currently present in assets/court_case_downloads/lisa-marx-v-tara-condominium-association-cv2025-012980/raw/: 159 PDFs, 1 supporting review/media file. Files are ordered by the date/sequence embedded in the normalized filename; AI-generated review materials are labeled separately and should not be treated as court filings.
1 Minute Entry 4 14 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
1 2025 05 28 Partial Mtd Plaintiffs Derivative Claims 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
2 Minute Entry 6 23 25 From Court Hearing Same Date
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
3 6 25 25 Minute Entry Denying The Motion For Preliminary Injunction
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
4 Minute Entry 6 26 25 Claim Not Derivative
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
Responsive Memo 7 18 25
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
5 Minute Entry 7 25 25 Order To File Amended Complaint
Type: Court order/minute entry
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
6 Ruling 7 31 25 Dismissing Mark And Dennis
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
7 Order 8 12 25 Denying Motion For Reconsideration Filed The 14 Th
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Affidavit In Support Of Attorneys Fees 9 4 25
Type: Procedural/service filing
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Application For Attorneys Fees 9 4 25
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Statement Of Costs 9 4 25
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
9 Order 9 10 25 To File Amended Complaint
Type: Court order/minute entry
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
10 Order 9 15 25 Denying Motion To Strike Reply In Support Of Motion To Strike Portions Of Amended Complaint
Type: Court order/minute entry
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
11 Order 9 15 25 On Stipulation To Extend Time To File Response For Attorneys Fees
Type: Court order/minute entry
Opposing or responsive paper; compare it to the motion or request filed immediately before it.
1 Exhibit I 9 20 25 Minutes
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit U Ltr To Bd 9 27 25
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
12 Order Granting Defendants Application For Attorneys Fees 10 1 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
13 Minute Entry 10 2 2025 Vacated 10 7 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
4 Ex F Email 10 5 25 From Lisa Marx To View Voting Materials
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex F Email 10 5 25 From Lisa Marx To View Voting Materials
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
14 Minute Entry Ruling 10 7 25 Vacating The September 30 2025 Minute Entry Filed October 2 2025
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
2 Request For Expedited Hearing 10 9 25
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
26 Request For Expedited Hearing 10 9 25
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Joint Report 10 10 25 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Case-management filing; it tells the court how the parties propose to schedule and manage the case.
15 10 14 25 Adr Referral
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
16 Minute Entry 10 15 25 Regarding Attorneys Fees And Costs
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
19 Scheduling Order 10 15 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Sets or changes case deadlines, hearing dates, disclosure dates, or other procedural milestones.
17 Minute Entry Order 10 16 25 Docketed 10 17 25 Correcting Adr Referral
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
4 Ex D Amendment Change 10 17 25 Recorded
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex D Amendment Change 10 17 25 Recorded
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
4 Ex A Email 10 18 25 Announcing Amendment Vote Tally
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex A Email 10 18 25 Announcing Amendment Vote Tally
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
4 Ex B Email From Mark 10 22 25 To Review Voting Materials
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
27 2025 10 22 Proposed Order Extending Case Deadlines
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
27 2025 10 22 Stipulation To Continue Case Deadlines
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex B Email From Mark 10 22 25 To Review Voting Materials
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
4 Ex C 10 23 25 Email From Mark Re Viewing Ballots
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex C 10 23 25 Email From Mark Re Viewing Ballots
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
20 Proposed Order Granting Leave Reply To Third Amended Complaint 10 31 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
21 Proposed Order To File Reply Late For Temporary Injunction 11 4 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Reply paper; usually the final written response before the court takes the issue under advisement.
6 Ex A Email 11 10 25 From Board With 12 1 25 Deadline For Insurance Proof
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
23 Minute Entry 11 18 25
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
24 Case Reassignment Civil Presiding Judge 11 26 25
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
25 Minute Entry 12 4 25 Case Consolidation
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
26 Alternative Dispute Resolution Vacated 12 19 25
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
27 Minute Entry 1 9 26 Motion For Reconsideration No Authority Due To Appeal
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Subpoena For Casey Bell American Family Ins 1 20 26
Type: Motion/application
Discovery or evidence request material; read it with the later order to see what was allowed or denied.
Subpoena To Colby 1 20 26
Type: Motion/application
Discovery or evidence request material; read it with the later order to see what was allowed or denied.
Affidavit Of Service Civil Subpoena Colby Management 1 23 26
Type: Motion/application
Proof-of-service material; check it to understand who was served and when deadlines started.
Affidavit Of Service Of Civil Subpoena Casey Bell Agency 1 23 26
Type: Motion/application
Proof-of-service material; check it to understand who was served and when deadlines started.
1 30 26 Supplemental Memorandum In Support Of Pending Motions
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
28 Minute Entry Order 2 12 26
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
29 Minute Entry 2 27 26 Motion To Compel Withdrawan Wo Prejudice
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
30 Minute Entry 3 16 2026 Hearing
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
31 Minute Entry 3 16 26
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
32 Minute Entry 3 30 26
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
2026 05 27 Motion For Judgment On The Pleadings
Type: Decision or judgment
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
1 Exhibit A Marx Warranty Deed
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit B Tara Ccrs
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit C Travis Law Firm
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit D Proposed Amendments
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit E Plaintiff Email
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit F Statement Read
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit G Plaintiff Letter
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit H Email To Homeowners
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit J Action
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit K Changes To Ccr Ltr
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit L Differences
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit M Board Email
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit N Cert Of Ins For 25 26
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit O Cert Of Ins Ltr 25 26
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit P Tara 2025 Budgetletter
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit Q Budget Vote 24 Email
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit R 2025 Budget
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit S Tara 25 Bud Ballot
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
1 Exhibit T Pl Motion For Leave
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
1 Plaintiffs Motion For Preliminary Inj Copy
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
1 St Amended Complaint 8 15 25
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
3 Plaint 1 PDF 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
4 Emergency Motion For Temporary Restraining Order Arcp 65 B
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
4 November 5 2025 Minute Entry Denying Emergency Motion Tro
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
4 Ex E 251025 001 Meeting To View Ballots
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
5 Ex V Tara 2026 Budget Ballot
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
5 Ex W 2026 Budget Tara Condominium Association 15 Reduction
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
5 Plaintiffs Amended Motion To Set Evidentiary Hearing On Motion For Preliminary Injunction
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
8 Proposed Order To Extend Time Joint Report And Scheduling
Type: Court order/minute entry
Case-management filing; it tells the court how the parties propose to schedule and manage the case.
11 Motion To Dismiss Defendants Mark Gottmann And Dennis Anderson
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
15 Plaintiffs Initial Rule 26 1 Disclosure Statement
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
16 Noti 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
16 1 Order Granting Defendants Application For Costs Oct 15 2025
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
18 Order Extending Case Deadlines Oct 24 2025
Type: Court order/minute entry
Court or agency order; this is usually the document that tells readers what changed next.
18 1 Response To Motion To Vacate Order On Attorneys Fees
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
22 November 5 2025 Minute Entry Denying Emergency Motion Tro
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Affidavit Of Lisa Marx In Support Of Motion For Change Of Judge For Cause
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Affida 1 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Affida 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Case No CV 2025 012980 Responsive Memorandum To Associations Partial Motion To Dismiss Plaintiffs Claims That Are Derivi
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Cc And R Amendment Update From The Arizona Supreme Court Chdb Law
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Colby Subpoena
Type: Motion/application
Discovery or evidence request material; read it with the later order to see what was allowed or denied.
Colbyn 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
CV 2025 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
CV 2025 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Defendants Reply To Plaintiffs Response To Motion
Type: Motion/application
Reply paper; usually the final written response before the court takes the issue under advisement.
Emergency Motion For Temporary Restraining Order Arcp 65 B Expedited Consideration Requested
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Ex A Copy Second Amended Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Ex A Master Insurance As Of Dec 1 2025
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex B Copy First Amended Civil Complaint For Declaratory Judgment And Injunctive Relief
Type: Decision or judgment
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Ex D Organization Of Claims For Presentation
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex E 251025 001 Meeting To View Ballots
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex W 2026 Budget Tara Condominium Association 15 Reduction
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Ex V Tara 2026 Budget Ballot
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Exapla 1 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Exapla 1 2
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Exapla 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Exbaff 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Exhibit A Email Requesting Reply To Motion Be Rescinded
Type: Motion/application
Reply paper; usually the final written response before the court takes the issue under advisement.
Exhibit B Email Requesting Stipulated Extension
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
First Amended Civil Complaint For Declaratory Judgment And Injunctive Relief
Type: Decision or judgment
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Insurance Subpoena
Type: Motion/application
Discovery or evidence request material; read it with the later order to see what was allowed or denied.
Insura 2
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Jointn 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Minute 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Motion For Change Of Judge For Cause Pursuant To Arcp 42 2
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Motion For Leave For 3 Rd Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Motion For Reconsideration Of October 1 2025 Order
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Motion To Strike Defendants Reply In Support Of Motion To Strike Portions Of Amended Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Motion To Vacate Order On Attorney Fees
Type: Court order/minute entry
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Motion 1 1
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Motion 1
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Notice Of Withdrawal Of Motion To Compel
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Objection To Plaintiffs Notice
Type: Briefing paper
Opposing or responsive paper; compare it to the motion or request filed immediately before it.
Object 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plain Reply To 3 Rd Amended Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Plaintiffs First Supplemental Disclosure Statement
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaintiffs Motion For Preliminary Inj Copy
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Plaint 1 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 10
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 11
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 12
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 2
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 3
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 4
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 5
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 6
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 7
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1 8
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plaint 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Plares 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Reply To Resp And Obj To Mot For Lea
Type: Briefing paper
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Reques 1 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Reques 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Reques 2
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Response To Motion To Dismiss Mark Gottmann And Dennis Anderson 1
Type: Motion/application
A request for a specific ruling or procedural action; the next document is often a response or order.
Response To Motion To Strike Portions Of Amended Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Respon 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Second Amended Complaint
Type: Opening pleading
Starts or reframes the case and identifies the claims or relief requested.
Stipul 1
Type: Court/source PDF
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Supplemental Verified Affidavit Of Lisa Marx
Type: Procedural/service filing
Uploaded source file in the case record; read it in sequence with the surrounding filings to follow the procedure.
Source File Roadmap 2026 05 31
Type: Source roadmap CSV
Upload/source spreadsheet that helps cross-check filing order, source names, or AI review notes.
Primary sources
Reviewed against the uploaded Superior Court filings through May 27, 2026 and the normalized source-file roadmap. Unfiled draft materials are not treated as court sources. This page is educational information for Arizona HOA and condominium governance research. It is not legal advice for any specific dispute.