CV2026-001831 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · June 9, 2026 · Nataijah Fields (Plaintiff) v. Sun Groves HOA and Kati Soundos Nasser (Defendants)
Why it matters
Sun Groves HOA was dismissed from a quiet-title suit because no ownership or other claim was alleged against it.
ProcedureAttorney FeesCovenants
Read case analysis →
CV2025-036771
Superior Court · June 1, 2026 · A self-managed 2,035-home Gilbert HOA sued a vocal resident (former Gilbert mayor Steve B…
Why it matters
An Arizona HOA cannot convert member criticism — even repeated, anonymous, and harsh mass emails about board…
Board GovernanceFree SpeechProcedure
Read case analysis →
Maricopa County Superior Court No. CV2024-005940 (consolidated with CV2024-013806)
Superior Court · May 27, 2026 · A Gilbert homeowner, appearing pro se, sued her HOA, its management company, and three in…
Why it matters
On the operative pleading, the court held that an HOA's CC&Rs are the contract between owner and association, so…
ProcedureCC&RsNegligenceRecords RequestsEconomic Loss DoctrinePro Se Litigant
Read case analysis →
CV2024-003271 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · May 11, 2026 · Val Vista Classic Community Association (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Levi Rosen…
Why it matters
Routine HOA assessment foreclosure: unpaid assessments supported summary judgment for the association.
AssessmentsForeclosureLiensAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2026-004481 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 30, 2026 · Igor Kokoskov and Patricia Kokoskov (Plaintiffs, neighboring owners) v. Sean Harapko, Ali…
Why it matters
Preliminary injunction denied against Grayhawk-approved construction under disputed design guidelines.
Architectural ReviewCC&RsCovenantsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2025-036877
Superior Court · March 4, 2026 · The companion suit Trilogy at Power Ranch filed the same day, targeting 50 unidentified '…
Why it matters
An association cannot keep an injunction case alive against unidentified 'John Doe' defendants it never serves…
Board GovernanceFree SpeechProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2023-014388 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · February 27, 2026 · Shawn Blakley (Plaintiff) v. Roosevelt Grover Parker, Patricia L. Parker, and Litchfield…
Why it matters
HOA won all claims and fees under § 12-341.01 for alleged contractual enforcement-duty failures.
CC&RsCovenantsAttorney FeesSelective Enforcement
Read case analysis →
CV2026-008484
Superior Court · February 26, 2026 · AZNH brought a special action against the ADRE Commissioner, the OAH Interim Director, an…
Why it matters
Pending special-action challenge over ADRE/OAH response authority; no final merits ruling in the file set.
Admin. AppealsBoard GovernanceProcedureElections
Read case analysis →
CV2025-060700 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · February 2, 2026 · Steve Pandi (Plaintiff, homeowner) v. Crown Point Homeowners Association, Beth Mulcahy, a…
Why it matters
Separate HOA foreclosure claims were dismissed as mandatory counterclaims in a pending assessment case.
AssessmentsForeclosureLiensProcedureFDCPABankruptcy
Read case analysis →
CV2025-007913 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 6, 2025 · John Ballard and Claudia Ballard (Plaintiffs) v. Carriage Square at Gainey Village Homeow…
Why it matters
HOA answer was struck after default, but loss-of-value damages still required a judge-run proof hearing.
Architectural ReviewCovenantsProcedureBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2024-090807 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 28, 2025 · Faisal Elhassan (Plaintiff) v. Coventry Tempe Community Association and other defendants
Why it matters
Coventry Tempe won summary judgment because the owner offered no evidence disputing the ledger.
AssessmentsLiensGood Faith & Fair DealingProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2025-010660 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 19, 2025 · Russell Ranch Homeowners Association (Plaintiff) v. Gregory T Heard (Defendant)
Why it matters
Russell Ranch obtained a foreclosure judgment and order of sale after default proceedings.
AssessmentsLiensProcedureForeclosure
Read case analysis →
CV2024-017272 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 31, 2025 · The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Peter J. Cahill (Defendant)
Why it matters
Val Vista Lakes obtained default judgment after findings on service and reasonable fees and costs.
AssessmentsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2024-037894 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 8, 2025 · Mountain Vista Ranch Owners Association (Plaintiff) v. Ismael Rivas (Defendant)
Why it matters
Mountain Vista Ranch obtained a foreclosure judgment and order of sale after default proceedings.
AssessmentsLiensProcedureForeclosure
Read case analysis →
CV2024-022259 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · June 17, 2025 · Ronald C. Russ (Plaintiff) v. Rob Lewis, Sonoran Mountain Ranch Homeowners Association, A…
Why it matters
HOA-meeting complaint was dismissed because the pleading did not give each defendant fair notice of the claims.
ProcedureMeetings & RecordsBoard GovernanceGood Faith & Fair DealingPro Se Litigant
Read case analysis →
CV2024-022478 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · May 20, 2025 · The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Christina Lynn Brooks (Defendant)
Why it matters
Val Vista Lakes obtained a formal judgment after default proceedings, with no amount stated in the entries.
AssessmentsLiensProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2023-008406 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 30, 2025 · Merrick Avenue Management, LLC; Edward Trenton Albarracin; Gretchen Marie Zamjahn (Plaint…
Why it matters
The superior court granted Troon Fairways HOA and the moving individual defendants summary judgment on all counts…
CC&RsBoard GovernanceProcedureNegligence
Read case analysis →
CV2025-012980
Superior Court · April 14, 2025 · Lisa Marx, a Tara condominium owner, sued Tara Condominiums Association over alleged open…
Why it matters
Pending condo-governance suit with nine July 2026 summary-judgment motions and no final merits decision.
Meetings & RecordsBoard GovernanceCC&RsRecords RequestsProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2024-090662 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 14, 2025 · Val Vista Lakes Community Association, The (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Ben J.…
Why it matters
HOA won assessment-collection summary judgment after homeowners missed Rule 56 response requirements.
AssessmentsProcedureAttorney FeesCC&Rs
Read case analysis →
CV2024-031553 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 25, 2025 · Oleg Bortman and JIMBO, LLC (Plaintiffs — JIMBO owns a commercial condominium in the Safa…
Why it matters
The superior court dismissed the First Amended Complaint without prejudice: Bortman and JIMBO, LLC lacked standing…
Board GovernanceAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2023-093035 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 10, 2025 · Desert Cove Condominium Association (Plaintiff, condominium association) v. BCK Coatings…
Why it matters
Condo association won $1.04M summary judgment for defective contractor work after BCK lacked usable evidence.
ProcedureCondominiumsAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2024-002225 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 18, 2024 · Iqtunheimr LLC (Plaintiff) v. The Val Vista Lakes Community Association and Timothy Hedri…
Why it matters
Community-wide HOA claims were derivative, while direct selective-enforcement claims survived before fees and sanctions.
CC&RsSelective EnforcementGood Faith & Fair DealingBoard GovernanceAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2022-014709 / 1 CA-CV 23-0350
Superior Court · January 30, 2024 · A condominium owner sought contempt enforcement of a 2015 administrative budget order aga…
Why it matters
The courts rejected contempt enforcement against Hilton Casitas because the 2015 administrative budget order did not…
ProcedureBoard GovernanceAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2023-010115 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 9, 2023 · Michal and Jennifer Reilly (Plaintiffs, condominium owners) v. Jackson Builders of Arizon…
Why it matters
Condo bylaws supported owner contract claims for private-unit damage despite board-enforcement arguments.
CC&RsCovenantsGood Faith & Fair DealingProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2021-019511 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 30, 2023 · Jennifer Duncan and Raymond Duncan (Plaintiffs/homeowners) v. LaBlonde Development Corpor…
Why it matters
HOA fine injunction resolved construction-enforcement claim; both sides lost fee requests.
CC&RsArchitectural ReviewFinesAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2023-092215 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 18, 2023 · The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Casey Wade Russell and Danielle…
Why it matters
Val Vista Lakes obtained a stipulated judgment, with no amount or merits analysis in the minute entry.
AssessmentsLiensProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2021-050888 / 1 CA-CV 22-0202
Superior Court · January 19, 2023 · A condominium owner brought statutory budget, assessment, audit, and administrative-order…
Why it matters
The Superior Court dismissed the statutory enforcement claims, but the Court of Appeals vacated the contract-based…
ProcedureAttorney FeesBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2021-018062 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 2, 2022 · The Sun Groves Homeowners Association (Plaintiff) v. Dawna M. Greene and the trustee of t…
Why it matters
Sun Groves obtained a default foreclosure judgment and order of sale, with no merits analysis in the entries.
AssessmentsLiensForeclosureProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2016-050453 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 13, 2022 · Village At Grayhawk Owners Association (Plaintiff/Counterdefendant) v. Kathryn Marie Jone…
Why it matters
Self-represented owner lost on summary judgment after failing to respond with admissible Rule 56 facts.
ProcedureAttorney FeesCC&Rs
Read case analysis →
CV2021-051550 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 1, 2022 · Cottonfields Community Association (Plaintiff, homeowners association for 450 homes) v. R…
Why it matters
The superior court found by clear and convincing evidence that RCP Southern Ridge, LLP was violating the judgment…
CC&RsProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2020-013607 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · February 7, 2022 · Maricopoly LLC (Plaintiff) v. Tierra Santa Community Association, Inc., Maxwell & Morgan,…
Why it matters
Fraud allegations over an extinguished HOA lien sale defeated summary judgment; § 33-420 did not apply to the firm.
ForeclosureLiensCC&RsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2021-001103 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · December 3, 2021 · Coventry Tempe Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Faisal H Elhassan (Defendant)
Why it matters
Coventry Tempe obtained a foreclosure judgment and order of sale after default proceedings.
AssessmentsLiensProcedureForeclosure
Read case analysis →
CV2020-092936 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · December 1, 2021 · Silverton Deer Village Homeowners Association, Inc. (Plaintiff) v. Janet DeFine (Defendan…
Why it matters
HOA collection case expanded into third-party FDCPA and abuse-of-process claims that survived pleading attacks.
AssessmentsForeclosureLiensFDCPAProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2021-094264 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · December 1, 2021 · Suntrails III Homeowners Association (Plaintiff) v. John Ward (Defendant)
Why it matters
Suntrails III obtained a formal judgment in a thin minute-entry record.
AssessmentsLiensProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2019-015684 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 2, 2021 · Edet Effiong Asuquo (Plaintiff) v. La Fuente Condominium Association (Defendant)
Why it matters
The court enforced a Rule 80 settlement resolving roof and HVAC claims against La Fuente.
CC&RsCovenantsProcedureAttorney FeesCondominiumsPro Se Litigant
Read case analysis →
CV2021-001880 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 3, 2021 · Val Vista Lakes Community Association, The (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Safwat…
Why it matters
HOA obtained uncontested summary judgment in an injunctive-relief case, with final judgment still to be lodged.
ProcedureCovenantsCC&Rs
Read case analysis →
CV2018-014261 (Maricopa Cnty. Super. Ct.)
Superior Court · June 16, 2021 · Plaintiffs Jason and Melissa Komorowski v. Defendant Whisper Mountain Homeowners Associat…
Why it matters
Court ordered HOA to pay $17,800 in damages and permanently maintain a drainage ditch to prevent flooding.
CC&RsProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2021-002089 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · May 12, 2021 · The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Leland L. Leeds, Discover Bank,…
Why it matters
Val Vista Lakes obtained a default foreclosure judgment, with no merits analysis in the minute entries.
AssessmentsLiensForeclosureProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2019-010791 (Maricopa Cnty. Super. Ct.)
Superior Court · February 8, 2021 · Mardy C. Toepke and Kate E. Toepke (plaintiff unit owners) v. Pioneer Condominium Associa…
Why it matters
A condo association needed unanimous owner consent to add rental and occupancy use restrictions.
CC&RsBoard GovernanceVoting And ElectionsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2018-053929 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 9, 2020 · Sky Boles (Plaintiff) v. Jason Tarrell, Northern Manor Townhouse Association, Erik Wright…
Why it matters
Quiet-title claimant lost after a sheriff’s sale cut off any ownership or possession rights.
ForeclosureLiensCC&RsProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2019-094307 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · December 11, 2019 · Sycamore Hills Estates Homeowners Association, Inc. (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v…
Why it matters
An attorney's alleged failure to follow a client's oral directions — including directions from the settlement…
Attorney FeesBoard GovernanceProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2019-005775 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 16, 2019 · Debbie Westerman (Plaintiff) v. Michael Brubaker and Bridgewood Nine 30 Property Owners A…
Why it matters
Pleading-stage HOA claims narrowed: no fiduciary duty or tort good-faith remedies, but contract enforcement survived.
CC&RsCovenantsGood Faith & Fair DealingSelective EnforcementProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2014-097453 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 24, 2019 · North Canyon Ranch Owners Association (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Pamela J. Al…
Why it matters
After appeal, the HOA received foreclosure judgment and post-bankruptcy fees; pre-bankruptcy amounts were excluded.
AssessmentsLiensForeclosureAttorney FeesCC&RsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2017-094721 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 3, 2019 · Woodmar IV Association, Inc. (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Paul S. Rubin, Inc.,…
Why it matters
Management company could not win judgment on the pleadings against HOA computer-data claims.
ProcedureBoard GovernanceAttorney FeesMeetings & RecordsNegligence
Read case analysis →
LC2018-000441 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 7, 2019 · Deborah Minamyer (Appellant) v. Montelena Villas Homeowners Association (Appellee)
Why it matters
The superior court affirmed dismissal of old condominium roof-leak claims on limitations grounds.
CovenantsProcedure
Read case analysis →
LC2018-000421 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · January 14, 2019 · David Falk and Melody Falk (Appellants) v. Paloma Paseo Homeowners Association (Appellee)
Why it matters
A justice-court post-judgment fee award to an HOA was vacated as untimely after final judgment.
Attorney FeesAssessmentsProcedureLiens
Read case analysis →
CV2017-003266 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · December 12, 2018 · The Lakewood Community Association (Plaintiff / Cross-defendant) v. Stephen S. Edwards, a…
Why it matters
Court recommended vexatious-litigant limits after repeated filings from a CC&R wall dispute.
ProcedureCC&RsCovenantsLiensAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2018-090922 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 26, 2018 · Palm Valley Community Association (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Stella Benton (D…
Why it matters
The superior court granted the Association summary judgment on its assessment-lien foreclosure complaint, finding no…
ForeclosureAssessmentsCC&RsAttorney FeesLiens
Read case analysis →
CV2017-011347 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 17, 2018 · Mark D. Goldman (Plaintiff) v. Mark Kristopher Sahl, Kayla L. Sahl, Carpenter Hazlewood,…
Why it matters
HOA counsel's letters to members about threatened litigation were privileged; sanctions were limited.
Free SpeechBoard GovernanceAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2017-015815 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 18, 2018 · Joyce Jasper-Burnett (Plaintiff) v. Chateau De Vie Four Townhouse Association and AAM, LL…
Why it matters
The superior court granted in part and denied in part the defendants' Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss: it dismissed…
ProcedureBoard GovernanceMembershipNegligence
Read case analysis →
CV2017-002958 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · May 2, 2018 · Enclave Villas Condominium Council Of Co-owners INC (Plaintiff) v. Thomas C Tracy (Defend…
Why it matters
Enclave Villas obtained a formal judgment against the owner after default-related proceedings.
AssessmentsLiensProcedureCondominiums
Read case analysis →
CV2015-005625 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 14, 2017 · Violet Kaplan (Plaintiff, condominium owner) v. AAM LLC, VSS Security Services, Allen Sve…
Why it matters
Condo manager faced negligence trial over guest key-fob access; security vendor won summary judgment.
CondominiumsProcedureArchitectural Review
Read case analysis →
CV2015-095178 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 21, 2016 · Sundance Residential Homeowners Association Inc. (Plaintiff) v. Lorri Glawe, Curt Glawe,…
Why it matters
Sundance won breach summary judgment, but no late fees, collection fees, or foreclosure after payment.
AssessmentsLiensForeclosureAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2013-004301 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 8, 2016 · Suzanne Sallus (Plaintiff) v. Sunrise Desert Vistas P.O.A. and Gary S. Layton (Defendants)
Why it matters
POA document suit ended in dismissal with prejudice and an $8,185.75 fee award to defendants.
Records RequestsProcedureAttorney FeesBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2015-094714 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 20, 2016 · Hallcraft Villas East I, II & III Homeowners Association (Plaintiff, homeowners associati…
Why it matters
HOA obtained judgment and fees, but notice and contract-breach fact disputes kept related claims alive.
ProcedureCC&RsAssessmentsAttorney FeesBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2014-094190 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · February 4, 2016 · Tanglewood HOA (Plaintiff) v. Molly Fagen and Jason Fagen (Defendants)
Why it matters
HOA default packet for lien foreclosure was rejected after the case had already been dismissed.
ForeclosureLiensAssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2014-094502 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · January 25, 2016 · Tanglewood HOA (Plaintiff) v. James E. Goode (Defendant)
Why it matters
Unopposed HOA summary judgment entered; later order addressed redemption-period waste.
ProcedureForeclosureCC&RsLiens
Read case analysis →
CV2015-053091 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · January 15, 2016 · R.L. Whitmer and other plaintiffs v. Hilton Casitas Council of Co-Owners and other defend…
Why it matters
The court dismissed a receivership case against Hilton Casitas and later denied Rule 60 relief.
ProcedureAttorney FeesBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2013-015763 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 22, 2015 · Cottonflower Goodyear Community Association, Inc. (Plaintiff) v. Malik Bey, et al. (Defen…
Why it matters
HOA foreclosure judgment stood after challenges, with later excess-sale proceeds handled through court process.
ForeclosureLiensAssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2015-090368 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 15, 2015 · Michael and Anna McMullen (Plaintiffs, homeowners) v. Val Vista Lakes Community Associati…
Why it matters
HOA and related defendants won summary judgment on HOA-board and website-related defamation theories.
Free SpeechBoard GovernanceProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2014-053595 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 3, 2015 · Ralph Bianco, Wayne Holsinger, Gary Nelson, Don Foster, Sally Foster, and John Walker (Pl…
Why it matters
Fact issues over Tract G use and covenant enforcement defeated the community association's summary judgment.
CC&RsCovenantsMembershipBoard GovernanceProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2014-094169 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 15, 2015 · Troon North Association (Plaintiff/Counterdefendant, homeowners association) v. Ripson Ho…
Why it matters
HOA foreclosure judgment quieted lien priority and rejected homeowner recording-penalty theories.
ForeclosureAssessmentsCC&RsAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2014-090909 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 20, 2015 · Lake Park Village I Homeowners Association (Plaintiff, homeowners association) v. Cia Spy…
Why it matters
HOA won summary judgment to foreclose its assessment lien after the court found no factual dispute over delinquency.
AssessmentsLiensForeclosureAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2013-014446 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 2, 2015 · Steven Piper and Janet Piper (Plaintiffs/Counterdefendants) v. Will Rogers Equestrian Ran…
Why it matters
The superior court granted the association's verified motion for summary judgment on all four of the plaintiffs'…
CC&RsCovenantsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2012-018443 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 25, 2014 · Andrew Kuhn (Plaintiff) v. Southern Village Estates Condominium Association and Pride Ass…
Why it matters
Water shutoff collection rule went to factfinder; Pride was not an FDCPA debt collector for pre-default HOA dues.
AssessmentsFDCPACC&RsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2012-090015 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 14, 2014 · Dynamite Mountain Ranch Homeowners Association (Plaintiff) v. Kay E. Larson and Constance…
Why it matters
After a home-business injunction settlement, the HOA won $35,000 in fees under CC&Rs and sanctions rulings.
CovenantsAttorney FeesProcedureBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
CV2012-012813 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 9, 2014 · Ballantrae Ridge Homeowners Association (Plaintiff, judgment creditor) v. Windy Walk Prop…
Why it matters
The excess proceeds from the sheriff's sale following the association's lien foreclosure must be distributed by lien…
ForeclosureAssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2012-017609 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 17, 2014 · Penelope Johnson (Plaintiff) v. The Pointe South Mountain Residential Association (Defend…
Why it matters
After a bench trial, the court held that the Declaration did not permit the Association to use courthome…
AssessmentsCC&RsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
LC2013-000373-001 DT
Superior Court · January 23, 2014 · An HOA appealed from justice court after its assessment-collection case against a homeown…
Why it matters
The superior court dismissed the HOA's record appeal as untimely, leaving the justice court's dismissal and fee…
AssessmentsProcedureAttorney Fees
Read case analysis →
CV2013-008642 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 20, 2013 · The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Wanita S. Holmes and Beach Club…
Why it matters
Val Vista Lakes obtained a stipulated judgment against one defendant, with no merits analysis in the minute entry.
AssessmentsLiensProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2013-095550 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 29, 2013 · Camelback House Homeowners Association INC (Plaintiff) v. Terri A Ware (Defendant)
Why it matters
Camelback House obtained a stipulated foreclosure and money judgment.
AssessmentsLiensProcedureForeclosure
Read case analysis →
CV2012-050858 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · July 10, 2013 · Labadi Family Limited Partnership and Osuji Family Limited Partnership (Plaintiffs) v. Be…
Why it matters
Bellasera won reconsideration because disputed facts remained over claimed access through its gated roads.
CovenantsProcedureBoard Governance
Read case analysis →
LC2012-000034-001 DT
Superior Court · June 21, 2013 · An HOA sought unpaid assessments from a woman it claimed inherited the property, and appe…
Why it matters
Improper service justified setting aside the HOA default judgment in an assessment collection case.
AssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
LC2012-000317 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · August 20, 2012 · AAM, LLC (Plaintiff) v. Board of Legal Document Preparers and Les Krambeal (Defendants)
Why it matters
AAM won a special action allowing an authorized legal document preparer to sign an HOA lien as agent.
LiensAdmin. AppealsProcedureNonprofit Corporation
Read case analysis →
CV2011-008669 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · June 25, 2012 · Caroline Brown (Plaintiff, unit owner) v. Camelback Village Improvement Association, Inc.…
Why it matters
The Declaration undisputedly required CVIA to procure a blanket insurance policy insuring the owners with proceeds…
CC&RsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2011-053961 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · September 22, 2011 · Empire West Title Agency LLC (Plaintiff) v. Charles Hoskins (Defendant); Westwind Homeown…
Why it matters
Two HOAs received priority distributions from trustee-sale proceeds before the remaining balance went to a lender.
LiensForeclosureAssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2008-054299 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · January 5, 2009 · Gary Lafleur and Diane Chambers (Plaintiffs) v. Val Vista Lakes Community Association Inc…
Why it matters
TRO over architectural committee decisions dissolved, then HOA won fees after voluntary dismissal.
Architectural ReviewCC&RsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2005-012018 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · June 8, 2006 · Mountain Vista Ranch Owners Association (Plaintiff) v. John and Holly Dickerson (Defendan…
Why it matters
The court entered $454 for late fees, fines, and NSF charges but denied association attorney fees.
Architectural ReviewFinesAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2005-091216 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · October 25, 2005 · Summer Place Terrace Homeowners Association (Plaintiff) v. Sundance Unlimited (Defendant)
Why it matters
Summer Place Terrace obtained a default quiet-title judgment against corporate defendants on a thin record.
Quiet TitleProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2004-092611 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · March 10, 2005 · Tempe Gardens Townhouse Corp. (Plaintiff) v. Gary Tibshraeny and other defendants
Why it matters
Tempe Gardens obtained summary judgment and a reasonable-fee finding in a thin minute-entry record.
AssessmentsAttorney FeesProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2002-092314 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · November 25, 2002 · Hallcraft Villas East I II & III Homeowners Association Inc. (Plaintiff) v. Kenneth Ray L…
Why it matters
HOA could take judgment on the property while an insurer’s interest was treated as subordinate by stipulation.
LiensForeclosureAssessmentsProcedure
Read case analysis →
CV2002-002028 (Maricopa County Superior Court)
Superior Court · April 3, 2002 · Tatum Highlands Community Association (Plaintiff) v. Michael R Burns (Defendant)
Why it matters
Tatum Highlands obtained judgment in a one-entry record with no merits analysis.
AssessmentsLiensProcedure
Read case analysis →
