Braylon Hanson vs Casabella Condominium Association

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H100-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date—
Administrative Law JudgeAdam D. Stone
OutcomeCasabella Condominium Association (Respondent)
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties$0.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerBraylon HansonCounsel—
RespondentCasabella Condominium AssociationCounsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H100-REL Case document – 10_9- Denial Letter from Casabella Legal counsel. 2 pages.pdf

(212.3 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 11_HOA Petition Request Form – signed.pdf

(390.7 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 12_Supporting Documents and Exhibits. 4 pages.pdf

(605.9 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 1467714.pdf

(55.3 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 1471977.pdf

(40.6 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 1474311.pdf

(42.4 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 1480580.pdf

(109.4 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 1_1-Casabella Complete CC&Rs Document.pdf

(32759.9 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 26F-H100 Notice of Hearing.pdf

(202.0 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 2_10-Braylon Hanson Witness list.pdf

(223.4 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 3_2-Casabella Complete Rules & Regulations.pdf

(7308.7 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 4.6.26 Petition Submission.pdf

(168.6 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 4_3-ARS 33-1221 Complete Statute. 1 page.pdf

(80.2 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 5_4-Notice of non-compliance, architectural request and rejection correspondence. 7 pages .pdf

(536.8 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 6_5-Request for hearing, authorization of Robert Gelinas as acting agent, email confirming meeting. 4 pages.pdf

(247.3 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 7_6-Record of flooring installation date. 2 pages.pdf

(731.4 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 8_7-Board of Directors January 29, 2026 Appeal Meeting Details 2 Pages.pdf

(464.0 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – 9_8-Casabella By-Laws Complete Document.pdf

(25405.1 KB)

26F-H100-REL Case document – Notice of Petition.pdf

(165.1 KB)

Executive Briefing Document: Legal Dispute Analysis – Hanson v. Casabella Condominium Association (Docket No. 26F-H100-REL)

Executive Summary

This briefing document provides an exhaustive synthesis of the legal dispute, administrative proceedings, and ultimate adjudication between petitioner Braylon Hanson (owner of Unit 2037) and respondent Casabella Condominium Association regarding the installation of second-floor hard-surface flooring.

The conflict originated in December 2025 when Hanson listed Unit 2037 for sale. Casabella issued a violation notice after discovering luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring in real estate listing photographs, asserting it was installed without architectural approval in violation of community rules. Hanson countered that the flooring was installed in March/April 2023 pursuant to Article 4, Section 4.3(B) of the Casabella Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) and A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1), both of which permit nonstructural interior alterations without prior board approval.

Following an internal appeal denial supported by legal counsel (VF Law), Hanson filed a petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE). The matter was referred to the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) under Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Adam D. Stone. Following an evidentiary hearing on October 1, 2026, ALJ Stone issued a final decision on October 16, 2026, ruling entirely in favor of the Association. The tribunal concluded that under A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), unit owners bear the burden of demonstrating that interior alterations eliminate or minimize noise disturbances for adjacent neighbors—a burden Hanson failed to meet by repeatedly refusing floor inspections and withholding acoustic underlayment specifications.


Case Overview & Key Metadata

ParameterDetails
Case NameBraylon Hanson v. Casabella Condominium Association
Docket Number26F-H100-REL
Adjudicating ForumState of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) / ADRE
Presiding JudgeAdministrative Law Judge Adam D. Stone
PetitionerBraylon Hanson (Owner, Unit 2037; Kennewick, WA resident)
Petitioner RepresentativeSelf-represented; assisted by Robert Gelinas (Unit 2036)
RespondentCasabella Condominium Association (Scottsdale, AZ)
Respondent Legal CounselChristina N. Morgan, Esq. (VF Law / Vial Fotheringham, LLP)
Key Witness (Respondent)Terrance Chadedock (Board Member & Architectural Committee Member)
Disputed Property10101 N. Arabian Trail, Unit 2037, Scottsdale, AZ 85258
Hearing DateOctober 1, 2026
Final Decision DateOctober 16, 2026
OutcomePetition Denied; Association rules and violation notice upheld.

Chronological Case History

“ [March–April 2023] ──> Hanson installs LVP flooring in Unit 2037. [March 29, 2024] ──> AZ Legislature passes HB 2141 (Amends A.R.S. § 33-1221). [Sept 14, 2024] ──> A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) officially takes effect. [Dec 6, 2025] ──> Hanson lists Unit 2037 for sale; MLS photos reveal LVP floors. [Dec 16, 2025] ──> Hanson submits retroactive ADR Form to facilitate pending escrow. [Dec 18, 2025] ──> Association denies ADR Form due to lack of flooring/underlayment specs. [Jan 29, 2026] ──> Executive session appeal meeting; Robert Gelinas represents Hanson. [March 11, 2026] ──> VF Law (Christina Morgan) issues formal legal opinion denying appeal. [April 6, 2026] ──> Hanson files ADRE Petition ($500 fee paid). [Sept 10, 2026] ──> ALJ Stone issues Order setting hearing for October 1, 2026. [Oct 1, 2026] ──> Evidentiary hearing conducted via Google Meet. [Oct 16, 2026] ──> ALJ Stone issues Administrative Law Judge Decision denying all relief. “


Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

1. Statutory Interpretation vs. Community CC&R Authority

The core legal dispute centered on the tension between community governing documents and state statutes regarding interior alterations:

  • Petitioner's Argument: Hanson contended that Article 4, Section 4.3(B) of the CC&Rs explicitly states that any unit owner may make nonstructural additions, alterations, and improvements within their unit without prior written approval of the Board. He argued that Section 2.1(A) defines finished flooring as part of the Unit (not a Common Element) and Section 6.2 restricts Board rule-making authority strictly to Common Elements. Consequently, Hanson asserted that the Association's adopted Rule prohibiting hard flooring in upper-level living areas/bedrooms was an illegal, ultra vires modification of the CC&Rs executed without the required 67% vote of unit owners under Section 10.4(A).
  • Respondent's Defense: Legal counsel Christina Morgan acknowledged that CC&R Section 4.3(B) does not explicitly mandate advance board approval for interior nonstructural work. However, the Association pointed to CC&R Section 6.2 (broad authority to regulate unit use and maintenance), Section 3.8(E) (easement to enter units to verify compliance), and Section 4.17 (nuisance provisions). Crucially, the HOA relied on A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), which grants associations a statutory right to ensure interior modifications do not create noise disturbances for adjacent occupants, overriding conflicting community language.
2. Retroactivity, Legislative Evolution, and Sound Mitigation Standards

A central element of contention was the application of statutory amendments and community sound guidelines across different timeframes:

  • House Bill 2141 / A.R.S. § 33-1221(B): HB 2141 was signed into law on March 29, 2024, taking effect on September 14, 2024. Subsection (B) provides that "notwithstanding the condominium documents, the association shall not prohibit a unit owner from improving or altering the interior of the unit in a manner that may disturb adjacent unit occupants if the unit owner purchases and installs at the unit owner's own expense any reasonably necessary improved materials, accessories or other adjustments that eliminate or minimize the potential disturbance."
  • Temporal Contention: Hanson argued that because his installation occurred in March/April 2023, the September 2024 statutory amendment (Subsection B) and the Association's 2025 "Proposed Architectural Requirements for Second Floor Hard Floor Covering" could not be retroactively applied to his work.
  • Judicial Resolution: ALJ Stone rejected Hanson's retroactivity argument. The tribunal ruled that regardless of when the floor was physically installed, ongoing compliance is evaluated when enforcement takes place. Because A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) explicitly contains a "notwithstanding" clause, it controls present compliance, obligating the homeowner to establish sound mitigation regardless of CC&R phrasing.
3. Evidentiary Burden and Non-Cooperation

The case ultimately turned on evidentiary compliance and cooperative discovery:

  • Failure of Burden: Under A.A.C. R2-19-119, the petitioner bears the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence. Hanson admitted during cross-examination that he hired a contractor, did not know the underlayment specifications, refused to provide the floor manufacturer information to the HOA, and ignored multiple written requests from Community Manager Regina Goodwin and VF Law to schedule an in-unit acoustic inspection.
  • Tribunal Finding: ALJ Stone highlighted that because Hanson refused to provide any technical specifications or permit an inspection, it was impossible for either the HOA or the tribunal to determine whether the LVP floor minimized noise disturbances for the downstairs neighbor. Because the homeowner thwarted verification, the Association was legally justified in maintaining its Notice of Violation.

Important Quotes with Detailed Context

Quote 1: VF Law Legal Opinion Letter

"While Section 4.3(B) of the Declaration does not grant the Association the explicit right to require advance approval for flooring, Section 6.2 of the Declaration grants the Board broad authority to adopt Rules regulating the use and maintenance of Units… [A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)] gives the Association a statutory right to ensure that interior modifications do not create a disturbance to adjacent occupants." — Christina N. Morgan, Esq. (Letter to Braylon Hanson, March 11, 2026)

  • Context: This quote represents the core legal rationale used by Casabella’s counsel to deny Hanson’s executive appeal. It acknowledges that while the CC&Rs lack explicit advance approval mandates for interior flooring, state statutory law supersedes governing documents and empowers the HOA to enforce sound mitigation standards.
Quote 2: Petitioner Hearing Testimony

"I installed LVP flooring inside my second floor unit. And more than two years later, Casabella discovered the flooring through listing photographs and issued a violation stating that it was installed without an architectural design request… Casabella's own legal counsel later acknowledged in writing that prior approval for flooring was not necessarily required." — Braylon Hanson (OAH Hearing Transcript, Oct 1, 2026)

  • Context: Hanson’s opening testimony at the administrative hearing emphasizing his position that the HOA engaged in delayed, selective enforcement. He relied on admissions within VF Law's denial letter to argue that the HOA lacked authority to require prior design requests for nonstructural work.
Quote 3: Cross-Examination on Technical Specifications

Ms. Morgan: "Do you have the information about the underlayment for the flooring right now?" Mr. Hanson: "I do not." Ms. Morgan: "Why, Mr. Hanson, if you have information at least about the manufacturer of your floor, have you not provided that to the association?" Mr. Hanson: "I don't believe that's relevant to my case today." — Cross-Examination Exchange (OAH Hearing Transcript, Oct 1, 2026)

  • Context: A critical evidentiary exchange during the hearing where Hanson conceded he lacked underlayment data and refused to provide flooring product details to the HOA board. This testimony directly damaged his position before the Administrative Law Judge.
Quote 4: Respondent Closing Argument

"The statute doesn't eliminate compliance requirements, it makes compliance with sound mitigation the key inquiry… The board is not saying that Mr. Hanson cannot have hard flooring. It's saying that it has to comply with the statute by having materials that mitigate sound that protect the surrounding neighbors." — Christina N. Morgan, Esq. (Closing Argument, Oct 1, 2026)

  • Context: Respondent counsel clarifying the HOA’s position to ALJ Stone. The Association reframed the dispute from a ban on hard-surface flooring to an enforcement of statutory sound mitigation compliance.
Quote 5: Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law in ALJ Decision

"Petitioner’s reliance on ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 33-1221 misplaced, as the section B of the statute requires the owner to 'eliminate or minimize the potential disturbance' on adjacent neighbors. Despite numerous requests from the Association, Petitioner has yet to provide ANY specifications to the Association, or this tribunal for that matter, that he eliminated or minimized any potential disturbances for his neighbors. Because of this, there is no way to know if Petitioner’s flooring is appropriate." — ALJ Adam D. Stone (Administrative Law Judge Decision, Oct 16, 2026)

  • Context: The decisive legal conclusion from ALJ Stone's final ruling. It articulates why the petitioner failed to satisfy his legal burden of proof, establishing that statutory rights under A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) are contingent upon proving sound mitigation.

Actionable Insights & Strategic Takeaways

For Homeowners & Condominium Unit Owners
  1. Statutory Mandates Supercede CC&R Silence: Even if a condominium's CC&Rs permit interior alterations without prior board approval, state statutes (such as A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)) grant HOAs statutory oversight regarding noise transference. Unit owners installing hard flooring in multi-story buildings must verify sound compliance regardless of CC&R phrasing.
  2. Preserve Installation Specifications: Owners must retain technical documentation for all interior alterations, specifically underlayment acoustic ratings (e.g., Sound Transmission Class [STC] and Impact Insulation Class [IIC] ratings), material receipts, and contractor agreements.
  3. Proactive Cooperation Prevents Escalation: Refusing HOA inspection requests or withholding material data shifts the legal burden unfavorably onto the owner during dispute resolution. Demonstrating compliance early prevents costly administrative proceedings and real estate transaction delays.
For Homeowners Associations & Board Directors
  1. Shift Focus from Prohibition to Verification: Under amended A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), total bans on second-floor hard flooring are unenforceable if an owner installs effective acoustic underlayment. Boards should adopt clear, objective acoustic guidelines (STC/IIC standards) rather than blanket prohibitions.
  2. Maintain Consistent Enforcement Protocols: Monitoring public MLS listing photos for unapproved modifications is a recognized enforcement mechanism, provided the HOA applies inspection and correction protocols uniformly across all units without levying arbitrary penalties prior to due process.
  3. Offer Pre-Approved Architectural Guidelines: Establishing and publishing clear acoustic underlayment requirements online streamline compliance for unit owners, reducing legal exposure and friction during property sales.

Comprehensive Study Guide: Condominium Governance, Statutory Interpretation, and Administrative Dispute Resolution

This study guide provides an exhaustive analysis of the legal, statutory, and administrative dispute between unit owner Braylon Hanson and the Casabella Condominium Association (Braylon Hanson v. Casabella Condominium Association, Docket No. 26F-H100-REL). It covers foundational concepts of Homeowners Association (HOA) governance, the interplay between recorded Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), Association Rules, state statutes (specifically Arizona Revised Statutes Title 33), and the formal administrative hearing process before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).


1. Key Concepts & Critical Analysis

A. Case Overview & Factual Background
  • Subject Property: 10101 N. Arabian Trail, Unit 2037, Scottsdale, AZ 85258 (a second-floor unit situated above downstairs residents).
  • Petitioner: Braylon Hanson, a unit owner, licensed Arizona real estate agent, and content creator residing in Kennewick, Washington.
  • Respondent: Casabella Condominium Association, a Scottsdale condominium community managed by Associated Asset Management (AAM) / APM, represented by legal counsel Christina N. Morgan, Esq., of VF Law (Vial Fotheringham, LLP).
  • Core Dispute: In March–April 2023, Hanson installed Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) hard-surface flooring throughout Unit 2037 without requesting prior architectural approval from the Association. When the unit was listed for sale on the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) in December 2025, the Association identified the hard flooring via listing photographs and issued a notice of non-compliance/violation. The Association demanded floor removal, replacement, or proof of compliance with sound mitigation standards under threat of monetary fines.

B. Principal Entities and Roles
Entity / PersonRole / TitleKey Actions & Testimony
Braylon HansonPetitioner / Unit Owner (Unit 2037)Installed LVP flooring in April 2023; filed ADRE petition challenging HOA enforcement based on CC&R § 4.3(B) and A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1). Refused to provide flooring/underlayment specifications or submit to inspection.
Casabella Condominium AssociationRespondent / Condominium HOAIssued non-compliance notice; asserted authority under CC&R Section 6.2, Section 3.8(E), Section 4.17, and A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) to mandate sound-transmission compliance for second-floor hard flooring.
Christina N. Morgan, Esq. (VF Law)Respondent’s Legal CounselAuthored the March 11, 2026 appeal denial letter; represented the HOA at the OAH hearing; argued A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) overrides conflicting CC&Rs and requires sound mitigation proof.
Robert ("Bob") GelinasPetitioner’s Authorized Representative & Witness (Unit 2036)Neighbor who represented Hanson at the January 29, 2026 Board appeal meeting; testified that HOA Rules restricting interior unit flooring exceed Board jurisdiction over Common Elements.
Terrance ("Terry") ChadedockHOA Board Director & Architectural Committee MemberTestified for the HOA; explained historical policy banning second-floor hard flooring since 1999 conversion, updated acoustic guidelines adopted in 2024 under A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), and lack of fines levied against Hanson.
Regina GoodwinHOA Community ManagerHandled non-compliance notices and repeatedly requested flooring specifications and inspection access from Hanson.
Adam D. StoneAdministrative Law Judge (ALJ)Presided over OAH Docket No. 26F-H100-REL; authored the October 16, 2026 decision denying Hanson's petition.

C. Statutory and Contractual Framework Comparison

The legal conflict centered on three competing sources of authority: recorded CC&Rs, Association Rules & Regulations, and the Arizona Condominium Act (A.R.S. Title 33).

“ +-------------------------------------------------------+ | Arizona State Statutes | | A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1) & § 33-1221(B) [HB 2141] | +---------------------------+---------------------------+ | v +-------------------------------------------------------+ | Casabella Declaration (CC&Rs) | | Section 2.1(A) - Unit Boundaries / Finished Flooring | | Section 4.3(B) - Nonstructural Alterations | | Section 6.2 - Rulemaking Authority | +---------------------------+---------------------------+ | v +-------------------------------------------------------+ | Casabella Rules & Regulations / Guidelines | | Page 6: Flooring Restrictions (Second Floor) | | 2024/2025 Proposed Acoustic & Sound Standards | +-------------------------------------------------------+ “

1. Declaration of Condominium (CC&Rs)
  • Section 2.1(A) [Unit Boundaries]: Establishes that finished flooring, wallboard, paint, and interior decorated surfaces constitute part of the individual Unit, whereas structural elements belong to Common Elements or Limited Common Elements.
  • Section 4.3(B) [Nonstructural Improvements]: Explicitly provides that "Any Unit Owner may make nonstructural additions, alterations and improvements within his Unit without the prior written approval of the Board…" provided the owner remains responsible for damages resulting from such alterations.
  • Section 3.8(E) [Easement in Favor of Association]: Grants the HOA an easement to enter Units at reasonable times and upon reasonable notice to verify compliance with Condominium Documents.
  • Section 6.2 [Rules]: Authorizes the Board to adopt rules restricting unit use, provided such rules are not inconsistent with the Declaration or state/federal law.
2. Casabella Rules & Regulations
  • Page 6 (Improvements – Non-Structural): States that while nonstructural interior work generally does not require prior approval, "no hard flooring (tiles, hardwood, laminate, vinyl, etc.) is allowed in the following areas of upstairs units: dining room (not including entry), living room (not including fireplace surrounds) or bedrooms." Furthermore, second-level floor replacements require architectural committee review.
3. Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S. § 33-1221 & House Bill 2141)
  • A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1): Allows unit owners to make improvements or alterations that do not impair structural integrity, mechanical systems, or support.
  • A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) [Enacted via HB 2141; Effective Sept 14, 2024]:

"In addition to allowed modifications as prescribed by subsection A of this section and notwithstanding the condominium documents, the association shall not prohibit a unit owner from improving or altering the interior of the unit in a manner that may disturb adjacent unit occupants if the unit owner purchases and installs at the unit owner's own expense any reasonably necessary improved materials, accessories or other adjustments that eliminate or minimize the potential disturbance…"


D. Chronological Timeline of Administrative and Legal Proceedings
DateEvent / ActionDetails & Source Reference
May 22, 1998Recording of Casabella CC&RsDeclaration recorded in Maricopa County Official Records (98-0429408).
1999Condominium ConversionProperty converted from apartment complex to condominiums. Initial rules ban upper-level hard flooring.
March–April 2023Flooring InstallationBraylon Hanson purchases Unit 2037 and installs LVP flooring without notifying the Board.
March 29, 2024Passage of HB 2141Arizona Legislature passes HB 2141 amending A.R.S. § 33-1221 to protect owner rights to install interior hard flooring with sound mitigation.
September 14, 2024Effective Date of HB 2141Statutory amendment (A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)) takes effect statewide.
Late 2024HOA Adopts Acoustic GuidelinesCasabella Board enacts minimum sound specification requirements for second-floor hard flooring.
December 6, 2025MLS ListingHanson lists Unit 2037 for sale; MLS photos disclose hard flooring.
Mid-December 2025Notice of Non-ComplianceHOA sends courtesy violation notice requesting flooring removal or architectural submittal.
December 16, 2025ADR SubmittalHanson submits Architectural Design Approval Form to clear title for sale, noting work is existing.
December 18, 2025ADR DenialHOA rejects the retroactive design request due to lack of flooring/underlayment specifications.
January 29, 2026Executive Board AppealRobert Gelinas represents Hanson at Board meeting, arguing rule exceeds Board jurisdiction.
March 11, 2026Legal Counsel Denial LetterChristina Morgan (VF Law) affirms appeal denial based on A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) sound mitigation authority.
April 6, 2026Filing of ADRE PetitionHanson files formal petition with ADRE (paying $500 filing fee) alleging violation of CC&R § 4.3(B) and A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1).
April 15, 2026HOA Follow-Up RequestHOA manager requests flooring brand, underlayment specifications, and inspection schedule. Hanson ignores request.
August 25, 2026Notice of HearingADRE refers case to OAH; sets evidentiary hearing for October 1, 2026.
September 10, 2026Pre-Hearing OrderALJ Adam D. Stone issues scheduling order setting Google Meet videoconference details.
September 22, 2026Motion OrderALJ orders responses to Hanson’s Motion to Vacate.
September 29, 2026Order Denying MotionsALJ denies Hanson’s Motion to Strike and Vacate Hearing.
October 1, 2026OAH Evidentiary HearingHearing convened via Google Meet before ALJ Stone; testimony taken from Hanson, Gelinas, and Chadedock.
October 16, 2026ALJ Final Decision & OrderALJ Stone rules in favor of Association; denies petition and denies fee reimbursement.

2. Short-Answer Practice Questions & Model Answers

Question 1

What specific provisions of the Casabella CC&Rs and Arizona Revised Statutes did Braylon Hanson cite to support his argument that prior Board approval was not required for installing luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring?

Model Answer:

Hanson relied upon:

  1. Article 4, Section 4.3(B) of the Casabella Declaration (CC&Rs): Stating that any Unit Owner may make nonstructural additions, alterations, and improvements within their Unit without the prior written approval of the Board.
  2. Article 2, Section 2.1(A) of the CC&Rs: Defining finished flooring as part of the individual Unit rather than Common Elements.
  3. A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1): Providing that a unit owner may make any improvements or alterations to their unit that do not impair structural integrity, mechanical systems, or support.

Question 2

How did the Association's legal counsel reconcile the CC&R provision permitting nonstructural alterations without prior approval with the Association's demand for flooring specifications and inspections?

Model Answer:

Legal counsel Christina Morgan argued that while CC&R § 4.3(B) does not require advance approval for nonstructural alterations, A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) applies "notwithstanding the condominium documents." Subsection B allows interior alterations that may disturb adjacent occupants only if the owner installs materials that eliminate or minimize sound transmission. Counsel asserted that A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), alongside CC&R § 3.8(E) (easement to inspect) and CC&R § 4.17 (nuisance provision), grants the HOA statutory authority independent of advance approval requirements to inspect flooring and enforce acoustic mitigation standards.


Question 3

What was Braylon Hanson's argument regarding the legislative history and effective date of House Bill 2141 (A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)), and why did the Administrative Law Judge reject this argument?

Model Answer:

Hanson argued that HB 2141 / A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) went into effect on September 14, 2024, whereas his flooring installation occurred in March–April 2023. He contended that a law enacted in 2024 could not be applied retroactively to govern an installation completed in 2023.

The Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) rejected this reasoning because the dispute and enforcement occurred in 2025–2026. Under A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), an owner seeking to maintain hard flooring that might disturb lower neighbors bears an ongoing obligation to demonstrate that reasonably necessary sound-mitigating materials were installed. Because Hanson refused to provide any specifications showing sound mitigation, he failed to prove compliance under either the statute or community standards active during enforcement.


Question 4

What procedural role did Robert Gelinas play in the dispute, and what key jurisdictional argument did he present during his testimony?

Model Answer:

Robert Gelinas acted as Hanson’s authorized designated representative at the January 29, 2026 Board appeal meeting and testified as a witness at the OAH hearing. Gelinas argued that under CC&R Section 6.2 and Bylaws Section 3.11(A)(vii), the Board’s rulemaking authority is strictly confined to governing the Common Elements. He contended that the Board exceeded its lawful jurisdiction by adopting a Rule restricting interior unit flooring choices, and that any restriction on interior unit modifications represented an illegal, unvoted amendment to the CC&Rs.


Question 5

**Explain the evidentiary burden of proof in an ADRE/OAH administrative hearing and identify who bore this burden in Hanson v. Casabella Condominium Association.**

Model Answer:

Pursuant to Arizona Administrative Code R2-19-119, the Petitioner (Braylon Hanson) bore the burden of proof. The standard of proof is the preponderance of the evidence, meaning the petitioner must present evidence demonstrating that the allegation—that the HOA violated statutes or governing documents—is more probably true than not ("superior evidentiary weight").


Question 6

Why did ALJ Adam D. Stone rule against Hanson, despite acknowledging that CC&R § 4.3(B) allows nonstructural alterations without prior written approval?

Model Answer:

ALJ Stone concluded that Hanson's reliance on A.R.S. § 33-1221 was misplaced. While A.R.S. § 33-1221(A) and CC&R § 4.3(B) permit nonstructural alterations, A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) conditions the right to install hard surface interior flooring on the owner eliminating or minimizing potential noise disturbances to adjacent occupants. Because Hanson consistently refused to provide flooring brand details, underlayment ratings, or allow an inspection, he failed to present any evidence proving his floor was acoustically compliant. Consequently, he failed to satisfy his burden of proof, validating the HOA's Notice of Violation.


Question 7

Describe the history of hard flooring rules at Casabella as testified by Board Director Terrance Chadedock.

Model Answer:

Chadedock testified that Casabella was an apartment complex converted to condominiums in 1999. Since conversion, the community rules prohibited hard flooring in specified upper-level areas (living room, dining room, bedrooms) to prevent noise transference. Following the 2024 passage of A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), the Board adapted its policy in good faith to allow second-floor hard flooring, provided owners submit acoustic documentation meeting minimum sound specifications (STC/IIC noise ratings). He noted four to five other upper-level units successfully installed hard flooring after providing proof of proper underlayment.


Question 8

What financial remedy was awarded (or denied) in the final Order issued by the Office of Administrative Hearings on October 16, 2026?

Model Answer:

ALJ Stone denied Hanson’s petition in its entirety. Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), because Hanson did not prevail, the Order mandated that the Association was not required to reimburse Hanson's $500.00 petition filing fee. No civil penalties or fines were awarded to either party.


3. Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Essay Prompt 1: Statutory Preemption and the Evolution of HOA Governance

Prompt: Analyze the tension between recorded CC&Rs, association-adopted Rules, and state legislation as highlighted in Hanson v. Casabella Condominium Association. Specifically, evaluate the legal impact of the clause "notwithstanding the condominium documents" contained in A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) (HB 2141). How does this statutory language alter traditional real estate contract principles regarding recorded CC&Rs, and what are the practical implications for condominium boards seeking to regulate interior unit alterations versus unit owners asserting property rights?

Key Structural Guidance for Essay:
  • Contractual Foundation: Explain how CC&Rs represent a binding contract between property owners and the association, established upon recording under A.R.S. Title 33.
  • Statutory Preemption: Examine the phrase "notwithstanding the condominium documents." Discuss how state police power allows the legislature to override private restrictive covenants to address public policy issues (e.g., preventing HOAs from banning hard flooring when acoustic underlayment technology can mitigate noise).
  • The Dual Obligation: Detail how A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) creates a reciprocal standard: HOAs cannot outright ban hard flooring, but unit owners cannot alter interior floors without installing "reasonably necessary improved materials" to protect downstairs neighbors from noise nuisance.
  • Application to Case: Critique Hanson's argument that the Board lacked jurisdiction over interior unit spaces under CC&R § 6.2, contrasted against the statutory mandate of A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) that extends association oversight to sound transmission impacts.

Essay Prompt 2: Evidentiary Strategy and Administrative Procedure

Prompt: Evaluate the administrative hearing process before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH). Focus on the tactical errors and evidentiary omissions committed by the Petitioner that led to the dismissal of his petition. Discuss how the outcome might have differed had the Petitioner submitted acoustic rating specifications (e.g., Impact Insulation Class or Sound Transmission Class ratings) or consented to an independent HOA inspection under CC&R Section 3.8(E).

Key Structural Guidance for Essay:
  • Burden of Proof & Evidentiary Standard: Reiterate that the petitioner bears the burden under the preponderance of the evidence standard (A.A.C. R2-19-119).
  • Analysis of Petitioner's Trial Strategy: Discuss Hanson's strategy of relying strictly on a legal argument (that no prior approval was required under CC&R § 4.3(B)) while withholding all factual evidence regarding the physical floor and underlayment.
  • The Impact of Non-Cooperation: Analyze how Hanson’s refusal to answer questions regarding underlayment, floor manufacturer, or inspection allowed the ALJ to draw negative inferences and conclude that compliance with A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) was unproven.
  • Role of Expert/Technical Evidence: Explain how acoustic ratings (STC/IIC) operate in architectural disputes and why presenting technical evidence of sound mitigation is essential when challenging an architectural violation under state condominium law.

Essay Prompt 3: Prospective vs. Retroactive Application of Statutory Amendments in Property Disputes

Prompt: Examine the legal principles governing the retroactive application of statutory amendments in residential property disputes. Contrast Braylon Hanson's argument—that A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) (effective September 14, 2024) could not apply to a flooring installation completed in April 2023—with the legal position adopted by the Association and affirmed by the OAH tribunal. Discuss how ongoing real estate compliance and unapproved unrecorded alterations impact this legal analysis.

Key Structural Guidance for Essay:
  • The Retroactivity Standard: Define general legal principles regarding the non-retroactivity of statutes unless expressly declared by the legislature.
  • Static Act vs. Ongoing Condition: Distinguish between a completed, fully permitted past act and an unapproved, concealed interior alteration that creates an ongoing potential nuisance (noise transference) discovered during a subsequent real estate transaction (2025 MLS listing).
  • Statutory Interplay: Analyze how A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1) (in effect prior to 2024) and A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) interact. Show that even prior to HB 2141, unit modifications were subject to general nuisance provisions (CC&R § 4.17) and structural/support limitations.
  • Practical Synthesis: Conclude whether an association’s enforcement action initiated in 2025–2026 is governed by the statutory framework active at the time of enforcement or at the time of uninspected installation.

4. Glossary of Important Terms

“ +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | GLOSSARY INDEX | | 1. A.R.S. § 33-1221 7. General Counsel | | 2. Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) 8. House Bill 2141 (HB 2141) | | 3. Architectural Design Request 9. Nonstructural Improvements | | 4. Covenants, Conditions & Rest. 10. Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) | | 5. Declaration of Condominium 11. Preponderance of the Evidence | | 6. Easement for Inspection 12. Sound Transmission Mitigation | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

  1. A.R.S. § 33-1221 (Arizona Revised Statutes § 33-1221): The core statutory provision within the Arizona Condominium Act governing alterations of units. Subsection A allows nonstructural alterations; Subsection B (added 2024) prohibits HOAs from banning interior modifications (including hard flooring) if the owner installs reasonably necessary materials to minimize disturbance to adjacent occupants.
  2. Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): An independent judicial officer appointed pursuant to A.R.S. § 41-1092 to preside over contested administrative cases, evaluate evidence, conduct hearings, and issue binding decisions or findings of fact and conclusions of law.
  3. Architectural Design Request (ADR) / Architectural Design Approval Form: The formal application submitted by a unit owner to an HOA architectural committee seeking written permission to perform modifications, additions, or structural/nonstructural alterations to a unit.
  4. Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs): The recorded legal document establishing the rights, restrictions, duties, and obligations of unit owners and the homeowners association within a planned community or condominium development.
  5. Declaration of Condominium: The legal instrument recorded in county land records that officially creates the condominium regime, defines unit boundaries, allocates common element ownership percentages, and establishes community governance structures.
  6. Easement for Inspection (CC&R Section 3.8(E)): A legal right granted to the Association, its officers, and agents to enter individual units at reasonable times and upon reasonable notice to verify compliance with condominium documents and statutory requirements.
  7. General Counsel: Legal representation retained by an HOA Board (in this case, VF Law / Christina N. Morgan, Esq.) to advise on community governance, interpret governing documents, draft legal correspondence, and defend the HOA in administrative or judicial proceedings.
  8. House Bill 2141 (HB 2141): Legislation sponsored by Representative Laurin Hendrix, passed by the Arizona Legislature on March 29, 2024, and effective September 14, 2024. It amended A.R.S. § 33-1221 to protect condominium owners' rights to alter unit interiors and install hard flooring, provided sound transference mitigation is implemented.
  9. Nonstructural Improvements: Additions, alterations, or cosmetic changes made within the physical boundaries of a unit (e.g., paint, wall coverings, finished flooring) that do not impact the load-bearing walls, structural integrity, mechanical systems, or physical support of the building.
  10. Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH): An independent Arizona state agency authorized under A.R.S. § 41-1092 et seq. to hold evidentiary hearings for state regulatory bodies, including HOA disputes referred by the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).
  11. Preponderance of the Evidence: The standard of proof required in administrative civil proceedings. It demands that the party bearing the burden of proof establish that their claim is more probably true than not, based on the convincing force and superior weight of the evidence presented.
  12. Sound Transmission Mitigation / Acoustic Standards: Engineering measures, underlayment materials, and noise insulation products designed to reduce impact sound (e.g., footfalls) and airborne sound between multi-story condominium units to prevent nuisance to adjacent occupants.

Hardwood, Rules, and Rights: Lessons from an Arizona HOA Flooring Dispute

Catchy Introduction: The $500 Flooring Battle

A simple home interior upgrade can quickly escalate into an administrative legal battle when an owner’s modification rights clash with an association’s statutory sound mitigation authority. In early 2023, unit owner Braylon Hanson purchased a second-floor condominium (Unit 2037) at Casabella Condominiums in Scottsdale, Arizona, and promptly hired a contractor to remove the carpet and install Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) flooring throughout the unit. Over two years passed without incident until December 2025, when Hanson listed the property for sale. Upon inspecting public Multiple Listing Service (MLS) photographs, the Homeowners Association (HOA) identified the unapproved hard-surface flooring and issued a formal violation notice—bringing transaction negotiations to a sudden halt. Notably, Hanson was not an uninformed buyer; he held an active Arizona real estate license and worked as a realtor and content creator. Yet, his reliance on standard Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) language failed to account for complex state statutory provisions.

Adding to the tension was the property's physical build: as long-time Board Member Terrance Chadedock testified at trial, Casabella was originally constructed as an apartment complex before being converted into condominiums in 1999. Because the multi-family structure lacked thick inter-floor concrete pours, sound transmission between upper and lower units had been a high-priority operational concern since the community's inception. What began as a routine interior remodel transformed into an administrative evidentiary hearing before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) over a $500 filing fee, creating a crucial precedent on how Arizona law balances homeowner alteration rights against association noise regulations.


The Core Conflict: Owner Rights vs. Association Authority

The legal dispute, adjudicated under OAH Docket No. 26F-H100-REL, framed a sharp conflict between contractual CC&R interpretation, statutory preemption, and the scope of association rulemaking.

Legal Positions & Governing References
Homeowner's Position (Braylon Hanson & Representative Robert Gelinas)Association's Position (Casabella Condominium Association & Attorney Christina N. Morgan)
Nonstructural Right to Alter: Claimed CC&R Article 4, Section 4.3(B) and A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1) grant explicit rights to unit owners to make nonstructural interior alterations—including finished floor coverings—without obtaining prior written Board approval.Statutory Sound Mitigation Preemption: Maintained that even if advance written approval is not strictly mandated under CC&Rs, A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) grants the HOA statutory authority "notwithstanding the condominium documents" to enforce sound mitigation standards preventing noise disturbances to lower units.
Rulemaking Limitations to Common Elements: Argued that the HOA board's rule banning hard flooring in upstairs dining, living, and bedroom areas exceeded its regulatory jurisdiction under CC&R Section 6.2, which restricts association rulemaking authority strictly to the Common Elements.Inspection Rights & Nuisance Enforcement: Pointed out that under CC&R Section 3.8(E) (granting inspection easements) and Section 4.17 (prohibiting nuisances and offensive activity), the HOA possessed the legal right to inspect the unit and demand acoustic proof after Hanson repeatedly refused to provide floor or underlayment specifications.
Non-Retroactivity of Statute: Contended that A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)—enacted via House Bill 2141 in September 2024—could not be applied retroactively to invalidate or regulate an LVP flooring installation completed in Spring 2023.Conditional Statutory Safe Harbor: Asserted that statutory noise prevention requirements apply independently of CC&R prior-approval clauses, meaning an owner is only protected from HOA flooring prohibitions if they actively present evidence of installed acoustic mitigation materials.

Timeline of Events: From Installation to Administrative Hearing

  • March – April 2023: Hanson purchases Unit 2037 at Casabella Condominiums and hires a contractor to replace interior carpet with LVP flooring throughout the second-floor unit.
  • December 6–16, 2025: Hanson lists the unit for sale on the MLS. The HOA discovers the hard-surface flooring in listing photos and issues a notice of non-compliance. In response, Hanson submits a reactive Architectural Design Approval Request (ADR) form to document the existing flooring and protect the pending escrow.
  • December 18, 2025 – January 29, 2026: The HOA Architectural Committee denies Hanson's reactive ADR request on December 18. Hanson appeals, and his authorized representative, neighbor Robert Gelinas, presents the case to the Board of Directors in Executive Session on January 29, 2026.
  • March 11, 2026: HOA legal counsel (Christina N. Morgan of VF Law) issues a formal denial letter upholding the violation. Citing A.R.S. § 33-1221(B), CC&R Section 3.8(E), and CC&R Section 4.17, counsel requests manufacturer specifications, acoustic ratings, and access for an inside acoustic inspection.
  • April 6, 2026: Hanson files an HOA Petition Request Form with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE), paying the $500 filing fee to challenge the HOA's enforcement actions under A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1) and CC&R Section 4.3(B).
  • October 1, 2026: An evidentiary hearing convenes before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Adam D. Stone via Google Meet, featuring testimony from Hanson, representative Robert Gelinas, Board Member Terrance Chadedock, and HOA counsel Christina N. Morgan.
  • October 16, 2026: ALJ Stone issues a final Administrative Law Judge Decision denying Hanson's petition in its entirety and ruling in favor of Casabella Condominium Association.

The Ruling: Why the Administrative Law Judge Ruled for the HOA

In his October 16, 2026 decision, Administrative Law Judge Adam D. Stone systematically rejected the petitioner’s legal arguments, illustrating how statutory sound mitigation duties override basic nonstructural modification clauses.

Procedural Law: Burden of Proof

Under A.R.S. § 32-2199 and A.A.C. R2-19-119, the petitioner in an administrative HOA dispute bears the burden of proving an alleged violation by a preponderance of the evidence. To prevail, Hanson was required to demonstrate that the association acted outside its legal authority when issuing the violation notice.

Substantive Law: Statutory Sound Mitigation & Preemption

ALJ Stone determined that Hanson’s heavy reliance on A.R.S. § 33-1221(A)(1) and CC&R Section 4.3(B) was legally incomplete. In 2024, the Arizona Legislature passed House Bill 2141 (sponsored by Rep. Laurin Hendrix, effective September 14, 2024), adding Subsection B to A.R.S. § 33-1221. This statute was specifically enacted to resolve multi-story flooring disputes across Arizona by establishing a conditional safe harbor.

Crucially, A.R.S. § 33-1221(B) contains the express statutory mandate "notwithstanding the condominium documents." This language ensures that state sound mitigation standards supersede conflicting CC&R provisions or community rules. Under Subsection B, an association cannot prohibit interior alterations that may disturb adjacent occupants only if the unit owner purchases and installs, at their own expense, reasonably necessary materials to eliminate or minimize potential noise transmission. The statute does not grant owners an unconditional right to install hard flooring; rather, it conditions their right on verifiable acoustic mitigation.

Evidentiary Failure: Refusal to Provide Technical Specifications

The petitioner's case collapsed due to a complete absence of technical evidence. During cross-examination, Hanson admitted that he never requested underlayment details from his contractor, did not know the underlayment specifications, and repeatedly refused management and legal counsel's requests for manufacturer data or acoustic test metrics—specifically standard industry metrics such as Sound Transmission Class (STC) and Impact Insulation Class (IIC). Furthermore, Hanson refused to grant the association access to inspect the unit under the inspection easement established in CC&R Section 3.8(E). Because Hanson presented zero evidentiary proof to the tribunal that his LVP installation eliminated or minimized sound disturbances for the lower unit, he failed to satisfy his statutory burden under A.R.S. § 33-1221(B).

The "Reactive ADR" Trap & MLS Disclosures

The ruling also underscored the tactical failure of submitting a "reactive" ADR form. When a seller attempts to retroactively document unapproved work during an active listing, it creates immediate exposure. Under A.R.S. § 33-1260, associations are mandated to disclose unapproved modifications and active violations in pre-escrow resale packages. By submitting an ADR request right before closing without providing supporting STC/IIC technical documentation, Hanson alerted management, triggered mandatory resale disclosure violations, and trapped his own real estate transaction in an administrative standstill.


Key Takeaways for Homeowners and HOAs

  1. Statutes Override CC&Rs via "Notwithstanding" Clauses: Legislative provisions containing terms like "notwithstanding the condominium documents" (such as A.R.S. § 33-1221(B)) take absolute precedence over community CC&Rs. Even if a community declaration allows nonstructural alterations without prior board approval, statutory sound mitigation obligations remain fully enforceable.
  2. Prior Approval vs. Statutory Compliance: The absence of a CC&R requirement for prior written approval does not grant an owner immunity from compliance. Associations retain independent authority under statutory law and general nuisance provisions (e.g., CC&R Section 4.17) to demand post-installation proof of acoustic mitigation.
  3. Technical Documentation and Cooperation Are Essential: In upper-floor hard surface disputes, legal outcomes hinge entirely on objective acoustic data. Homeowners must secure detailed manufacturer spec sheets and verified STC/IIC underlayment ratings prior to installation. Refusing to supply specifications or denying entry under inspection easements (such as CC&R Section 3.8(E)) creates an unwinnable posture in administrative hearings.
  4. MLS Listings and Reactive ADR Submissions Create Escrow Hazards: HOA management teams routinely monitor public MLS photos and virtual marketing tours for unauthorized alterations prior to closing. Submitting a reactive architectural request during active escrow without supporting acoustic data triggers mandatory violation disclosures under A.R.S. § 33-1260, risking transaction delays or cancellation.
  5. Historical Building Context Dictates HOA Rule Enforcement: Multi-family structures converted from apartments to condominiums (such as Casabella's 1999 conversion) often feature subfloor assemblies that easily transmit footfall noise. Owners in converted complexes must recognize that associations will aggressively enforce acoustic mitigation standards to protect lower-unit residents from sound disturbances.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Braylon Hanson (Petitioner)
    Casabella Condominium Association Unit Owner
    Homeowner of Unit 2037 who filed the petition contesting an architectural non-compliance notice regarding interior LVP flooring.
  • Robert Gelinas (Petitioner's Authorized Representative and Witness)
    Casabella Condominium Association Resident
    Neighbor and designated representative for Braylon Hanson who presented the appeal to the HOA board and testified at the OAH hearing.

Respondent Side

  • Christina N. Morgan (Attorney for Respondent)
    Vial Fotheringham, LLP
    Legal counsel representing Casabella Condominium Association in the administrative hearing and prior appeal correspondence.
  • Terrance Chadedock (Board Director and Architectural Committee Member)
    Casabella Condominium Association
    Board member and Architectural Committee member who testified on behalf of Casabella Condominium Association.
  • Regina Goodwin (Community Manager)
    Associated Property Management Inc.
    Management consultant and community manager for Casabella Condominium Association who issued violation notices and handled compliance correspondence.

Neutral Parties

  • Adam D. Stone (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
    Presiding Administrative Law Judge who conducted the evidentiary hearing and issued the administrative law judge decision.
  • Vivian Nunez (HOA Dispute Coordinator)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
    ADRE employee assigned to handle the processing and transmission of the HOA dispute petition.
  • Mandy Neat (Deputy Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
    Deputy Commissioner at the Arizona Department of Real Estate who e-filed the Notice of Hearing.
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
    Commissioner of the Arizona Department of Real Estate.

Thea White vs Encanto Garden Townhouses Association

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H223-HOA
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-10-09
Administrative Law JudgeNedra-Su Kawasaki
OutcomeDefault Decision
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties$0.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerThea WhiteCounsel—
RespondentEncanto Garden Townhouses AssociationCounsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Key Issues & Findings

Respondent denied Petitioner's application for open security bars three times (June 22, July 1, and July 6, 2026), improperly evaluating the request as an enclosed back porch. Respondent relied on alleged police/fire guidance and a grandfathering restriction, but failed to produce supporting documentation despite written requests on July 6 and July 13, 2026.

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H223-HOA Case document – 1478087.pdf

(91.1 KB)

Legal Briefing: Administrative Law Judge Decision (Thea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association)

Executive Summary

On October 9, 2026, Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Nedra-Su Kawasaki of the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) issued a binding decision in Case No. 26F-H223-HOA in favor of Petitioner Thea White against Respondent Encanto Garden Townhouses Association.

The dispute centered on the Association’s repeated improper denials of White’s architectural application to install open security bars at her Phoenix townhouse unit. The Association mischaracterized the application as an enclosed back porch and failed to produce requested documentation supporting its denials (specifically, cited police/fire guidance and a purported grandfathering restriction).

Because Respondent failed to file a required response with the Department of Real Estate by the August 10, 2026 statutory deadline and failed to appear at the October 9, 2026 evidentiary hearing, the tribunal deemed all factual allegations in the Petition admitted pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E). Petitioner was named the prevailing party, and the Association was ordered to reimburse Petitioner’s $500.00 filing fee within 30 days and comply strictly with its governing Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).


Case Reference Summary

ParameterCase Information
TribunalState of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings
Case NumberNo. 26F-H223-HOA
Administrative Law JudgeNedra-Su Kawasaki
Hearing Date / Decision DateOctober 9, 2026
PetitionerThea White (Owner of 2941 North 19th Avenue, Unit 95, Phoenix, AZ 85015)
RespondentEncanto Garden Townhouses Association (c/o Pride Community Management, Chandler, AZ)
Respondent AppearanceNo Appearance (Default)
Statutes in QuestionA.R.S. §§ 33-1242(A), 32-2199, 32-2199.01, 32-2199.02, 41-1092.09
CC&R Provision in QuestionArticle VIII, Section 1 (Architectural Control)
Financial OrderRespondent ordered to pay $500.00 to Petitioner within 30 days

Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

1. Misclassification of Architectural Requests and Lack of Substantiation

The underlying dispute originated from Petitioner’s June 17, 2026 application to install open security bars on her property. The Association’s architectural review process failed on both procedural and substantive grounds:

  • Repeated Mischaracterization: On three separate occasions (June 22, July 1, and July 6, 2026), the Association denied the application by evaluating it as an "enclosed back porch"—a design modification Petitioner never requested nor submitted.
  • Failure to Substantiate Denials: The Association’s first two denials relied on alleged "police and fire guidance concerning enclosed spaces," while the third denial cited an unverified "grandfathering restriction."
  • Refusal to Disclose Governing Documents: Despite formal written requests sent by Petitioner on July 6 and July 13, 2026, the Association failed to produce any written police/fire guidance or any official governing document establishing the cited grandfathering rule.
2. Failure of Notice Response and Statutory Default

Under Arizona law governing condominium associations (A.R.S. § 32-2199.01), legal notices trigger strict response requirements:

  • Service of Process: The Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) sent a Notice of Petition via USPS certified mail on July 21, 2026, to the Association in care of its management entity, Pride Community Management (sent to both P.O. Box 13615, Chandler, AZ 85248 and 2450 S. Gilbert Rd., Ste. 205, Chandler, AZ 85286). Delivery was confirmed via USPS tracking.
  • Mandatory Deadline: The notice required a response form to be returned no later than August 10, 2026.
  • Legal Effect of Default: Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E), failure to respond within the statutory window is deemed an automatic admission of the petition's allegations. The Association failed to submit a response and subsequently failed to appear at the October 9, 2026 evidentiary hearing, despite a 15-minute courtesy delay. Consequently, an Order of Default was established.
3. Balance of HOA Statutory Powers and CC&R Authority

The ruling highlights the legal constraints under which Condominium Associations operate in Arizona:

  • Statutory Framework (A.R.S. § 33-1242(A)): While condominium associations hold powers to adopt bylaws, rules, and exercise governance authority, these powers are explicitly "Subject to the provisions of the declaration."
  • Architectural Review Standard (CC&Rs Article VIII, Section 1): The Association holds the power of written approval regarding building alterations, aesthetics, and harmony with surrounding structures. However, the CC&Rs stipulate that if the Association fails to approve or act upon submitted plans within thirty (30) days, approval is no longer required, and the article is deemed fully complied with (provided modifications do not exceed original square footage).
  • Tribunal Authority Limits (A.R.S. § 32-2199.02): The ALJ is statutory empowered to order compliance with community documents and levy civil penalties for violations, but is explicitly restricted from ordering unrelated remediation or civil penalties outside the statutory scope.

Important Quotes with Context

1. On the Association's Evaluation Failures

Quote: "On June 22, July 1, and July 6, 2026, Respondent three times denied Petitioner’s June 17, 2026 application for open security bars; each denial evaluated the request as an enclosed back porch, a design Petitioner never submitted; the first two denials relied on police and fire guidance concerning enclosed spaces, and the third asserted a grandfathering restriction…"

  • Context: Excerpted from Findings of Fact (Paragraph 3), detailing Petitioner's initial claim regarding the Association's improper review methodology and unsubstantiated claim rejections.
2. On Association Powers Under Arizona Law

Quote: "A.R.S. § 33-1242(A) provides as follows, in pertinent part: 1. Subject to the provisions of the declaration, the association may: 1. Adopt and amend bylaws and rules… 16. Exercise any other powers conferred by the declaration or bylaws…"

  • Context: Referenced Statutes (Paragraph 12), establishing that statutory administrative authority granted to HOAs remains secondary and subordinate to the association's recorded Declaration (CC&Rs).
3. On CC&R Architectural Approval Provisions

Quote: "If the Association fails to approve or [illegible] such plans and specifications within thirty (30) days after submission thereof, approval will not be required and this ARTICLE will be deemed to have been fully complied with…"

  • Context: Excerpt from Article VIII, Section 1 of the Encanto Garden Townhouses Association CC&Rs, defining the 30-day decision deadline imposed on the architectural committee.
4. On Mandatory Default Judgments

Quote: "Failure of the respondent to answer is deemed an admission of the allegations made in the petition, and the commissioner shall issue a default decision."

  • Context: Conclusions of Law (Paragraph 2, citing A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E)), providing the statutory mandate used by ALJ Kawasaki to deem all of Petitioner's claims admitted due to the Association's failure to respond by August 10, 2026.

Actionable Insights & Compliance Takeaways

  1. Strict Adherence to Administrative Deadlines:
  • Property management entities (such as Pride Community Management) and HOA Boards must establish immediate intake protocols for certified mail received from state regulators. Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(C) & (E), missing a 20-day response window leads to an unappealable admission of all factual allegations via default.
  1. Evidentiary Support Requirement for Denials:
  • Architectural review boards cannot base application denials on unwritten rules, vague authority, or unrelated third-party guidelines. If an HOA cites external constraints (e.g., police/fire codes) or internal rules (e.g., grandfathering clauses), it must produce the written documentation upon member request.
  1. Accurate Review of Architectural Submissions:
  • Review bodies must evaluate plans strictly as submitted. Misclassifying an application (such as treating open security bars as an enclosed porch) constitutes arbitrary governance and violates standard CC&R architectural control provisions.
  1. Financial and Legal Liability for Non-Compliance:
  • A prevailing owner in an ADRE dispute is entitled to recover filing fees. Respondent Encanto Garden Townhouses Association is bound by court order to pay $500.00 directly to Petitioner within 30 days of October 9, 2026.
  1. Post-Decision Rehearing Procedure:
  • Pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(B) and A.R.S. § 41-1092.09, the ALJ decision is legally binding. Any party seeking a rehearing must file a formal request with the Commissioner of the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) within 30 days of the service of the Order.

Case Study Guide: Thea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association (Case No. 26F-H223-HOA)


Section 1: Executive Summary & Key Concepts

This study guide provides an exhaustive analysis of the administrative hearing decision in Case No. 26F-H223-HOA (Thea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association), adjudicated by Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Nedra-Su Kawasaki for the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) at the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).

Case Overview Reference
ParameterCase Details
Case NameThea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association
Docket / Case NumberNo. 26F-H223-HOA
Adjudicating ForumOffice of Administrative Hearings (OAH), State of Arizona
Administrative Law JudgeNedra-Su Kawasaki
PetitionerThea White (Homeowner & Association Member)
Petitioner Location2941 North 19th Avenue, Unit 95, Phoenix, AZ 85015
RespondentEncanto Garden Townhouses Association (Condominium Association)
Respondent ManagementPride Community Management (P.O. Box 13615 & 2450 S. Gilbert Rd., Ste. 205, Chandler, AZ)
Hearing DateOctober 9, 2026
Respondent AppearanceNo Appearance (Default)
Key IssuesArbitrary application denials, failure to produce supporting documentation, default under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E)
OutcomeJudgment for Petitioner; $500 filing fee reimbursed; Respondent ordered to comply with CC&Rs

Factual and Procedural Timeline

“ [June 17, 2026] --- Petitioner submits application for open security bars. │ [June 22 – July 6, 2026] --- Respondent denies application 3 times (treating it as an "enclosed back porch"). │ [July 6 & July 13, 2026] --- Petitioner makes written requests for supporting police/fire/governing documents. │ [July 17, 2026] --- Petitioner pays $500 fee and files Petition with ADRE. │ [July 21, 2026] --- ADRE mails Notice of Petition via USPS Certified Mail to Respondent. │ [August 10, 2026] --- Deadline for Respondent's Response Form (Respondent fails to respond). │ [October 9, 2026] --- Hearing held (Respondent fails to appear); ALJ issues Decision finding for Petitioner. “

  1. June 17, 2026: Petitioner (Thea White) submits an architectural application for the installation of open security bars at her unit (2941 North 19th Avenue, Unit 95, Phoenix, AZ).
  2. June 22, July 1, and July 6, 2026: Respondent (Encanto Garden Townhouses Association) denies Petitioner's application three separate times.
  • First two denials: Evaluated the request as an "enclosed back porch" (a design Petitioner never submitted) and relied on alleged police and fire guidance regarding enclosed spaces.
  • Third denial: Asserted an unwritten "grandfathering restriction."
  1. July 6 and July 13, 2026: Petitioner submits two written requests asking Respondent to produce the police and fire guidance or any governing documents establishing the alleged grandfathering restriction. Respondent produces neither.
  2. July 17, 2026: Petitioner pays the $500.00 filing fee and submits a formal Petition to the Arizona Department of Real Estate alleging violations of A.R.S. § 33-1242(A) and Declaration CC&Rs Article VIII, Section 1.
  3. July 21, 2026: ADRE sends the Notice of Petition via USPS Certified Mail to Respondent, in care of Pride Community Management, at two separate Chandler, AZ addresses.
  4. August 10, 2026: Statutory deadline for Respondent to submit a written response. Respondent fails to submit any response form.
  5. October 9, 2026: OAH conducts the evidentiary hearing. The hearing is delayed 15 minutes, but no representative appears for Respondent. Petitioner testifies; Administrative Notice is taken of the ADRE Hearing File.
  6. October 9, 2026: ALJ issues the final Order declaring Petitioner the prevailing party, ordering $500 reimbursement, and directing Respondent to comply with CC&R requirements.

Statutory and Governing Document Framework
1. Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) Title 33 & Title 32 Provisions
  • A.R.S. § 33-1242(A) (Powers of Condominium Association): Establishes that the powers of a condominium association (such as adopting/amending rules or exercising powers conferred by bylaws) are explicitly subject to the provisions of the declaration. Powers exercised must align with the governing CC&Rs.
  • A.R.S. § 32-2199: Grants Administrative Law Judges the legal authority to adjudicate disputes and ensure compliance with Title 33, Chapter 9 (Condominiums), and related condominium documents.
  • A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 (Petitions & Response Requirements):
  • Subsection A: Allows unit owners or associations to petition the ADRE regarding violations of condominium documents or statutes upon paying a filing fee.
  • Subsection C: Requires ADRE to serve the respondent via certified mail, granting 20 days from mailing to file an answer showing cause.
  • Subsection E: Mandates that a respondent's failure to answer is deemed an admission of the allegations made in the petition, requiring the commissioner to issue a default decision.
  • A.R.S. § 32-2199.02 (Scope of Remedies): Authorizes the ALJ to order any party to abide by the statutory or contract provision at issue and levy civil penalties per violation. It explicitly limits tribunal authority by stating the Tribunal is not authorized to order other remediation or civil penalties for other conduct.
  • A.R.S. §§ 32-2199.02(B), 32-2199.04, & 41-1092.09 (Rehearing Process): Rulings are binding unless a rehearing request is filed with the Commissioner of the Department of Real Estate within 30 days of service.
2. Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs)
  • Article VIII, Section 1 (Architectural Control):
  • Approval Mandate: No improvement, building, fence, wall, or structure may be commenced or maintained without written plans/specifications detailing shape, height, materials, floor plans, location, and cost submitted to and approved in writing by the Association.
  • Discretionary Standard: The Association can deny approval for aesthetic or other reasons, considering harmony/conformity with surrounding buildings and visibility from neighboring properties.
  • The 30-Day Failure Clause: If the Association fails to approve or act upon submitted plans within thirty (30) days after submission, prior written approval is no longer required, and the article is legally deemed fully complied with.
  • Square Footage Limitation: No unit owner is permitted under any circumstances to make additions or changes exceeding the original square footage of the residence.

Section 2: Short-Answer Practice Questions

Questions
  1. What specific design modification did Petitioner Thea White apply for on June 17, 2026, and how did Respondent mischaracterize it in their denials?
  2. What were the specific reasons provided by Respondent during its three denials of Petitioner's application?
  3. What statutory consequence occurs under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E) when a respondent fails to file a response form within the required timeframe?
  4. Who was the management company handling communications for Respondent, and to what addresses was the Notice of Petition delivered?
  5. How long did the Office of Administrative Hearings delay the October 9, 2026 hearing before proceeding in Respondent's absence?
  6. According to CC&Rs Article VIII, Section 1, what happens if the Association fails to approve or act on plans within thirty (30) days of submission?
  7. What exact monetary relief did the ALJ award to Petitioner, and what is the required timeline for payment?
  8. What limitation does A.R.S. § 32-2199.02 place on the Administrative Law Judge’s remedial authority?
  9. What is the deadline and procedure for a party seeking a rehearing of the ALJ’s Decision?
  10. Under A.R.S. § 33-1242(A), what primary constraint governs an association's exercise of its statutory powers?

Answer Key
  1. Petitioner's Application vs. Respondent's Mischaracterization:

Petitioner applied for open security bars. Respondent repeatedly mischaracterized and evaluated the application as an enclosed back porch, a design Petitioner never requested.

  1. Reasons Provided for Application Denials:
  • Denials 1 & 2: Cited external police and fire guidance regarding enclosed spaces.
  • Denial 3: Asserted an unwritten "grandfathering restriction."
  1. Statutory Consequence of Failing to Answer (A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E)):

The failure to answer is statutorily deemed an admission of all allegations set forth in the Petition, requiring the entry of a default decision against the respondent.

  1. Management Company and Service Addresses:

Respondent was managed by Pride Community Management. Notice of Petition was sent via USPS Certified Mail to:

  • P.O. Box 13615, Chandler, AZ 85248
  • 2450 S. Gilbert Rd., Ste. 205, Chandler, AZ 85286
  1. Hearing Delay Duration:

The OAH delayed the hearing by 15 minutes past the scheduled start time before starting proceedings without Respondent.

  1. The 30-Day Clause in CC&Rs Article VIII, Section 1:

If the Association fails to approve or act upon submitted plans within 30 days, formal approval is no longer required, and the unit owner is deemed to be in full compliance with Article VIII.

  1. Monetary Award and Payment Timeline:

Respondent was ordered to pay Petitioner directly the $500.00 filing fee within thirty (30) days of the Order.

  1. Statutory Remedial Limitation (A.R.S. § 32-2199.02):

The tribunal is strictly authorized to order compliance with statutes, governing documents, or contract provisions and levy civil penalties per violation. It is not authorized to award other forms of remediation or civil penalties for uncharged conduct.

  1. Rehearing Deadline and Procedure:

A party must file a written request for rehearing with the Commissioner of the Department of Real Estate within 30 days of service of the Order, pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 32-2199.04 and 41-1092.09.

  1. Constraint on Association Powers (A.R.S. § 33-1242(A)):

An association's broad statutory powers (e.g., rule-making, adopting bylaws, legal governance) are explicitly subject to the provisions of the declaration (CC&Rs).


Section 3: Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Essay Prompt 1: Administrative Default and Due Process in HOA Dispute Resolution

Prompt: Analyze the legal and procedural consequences of Respondent’s failure to file an answer and appear at the administrative hearing under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01. Discuss how statutory default provisions balance administrative efficiency with due process considerations for condominium unit owners and associations.

  • Key Points to Cover:
  • Define the requirement under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(C) (20-day response window following certified mail notice).
  • Analyze A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E), which transforms non-response into a legal admission of all alleged factual claims (arbitrary application denials, failure to produce governing rules, evaluation of unsubmitted designs).
  • Discuss the role of evidentiary procedures (taking Administrative Notice of the ADRE file, delaying 15 minutes to allow for tardiness) to ensure minimum procedural due process before issuing a default judgment.
  • Evaluate how default mechanisms prevent associations or homeowners from stalling administrative dispute resolution processes.

Essay Prompt 2: Arbitrary Architectural Governance and Statutory Authority

Prompt: Section 33-1242(A) of the Arizona Revised Statutes mandates that an association's statutory powers are "subject to the provisions of the declaration." Evaluate how Encanto Garden Townhouses Association breached both its governing CC&Rs (Article VIII, Section 1) and state statutes through its review process of Thea White’s application.

  • Key Points to Cover:
  • Detail the discrepancy between White’s actual submission (open security bars) and the Association’s evaluation basis (enclosed back porch).
  • Examine the duty of an HOA to base architectural rejections on clear, documented guidelines rather than unsubstantiated claims (e.g., failure to produce requested police/fire guidance or written grandfathering rules after two formal requests).
  • Interpret Article VIII, Section 1 discretionary standards (harmony, aesthetic, conformity) vs. arbitrary/capricious enforcement.
  • Discuss the interaction between A.R.S. § 33-1242(A) and CC&R compliance, demonstrating why an association acts ultra vires when rejecting applications outside the procedural rules established in its declaration.

Essay Prompt 3: Scope of Administrative Remedies in Condominium Disputes

Prompt: Examine the limits of administrative enforcement under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02. Discuss what remedies the Administrative Law Judge was statutorily authorized to grant, what remedies were excluded, and the practical implications for prevailing petitioners seeking full relief.

  • Key Points to Cover:
  • Detail the specific statutory authorization under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02 (ordering compliance, levying per-violation civil penalties, restoring filing fees).
  • Contrast allowed remedies with explicit statutory restrictions ("This Tribunal is not authorized to order other remediation or order civil penalties for other conduct").
  • Analyze the specific mandates of ALJ Kawasaki’s final Order ($500 fee reimbursement within 30 days and direction to comply with CC&Rs).
  • Discuss the practical effectiveness of an administrative compliance order when an HOA management company fails to participate in proceedings.

Section 4: Key Terms Glossary

“ ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ GLOSSARY │ └─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ “

  1. Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): A judicial official who presides over administrative hearings, evaluates testimony and documentary evidence, and issues binding findings of fact, conclusions of law, and orders. (e.g., Nedra-Su Kawasaki).
  2. Administrative Notice: A rule of evidence permitting a judge to accept as factually true established official records or publicly verifiable documents without requiring formal independent proof (e.g., taking administrative notice of the ADRE Hearing File).
  3. A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq.: The statutory framework within the Arizona Revised Statutes authorizing the Department of Real Estate and OAH to hear, adjudicate, and enforce compliance regarding condominium and planned community governance disputes.
  4. A.R.S. § 33-1242(A): The Arizona statute governing condominium association powers, establishing that all association actions, bylaws, and rule enforcement remain strictly subordinate to the community’s recorded declaration.
  5. Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs): The recorded legal document establishing the rules, architectural controls, rights, and restrictions binding property owners within a specific condominium or planned community development.
  6. Default Decision: A decision issued against a party that fails to submit a required legal answer, pleading, or appearance within a statutorily defined deadline, legally deeming all opponent claims admitted.
  7. Grandfathering Restriction: An exception allowing existing conditions or structures to remain legal even if new rules prohibit them; in this case, an unproven defense raised by Respondent without producing governing documentation.
  8. Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH): An independent Arizona state agency responsible for conducting impartial, neutral administrative evidentiary hearings for state regulatory agencies.
  9. Petitioner: The initiating party in an administrative proceeding who files a formal complaint or petition seeking legal relief (e.g., home/unit owner Thea White).
  10. Respondent: The party against whom an administrative petition or lawsuit is brought, required to respond to allegations (e.g., Encanto Garden Townhouses Association).
  11. USPS Certified Mail: A official mailing service providing the sender with proof of mailing and verified electronic delivery confirmation, used legally by ADRE to serve Notice of Petitions under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(C).

When HOAs Ghost the Law: Key Takeaways from Thea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association

1. Introduction: A Classic HOA Dispute with a Default Twist

When a homeowner seeks to make security modifications to their residence, they expect their Homeowners Association (HOA) board and architectural committee to evaluate their plans in good faith according to established governing documents. However, when an association repeatedly denies an application based on unsupported rules and mischaracterized designs—and subsequently ignores formal state administrative proceedings—the legal system provides homeowners with a streamlined path to enforcement and relief.

In the administrative case Thea White v. Encanto Garden Townhouses Association (Docket No. 26F-H223-HOA), homeowner Thea White challenged her condominium association over the persistent, unsubstantiated rejection of her application for open security bars. The dispute originated at Unit 95, 2941 N 19th Ave, Phoenix, AZ 85015, and was brought before the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE). The matter was formally adjudicated at the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings by Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Nedra-Su Kawasaki.

Despite receiving official notice via certified mail sent in care of its management company, Pride Community Management, the HOA failed to submit a statutory response or appear at the scheduled evidentiary hearing. The result was a swift default judgment against the association, serving as a cautionary tale for HOA boards and management firms state-wide.

Key Case Theme: Ignoring official state administrative notices carries catastrophic legal consequences for an HOA. Under Arizona statute, failure to answer a formal petition operates as an automatic admission of all factual allegations, stripping the association of its defense and exposing it to direct judicial orders.


2. The Core Dispute: Security Bars vs. "Enclosed Porch"

The underlying conflict demonstrates how administrative missteps by an HOA board or management company can escalate a routine architectural request into a formal legal proceeding.

Initial Application Submission

On June 17, 2026, Petitioner Thea White formally submitted an architectural application seeking approval for open security bars on her unit.

Sequence of Unsubstantiated Denials

Rather than evaluating the submission on its merits under community standards, the Association issued a series of three distinct denials:

  1. June 22, 2026: Respondent issued its first denial, mischaracterizing the application for open security bars as a request for an "enclosed back porch"—a structural modification the homeowner never requested. The denial vaguely cited alleged police and fire guidance concerning enclosed spaces.
  2. July 1, 2026: Respondent issued a second denial, maintaining its factual mischaracterization of an enclosed back porch and repeating its reliance on unverified police and fire guidance.
  3. July 6, 2026: Respondent issued a third denial, shifting its legal basis entirely to assert an unproven "grandfathering restriction."
Record Requests Ignored

To challenge these assertions, Ms. White submitted formal written requests on July 6, 2026, and July 13, 2026, asking the Association to produce the cited police and fire documentation as well as any governing instrument establishing the claimed grandfathering rule. The HOA failed to produce a single record to substantiate its claims.

Legal Analysis: The 30-Day CC&R Approval Mechanism

From a legal perspective, the HOA's improper rejections created a critical intersection with Article VIII, Section 1 of the Association's own Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs). Under Article VIII, Section 1, if the Association fails to approve or act upon submitted plans within thirty (30) days after submission, formal written approval is no longer required and the architectural clause is deemed fully complied with (provided the changes do not exceed original square footage).

Ms. White submitted her original plan on June 17, 2026. Exactly thirty days later, on July 17, 2026—having faced three legally flawed denials based on non-existent documentation—she filed her formal administrative petition. By attempting to enforce unwritten rules and mischaracterizing her application, the Association not only breached its duty under A.R.S. § 33-1242(A) to act subject to the declaration, but also allowed the statutory and CC&R timelines to mature directly in the homeowner's favor.


3. Procedural Timeline: The Cost of Ignoring the Department of Real Estate

The procedural history of this case illustrates how administrative inaction by a professional management firm can compromise an association's legal posture.

DateEvent Description
June 17, 2026Initial architectural application for open security bars submitted by Petitioner Thea White.
July 17, 2026Petitioner pays the required $500.00 filing fee and files a formal Petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate.
July 21, 2026ADRE issues Notice of Petition via USPS certified mail to Respondent, sent in care of Pride Community Management at both P.O. Box 13615, Chandler, AZ 85248 and 2450 S. Gilbert Rd., Ste. 205, Chandler, AZ 85286.
August 10, 2026Statutory deadline for Respondent to complete and submit a formal Response Form to the Department showing cause why the petition should be dismissed.
October 9, 2026Evidentiary hearing convened before Administrative Law Judge Nedra-Su Kawasaki. After a 15-minute grace period, no representative appears for the HOA.
The Legal Mechanics of Default

Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E), state administrative procedures establish strict default mechanisms: a respondent's failure to answer an administrative petition operates as a complete legal admission of all allegations contained within the filing. Because Encanto Garden Townhouses Association failed to file a response by August 10, 2026, and subsequently failed to appear at the October 9, 2026 hearing, ALJ Kawasaki deemed all factual allegations admitted as a matter of law.

Legal Commentary: Management Company Liability & Negligence Risks

This procedural failure highlights a severe exposure point for HOA communities. The Department of Real Estate confirmed delivery of certified mail specifically addressed in care of Pride Community Management across two separate corporate addresses. When a contracted property management company fails to log, process, or legal-route certified mail from state regulatory authorities, the HOA board remains fully bound by the fallout. The board loses its ability to defend community standards, incurs financial obligations, and faces court-ordered enforcement purely due to third-party administrative negligence.


4. Legal Breakdown: Statutes & CC&R Violations

The Administrative Law Judge's ruling rests on a dual framework of Arizona statutory law and community governing documents.

A.R.S. § 33-1242(A)

This statute governs the general powers of a condominium association. Crucially, it provides that all corporate and governance powers—including adopting rules, enforcing restrictions, and managing architectural review—are explicitly exercised subject to the provisions of the association's declaration. Board actions that contradict or bypass CC&R provisions exceed statutory authority.

CC&Rs Article VIII, Section 1 (Architectural Control)

This governing provision mandates prior written approval for improvements and grants the Association discretionary authority to evaluate harmony, design, and aesthetics. However, it balances board authority with homeowner protection through two vital caveats:

  1. The 30-Day Default Approval Window: If the Association fails to approve or act upon submitted plans within 30 days after submission, written approval is no longer required and the article is deemed fully complied with (provided additions do not exceed original square footage).
  2. Substantiated Discretion: Evaluative decisions cannot be manufactured through false characterizations (e.g., calling open bars an "enclosed porch") or unwritten restrictions unsupported by official records.
A.R.S. §§ 32-2199, 32-2199.01, & 32-2199.02

These provisions define the jurisdiction and powers of the Arizona Department of Real Estate and Office of Administrative Hearings:

  • § 32-2199: Grants jurisdiction to adjudicate complaints and enforce compliance regarding condominium statutes (Title 33, Chapter 9) and community documents.
  • § 32-2199.01: Establishes petition procedures, filing fees, certified mail notice requirements, mandatory 20-day response windows, and the statutory default mechanism under subsection (E).
  • § 32-2199.02: Authorizes the Administrative Law Judge to issue binding enforcement orders commanding parties to abide by governing documents and order the reimbursement of filing fees.
Statutory Limitation on Administrative Authority

It is equally vital for practitioners to note the jurisdictional boundary set forth in Conclusion of Law #3: A.R.S. § 32-2199.02 authorizes the tribunal to order compliance and assess filing fee remedies, but the tribunal is explicitly not authorized to order other remediation or levy civil penalties for unpleaded or unrelated conduct. Administrative hearings offer target relief defined strictly by the governing statutes.


5. The Ruling & Remedies Ordered

Following the October 9, 2026 evidentiary hearing, Administrative Law Judge Nedra-Su Kawasaki issued a formal written order granting full relief to the homeowner:

  • Prevailing Party Status: Petitioner Thea White was formally declared the prevailing party in the administrative action.
  • Filing Fee Reimbursement: Respondent Encanto Garden Townhouses Association was ordered to reimburse the $500.00 filing fee directly to Petitioner within thirty (30) days of the Order.
  • Mandated CC&R Compliance: Respondent was explicitly directed to comply with the requirements of the Association's CC&Rs regarding architectural review and governance.
Formal Rehearing Rules & Procedures

Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(B), the Order is binding on both parties unless a rehearing is granted pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.04. To seek a rehearing, an aggrieved party must file a formal written request directly with the Commissioner of the Department of Real Estate within thirty (30) days of the service of the Order, in strict compliance with A.R.S. § 41-1092.09.


6. Key Takeaways for Homeowners and HOA Boards

  1. Unsubstantiated Rejections Are Legally Defective: HOA boards and architectural committees cannot cite hypothetical municipal codes, unwritten rules, or fictitious "grandfathering clauses" to deny architectural requests. If an association cites external fire/police guidance, it must possess and produce tangible evidence upon request.
  2. Ignore Administrative Notices at Your Own Peril: Failing to open, process, or respond to certified mail from state agencies triggers automatic default under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E). HOA boards must ensure their property management companies have rigorous protocols to handle official administrative notices immediately.
  3. State Administrative Tribunals Provide Direct Relief: Homeowners facing arbitrary architectural denials or governance failures are not forced to endure expensive Superior Court litigation. The Arizona Department of Real Estate and Office of Administrative Hearings offer an accessible, binding forum to enforce CC&R compliance and recover dispute costs.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Thea White (Petitioner)

Neutral Parties

  • Nedra-Su Kawasaki (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (HOA Division Representative)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Sophia Xu

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H194-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-10-09
Administrative Law Judge—
OutcomeOrdered that no action is required of Respondent and Petitioner's Petition is dismissed.
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties—

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerSophia XuCounselPro Per / Self-Represented
RespondentMagic Ranch Community AssociationCounsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Key Issues & Findings

Alleged failure of statutory pre-lien certified mail notice and premature recording of property lien.

Alleged excessive late fee charges exceeding statutory caps.

Alleged misapplication of assessment prepayments.

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H194-REL Case document – 1465327.pdf

(55.4 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 1477927.pdf

(95.5 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 1_01_ADRE_Petition_Form.pdf

(376.6 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 26F-H194 Notice of Hearing.pdf

(206.8 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 2_02_7_Section_Legal_Brief.pdf

(113.7 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 3_03_Exhibits_A_through_G.pdf.pdf

(12003.2 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – 6843_E_San_Tan_Way__UnitLedger_(7B2V-0D90)_07.24.2026.pdf

(33.3 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – Letter_07-09-2025 (3).pdf

(19.0 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – MRE – AZRE Petition Response.pdf

(1031.8 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – SKM_558e26070610570 (1).pdf

(145.3 KB)

26F-H194-REL Case document – signature (6).pdf

(14.7 KB)

Executive Briefing: Administrative Dispute Resolution in Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H194-REL)

Executive Summary

This briefing document provides an exhaustive synthesis of the administrative legal proceedings, factual disputes, statutory analyses, and final adjudication in the matter of Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H194-REL / File No. 26F-H194). Conducted under the auspices of the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) for the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE), this case addresses critical standards governing Planned Community Association assessment collections, statutory notification requirements, assessment late-fee calculations, and accounting payment allocations under Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) Title 33.

The dispute originated from a petition filed by homeowner Sophia (Hong) Xu ("Petitioner") on June 26, 2026, challenging enforcement actions taken by Magic Ranch Community Association ("Respondent"), managed by PMI San Tan via Community Manager Eric DeBoer. Petitioner alleged that Respondent violated A.R.S. § 33-1807 and A.R.S. § 33-1803 by prematurely recording a $2,027.00 property lien against her primary residence (6843 E San Tan Way, Florence, AZ 85132) without verified delivery of statutory delinquent notices, charging improper late fees, and misapplying tendered assessment funds.

Following an evidentiary hearing held on September 28, 2026, Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Sondra J. Vanella issued an Administrative Law Judge Decision on October 9, 2026. The Tribunal concluded that Petitioner failed to sustain her burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence. ALJ Vanella found that Respondent met all statutory prerequisites by mailing required pre-collection warnings via certified mail to Petitioner’s address of record as provided by prior property management, correctly assessed $15.00 monthly late charges pursuant to statutory allowances, and did not misapply assessment payments. Consequently, the Tribunal ordered the petition dismissed with no corrective action required of Respondent.

Core Case Parameters & Key Dates Table
Parameter / MilestoneDetails & FactsSource Document Reference
PetitionerSophia (Hong) Xu (In Pro Per)ADRE Petition Form; Legal Brief
RespondentMagic Ranch Community Association (c/o PMI San Tan; Eric DeBoer, Manager)ADRE Petition Form; Transcript
Subject Property6843 E San Tan Way, Florence, AZ 85132 (Lot 111, Unit ID: 7B2V-0D90)Recorded Lien (Ex. C); Petition
Off-Site Address of Record1105 S. 4th Ave, Apt 2, Phoenix, AZ 85005 (Rental Property, Zip 85003)Management Export; Ex. D Demand
Statutes AdjudicatedA.R.S. § 33-1807 (Liens & Notice) and A.R.S. § 33-1803 (Late Fees & Allocation)Notice of Hearing; ALJ Decision
Recorded Property LienFee # 2026-025831, recorded March 30, 2026, at 3:19 PM ($2,027.00 total)Pinal County Recorder (Ex. C)
ADRE Petition Filing DateFiled June 26, 2026; $500.00 Filing Fee paid June 30, 2026ADRE Petition Form; Notice
OAH Evidentiary HearingSeptember 28, 2026, at 1:00 PM (Conducted via Google Meet)OAH Order; Transcript
Final Decision DateOctober 9, 2026 (Issued by ALJ Sondra J. Vanella)ALJ Decision (1477927.pdf)
Final DispositionPetition Dismissed; No action required of RespondentALJ Decision, Order Page 5

Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

Theme 1: Statutory Scope and Jurisdictional Limitations of Administrative Hearings

A central conflict throughout the proceedings involved the strict jurisdictional boundaries governing ADRE and OAH administrative hearings versus the broader legal theories introduced by Petitioner.

Under A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq., the Department of Real Estate serves as a nominal administrative entity with limited statutory authority. It does not possess jurisdiction to prosecute claims, award monetary damages/restitution to homeowners, evaluate corporate fiduciary duty breaches, or enforce federal consumer protection laws. As established in statutory precedents cited by the ADRE (Gelb v. Dept. of Fire, Bldg. and Life; Woods v. Block; Cactus Wren Partners; J.W. Hancock Enterprises), the Tribunal's scope is strictly confined to determining whether a respondent violated the specific state statutes identified in the initial petition and Notice of Hearing.

“ +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ADRE / OAH DOCKET JURISDICTION | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | IN-SCOPE STATUTORY PROVISIONS | EXCLUDED LEGAL CLAIMS | | A.R.S. § 33-1807 (Pre-lien written notice | Federal FDCPA (15 U.S.C. § 1692) | | and certified mailing hierarchy) | Association CC&Rs & Bylaws | | A.R.S. § 33-1803 (Late fee caps & principal | (Not explicitly pled) | | first payment allocation rules) | Board Fiduciary Duty Breaches | | | Monetary Damage Awards/Refunds | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

During the hearing, Petitioner admitted to relying on Artificial Intelligence (AI) software to prepare her legal arguments, resulting in extensive references to federal statutes—specifically the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA, 15 U.S.C. § 1692g and § 1692f)—as well as alleged violations of community Declaration Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) and A.R.S. § 33-1809. ALJ Vanella repeatedly instructed Petitioner that these unpled claims were legally barred from consideration:

  1. Exclusion of CC&Rs and Bylaws: Because Petitioner failed to check the designated boxes or cite governing community document provisions in her ADRE Petition Request Form, the ALJ prohibited testimony or rulings concerning CC&R compliance.
  2. Exclusion of Federal Law: Federal debt collection validation freezes and statutory stays under 15 U.S.C. § 1692g do not fall under state administrative tribunal jurisdiction.
  3. Limitation of Remedies: The Tribunal clarified that even if a violation were proven, OAH authority is limited to ordering a respondent to comply with state statutes prospectively; OAH cannot order an HOA to pay damages or grant monetary refunds.
Theme 2: Pre-Collection Mandatory Notice Hierarchy and Address of Record

The primary factual dispute centered on whether Magic Ranch Community Association fulfilled the mandatory pre-collection notification hierarchy mandated by A.R.S. § 33-1807(L).

Statutory Mandate (A.R.S. § 33-1807(L))

The statute dictates that at least 30 days before authorizing an attorney or collection agency to initiate collection activity, an association must send a written notice to the member's address as provided to the association. The notice must contain specific boldface or all-capital warning text regarding potential legal action/foreclosure, provide designated contact details, and be transmitted via certified mail, return receipt requested.

The Parties' Arguments & Evidence
  • Petitioner's Notice Failure Allegations: Petitioner contended that Respondent failed to deliver required notices to her primary residence in Florence, AZ, where she continuously resided. She asserted that the only pre-collection document presented by Respondent—a Final Notice of Delinquency dated July 9, 2025—was legally defective because it was addressed to an incorrect name ("Hong2 Xu" / "Hong Su"), listed a rental property address in Phoenix with an incorrect zip code (85005 instead of 85003), and was returned to the HOA as "unclaimed" on August 11, 2025. Petitioner argued that because the HOA physically signed for the returned unclaimed mail, it possessed actual knowledge of non-delivery and breached its duty of due diligence, particularly given that the Board President lived four doors down on the same street.
  • Respondent's Address of Record Defense: Eric DeBoer presented historical management data exports demonstrating that when PMI San Tan assumed management in mid-2024 from exiting manager GUD Property Management (formerly Snow Property Management), the official owner registry listed the off-site Phoenix address (1105 S. 4th Ave, Apt 2) as Petitioner's primary mailing address. Respondent argued that sending certified mail to the off-site address of record satisfied A.R.S. § 33-1807(L). Furthermore, DeBoer produced USPS postal signature records showing the certified envelope was returned marked "unclaimed" rather than "undeliverable."

“` PRE-COLLECTION NOTICE & SERVICE TIMELINE (A.R.S. § 33-1807)

Mid-2024 July 9, 2025 Aug 11, 2025 March 30, 2026 +——-+ +———-+ +———-+ +————–+ | HOA |——-> | Certified|——> | USPS |—–> | Common | | Mgmt | | Notice | | Returned | | Expense Lien | | Data | | Mailed | | Unclaimed| | Recorded | +——-+ +———-+ +———-+ +————–+ Off-Site Address Contains Bold Signed for by Pinal County 1105 S 4th Ave Statutory Text UPS Store Mail Fee #2026-025831 Phoenix AZ A.R.S. 33-1807(L) Address Amount: $2,027.00 “`

Tribunal Ruling

ALJ Vanella held that Respondent complied with statutory requirements. The Tribunal concluded that mailing the boldfaced statutory notice via certified mail to the off-site mailing address maintained in the Association's records satisfied A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), and that a recipient's failure to claim certified mail does not invalidate statutory service.

Theme 3: Late Fee Calculation, Statutory Caps, and Lien Recording Mechanics

Petitioner challenged both the monthly assessment of late charges under A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) and the physical execution of the property lien.

Late Fee Statutory Cap Analysis (A.R.S. § 33-1803(A))

Under A.R.S. § 33-1803(A), an association may impose reasonable late charges if an assessment remains unpaid 15 or more days past its due date. The statute explicitly caps late fees at the greater of fifteen dollars ($15.00) or ten percent (10%) of the amount of the unpaid assessment.

Petitioner misconstrued this statutory formula during testimony, asserting that because her monthly assessment was $50.00, 10% equaled $5.00, making the $15.00 fee charged by the HOA excessive. The ALJ corrected this interpretation on the record:

$$\text{Statutory Late Fee Limit} = \max(\$15.00, \, 0.10 \times \text{Unpaid Assessment})$$

$$\text{For } \$50.00 \text{ dues: } \max(\$15.00, \, \$5.00) = \mathbf{\$15.00}$$

The Tribunal confirmed that assessing a $15.00 monthly fee is fully compliant with state law.

Lien Recording & Demand Letter Discrepancies

Petitioner introduced official county records and collection letters to allege bad-faith fee stacking and procedural defects:

  • Recorded Lien (Exhibit C): Instrument Fee # 2026-025831, recorded with the Pinal County Recorder on March 30, 2026, at 3:19 PM by attorney Charlene Cruz, Esq., reflected a total encumbrance of $2,027.00 ($942.00 unpaid assessments, $285.00 late fees, and $800.00 collection costs).
  • Demand Letter (Exhibits D & 17): A Notice of Assessment Lien Demand Letter issued by Schwartz Vays, LLC, dated March 31, 2026, and emailed April 3, 2026, listed total outstanding charges of $2,540.46, including a secured lien balance of $2,267.00 ($1,162.00 assessments, $305.00 late fees, $800.00 collection costs), plus $113.46 interest and $160.00 other charges.
  • Petitioner's Argument: Petitioner argued the late fee jumped $20.00 in 24 hours ($285.00 on March 30 to $305.00 on March 31) and that transmitting the demand notice days after recording the lien inverted the statutory timeline.
  • Respondent's Rebuttal: Respondent clarified that late fees hit on the first of each month, and the collection ledger reflected an unbilled $15.00 late fee from February processed concurrently by the third-party agent. Respondent maintained that the lien was recorded strictly in accordance with statutory remedies for delinquent common expenses.
Theme 4: Assessment Accounting, Payment Application, and Evidence Standard

The final core theme focused on the mandatory payment hierarchy set forth in A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) and the evidentiary standards required to establish accounting violations.

Statutory Allocation Rule (A.R.S. § 33-1803(A))

The statute mandates strict priority for funds tendered by a homeowner:

$$\text{Tendered Monies} \longrightarrow \mathbf{1. \text{ Principal Unpaid Assessment}} \longrightarrow \mathbf{2. \text{ Accrued Interest}} \longrightarrow \mathbf{3. \text{ Late Charges / Legal Costs}}$$

Evidentiary Findings

“` PAYMENT ALLOCATION FLOWCHART

[ Homeowner Tenders Assessment Check (e.g., $150.00) ] | v +———————————+ | Does Account Have Unpaid | | Assessment Principal Balance? | +———————————+ / \ YES / \ NO v v +————————–+ +————————–+ | Apply FIRST to Principal | | Apply to Accrued Interest| | Assessment Balance | | & Approved Collection | | (A.R.S. § 33-1803(A)) | | Costs / Attorney Fees | +————————–+ +————————–+ “`

Petitioner submitted Exhibit J, containing copies of cashier's/personal checks totaling $1,312.00 ($1,162.00 tendered to the collection agent on April 4, 2026, for assessment principal, alongside three $50.00 checks marked specifically for April, May, and June 2026 HOA fees). Petitioner argued that Respondent held these checks for two months until June 5, 2026, and diverted the funds toward attorney invoices and county mailing costs rather than crediting assessment principal, thereby artificially prolonging account delinquency.

Upon reviewing the unit ledger, ALJ Vanella observed that an $1,162.00 principal payment was posted to the ledger on April 15, 2026. The Tribunal determined that Petitioner failed to produce persuasive, credible evidence showing that payments were improperly diverted or applied out of statutory sequence. Consequently, the claim of misapplied assessment funds was rejected for lack of evidentiary support.


Important Quotes with Context

The following curated quotes from the official transcript, exhibits, and judicial findings illustrate the central arguments, legal misunderstandings, and ultimate rulings defining this case.

1. Ruling on Administrative Jurisdiction and Scope

"Because my jurisdiction is very limited, I can only adjudicate what's been noticed… I don't tell them to reimburse you. This is not about money. This is just if I find there's been a violation of one or both of those statutes, then I tell them that they have to abide by those statutes… I am only going to be determining whether or not you've proven a violation of the two statutes that you cited." — Administrative Law Judge Sondra J. Vanella (Transcript: 1475602.aac / 1475602.txt)

  • Context: Spoken during the opening phase of the September 28, 2026 hearing. Petitioner attempted to argue federal FDCPA debt validation claims, CC&R violations, and sought a monetary order compelling the HOA to refund filing and legal fees. ALJ Vanella established that OAH jurisdiction is strictly confined to the state statutes explicitly cited in the petition (A.R.S. §§ 33-1807 and 33-1803) and explained that administrative judges cannot award monetary damages.
2. Judicial Warning Regarding Reliance on Artificial Intelligence

"You cited 33-1807 and 33-1803. So that's all I'm going to be determining… And the fact that you got help from AI may or may not have been beneficial to you because AI can sometimes not be accurate." — Administrative Law Judge Sondra J. Vanella (Transcript: 1475602.aac / 1475602.txt)

  • Context: Delivered after Petitioner acknowledged using AI software to research and draft her legal petition and opening statement. The AI tool introduced inapplicable federal statutory concepts and omitted necessary CC&R claims from the petition form, leaving Petitioner unprepared to meet her burden of proof on the specific state statutory elements.
3. Petitioner’s Notice Failure Argument

"Under the association's own rules, they are required to send initial 30-day late notices… Furthermore, the only notice the association has ever presented is a single final notice of delinquency dated July 9th, 2025. Their own records prove this mail was sent to a wrong name, Hong Su, and to a wrong city with an unmatched zip… This mail was returned to the association unclaimed on August 11th, 2025. They physically signed for it, meaning they had actual possession of the returned mail and knew it was never delivered." — Sophia Xu, Petitioner (Transcript: 1474276.aac / 1475602.aac)

  • Context: Excerpted from Petitioner's primary testimony. Petitioner argued that the HOA’s pre-collection notice was legally void because it contained typographical errors in the name and address, was delivered to a rental property, and was returned to the HOA undelivered, proving the HOA had knowledge that actual delivery failed.
4. Respondent’s Address of Record and Certified Mail Defense

"Regarding the address and the certified letter being sent to the address that she's claiming it was, that is accurate. That is the information that we received from exiting management when we took over in 2024. So as 1807 states, sending it to the address of record, that's what we have… This is the signature for when the certified mailing came back to us… returned to us as unclaimed. It was not delivered to us as undeliverable. It was unclaimed… which is why we send it certified mail and which is why it's required." — Eric DeBoer, Community Manager (Transcript: 1474276.aac / 1474276.txt)

  • Context: Spoken during Respondent's defense presentation. DeBoer demonstrated that the HOA relied on official property management records inherited during a 2024 management transition. He argued that mailing certified notices to the owner's address of record satisfies A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), and that an owner's failure to claim certified mail does not defeat statutory compliance.
5. Final Judicial Findings on Statutory Notice and Accounting Compliance

"Petitioner failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that Respondent violated the cited statutory provisions. The credible evidence of record established that Respondent sent proper notice to Petitioner of the delinquency and the potential of her account being sent to collections. The notice was sent to Petitioner’s address of record and contained the required statutory elements. Petitioner failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that Respondent improperly applied her payments." — ALJ Decision, Conclusions of Law ¶ 4 (Administrative Order: 1477927.pdf)

  • Context: The definitive legal conclusion issued by ALJ Vanella on October 9, 2026. This finding resulted in the formal dismissal of Petitioner's claim and affirmed the legality of Respondent's notice procedures and assessment accounting.

Actionable Insights & Operational Takeaways

The findings and procedural rulings in Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association offer vital operational lessons for Planned Community Boards, Property Management Companies, and Homeowners navigating administrative dispute resolution.

“ +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | STRATEGIC COMPLIANCE ROADMAP | +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FOR HOAs & PROPERTY MANAGERS | FOR HOMEOWNERS & LITIGANTS | | 1. Maintain Audited Address-of-Record Logs. | 1. Submit Formal Address Changes. | | 2. Archive Complete Management Transitions. | 2. Strictly Plead Statutory Issues| | 3. Execute Certified Mailings with Bold Text. | on ADRE Petition Forms. | | 4. Maintain Automated Principal-First Ledgers.| 3. Verify AI-Generated Legal Data.| +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

For HOA Boards and Property Management Entities
  1. Maintain Rigorous Address-of-Record Change Logs:
  • Lesson: The HOA successfully defended its statutory notice position because it mailed certified warnings to the official off-site address listed in its inherited registry.
  • Action: Property managers must maintain digital and paper audit trails for all owner address records. Address updates should only be processed upon formal written notification from the unit owner to prevent reliance on stale data.
  1. Preserve Management Transition Data:
  • Lesson: Respondent presented data exports from former management companies (Snow Property Management / GUD Property Management) to establish good-faith compliance.
  • Action: During management transitions, incoming management companies must conduct formal data audits, preserving all historical owner registries, mailing logs, and certified postal receipts.
  1. Ensure Strict Compliance with Statutory Notice Text:
  • Lesson: The July 9, 2025 Final Notice of Delinquency stood up in court because it contained exact boldface statutory warning text required by A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) and was sent via certified mail 30 days prior to legal referral.
  • Action: Standardize collection templates to ensure boldface/all-caps language, contact information, and mandatory 30-day cure warnings are present on all pre-collection notices.
  1. Automate Principal-First Payment Accounting:
  • Lesson: Petitioner alleged that tendered dues were illegally diverted to attorney fees. Respondent's unit ledger demonstrated proper posting to principal balances.
  • Action: Management software must be hardcoded to apply incoming partial payments to assessment principal balances first, pursuant to A.R.S. § 33-1803(A), before allocating funds to accrued interest, late fees, or legal costs.
For Homeowners and Self-Represented Litigants
  1. Ensure Formal Written Notice of Mailing Address Updates:
  • Lesson: Petitioner resided in Florence, AZ, but statutory notices were sent to a rental property in Phoenix because the HOA's database was never formally updated.
  • Action: Homeowners who lease their primary properties or maintain multiple addresses must send written notice of their preferred mailing address via certified mail to the HOA management company and retain proof of delivery.
  1. Strictly Align ADRE Petitions with Statutory Claims:
  • Lesson: Petitioner lost the opportunity to litigate CC&R violations because she failed to check the appropriate boxes on the ADRE Petition Request Form.
  • Action: When filing an ADRE petition, petitioners must explicitly list every statutory section (e.g., A.R.S. § 33-1803, § 33-1807, § 33-1809) and every CC&R/Bylaw section at issue. Administrative tribunals cannot rule on unpled claims.
  1. Verify AI-Generated Legal Claims Against Jurisdictional Limits:
  • Lesson: Petitioner relied on AI-drafted briefs containing federal FDCPA claims and damage demands that OAH judges have no legal authority to adjudicate.
  • Action: Self-represented litigants using AI research tools must independently verify that cited statutes fall under state administrative jurisdiction. Federal statutes (FDCPA) and monetary damage claims must be pursued in court civil venues, not administrative tribunals.
  1. Understand Late Fee Calculation Formulas:
  • Lesson: Petitioner incorrectly argued that a $15.00 late fee exceeded the 10% statutory cap on a $50.00 assessment.
  • Action: Litigants must recognize that A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) authorizes the greater of $15.00 or 10%. On low monthly dues, the $15.00 flat fee is legally permissible.

Study Guide: Arizona Administrative HOA Dispute Resolution and Statutory Interpretation

In the Matter of Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H194-REL)


1. Executive Overview & Case Summary

This study guide provides an exhaustive analysis of the administrative dispute adjudicated before the State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) between Sophia (Hong) Xu (Petitioner) and Magic Ranch Community Association (Respondent).

The case highlights the operational procedures of the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) HOA Dispute Process, the evidentiary burdens governed by Arizona Administrative Code and Revised Statutes, the precise limits of administrative tribunal jurisdiction, and the practical application of planned community statutes: A.R.S. § 33-1807 (common expense liens and statutory notice requirements) and A.R.S. § 33-1803 (assessment limitations, late fee caps, and payment application order).

Core Case Synopsis
  • Forum: State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) / Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).
  • Docket / File Number: Docket No. 26F-H194-REL / File No. 26F-H194.
  • Presiding Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): Sondra J. Vanella (Hearing Order issued by ALJ Tammy L. Eigenheer; Notice of Hearing issued under ALJ Nedra-Su Kawasaki).
  • Petitioner: Sophia (Hong) Xu (Homeowner in Pro Per).
  • Respondent: Magic Ranch Community Association (represented by Eric DeBoer, Community Manager, PMI San Tan; legal counsel of record: Mulcahy Law Firm, PC / CHDB Law LLP / Schwartz Vays, LLC).
  • Subject Property: 6843 E. San Tan Way, Florence, AZ 85132 (Unit ID: 7B2V-0D90).
  • Off-Site Rental Property Address in Dispute: 1105 S. 4th Ave., Apt. 2, Phoenix, AZ (Zip codes referenced: 85005 vs. 85003).
  • Filing Date & Fee: Petition filed June 26, 2026; $500.00 statutory filing fee paid June 30, 2026.
  • Hearing Date: September 28, 2026 at 1:00 p.m. (conducted via Google Meet video/telephone conferencing).
  • Final Administrative Decision Date: October 9, 2026 (Petition Dismissed; Order binding subject to rehearing requests).

2. Key Concepts & Statutory Framework

A. Statutory Provisions Under Review
1. A.R.S. § 33-1807: Unpaid Common Expense Liens & Mandatory Notice
  • Notice Hierarchy (Subsection L): Before an association can authorize an attorney or external collection agency (not acting as the association's managing agent) to initiate collection activity, it must provide a written notice to the member at the member's address as provided to the association at least 30 days prior to authorization.
  • Mandatory Statutory Text: The notice must be in bold-faced type or ALL CAPITAL LETTERS and contain the following explicit text:

"Your account is delinquent. If you do not bring your account current or make arrangements that are approved by the association to bring your account current within thirty days after the date of this notice, your account will be turned over for further collection proceedings. Such collection proceedings could include bringing a foreclosure action against your property."

  • Delivery Method: Must be transmitted via certified mail, return receipt requested. It may be included within other delinquency correspondence.
  • Payment Allocation & Tender (Subsection N): Mandates association handling and acceptance of tendered payments against outstanding balances.
2. A.R.S. § 33-1803: Assessment Caps, Late Fees, and Payment Hierarchy
  • Late Fee Statutory Cap (Subsection A): Late fees imposed by an association for delinquent assessment payments are capped at the greater of $15.00 or 10% of the unpaid assessment amount.
  • Grace Period: A payment is deemed late if unpaid 15 or more days after its due date (unless community documents specify a longer period).
  • Notice Requirement: Late fees may only be imposed after the association has provided notice that the assessment is overdue or that it will be considered overdue after a specific date.
  • Statutory Application of Monies: Any funds paid by a member for an unpaid assessment must be applied first to the principal amount unpaid, and subsequently to accrued interest.
3. Administrative Jurisdiction & Scope (A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq. & A.R.S. § 41-1092 et seq.)
  • ADRE's Limited Role: ADRE surveys petitions for administrative completeness and forwards contested matters to OAH. ADRE has no statutory authority to investigate, litigate, prosecute, award monetary damages, or refund legal expenses.
  • Strict Jurisdictional Limits of OAH: The tribunal can only adjudicate specific statutory or CC&R violations explicitly pleaded in the initial Petition and noticed in the Notice of Hearing. Unnoticed claims (e.g., federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act [FDCPA] violations under 15 U.S.C. § 1692 or unpleaded Bylaw/CC&R provisions) cannot be adjudicated.
  • Remedies Available: If a violation is proven, the ALJ orders the Respondent to comply with the statute or community document prospectively. The tribunal cannot award third-party debt collection fee reimbursements to non-petitioners or grant monetary damages.

B. Summary Breakdown of Parties' Positions and Evidence
Analytical DimensionPetitioner's Position (Sophia Xu)Respondent's Position (Magic Ranch / Eric DeBoer)Tribunal's Final Finding & Conclusion
Notice of Delinquency & Address RecordNotice failed because it was sent to an off-site rental property (Phoenix, AZ) with an incorrect name ("Hong2" / "Hang Su") and wrong zip code (85005 instead of 85003). Claimed HOA had actual knowledge of her Florence residence (where the Board President lived 4–7 houses away).Notice was sent via certified mail on July 9, 2025, to the official off-site address of record exported from prior management (GUD / Snow Property Management). Included required bold/capital statutory warning text. Returned as "unclaimed."Sustained for Respondent. Notice complied with A.R.S. § 33-1807(L). Sending certified mail to the member's address of record in the association's database satisfies the 30-day statutory prerequisite, even if returned "unclaimed."
Assessment Late Fee ChargesClaimed Respondent exceeded the statutory cap under A.R.S. § 33-1803 by charging $20 late fees within 24 hours between the March 30, 2026 lien ($285 late fees) and March 31, 2026 demand letter ($305 late fees).Account ledger demonstrates standard $15.00 monthly late fees charged on the 1st of the month following a 15-day grace period. Discrepancies were due to third-party collection timing/adjustments, not illegal rates.Sustained for Respondent. Unit Ledger proves Petitioner was charged $15.00 monthly late fees, fully adhering to A.R.S. § 33-1803(A)'s statutory limit (greater of $15 or 10%).
Application of Assessment PaymentsClaimed Respondent violated A.R.S. § 33-1803 by holding three tendered assessment checks ($150 total for April, May, June 2026) until June 5, 2026, and applying them to attorney invoices rather than principal assessment dues.Principal payments were properly credited to the account ledger; outstanding balances were valid hard collection costs incurred by the association through third-party collection agencies.Sustained for Respondent. Petitioner failed to present persuasive, credible evidence establishing that payments were misapplied contrary to statutory principal-first requirements.
Lien Validity (Fee #2026-025831)Lien recorded March 30, 2026 ($2,027 total: $942 principal, $285 late fees, $800 collection costs) was premature, unvalidated, and procedurally defective.Common expense lien was lawfully recorded by collection counsel after statutory 30-day notice requirements were fulfilled.Sustained for Respondent. Petitioner failed to meet the burden of proof to show procedural defect under A.R.S. § 33-1807. Petition dismissed.

3. Procedural & Evidentiary Rules in Administrative Hearings

Evidentiary Standards & Burden of Proof
  1. Burden of Proof (A.A.C. R2-19-119): The burden of proof rests entirely upon the Petitioner to establish the alleged statutory violations by a preponderance of the evidence.
  2. Definition of Preponderance of the Evidence: Proof that convinces the trier of fact that the contention is more probably true than not; superior evidentiary weight that inclines a fair and impartial mind to one side of the issue (Vazzano v. Superior Court; Black's Law Dictionary).
  3. Applicability of Evidence Rules: Pursuant to A.R.S. § 41-1092.07, formal Arizona Rules of Evidence do not strictly apply in OAH administrative hearings. All relevant testimony and reliable evidence may be admitted, provided proper foundation is established.
  4. Admissibility Requirement: Documents submitted prior to a hearing are not automatically considered evidence. Parties must formally offer exhibits into evidence during the hearing and lay foundational context.
  • Admitted Petitioner Exhibits: Exhibit C (Certified Copy of Common Expense Lien recorded March 30, 2026), Exhibit D (March 31, 2026 Schwartz Vays Demand Letter / April 3 email), Exhibit H (July 9, 2025 Final Notice of Delinquency & envelope/mail log), Exhibit J (Tendered checks and Unit Ledger showing June 5 attorney cost entries).
  • Administrative Notice: The tribunal took official Administrative Notice of the entire ADRE Agency Record.
Pitfalls of AI-Generated Legal Arguments in Administrative Forums

During the hearing, Petitioner admitted to relying on Artificial Intelligence (AI) to prepare her legal brief and oral presentation. This introduced critical structural defects into her case:

  • Extralegal Claims: AI generated arguments alleging violations of federal consumer protection statutes (e.g., FDCPA 15 U.S.C. § 1692g debt validation stays), which ALJ Vanella barred due to lack of subject-matter jurisdiction.
  • Unpleaded Allegations: AI incorporated arguments regarding internal CC&Rs and Bylaws that Petitioner failed to include in her initial ADRE Petition form. The ALJ restricted the scope exclusively to A.R.S. §§ 33-1807 and 33-1803.
  • Procedural Confusion: Relying on automated legal drafts caused Petitioner to conflate closing arguments with new testimony, leading to procedural errors during her case-in-chief.

4. Short-Answer Practice Questions

Question 1

Under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), what specific delivery method and timeframe are required before an HOA may authorize an outside collection agency or attorney to initiate formal collection proceedings against a homeowner?

Answer

The association must send written notice via certified mail, return receipt requested, to the member’s address as provided to the association, at least 30 days prior to authorizing an attorney or collection agency to begin collection activity. The notice must contain specific mandatory warning language regarding delinquency and potential foreclosure in bold-faced type or ALL CAPITAL LETTERS.


Question 2

How does A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) define the statutory cap for late fees that a planned community association may legally impose on delinquent assessment payments?

Answer

Late fee charges are strictly limited to the greater of $15.00 or 10% of the amount of the unpaid assessment. They may only be assessed if the payment is unpaid 15 or more days after its due date (or a longer period if defined in community documents) and after proper overdue notice has been provided.


Question 3

In what precise order does A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) mandate that an association apply monies received from a member for an unpaid assessment?

Answer

Any monies paid by a member for an unpaid assessment must be applied first to the principal amount unpaid, and only after the principal is satisfied may remaining funds be applied to accrued interest or other charges.


Question 4

Why did ALJ Sondra J. Vanella refuse to adjudicate Petitioner's arguments regarding the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) and internal HOA CC&Rs during the September 28, 2026 hearing?

Answer

OAH administrative law judges possess strictly limited statutory jurisdiction. The ALJ could only adjudicate claims specifically set forth in the ADRE Notice of Hearing and initial Petition (which cited only A.R.S. §§ 33-1807 and 33-1803). OAH has no jurisdiction over federal statutes (15 U.S.C. § 1692), and Petitioner failed to cite CC&R or Bylaw violations on her petition form.


Question 5

What constitutes compliance with sending notice under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) when certified mail sent by an HOA is returned by the United States Postal Service as "unclaimed"?

Answer

Sending the statutorily compliant notice via certified mail to the member’s address of record in the association's system fulfills the statutory requirement. The statute does not require proof of actual receipt or physical opening by the homeowner; returned "unclaimed" certified mail demonstrates verifiable delivery attempt to the address of record.


Question 6

What is the standard of proof required for a petitioner to prevail in an HOA dispute hearing before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings, and how is it defined?

Answer

The standard of proof is the preponderance of the evidence (A.A.C. R2-19-119). It requires the petitioner to present evidence that inclines a fair and impartial mind to conclude that the alleged violation is more probably true than not.


Question 7

What administrative remedies can the Office of Administrative Hearings grant if an HOA is found to have violated Arizona planned community statutes?

Answer

The ALJ may issue a binding order directing the association to comply prospectively with the specific Arizona statute(s) or community document provisions violated. The tribunal cannot award monetary damages, grant attorney fee reimbursements to non-petitioners, or adjudicate third-party collection fee disputes outside statutory mandates.


Question 8

What was the factual basis for Respondent Magic Ranch Community Association mailing collection notices to an address in Phoenix, AZ, when Petitioner resided in Florence, AZ?

Answer

Respondent utilized the owner off-site mailing address recorded in the homeowner registry export dataset transferred to them by the exiting property management company (Snow Property Management / GUD Property Management) upon taking over management in 2024. Under statute, the HOA is obligated to send notices to the address of record provided to the association.


5. Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Essay Prompt 1: Statutory Notice vs. Actual Knowledge in HOA Administrative Enforcement

Prompt: Analyze the legal and procedural tensions between an HOA’s reliance on an "address of record" under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) and a homeowner's claim of "actual knowledge" by community leaders. In Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association, the Petitioner argued that because the Board President resided four to seven houses away from her primary Florence residence, the association possessed actual knowledge of her true physical location, rendering certified mail sent to her Phoenix rental property legally defective. Evaluate the legal merits of this argument under Arizona administrative law, the evidentiary standard required of management entities, and the statutory obligations of homeowners to maintain updated contact records.

Analytical Outline & Key Points to Include:
  • Statutory Strict Construction: A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) requires notice to be sent to "the member's address as provided to the association." The statute establishes an objective standard tied to the official corporate database, not a subjective standard based on individual board members' personal observations.
  • Corporate Entity vs. Individual Knowledge: The association operates as a corporate entity through its managing agent (PMI San Tan). Knowledge possessed by an individual neighbor who happens to be a board president does not legally override the formal database records inherited from prior management (GUD / Snow Property Management).
  • Homeowner Due Diligence: Homeowners maintain an affirmative obligation to ensure their legal mailing address is updated in writing with the association, especially when leasing off-site properties.
  • Tribunal Holding: ALJ Vanella correctly ruled that sending certified mail to the off-site address of record satisfied A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), and returned "unclaimed" mail did not invalidate the statutory notice process.

Essay Prompt 2: Evidentiary and Jurisdictional Constraints of Administrative Tribunals

Prompt: Discuss the jurisdictional boundaries and evidentiary rules governing the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings as demonstrated in Docket No. 26F-H194-REL. Contrast the administrative dispute process under A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq. with general civil litigation in Superior Court, focusing on: 1. The limitation of issues to those explicitly noticed. 2. The preclusion of federal claims (such as the FDCPA) and unpleaded CC&R provisions. 3. The impact of uncritical reliance on AI-generated pleadings by pro per litigants.

Analytical Outline & Key Points to Include:
  • Jurisdictional Narrowness: OAH's authority is strictly delegated by state statute (A.R.S. § 41-1092 et seq.). It lacks general jurisdiction; it cannot hear federal causes of action (15 U.S.C. § 1692) or award civil tort damages.
  • Notice and Due Process: Due process requires that respondents be formally noticed of exact charges. Because Petitioner only cited A.R.S. §§ 33-1807 and 33-1803 on her ADRE petition form, the ALJ was legally prohibited from ruling on CC&R or Bylaw violations.
  • Administrative vs. Judicial Rules of Evidence: While formal evidence rules are relaxed (A.R.S. § 41-1092.07), evidentiary rules regarding foundation, authentication, and burden of proof remain strict. Merely submitting 39 pages of documents does not make them evidence until offered and admitted (e.g., Exhibits C, D, H, J).
  • The AI Risks in Pro Se Advocacy: AI tools often blend federal law, state statutes, and contract law without understanding forum-specific subject-matter jurisdiction. This created false expectations for the Petitioner, leading her to focus on non-jurisdictional FDCPA arguments rather than proving her statutory state claims.

6. Glossary of Important Terms

“ +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Term | Definition & Context | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Address of Record | The official mailing address provided by a property owner to an HOA and maintained in the | | | association's corporate database for formal legal and billing notices. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) | An independent judicial officer appointed under A.R.S. § 41-1092 to preside over contested state | | | administrative hearings and render binding decisions or recommendations. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Administrative Notice | A formal action by a judge recognizing certain official public records (such as the ADRE Agency | | | Record) as established evidence without requiring independent testimony or authentication. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | ADRE | Arizona Department of Real Estate; the state executive agency responsible for processing HOA | | | dispute petitions pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | A.R.S. § 33-1803 | Arizona Revised Statute governing planned community assessment limits, late fee caps (greater of | | | $15 or 10%), and the mandatory order of funds application (principal first). | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | A.R.S. § 33-1807 | Arizona Revised Statute governing HOA common expense liens, payment allocations, and mandatory | | | certified 30-day pre-collection notices. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Burden of Proof | The legal duty of a party (the Petitioner in administrative disputes) to establish alleged facts | | | by the required evidentiary standard (preponderance of the evidence). | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CC&Rs | Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions; the recorded legal governing documents establishing rights| | | and obligations within a planned community. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Certified Mail, Return Receipt | A USPS mailing service providing proof of dispatch and delivery attempt, statutorily mandated for | | Requested | formal HOA delinquency notices under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L). | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Common Expense Lien | A statutory lien recorded against a homeowner's real property by an HOA for delinquent | | | assessments, late fees, and collection costs (e.g., Fee #2026-025831). | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Debt Validation Request | A formal demand sent pursuant to the federal FDCPA (15 U.S.C. § 1692g) requiring debt collectors | | | to verify an underlying debt; outside OAH administrative jurisdiction. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | FDCPA | Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (15 U.S.C. § 1692 et seq.); federal law governing third-party | | | debt collectors, non-adjudicable in ADRE/OAH state administrative proceedings. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Notice of Hearing | The official jurisdictional document issued by ADRE defining the specific parties, dockets, date, | | | and statutory issues to be adjudicated by OAH. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | OAH | Office of Administrative Hearings; the independent Arizona state agency responsible for conducting| | | neutral administrative hearings for regulatory state agencies. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Preponderance of the Evidence | The evidentiary standard in administrative hearings requiring proof that a claim is more | | | probably true than not true. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Pro Per / Pro Se | A party who represents themselves in legal or administrative proceedings without attorney counsel. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Unclaimed Certified Mail | Certified mail returned by the USPS after multiple failed delivery attempts; legally fulfills | | | statutory mailing requirements if sent to the owner's address of record. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Unit Ledger | The official financial record kept by an HOA tracking assessment charges, late fees, interest, | | | collection entries, and payment deposits for a specific property unit. | +-----------------------------------+---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

Inside an HOA Dispute: Key Lessons from Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association

1. Introduction: The Risks of AI-Driven HOA Litigation

Administrative dispute resolution before state real estate departments offers homeowners and homeowners associations (HOAs) an accessible tribunal to resolve operational and financial conflicts. However, administrative proceedings operate within strict statutory boundaries. Under Arizona law, the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) performs an administrative intake role pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq., screening petitions for administrative completeness upon payment of the statutory filing fee (such as the $500.00 fee paid in single-issue disputes). Once screened, the matter is transmitted to the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) pursuant to A.R.S. § 41-1092 et seq., where an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) exercises strictly limited judicial oversight.

The case of Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association (OAH Docket No. 26F-H194-REL / ADRE File No. 26F-H194) illustrates the fatal risks of reliance on unvetted Artificial Intelligence (AI) prompts to construct a legal strategy in administrative tribunals. Petitioner Sophia Xu (also identified in property records as Sophia Hong Xu) filed an ADRE dispute petition on June 26, 2026, challenging a common expense property lien recorded against her property on March 30, 2026 (Fee #2026-025831, Pinal County Recorder). Xu alleged that Respondent Magic Ranch Community Association prematurely recorded the lien without sending mandatory pre-lien delinquency notices to her primary residence, imposed improper late fees, and misapplied tendered assessment payments. Respondent appeared through Community Manager Eric DeBoer.

The formal administrative hearing convened on September 28, 2026, at 1:04 p.m. via Google Meet video conference before ALJ Sondra J. Vanella. On October 9, 2026, ALJ Vanella issued a final Administrative Law Judge Decision dismissing Xu’s petition in its entirety and ordering that no action was required of the HOA. The downfall of the petitioner’s case stemmed directly from her reliance on AI legal drafting, which generated extensive arguments under federal consumer debt statutes and internal community covenants that OAH had no statutory jurisdiction to hear, while leaving her unequipped to satisfy the evidentiary burden on the state statutes actually noticed for hearing.


2. Breakdown of Allegations vs. Evidence

During the September 28, 2026 hearing, ALJ Vanella evaluated Xu’s assertions against the association's unit ledgers, postal records, and management testimony. The table below contrasts the petitioner's primary allegations against the evidence admitted into the record and the tribunal's factual findings:

Petitioner's AllegationsHOA Response & Evidence / Court Findings
Defective Pre-Lien Notice & Mailing Address: The HOA violated pre-lien notification duties by mailing notices to an off-site rental property (1105 S. 4th Ave, Apt 2, Phoenix, AZ 85005) with an incorrect name ("Hong Tu" / "Hang Su") and an incorrect zip code (listing 85005 instead of the actual rental zip 85003), rather than her primary residence (6843 E San Tan Way, Florence, AZ 85132).Statutory "Address of Record" Satisfied: Community Manager Eric DeBoer introduced data export ledgers inherited during a mid-2024 management transition from former management entities (Snow Property Management / GUD Property Management). This record established 1105 S. 4th Ave, Apt 2, Phoenix, AZ 85005 as the owner's designated off-site address of record on file. Mailing certified notices to this address satisfied A.R.S. § 33-1807(L).
Invalid Delivery Status: The July 9, 2025 Final Notice of Delinquency was returned to the HOA undelivered, which Xu argued constituted defective service that invalidated subsequent collection and lien recording actions."Unclaimed" Certified Mail Constitutes Valid Notice: USPS tracking evidence established that the July 9, 2025 certified letter was returned marked "unclaimed" on August 11, 2025, and signed for upon return by the HOA's mailing drop at the UPS Store. Under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), an "unclaimed" status does not defeat statutory notice compliance.
Excessive Late Fees Exceeding Statutory Cap: The HOA violated A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) by charging excessive late fees, citing a $20.00 fee variance between the March 30, 2026 recorded lien ($285.00 in late fees) and a March 31, 2026 collection demand letter ($305.00 in late fees).Fees Aligned with Statutory Caps: Unit ledgers confirmed the HOA consistently assessed standard monthly late charges of $15.00, fully compliant with the statutory cap under A.R.S. § 33-1803(A). DeBoer clarified that the single-day $20.00 ledger variance resulted from a standard $15.00 late fee posting alongside a separate $15.00 unbilled February late fee catch-up entry posted by collection agent Schwartz Vays, LLC.
Misapplication of Assessment Prepayments: The HOA violated A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) by withholding tendered assessment payments ($1,162.00 check on April 15, 2026, plus three cashier's checks of $150.00 each tendered under protest) and applying funds to legal/collection fees instead of principal assessments.Failure to Meet Evidentiary Burden: The unit ledger reflected that an April 15, 2026 payment of $1,162.00 was credited directly to principal assessment balances. ALJ Vanella ruled that Xu failed to present persuasive accounting evidence showing that tendered assessment monies were improperly diverted to legal fees.

3. Three Critical Pitfalls That Decided the Case

3.1 Jurisdiction Limits vs. AI-Generated Arguments

A fatal flaw in the petitioner's presentation was her heavy reliance on AI tools to construct her legal brief and opening statement. Xu’s filings raised sweeping claims under the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA, 15 U.S.C. § 1692g), asserted internal breaches of the association's Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), and cited unpled state statutes such as A.R.S. § 33-1809.

ALJ Vanella repeatedly intervened to explain the jurisdictional boundaries governing administrative proceedings. Under A.R.S. § 32-2199 and the official Notice of Hearing, OAH’s authority was strictly confined to adjudicating the specific statutory claims checked on the initial ADRE petition request form: A.R.S. § 33-1807 (common expense liens) and A.R.S. § 33-1803 (assessment limitations and late fees). Because federal statutes, internal CC&Rs, and unpled state laws were outside the tribunal's administrative jurisdiction, ALJ Vanella barred them from consideration.

When informed that her AI-drafted FDCPA debt validation and CC&R arguments were completely inadmissible, Xu was caught entirely unprepared to present structured testimony on the two state statutes actually at issue. Recognizing the petitioner's distress, ALJ Vanella placed the hearing on a 10-minute administrative recess to allow Xu time to locate her statutory exhibits. Upon returning, Xu acknowledged her tactical error on the record, stating, "I spent a long time prepared for this hearing, but obviously I'm not knowledgeable enough."

3.2 "Address of Record" and "Unclaimed" Certified Dues Notices

Xu contended that pre-lien collection notices were procedurally defective because they were sent to her Phoenix rental property rather than her primary residence in Florence, where the HOA board president resided four doors down. Under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), an association must send written notice via certified mail, return receipt requested, to the member's address as provided to the association at least 30 days before authorizing an attorney or collection agency to initiate collection activity.

Community Manager Eric DeBoer produced data exports obtained from prior property management entities (Snow Property Management and GUD Property Management) during a 2024 management transfer. This export designated 1105 S. 4th Ave, Apt 2, Phoenix, AZ 85005 as Xu’s official off-site mailing address of record. Furthermore, the HOA established that on July 9, 2025, it dispatched a Final Notice of Delinquency via certified mail to that address of record, containing the exact mandatory statutory warning text in boldfaced type pursuant to A.R.S. § 33-1807(L):

"Your account is delinquent. If you do not bring your account current or make arrangements that are approved by the association to bring your account current within thirty days after the date of this notice, your account will be turned over for further collection proceedings. Such collection proceedings could include bringing a foreclosure action against your property."

USPS tracking records demonstrated that this certified letter was returned marked "unclaimed" on August 11, 2025, and signed for upon return by the HOA’s designated mail drop at the UPS Store. ALJ Vanella confirmed that sending statutory certified mail to the address of record on file satisfies the association’s legal obligation under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L). A homeowner’s failure or refusal to claim certified mail does not defeat legal notice or invalidate subsequent collection steps.

3.3 Burden of Proof on Fee Caps and Payment Misapplication

In administrative proceedings under A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2) and Arizona Administrative Code R2-19-119(A), the petitioner bears the burden of proof to establish alleged statutory violations by a preponderance of the evidence. As articulated in Conclusions of Law ¶ 3 of the ALJ Decision (citing Morris K. Udall, Arizona Law of Evidence § 5 and Black's Law Dictionary 8th ed.), a preponderance of the evidence represents "superior evidentiary weight that… is still sufficient to incline a fair and impartial mind to one side of the issue rather than the other."

Xu sought to prove two distinct financial violations under A.R.S. § 33-1803:

  1. Late Fee Violations (A.R.S. § 33-1803(A)): Late charges are statutorily capped at the greater of $15.00 or 10% of the unpaid assessment. Xu pointed to a March 30, 2026 recorded lien listing $285.00 in late fees and a March 31, 2026 demand letter listing $305.00 in late fees, alleging an improper $20.00 fee spike over 24 hours. However, the unit ledger established that the HOA consistently charged standard $15.00 monthly late fees assessed in the subsequent month. DeBoer explained that the ledger variance resulted from a standard $15.00 monthly fee posting alongside an unposted $15.00 February late fee catch-up entry processed by collection agent Schwartz Vays, LLC, rather than an illegal rate increase.
  2. Payment Misapplication (A.R.S. § 33-1803(A)): Statutory payment hierarchies mandate that owner payments be applied first to principal assessment balances before interest or secondary collection costs. Xu highlighted an April 15, 2026 payment of $1,162.00 toward principal assessments, as well as subsequent cashier's checks of $150.00 tendered for April, May, and June dues (totaling $1,312.00 tendered under protest). However, unit ledgers admitted into evidence demonstrated that payments were credited to assessment balances, and Xu failed to present persuasive accounting evidence showing that principal funds were diverted to legal fees in violation of A.R.S. § 33-1803(A).

4. Essential Takeaways for Homeowners and HOA Boards

The decision in Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association offers critical legal insights for property owners and community association management operating under Arizona administrative law.

For Homeowners:
  • Maintain Explicit, Written Address-of-Record Updates: Under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L), associations fulfill their statutory notice duties by mailing notices to the address currently on file. Never assume management or board members have actual knowledge of your primary residence based on localized neighborhood interactions. File written, formal address updates whenever mailing details change.
  • Plead Statutory Claims Correctly Before ADRE Intake: The ADRE dispute intake process under A.R.S. § 32-2199 limits OAH hearing jurisdiction strictly to the specific statutory boxes checked on the initial petition form. Administrative tribunals cannot hear federal FDCPA consumer debt claims, unpled state statutes, or unpled CC&R provisions.
  • Unclaimed Certified Mail Does Not Halt Collection Proceedings: Refusing to accept or retrieve certified mail from the post office does not stay statutory collection activity. Signature delivery back to an HOA’s mailing drop for "unclaimed" postal items completes statutory service.
For HOA Boards & Management:
  • Retain Verified Data Exports During Management Transitions: Preserve complete homeowner registry exports and historical address records whenever transitioning between management firms (such as the transition from Snow/GUD Property Management to PMI San Tan) to defend the integrity of notice chains.
  • Include Exact Statutory Boldfaced Warning Text: Ensure all 30-day pre-collection delinquency notices contain the precise boldfaced statutory language mandated by A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) and are transmitted via certified mail, return receipt requested, prior to legal escalation.
  • Maintain Itemized Account Ledgers Aligned with Fee Caps: Maintain clear unit ledgers establishing that late charges do not exceed statutory limits ($15.00 or 10% of the unpaid assessment, whichever is greater) under A.R.S. § 33-1803(A) and that all tendered monies are credited to principal assessment balances first.

5. Conclusion

The dismissal of the petition in Sophia Xu v. Magic Ranch Community Association illustrates a foundational rule of administrative practice: successful tribunal advocacy depends on exact statutory pleadings, verified documentation, and meeting formal evidentiary burdens. While AI tools can provide preliminary research, relying on generic legal prompts without understanding administrative jurisdiction can destroy an active dispute. Whether proving statutory notice compliance under A.R.S. § 33-1807(L) or validating fee ledgers under A.R.S. § 33-1803(A), homeowners and HOA boards alike must rely on verified agency records and strict statutory compliance to prevail in administrative hearings.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Sophia Xu (Petitioner)

Respondent Side

  • Eric DeBoer (Community Manager)
    Magic Ranch Community Association
  • Beth Mulcahy (Attorney for Respondent)
    Mulcahy Law Firm, P.C.
  • Charlene Cruz (Attorney)
    CHDB Law LLP
  • Robert Cox (Board President)
    Magic Ranch Estates Homeowners Association

Neutral Parties

  • Sondra J. Vanella (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Tammy L. Eigenheer (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Nedra-Su Kawasaki (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
  • Vivian Nunez (HOA Dispute Coordinator)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
  • Mandy Neat (Deputy Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp V. Golden Hills Homeowners Association

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H129-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-10-09
Administrative Law Judge—
OutcomePetition Dismissed
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties—

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerKenneth Christopher HonerkampCounselPro Se (Self-represented)
RespondentGolden Hills Homeowners Association (GHHA)Counsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Key Issues & Findings

Whether GHHA violated A.R.S. §§ 33-1802, 33-1817, or Section 13 of its CC&Rs by denying Petitioner's application to construct a 6-foot solid masonry safety wall to anchor an approved 16-foot golf safety net.

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H129-REL Case document – 1470065.pdf

(34.2 KB)

26F-H129-REL Case document – 1470073.pdf

(6.4 KB)

26F-H129-REL Case document – 1476971.pdf

(105.1 KB)

Briefing Document: Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association

1. Executive Summary

This briefing document summarizes the administrative hearing and subsequent judicial decision in Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association (Docket No. 26F-H129-REL), heard before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson at the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings in Phoenix, Arizona.

The dispute centers on a petition filed by homeowner Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp against the Golden Hills Homeowners Association (GHHA). Mr. Honerkamp sought architectural approval to construct a 6-foot solid masonry safety wall on his golf-course-adjacent lot to anchor an already approved 16-foot safety net and prevent trespassing. GHHA denied the wall request, citing a strict 4-foot height limitation on solid masonry walls under Section 13 of the Unit One Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).

Following a hearing on September 10, 2026, and an evidentiary submission period held open until September 21, 2026, the Administrative Law Judge issued an Order on October 9, 2026, dismissing Mr. Honerkamp's petition. The ALJ concluded that GHHA was legally obligated under its CC&Rs to deny the 6-foot solid wall and that Mr. Honerkamp failed to establish that GHHA engaged in selective enforcement or violated Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) §§ 33-1802 or 33-1817.

Case Overview & Metadata
ParameterDetails
Docket Number26F-H129-REL
TribunalState of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings
Administrative Law JudgeVelva Moses-Thompson
PetitionerKenneth Christopher Honerkamp (Homeowner, 925 S. Longwood Loop, Unit One)
RespondentGolden Hills Homeowners Association (Represented by Board President William Osborne and Vice President Derek Platt)
Key Statutes CitedA.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818 (Planned Communities Act); A.R.S. § 33-1802; A.R.S. § 33-1817
Hearing DateSeptember 10, 2026
Record Closure DateSeptember 21, 2026
Final Order DateOctober 9, 2026
Final DispositionPetition Dismissed in favor of Respondent (GHHA)

2. Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

Theme 1: Safety Risks, Property Damage, and Trespassing Issues

Mr. Honerkamp presented evidence regarding physical safety risks and property damage caused by high-velocity golf ball strikes coming from the adjacent fairway of the golf course (Apache Country Club Estates).

  • Property Damage and Physical Threats: Mr. Honerkamp purchased his home in 2025. Between January 2025 and May 2026, his property sustained structural damage, including broken windows, damaged window screens, and roof damage. Mr. Honerkamp demonstrated that golf ball impacts occurred daily, presenting photos of a massive accumulation of golf balls, including a 5-gallon bucket filled between May and September 2026. He expressed fear for the physical safety of his wife and two young children.
  • Trespassing Concerns: Security camera logs and photographic evidence (Tab 5 / Exhibit E) demonstrated that golfers routinely crossed over Mr. Honerkamp’s existing 2.5-foot low fence onto his private lawn to retrieve stray balls, ignoring visible "No Trespassing" signs.
  • Safety Net Anchor Requirement: To resolve the projectile issue, GHHA previously approved a 16-foot-high, 64-foot-long safety net (consisting of two 36-foot sections). However, Mr. Honerkamp argued that anchoring a net of this scale requires a solid 6-foot masonry base to provide structural integrity against monsoon winds. He contended that a 4-foot base is structurally and functionally insufficient, creating a hazard where wind loads could knock the structure down. Additionally, the installation required a 30-day masonry cure period before the netting could be anchored.
Theme 2: Architectural Restrictions vs. Structural Necessity

The central conflict evolved around the tension between strict CC&R height limits and structural requirements for safety installations.

  • The 4-Foot Height Limitation: GHHA Section 13 (Unit One CC&Rs) explicitly mandates that no solid masonry or wood perimeter wall facing the golf course shall exceed 4 feet in height.
  • HOA Proposed Alternatives: GHHA Management (Heywood Community Management / Carmel Chandel) and Board members proposed two alternatives:
  1. Constructing a 4-foot solid concrete wall topped with 2 feet of see-through wrought iron or slat material (or decorative 2×2 columns to anchor the net).
  2. Petitioning the homeowners of Unit One to formally amend the CC&Rs to allow 6-foot solid walls.
  • Petitioner’s Objections to Alternatives: Using AI-generated visual models (Tab 9 / Exhibits H & I), Mr. Honerkamp argued that a 4-foot wall topped with 2 feet of wrought iron would remain easily climbable for trespassing golfers and would fail to keep small children inside the yard. He asserted that a 6-foot solid masonry wall was the only solution providing structural stability for the net while preventing intrusion and visual access.

“ [Proposed 6-Foot Netting System] | | <-- 16-Foot Approved Safety Netting (Two 36-ft Sections) | ======================= <-- Anchor Line (Requires 30-Day Masonry Cure) | | | 6-Ft Solid Wall | <-- DENIED BY HOA (Section 13 CC&R 4-Ft Limit) | (Requested Base) | <-- Petitioner argued 4-ft wall is structurally unsafe in monsoons | | ======================= “

Theme 3: Claims of Selective Enforcement and Neighborhood Precedents

To overcome the clear 4-foot restriction in Section 13, Mr. Honerkamp asserted that GHHA selectively enforced the height limit, violating A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3) (which prohibits unreasonably withholding architectural approvals) and general Arizona contract law principles regarding arbitrary enforcement.

  • Evidence Submitted by Petitioner: Mr. Honerkamp submitted photographic evidence (Tab 10 / Exhibit J) of nearby properties within the community possessing perimeter structures exceeding 4 feet:
  • 832 South Revolta Circle: Solid block wall measured at 65 inches (5.5 feet) with no wrought iron.
  • 706 South Saranac: Solid wall measured between 6 and 7 feet high.
  • Commercial Perimeter Wall: An 8-foot wall adjacent to Serranos Mexican Restaurant on Power Road.
  • Respondent’s Defense and ALJ Findings:
  • Commercial Boundary: GHHA established that the 8-foot wall near Serranos Mexican Restaurant was outside GHHA jurisdiction, sitting on the boundary between the resort and the commercial property owner.
  • Lack of Board Records / Knowledge: Board President Osborne testified that the current board (in office for 4–5 years) had no record or knowledge of prior board approvals for the non-conforming walls at Revolta Circle or Saranac. The existence of non-conforming structures built under prior boards or without authorization ("stealth installations") did not constitute intentional selective enforcement by the current board.
  • Judicial Determination: The ALJ found Board President Osborne’s testimony credible. The decision held that Mr. Honerkamp failed to present evidence that the Board knew of the non-conforming walls when constructed, approved them, targeted Mr. Honerkamp, or acted in bad faith.
Theme 4: Governance Structure and Statutory Compliance of Golden Hills HOA

The proceedings highlighted the unique organizational and legal framework of the Golden Hills Homeowners Association.

  • Subdivision Breakdown: GHHA encompasses approximately 780 homes built starting in 1960. The community is divided into six distinct units, each constructed by different developers and governed by its own separate set of CC&Rs (there are no blanket community-wide CC&Rs). Approximately 340 homes are situated on golf course lots.
  • Financial and Membership Structure: GHHA is non-traditional: it owns no common real property and charges no recurring monthly assessments. Homeowners pay a one-time fee upon title transfer/purchase to opt in as members. Non-members (those who opt out) remain deed-restricted by the CC&Rs tied to their lot plot under Arizona property law, though they are restricted from voting or attending HOA business meetings.
  • Difficulty of CC&R Amendments: GHHA leadership noted that passing a CC&R amendment to raise wall heights across Unit One is exceedingly difficult due to statutory voting thresholds across separate sub-entities, rendering homeowner-led amendments practically infeasible within a short timeframe.
  • Statutory Rulings (Planned Communities Act):
  • A.R.S. § 33-1802: Defined planned communities and community documents. The ALJ ruled Mr. Honerkamp provided no evidence showing GHHA violated this section.
  • A.R.S. § 33-1817: Mandates that architectural design approvals shall not be unreasonably withheld. The ALJ determined that denying an application that directly violates an explicit, un-amended CC&R height limitation is reasonable and legally required.

3. Important Quotes with Context

Quote 1: Petitioner on Safety Risks and Family Crisis

Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp: "We faced a constant dual threat, high velocity golf ball strikes and damage to property, and then unauthorized golfers constantly trespassing directly onto our private lawn to retrieve balls, creating an active safety and privacy crisis for my family. The conflict here is that the HOA acknowledged the safety risk and approved a 16 ft net. However, it denied the necessary 6ft masonry wall base required to structurally anchor that net and keep trespassers off our property citing a strict 4ft height limit in their own CCNRs."

  • Context: Spoken during Mr. Honerkamp’s opening statement. It summarizes his core factual argument: that approving the 16-foot safety net while denying the 6-foot solid base renders the net structurally unviable and leaves his family exposed to safety hazards and physical intrusion.
Quote 2: HOA President on Legal Duty to Enforce CC&Rs

William Osborne: "Our entire position on this is the fact that as a board we are charged with maintaining and administering our CCNRs. They're very plain. They've been in place for about 65 years… our position is that a 4ft wall would not be any less effective at intrusion than a 6ft wall and we cannot by law violate our own CCNRs."

  • Context: Spoken during Mr. Osborne’s opening response. It establishes GHHA’s legal defense: the Board lacks discretionary authority to grant architectural variances that explicitly violate unambiguous CC&R text limits (Section 13) that have run with the land for decades.
Quote 3: Petitioner on Selective Enforcement Evidence

Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp: "When I looked over and I saw my neighbor and they had a 5 and 1/2 ft wall, I said, 'Something's not right here.' … I went around the community and I'm finding multiple homes where it's well above their stated means. We're talking six feet. This one was seven… Denying my request while allowing similar perimeter structures throughout the neighborhood constitute impermissible selective enforcement."

  • Context: Presented during Mr. Honerkamp’s direct testimony regarding Tab 10 (Exhibit J). Honerkamp argued that the physical existence of 5.5-foot and 7-foot solid block walls elsewhere in the community proved that the 4-foot height rule was arbitrarily enforced.
Quote 4: HOA Vice President on Openness along Golf Course Lots

Derek Platt: "I live on the 15th hole… I do have a net so it helps a little bit, but I have gone through the same thing you have… but I also know that the walls can be to the side. It's just facing the golf course that is prohibited… historically we've been aligned with the resort… to do our best to maintain backyards that face the golf course in a neat and orderly fashion."

  • Context: Testimony provided by Board Vice President Derek Platt. He explained the underlying aesthetic intent behind Section 13: maintaining an open view and uniform appearance along the fairway perimeter across all 340 golf course lots, while allowing higher walls on side lot lines.
Quote 5: HOA President on Board Discretion and Rule of Law

William Osborne: "Quite simply, we're not owners. We're not jackbooted stormtroopers. We're required by law to adjudicate what we have in front of us which are the CCNRs."

  • Context: Delivered during Mr. Osborne’s closing argument. He re-emphasized that the Board’s denial was not personal or malicious, but a mandatory legal duty imposed by governing community documents.
Quote 6: ALJ Final Conclusion of Law

ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson: "The preponderance of the evidence shows that GHHA was required to deny Mr. Honerkamp’s request to build a six-foot-tall-wall on his property, pursuant to Section 13 of the CC&RS. Mr. Honerkamp presented no evidence that the request was denied for any other reason… Mr. Honerkamp failed to establish that the Board selectively enforced Section 13 of its CC&Rs."

  • Context: Excerpted from Conclusion of Law Paragraph 8 of the October 9, 2026 Administrative Law Judge Decision. This represents the binding legal finding that resolved the docket in favor of GHHA.

4. Actionable Insights

Based on the evidence presented and the legal rulings in Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association, the following actionable insights apply to homeowners, architectural review committees, and HOA boards:

For Homeowners Seeking Architectural Modifications
  1. Strict Adherence to Explicit CC&R Text: Administrative tribunals and courts will enforce plain-language height limits written in CC&Rs (e.g., Section 13's 4-foot limit). Discretionary statutory provisions prohibiting "unreasonably withheld" approvals (A.R.S. § 33-1817) cannot be used to compel an HOA board to grant a variance that directly conflicts with express CC&R prohibitions.
  2. Proving Selective Enforcement Requires Knowledge and Intent: To successfully claim "selective enforcement," a homeowner cannot merely present photos of non-conforming structures in the neighborhood. The homeowner must provide concrete proof that:
  • The non-conforming structures reside within the exact same governing unit/CC&R jurisdiction.
  • The current or prior HOA Board explicitly approved the non-conforming structures, or knew of their construction and knowingly failed to enforce the CC&Rs.
  • The Board acted in bad faith or intentionally targeted the applicant.
  1. Utilize HOA-Permitted Architectural Alternatives: When full structural requests are prohibited by CC&Rs, applicants should work within permitted guidelines (e.g., combining a solid 4-foot base wall with approved see-through wrought iron extensions or structural support columns) rather than insisting on a non-conforming design.
For HOA Boards and Architectural Committees
  1. Maintain Comprehensive Historical Records: Board turnover (e.g., GHHA's board being 4 years old) creates evidentiary gaps regarding whether legacy structures were board-approved or erected without permission. Associations should digitize and archive all architectural approvals, site plans, and variance decisions permanently by lot number.
  2. Conduct Prompt Investigations upon Notice of Violations: When a homeowner submits evidence of non-conforming structures during a dispute, the Board should utilize the record-open window (or business days following a hearing) to research property histories, determine if violations exist, and document enforcement actions.
  3. Clarify Multi-Unit Governance and Jurisdictions: HOAs comprising multiple distinct sub-units with separate CC&Rs must ensure clear communication to residents regarding which specific unit rules apply to their lot, avoiding confusion drawn from structures located in adjacent units or commercial boundaries.

Study Guide: Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association (Docket No. 26F-H129-REL)


Section 1: Executive Summary & Case Overview

This study guide examines the administrative hearing and subsequent judicial decision in Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association (Docket No. 26F-H129-REL), heard before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson at the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings in Phoenix, Arizona.

Key Case Details
  • Hearing Date: September 10, 2026 (Record held open through September 21, 2026)
  • Decision Issued: October 9, 2026
  • Petitioner: Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp (Property Owner, 925 S. Longwood Loop, Unit One, Mesa, AZ 85208)
  • Respondent: Golden Hills Homeowners Association (GHHA / Apache Country Club Estates)
  • Respondent Representatives: William Osborne (Board President) and Derek Platt (Board Vice President)
  • Tribunal / Agency: Office of Administrative Hearings / Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE)
  • Presiding Administrative Law Judge: Velva Moses-Thompson
Core Legal Dispute

The central dispute is whether the Golden Hills Homeowners Association violated Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) §§ 33-1802 and 33-1817, or its own Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), by denying Kenneth Honerkamp’s request to construct a 6-foot solid masonry safety wall along his rear property line adjacent to a golf course fairway.

Honerkamp sought the 6-foot masonry wall base to anchor an already approved 16-foot-tall, 64-foot-long safety net system and to prevent golf balls and trespassers from entering his yard. GHHA denied the request pursuant to Section 13 of the Unit One CC&Rs, which limits solid wall heights facing the golf course to a maximum of 4 feet. Honerkamp alleged arbitrary denial and selective enforcement, claiming that other properties within the community maintained non-conforming perimeter walls ranging from 5.5 to 8 feet in height.


Section 2: Breakdown of Key Concepts & Arguments

“ CASE DISPUTE STRUCTURE │ ┌──────────────────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────────────────┐ ▼ ▼ PETITIONER (Kenneth Honerkamp) RESPONDENT (Golden Hills HOA) • Property Safety Hazard (golf balls, trespassers) • Unit One CC&Rs Section 13 (4 ft solid wall cap) • Net Stability (6 ft base required for monsoon winds) • Offered Alternatives (4 ft wall + wrought iron / columns) • Claims Selective Enforcement (Exhibits of 5.5–8 ft walls) • Lack of Board Knowledge / Past Enforcement Records • Statutory Claims (A.R.S. §§ 33-1802, 33-1817) • Governance Structure (6 separate units, 780 homes) │ │ └──────────────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────────────┘ ▼ ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE RULING • Burden of Proof: Petitioner • Preponderance of Evidence Standard • Ruling: DISMISSED (No selective enforcement or statutory violation proven) “

1. Petitioner’s Case (Kenneth Honerkamp)
  • Safety & Property Damage Concerns: Honerkamp purchased his home in 2025. The rear boundary directly faces the golf course fairway, resulting in property damage (broken window, damaged roof, damaged window screen) and an ongoing accumulation of high-velocity golf balls (over a 5-gallon bucket collected between May and September 2026). Honerkamp cited safety risks to his two young children and active trespassing by golfers crossing his 2.5-foot low fence.
  • Structural Interdependence: GHHA approved a 16-foot high, 64-foot long safety net system. Honerkamp argued that a 4-foot wall base was structurally insufficient to anchor the netting, which acts like a "sail" during Arizona monsoon winds, creating a risk of structural collapse. The netting requires a 6-foot masonry base and a 30-day masonry cure period before anchoring.
  • Selective Enforcement Evidence (Exhibit J): Honerkamp presented photographs and measurements of taller walls in the neighborhood:
  • 832 S. Revolta Circle: 5.5-foot solid block wall (65 inches).
  • 706 S. Saranac: 6- to 7-foot solid perimeter wall facing the golf course.
  • Taller Perimeter Structure: A structure measuring nearly 8 feet in height.
  • Legal Theories Cited: Honerkamp asserted that GHHA violated A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3) (prohibiting unreasonable withholding of architectural approval), A.R.S. § 33-1802, and board discretion provisions under community governing documents.
2. Respondent’s Case (Golden Hills HOA)
  • Governing Restriction: Section 13 of the Unit One CC&Rs explicitly limits solid masonry or wood walls to a maximum height of 4 feet facing the golf course.
  • Reasonable Compromises Offered: The HOA board noted that past owners installed 4-foot solid masonry walls topped with 2 feet of see-through wrought iron or slat material, or utilized 2×2 decorative columns for support, which satisfy structural needs while preserving golf course views.
  • Community Governing Structure: Golden Hills comprises 780 homes split across six distinct units developed by different contractors starting in 1960. Each unit has its own unique set of CC&Rs. Amendments require voting across individual units, making CC&R changes difficult.
  • Rebuttal to Selective Enforcement:
  • The current board members had served for 4–5 years and had no record or knowledge of prior boards approving 6-foot solid walls facing the golf course. Taller existing walls may have been built without approval ("stealth approval").
  • The 8-foot wall depicted in Honerkamp's evidence was identified as being adjacent to Serranos Mexican Restaurant on Power Road—a commercial property managed by the golf resort, falling outside GHHA’s jurisdiction.
  • Financial/Membership Model: GHHA does not charge recurring monthly assessments. Members pay a one-time fee upon title transfer to "opt in." Homeowners who "opt out" (such as Honerkamp) remain bound by the CC&Rs run with the land, though non-members cannot attend HOA meetings or vote.
3. Statutory Framework & Burden of Proof
  • Burden of Proof: Under Arizona Administrative Code (A.A.C.) § R2-19-119, the petitioner bears the burden of proof under the preponderance of the evidence standard (the evidence must show that the allegation is more likely true than not).
  • A.R.S. § 33-1802 (Planned Communities Act Definitions): Defines key terminology such as "Association," "Community Documents," and "Planned Community."
  • A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3): Mandates that approval of a construction project’s architectural designs, plans, and amendments shall not be unreasonably withheld by an association.
4. Administrative Law Judge Findings & Order
  1. Governing Provision: Honerkamp initially cited Article 2, Section 18, but confirmed post-hearing that Section 13 of the Unit One CC&Rs governs the property and limits wall heights to 4 feet.
  2. Failure to Prove A.R.S. § 33-1802 Violation: Honerkamp provided no evidence establishing a violation of statutory definitions.
  3. Failure to Establish Selective Enforcement: While Honerkamp showed that non-conforming walls exist in the community, he failed to prove that:
  • The Board had knowledge of these walls when erected.
  • Prior or current Boards explicitly approved their construction.
  • The Board acted in bad faith or targeted Honerkamp arbitrarily.
  1. Final Disposition: Because GHHA was required by Section 13 of its CC&Rs to deny the 6-foot solid wall request, approval was not unreasonably withheld. Honerkamp’s petition was DISMISSED.

Section 3: Short-Answer Practice Questions

Questions
  1. What is the docket number, tribunal, and presiding judge for this administrative hearing?
  2. What specific address and community unit was at issue in this dispute?
  3. What explicit height limit for solid walls is set forth in Section 13 of the Golden Hills Unit One CC&Rs?
  4. What two distinct threats did Kenneth Honerkamp present as the primary justification for his requested 6-foot wall?
  5. Why did Honerkamp argue that an approved 16-foot safety net necessitated a 6-foot masonry wall base rather than a 4-foot wall base?
  6. What legal standard and burden of proof applied to the petitioner under A.A.C. § R2-19-119?
  7. Which statutory provision mandates that an HOA architectural committee shall not unreasonably withhold approval of construction plans?
  8. How did the HOA representatives explain the presence of an ~8-foot wall depicted in the petitioner's Exhibit J?
  9. What alternative structural configurations did the HOA board offer to accommodate Honerkamp's safety netting without violating the 4-foot solid wall height limit?
  10. Why did the ALJ conclude that Honerkamp failed to establish impermissible selective enforcement by the HOA?

Detailed Answer Keys
  1. Docket Number & Tribunal: Docket No. 26F-H129-REL, heard at the Office of Administrative Hearings in Phoenix, Arizona, before Administrative Law Judge Velva Moses-Thompson.
  2. Address & Unit: 925 S. Longwood Loop, Unit One, Mesa, AZ 85208 (located in Apache Country Club Estates / Golden Hills).
  3. Height Limit: Section 13 limits solid masonry or wood walls to a maximum height of 4 feet along the golf course fairway.
  4. Primary Threats:
  • Property damage and safety hazards from high-velocity golf ball strikes.
  • Active trespassing by unauthorized golfers crossing low perimeter boundaries to retrieve balls.
  1. Structural Stability Rationale: The 16-foot high by 64-foot long safety netting acts like a sail during strong monsoon winds. Honerkamp argued that a 4-foot masonry base was functionally and structurally insufficient to safely anchor the system against collapse.
  2. Burden & Standard of Proof: The burden of proof was on the petitioner (Kenneth Honerkamp) under the preponderance of the evidence standard (A.A.C. § R2-19-119).
  3. Statutory Provision: A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3).
  4. Explanation of the 8-Foot Wall: The HOA testified that the 8-foot wall was located adjacent to Serranos Mexican Restaurant on Power Road, which is commercial property operated between the resort and the restaurant owner, falling outside GHHA's jurisdiction and governance.
  5. Proposed Alternatives:
  • A 4-foot solid masonry wall topped with 2 feet of see-through wrought iron or slat material.
  • Constructing 2×2 decorative support columns at the ends and center of a 4-foot wall to anchor the netting structure.
  • Petitioning Unit One homeowners to formally amend the CC&Rs.
  1. Reason for Ruling on Selective Enforcement: Honerkamp failed to present evidence that the Board had knowledge of the existing non-conforming walls when built, that the Board had formally approved them, or that the Board acted in bad faith or targeted him arbitrarily.

Section 4: Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Essay Prompt 1: Analysis of Architectural Review Standards Under Arizona HOA Law

Prompt: Analyze the legal interplay between A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3)—which dictates that architectural approvals shall not be unreasonably withheld—and an HOA’s duty to enforce explicit CC&R height restrictions. Using Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association as a case study, discuss how an administrative tribunal evaluates whether a denial is "reasonable" when safety concerns conflict with express restrictive covenants.

Key Outline & Rubric Points:
  • Statutory Duty vs. Express Covenants: Explain that A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3) subjects HOA architectural decisions to a reasonableness standard. However, board discretion cannot override clear, unambiguous restrictions written into recorded CC&Rs unless granted explicitly by the declaration.
  • Evaluating "Reasonableness": Discuss how the ALJ evaluated GHHA’s denial. Because Section 13 strictly capped solid walls at 4 feet, the Board was legally required to deny a solid 6-foot wall request. Therefore, enforcing express CC&R text is per se reasonable absent bad faith or waiver.
  • Balancing Safety and Architectural Uniformity: Examine how the Board offered alternative designs (wrought iron extensions, support pillars) to balance the homeowner's safety needs (anchoring the net) with the community’s aesthetic restriction (preserving golf course openness).

Essay Prompt 2: Evidentiary Requirements for Establishing Selective Enforcement

Prompt: To successfully claim "selective enforcement" of community covenants, a property owner must present specific, convincing evidence beyond merely showing that non-conforming structures exist within a neighborhood. Detail the evidentiary threshold established in Honerkamp v. Golden Hills HOA and explain why the Petitioner's photographic evidence failed to meet the preponderance of the evidence standard.

Key Outline & Rubric Points:
  • Definition of Selective Enforcement: Define selective enforcement as the arbitrary or discriminatory enforcement of a rule against one homeowner while knowingly allowing identical violations by others.
  • Petitioner's Evidence: Identify Honerkamp’s Exhibit J evidence (photographs/measurements of walls at 832 S. Revolta Circle, 706 S. Saranac, and Serranos Mexican Restaurant ranging from 5.5 to 8 feet).
  • Evidentiary Deficiencies Identified by ALJ:
  1. Lack of Scienter/Knowledge: No proof that the current or prior Boards knew the walls existed or were built over height limits.
  2. Lack of Approval Proof: No evidence showing formal Board variance or architectural approval for those specific walls (possibility of "stealth" unapproved construction).
  3. Jurisdictional Errors: Inclusion of commercial/resort property (Serranos) outside HOA control.
  4. Absence of Bad Faith: No evidence that the HOA targeted Honerkamp maliciously or acted with arbitrary intent.

Essay Prompt 3: Governance Structures and Structural Constraints in Multi-Unit Planned Communities

Prompt: Golden Hills Homeowners Association features an unusual organizational structure comprising 780 homes across six distinct units, each governed by separate CC&Rs and operating on an "opt-in" single transfer fee model. Discuss the legal and operational challenges this structure presents for both boards and homeowners seeking CC&R amendments or uniform rule enforcement, as highlighted during the administrative hearing.

Key Outline & Rubric Points:
  • Multi-Unit Governance Dynamics: Explain that GHHA consists of 6 distinct sub-units created sequentially from 1960 onward. Because each unit maintains its own separate CC&Rs, restrictions in Unit One (e.g., Section 13) do not automatically apply to Units Two through Six.
  • Amendment Hurdles: Detail the board president’s testimony regarding the extreme difficulty of passing CC&R amendments across multiple units, requiring extensive owner voting that renders quick rule modifications nearly impossible.
  • Financial & Membership Framework: Analyze the non-traditional dues structure—a one-time title transfer fee with an opt-out mechanism—and its legal impact. Note that under Arizona law, recorded CC&Rs run with the land and bind all property owners regardless of whether they "opt in" to association membership activities.

Section 5: Glossary of Important Terms

TermSource Definition / Contextual Meaning
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)An independent judicial officer who conducts hearings and issues decisions in administrative legal disputes (in this case, ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson).
Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE)The state agency authorized under A.R.S. Title 32, Chapter 20, Article 11 to receive and decide petitions regarding dispute resolution in planned communities.
A.R.S. § 33-1802The statutory section of the Arizona Planned Communities Act defining terms such as "Association," "Declaration," "Community Documents," and "Planned Community."
A.R.S. § 33-1817Arizona statute governing declaration amendments and architectural review committees; explicitly mandates under § 33-1817(B)(3) that architectural approval shall not be unreasonably withheld.
Burden of ProofThe legal obligation of a party to prove their allegations. In this proceeding, the burden rested entirely on the petitioner, Kenneth Honerkamp.
Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs)Recorded legal obligations governing land use, architectural standards, and maintenance responsibilities within a real estate development.
Masonry Cure PeriodThe mandatory 30-day drying and hardening period required for newly poured concrete/masonry walls before structural netting anchors can be safely secured.
Opt-In / Opt-Out HOA ModelA non-recurring fee structure where buyers pay a one-time fee upon title transfer to join association activities. CC&Rs remain deeded to the plot and legally binding regardless of membership status.
Planned Communities ActChapter 16 of Title 33 of the Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818), governing homeowner associations and community operations.
Preponderance of the EvidenceThe standard of proof under A.A.C. § R2-19-119 requiring that the evidence presented demonstrates a claim is more convincing and more likely true than not.
Selective EnforcementThe illegal or arbitrary application of community covenants where an HOA enforces a rule against one owner while intentionally ignoring violations by others.
Stealth Approval / ConstructionUnapproved construction undertaken by homeowners without HOA knowledge or formal architectural permit applications.

Fences, Fairways, and CC&Rs: Inside the Golf Course HOA Wall Dispute (Honerkamp v. Golden Hills)

1. Introduction: A Backyard Safety Crisis vs. HOA Rules

On September 10, 2026, the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings in Phoenix convened to hear docket number 26F-H129-REL, a dispute that captures the ultimate suburban tension: a father’s desperate effort to protect his young children from high-velocity golf balls and trespassing golfers, matched against a board enforcing strict, long-standing architectural height limits. Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson presided over the administrative hearing between homeowner Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp and the Golden Hills Homeowners Association (GHHA).

The property at the center of the storm is located at 925 S. Longwood Loop, Unit One, in Apache Country Club Estates (Golden Hills) in Mesa, Arizona. Sitting directly adjacent to an active golf course fairway, Mr. Honerkamp’s backyard is on the receiving end of relentless errant drives. Seeking to resolve a multi-tiered safety hazard, Honerkamp requested architectural approval to construct a 6-foot solid masonry wall along his rear property boundary. This wall was designed to serve as the structural anchor for a previously approved 16-foot safety net. However, the GHHA Board denied the request, citing Section 13 of the Unit One Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs), which caps rear solid masonry walls facing the fairway at a maximum height of 4 feet.


2. The Homeowner’s Case: Flying Golf Balls, Trespassing, and Selective Enforcement

Mr. Honerkamp, representing himself pro se at the hearing, argued that the HOA’s denial was an arbitrary, rigid exercise of authority that placed his family in daily jeopardy. His case relied on extensive physical documentation, photographic proof, and statutory claims.

The Flying Ball Hazard & The Trespassing Crisis

Honerkamp purchased the home in January 2025 and quickly realized his family was trapped in a projectile landing zone. To demonstrate the severity of the issue, he outlined a mounting timeline of physical evidence:

  • Property Damage: Honerkamp presented photographs showing broken windows, chipped and damaged roof tiles, and torn window screens caused by golf ball strikes.
  • Escalating Golf Ball Accumulation: Initial photos submitted with his May 2026 petition to the Department of Real Estate showed a small pile of stray golf balls. By the night before the September 10, 2026 hearing, Honerkamp submitted updated photos showing a filled 5-gallon bucket—reflecting a massive surge of ball strikes (over 1.5 times the May collection) in just four months.
  • Security Camera Video Logs: Honerkamp submitted security camera footage showing golfers stepping over his existing 2.5-foot low boundary fence directly onto his private lawn to retrieve stray balls. These trespassers routinely ignored "No Trespassing" signs, creating severe privacy violations and safety risks for his two small children.
The Monsoon Sail: Why a 4-Foot Wall Couldn't Hold the Net

Honerkamp highlighted what he characterized as a structural "catch-22" created by the HOA board. While GHHA had granted approval for a massive 16-foot-high by 64-foot-long safety net (divided into two 36-foot sections), it refused to approve the 6-foot solid masonry wall needed to anchor it. Honerkamp testified that anchoring a 16-foot high screen to a flimsy 4-foot wall or small posts was dangerous. During seasonal Arizona monsoons, wind force against a 64-foot net creates a massive "sail" effect, threatening to tear down an under-anchored wall.

The Selective Enforcement Claim & Exhibit J

A cornerstone of Honerkamp's argument was that GHHA applied its height restrictions arbitrarily. In Exhibit J, he submitted photographs and measurements of several neighborhood properties featuring solid perimeter barriers well over the 4-foot limit:

  • 832 S. Revolta Circle: A solid block rear wall directly facing the course measured at 5.5 feet (65 inches) tall, built entirely of block without wrought iron.
  • 706 S. Saranac: A perimeter wall along the course measuring between 6 and 7 feet tall.
  • Commercial Boundary Wall: A perimeter wall reaching nearly 8 feet tall in the surrounding community area along Power Road.
Statutory Arguments: A Misunderstood Legal Shield

Grounding his claim in Arizona law, Honerkamp cited two key statutes:

  • A.R.S. § 33-1817(B)(3): Mandates that planned community architectural reviews must be conducted reasonably, stipulating that approval of architectural plans shall not be unreasonably withheld.
  • A.R.S. § 33-1802: Cited by Honerkamp under the belief that it granted broad, fundamental property protection rights against physical damage and public nuisances.

Specialist Commentary: Pro se litigants frequently misinterpret statutory provisions when battling HOAs. While A.R.S. § 33-1817 provides a genuine legal standard requiring architectural committees to act reasonably, citing general definitions or procedural statutes without establishing explicit board bad faith is a common tactical misstep.


3. The HOA’s Defense: CC&R Limits and Community Aesthetics

Representing GHHA, Board President William Osborne and Vice President Derek Platt provided the association's defense, grounding their arguments in strict contractual compliance, aesthetic uniformity, and architectural structural alternatives.

Inside Golden Hills: A Unique Governance Structure

President Osborne testified that Golden Hills, established in 1960, is a unique development comprising 780 homes divided across six distinct units—each constructed by different builders with separate CC&Rs.

The community operates under an uncommon administrative model: GHHA charges no recurring monthly or annual assessments. Instead, buyers pay a one-time fee upon purchasing the home to opt in to association membership, which grants voting and meeting attendance rights. However, regardless of whether a homeowner opts in or out, the recorded CC&Rs remain deeded directly to the plot and run with the land, legally binding every property owner. Out of 780 homes, roughly 340 sit directly on golf course lots.

CC&R Section 13: View Corridors vs. Side Yard Rules

GHHA argued that the board lacks the legal authority to violate written deed restrictions. Section 13 of the Unit One CC&Rs explicitly mandates that solid masonry or wood walls facing the golf course fairway cannot exceed 4 feet in height, preserving open fairway views and community aesthetics.

The board highlighted critical distinction rules across the neighborhood:

  • Rear Fairway Walls vs. Side Yard Walls: Side yard walls throughout Golden Hills have historically been permitted at 5 to 6 feet up to the street line. However, the strict 4-foot solid height cap applies specifically to rear walls directly facing the fairway view corridor.
The Design Alternative: Wrought Iron & Anchor Columns

In response to Honerkamp’s "monsoon sail" structural concerns, Vice President Derek Platt—an engineer and designer by trade—and President Osborne pointed out that the HOA's denial of a solid 6-foot masonry wall did not leave Honerkamp without options.

The board clarified that Section 13 allows homeowners to construct open, see-through decorative extensions above the 4-foot masonry base. Platt noted that Honerkamp could easily construct 2×2 structural columns, split-block posts, or wrought-iron support framing at key intervals to safely anchor the 16-foot netting without building an illegal solid 6-foot masonry barrier.

Rebutting the Taller Walls: Commercial Borders and Legacy Structures

Addressing Honerkamp’s Exhibit J selective enforcement evidence, the board systematically dismantled his comparisons:

  • Commercial Border Wall (Serrano's): The nearly 8-foot wall cited in Honerkamp's evidence borders Serrano’s Mexican Restaurant on Power Road. Osborne clarified that this wall sits on commercial property outside GHHA's residential governance, falling under the jurisdiction of the commercial owner and the golf resort.
  • Lack of Prior Board Approval Records: Regarding the tall block walls at Revolta Circle and Saranac, President Osborne testified that the current board (in office for 4 to 5 years) had no record or knowledge of those walls being approved. Osborne emphasized that unapproved legacy structures erected by past homeowners—or built without board knowledge—do not legally invalidate written CC&R restrictions or bind current board enforcement.

4. The Verdict: Administrative Law Judge Decision

Following the September 10, 2026 hearing, ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson issued an order keeping the evidentiary record open until September 21, 2026, allowing both parties to submit official copies of the governing unit CC&Rs.

On October 9, 2026, ALJ Moses-Thompson issued her formal administrative decision, ruling entirely in favor of the HOA.

Key Procedural & Legal Insights from the Ruling:
  1. The CC&R Provision Shift: In his initial petition and hearing testimony, Honerkamp argued that the board violated "Article 2, Section 18." However, as noted in Footnote 1 of the ALJ Decision, Honerkamp was forced to concede post-hearing that Section 13 was the actual controlling provision for Unit One, highlighting the critical necessity of verifying exact unit documents.
  2. The Statutory Rejection of § 33-1802: The ALJ explicitly clarified that A.R.S. § 33-1802 is purely a statutory definitions provision (defining terms like "Association," "Declaration," and "Planned Community") rather than a substantive statutory right to property protection. Because § 33-1802 provides no actionable cause of action, Honerkamp's statutory claim under this provision was rejected outright.
  3. Credibility & Selective Enforcement Findings: Crucially, Judge Moses-Thompson explicitly found Board President Osborne's testimony regarding the board's lack of knowledge about legacy non-conforming walls to be credible (Findings of Fact ¶ 13). (Blogger’s Note: In Finding of Fact ¶ 8 of the official written order, the ALJ included a minor administrative typo, typing "Mr. Hack presented no evidence…" when referring to Mr. Honerkamp). Because Honerkamp failed to prove the board knowingly permitted non-conforming walls or acted in bad faith, his selective enforcement claim collapsed.
Petitioner's ClaimsALJ's Findings & Ruling
Violation of A.R.S. § 33-1817 & CC&R Section 13: HOA unreasonably withheld approval for a 6-foot solid masonry wall needed to anchor an approved net and protect property.Unsubstantiated: Under A.R.S. § R2-19-119, the petitioner bore the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence. GHHA was legally bound to enforce Section 13 of the Unit One CC&Rs (limiting solid rear walls to 4 feet). The board offered valid design alternatives (wrought iron/posts), and no evidence showed approval was withheld in bad faith or unreasonably.
Violation of A.R.S. § 33-1802: HOA violated statutory property protection rights by denying the safety wall.Unsubstantiated: A.R.S. § 33-1802 is strictly a statutory definitions section. Petitioner presented zero evidence demonstrating a statutory violation of planned community definition standards.
Selective Enforcement: HOA enforced height rules arbitrarily, as proven by 5.5 to 7+ foot solid walls at nearby fairway properties (Exhibit J).Unsubstantiated: Petitioner failed to show the Board knew of the non-conforming walls, when they were built, or that past/present boards approved them. The ALJ found Board President Osborne's testimony credible. No evidence proved the Board targeted petitioner or acted arbitrarily.
Final OrderPETITION DISMISSED.

5. Key Takeaways for Homeowners and HOA Boards

The ruling in Honerkamp v. Golden Hills Homeowners Association serves as a crucial case study for homeowners and board members navigating architectural reviews, safety concerns, and administrative disputes:

  1. CC&Rs Are Binding Baseline Rules—Even in Safety Nuisances: Administrative law judges and Arizona courts will strictly enforce unambiguous, recorded deed restrictions as written. Even when a homeowner presents compelling evidence of severe property damage, trespassing, or safety risks to young children, an HOA board lacks the discretionary authority to grant architectural variances that directly violate plain CC&R height prohibitions unless formal community amendment procedures are executed.
  1. Proving Selective Enforcement Requires Proof of Board Knowledge and Bad Faith: Simply taking photos of existing, non-conforming neighbor structures is insufficient to win a selective enforcement claim. To establish selective enforcement under Arizona law, a homeowner must prove that the current or prior board knowingly approved those specific non-conforming structures, permitted them in deliberate bad faith, or intentionally targeted the applicant for unequal treatment.
  1. Explore Architectural Compromises Before Litigating: When dealing with structural challenges—such as anchoring high netting against wind loads—homeowners should engage directly with board-offered structural compromises (e.g., structural columns, split-block posts, or wrought-iron extensions) that comply with height limits. Rejecting legal design alternatives to insist on an unpermissible solid barrier will routinely lead to dismissal in administrative hearings.
  1. Verify Unit-Specific Documents and Statutory Provisions: In multi-unit or phased developments, rules differ significantly between sections. Homeowners must verify the exact recorded unit clause (e.g., Section 13 vs. Section 18) governing their specific lot and ensure they are citing substantive statutory standards (like A.R.S. § 33-1817) rather than procedural definition statutes (like A.R.S. § 33-1802) before initiating administrative legal petitions.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Kenneth Christopher Honerkamp (Petitioner)

Respondent Side

  • William Osborne (President, Board of Directors)
    Golden Hills Homeowners Association
  • Derek Platt (Vice President, Board of Directors)
    Golden Hills Homeowners Association

Neutral Parties

  • Velva Moses-Thompson (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings

Rainey, Chad D. / HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H114-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-10-09
Administrative Law JudgeNicole Robinson
OutcomePetition Granted
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties$0.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerChad D. RaineyCounsel—
RespondentThe Garden Lakes Community AssociationCounsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1442906.pdf

(57.1 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1445701.pdf

(48.0 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1445766.pdf

(45.5 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1447411.pdf

(57.2 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1447412.pdf

(7.9 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1461257.pdf

(45.8 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1478147.pdf

(155.4 KB)

26F-H114-REL Case document – 1481756.pdf

(43.4 KB)

Executive Briefing: OAH Administrative Proceeding (No. 26F-H114-REL) — Rainey v. The Garden Lakes Community Association

Executive Summary

This briefing document synthesizes the administrative proceedings, procedural rulings, witness testimony, legal arguments, and evidentiary findings in the matter of Chad D. Rainey / HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019 (Petitioner) v. The Garden Lakes Community Association (Respondent), Docket No. 26F-H114-REL, before the State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).

The dispute centers on allegations by Petitioner Chad Rainey that the Garden Lakes Community Association violated Arizona Revised Statute (A.R.S.) § 33-1805(A) by failing to fulfill two formal written records requests—submitted on April 25, 2025, and October 30, 2025—within the statutory 10-business-day window. The requested records pertained to Homeowners Association (HOA) board member training sessions, including dates, providers, agendas, notes, emails, invoices, and certificates of completion.

Respondent contended that the requested documents either do not exist, constitute requests for unrecorded information rather than existing custodial records, fall under attorney-client privilege, or represent third-party educational events outside association custody. Additionally, Respondent raised procedural defenses regarding standing and statute of limitations.

Following procedural orders issued by Administrative Law Judges Tammy L. Eigenheer and Nicole Robinson, an evidentiary hearing convened on August 31, 2026, before ALJ Nicole Robinson. Testimony was taken from Petitioner Chad Rainey, CCMC Community Manager Stephanie Zia, and Association Vice President Wayne Hunt.


Case Overview & Key Administrative Filings

The table below summarizes the core administrative orders, notices, and procedural milestones established in the OAH record.

Filing DateDocument Type / ActionPresiding ALJSummary of Action / Content
July 7, 2026Order Setting HearingTammy L. EigenheerSet initial hearing for July 31, 2026, at 3:00 p.m. via Google Meet or in-person at OAH Phoenix. Established 7-day pre-hearing document submission rule.
July 10, 2026Subpoena IssuedN/ASubpoena issued on behalf of Petitioner Chad Rainey.
July 14, 2026Subpoena ObjectionN/ARespondent filed formal objection to the July 10 subpoena.
July 15, 2026Order Quashing SubpoenaNicole RobinsonTribunal officially quashed the subpoena issued July 10, 2026.
July 15, 2026Order Upholding Quash of SubpoenaNicole RobinsonDenied Petitioner's Motion for Reconsideration, upholding the quash. Noted Petitioner could renew requests at trial based on case development.
July 20, 2026Order Granting ContinuanceNicole RobinsonGranted Respondent's request to continue the hearing to August 31, 2026, at 1:00 p.m. via Google Meet.
August 26, 2026Minute EntryNicole RobinsonAcknowledged Respondent's notice of intent to appear in-person for the August 31, 2026 hearing.
August 31, 2026Evidentiary HearingNicole RobinsonFormal hearing convened. Testimony taken, exhibits admitted, oral closing arguments delivered. Decision pending (due within 20 days).

Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

1. Scope of the Records Dispute under A.R.S. § 33-1805

Petitioner filed a single-issue petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) alleging a violation of A.R.S. § 33-1805(A), which mandates that all financial and other records of a planned community association be made reasonably available for examination within 10 business days.

  • The Initial Request (April 25, 2025 – Exhibit A): Requested (1) dates current board members attended training, (2) the training provider company, (3) meeting agendas, and (4) certificates or documentation showing successful completion.
  • The Second Request (October 30, 2025 – Exhibit G): Circled back to the April request, narrowing the window to the preceding 36 months and asking for communications, notes, records, emails, provider names, invoices, agendas, and completion certificates regarding board member training.
  • ALJ Procedural Ruling on Scope: Respondent argued that the petition should be strictly limited to the April 25, 2025 request. ALJ Robinson overruled the objection, ruling that the October 30, 2025 request directly clarified and pointed back to the initial request under the same alleged statutory violation. Both requests (Exhibits A and G) were admitted and considered part of the single-issue proceeding.
2. Legal Defenses & Threshold Objections

Respondent's counsel (Lauren Elliott Stine, Esq. and Jack Contrera, Esq. of Quarles & Brady LLP) raised three primary defenses:

  • Lack of Standing: Respondent contended that the subject property is titled to the HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019, with Heather Rainey listed as the trustor/owner under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 and CC&R definitions. Petitioner refuted this by presenting an admitted designation document (Exhibit 8_07-Heather Rainey designation), signed by Heather Rainey, designating Chad Rainey as her authorized representative for all non-voting association matters.
  • Statute of Limitations: Respondent posited that claims regarding the April 25, 2025 request were time-barred under A.R.S. § 12-541(5) (one-year limitation for actions created by statute), as the petition was filed on April 26, 2026. The ALJ noted procedural concerns regarding unbriefed threshold motions raised at hearing and permitted the hearing to move forward on the merits, while giving counsel latitude regarding briefing.
  • Attorney-Client Privilege: Respondent asserted that communications between property management and legal counsel, as well as substance discussed during internal board trainings conducted by association counsel, are protected under attorney-client privilege. ALJ Robinson sustained multiple privilege objections regarding direct communications between Manager Stephanie Zia and Attorney Curtis Eckmark.
3. Evidentiary Findings & Witness Testimony
Stephanie Zia (CCMC Community Manager)
  • Search Conducted: Upon receiving Rainey’s requests, Zia searched board meeting minutes dating back to 2017 (the limit of records stored on the association portal/website).
  • Findings in Minutes: Found references to board training in three specific meeting minutes:
  • July 16, 2020 (Exhibit B): Board set a training date for August 12, 2020.
  • May 20, 2021 (Exhibit C): Board scheduled training with the law firm Carpenter Hazelwood for June 7, 2021.
  • May 19, 2022 (Exhibit D): Board set training for June 28, 2022.
  • Non-Existence of Additional Documents: Zia testified under oath that no separate agendas, notes, invoices, or completion certificates exist for those three sessions. She confirmed she did not search individual email archives or personal calendars because no separate board training records existed outside the meeting minutes.
  • Third-Party Educational Events: Regarding a CCMC summer 2025 seminar (legislative and case law update presented by Attorney Curtis Eckmark), Zia clarified that this was a general CCMC-hosted seminar made available to all CCMC-managed community associations, not a Garden Lakes board training event or an association record.
Wayne Hunt (Vice President & Former Board President)
  • Nature of HOA Board Training: Hunt (a board member for 10–11 years) testified that "board training" at Garden Lakes typically involves general counsel advising board members on their statutory and fiduciary duties.
  • Absence of Secondary Documentation: Confirmed that board trainings do not generate completion certificates, formal agendas, written handouts, or separate records kept in the ordinary course of business.
  • Attendance at Third-Party Seminars: Confirmed attending the CCMC summer 2025 legislative update at CCMC’s office after receiving an email invitation sent directly to his personal email address. He confirmed the invitation was not an association record, was not forwarded to board files, and did not involve Garden Lakes-specific records.
Chad Rainey (Petitioner / Pro Se)
  • Main Contention: Argued that the association’s own meeting minutes prove board trainings occurred. He asserted that an adequate search would have yielded email invites, RSVPs, calendars, or presentation slides held either by the board or its management agent (CCMC).
  • Fulfillment Duty: Maintained that A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) requires actual fulfillment or formal notification of non-existence within 10 business days, rather than counsel asking clarifying questions or attempting to narrow the request.

Important Quotes with Context

The following quotes from the August 31, 2026 hearing record highlight crucial legal rulings, witness statements, and party positions:

1. On Administrative Jurisdiction and Post-Petition Evidence

Administrative Law Judge Nicole Robinson: "Anything that has to do with the June 2026 meeting is after your petition, and it's not relevant here today… Once again, I said it is not — I don't have jurisdiction over that time frame."

  • Context: ALJ Robinson ruling to strike and exclude Petitioner's attempts to introduce audio recordings and transcripts from a June 18, 2026 board meeting held after the petition was filed.
2. On the Definition and Reality of HOA Board Training

Wayne Hunt (Vice President, Garden Lakes): "Board training is typically we have our attorney, our general counsel come in and describe to the board what the duties of a board member are… No, it is not [mandatory]."

  • Context: Testimony explaining the informal and advisory nature of board sessions conducted by legal counsel, addressing why completion certificates or formal educational records do not exist.
3. On Custodial Records and Non-Existence of Agendas/Certificates

Stephanie Zia (CCMC Community Manager): "I checked our meeting minutes which would reference the dates and times. So, I checked the meeting minutes. Um, so I did do a search and located what he had and that was the extent… as there was no agendas or anything else."

  • Context: Manager Zia explaining her document search upon receiving Petitioner's October 30, 2025 request and testifying that no standalone agendas or completion certificates exist.
4. On Legal Counsel's Intermediary Role and Response

Chad Rainey (Petitioner): "They have 10 days to fulfill the request, not ask questions… Well, it's past the 10 days, so really too late to have a conversation about this."

  • Context: Petitioner Rainey recounting his email exchange with Association General Counsel Curtis Eckmark on November 14, 2025 (Exhibit H), where Eckmark asked for specific details to locate files, and Rainey terminated discussions due to the expiration of the 10-day statutory window.
5. On the Third-Party Nature of Management Seminars

Lauren Elliott Stine, Esq. (Respondent's Counsel): "The 2025 CCMC legislative update, that's not a board training. That's not specific to Garden Lakes. That's something that's put on by CCMC for all of its associations… that's not a board record."

  • Context: Closing argument emphasizing that general management company legal seminars are not official association records under A.R.S. § 33-1805.

Actionable Insights & Strategic Implications

Based on the evidence, witness testimonies, and administrative rulings in Docket No. 26F-H114-REL, the following operational and legal takeaways apply to HOA record governance and administrative litigation:

1. Distinguish Requests for Information vs. Requests for Records
  • Analysis: A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) obligates associations to provide access to existing custodial records. It does not require associations or management companies to compile answers, generate non-existent summaries, or answer interrogatory-style inquiries (e.g., listing dates or provider names where no record exists).
  • Actionable Insight: When responding to statutory requests, community managers should explicitly differentiate between providing existing documents (e.g., meeting minutes) and disclaiming obligations to create new documentation or provide non-recorded information.
2. Formalize Written Written Responses within the Statutory 10-Day Window
  • Analysis: A primary driver of this petition was the lack of a direct, formal written response from management within 10 business days explicitly stating that no separate agendas, invoices, or certificates existed.
  • Actionable Insight: If a search reveals that requested documents do not exist or are protected by attorney-client privilege, management or legal counsel must issue a formal written notice to the requesting owner within the 10-business-day window stating the exact disposition (e.g., "No responsive records exist outside public meeting minutes" or identifying specific statutory exemptions).
3. Establish Clear Boundaries for Third-Party & Educational Events
  • Analysis: Confusion arose because board members attended a summer 2025 legislative update hosted by CCMC. Because invitations were emailed directly to personal email accounts by a third-party management firm, Petitioner argued they constituted association records.
  • Actionable Insight: Management companies should clearly label external multi-client educational seminars as "Third-Party Educational Events Hosted by CCMC" rather than board-specific trainings, preventing mischaracterization as association-specific business records.
4. Record Maintenance and Portal Archives
  • Analysis: CCMC maintained web portal access to meeting minutes dating back to 2017. Witnesses established under oath that meeting minutes represent the sole official record of scheduled board training dates.
  • Actionable Insight: Associations should maintain a standardized digital archive of all approved meeting minutes and ensure public portal access is continuously updated, as publicly accessible portal documents fulfill statutory disclosure requirements under A.R.S. § 33-1805.

Study Guide: Administrative Law Hearing and Records Request Dispute (Rainey v. The Garden Lakes Community Association)


1. Executive Summary & Case Overview

This study guide provides an exhaustive review of the administrative law matter Chad D. Rainey / HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019 v. The Garden Lakes Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H114-REL), adjudicated before the State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).

The dispute centers on allegations by Petitioner Chad D. Rainey that The Garden Lakes Community Association violated Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 33-1805(A) by failing to fulfill statutory requests for association records pertaining to board member training sessions within the mandatory 10-business-day response window.

“ +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CASE IDENTIFICATION MATRIX | +--------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Tribunal | Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), Phoenix, Arizona | | Docket Number | No. 26F-H114-REL | | Petitioner | Chad D. Rainey / HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019 | | Respondent | The Garden Lakes Community Association | | State Oversight Agency | Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) (Commissioner Susan Nicolson) | | Presiding Judges | Administrative Law Judge Tammy L. Eigenheer (Initial Scheduling Order) | | | Administrative Law Judge Nicole Robinson (Subpoena Rulings, Hearing ALJ) | | Governing Statute | A.R.S. § 33-1805 (Planned Community Records Disclosure) | | Management Entity | Capital Consultant Management Company (CCMC) (Prior: AAM) | +--------------------------+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “


2. Key Concepts & Legal Framework

A. Statutory Duty of Disclosure (A.R.S. § 33-1805)
  • 10-Business-Day Rule: Under A.R.S. § 33-1805(A), planned community associations are required to make all financial and other records reasonably available for examination within 10 business days after receipt of a written request.
  • Scope of Records: The statute encompasses "all financial and other records of the association" and records kept on or on behalf of the association and the board of directors.
  • Exceptions to Disclosure: A.R.S. § 33-1805(B) provides specific statutory exemptions where records may be withheld from disclosure (e.g., attorney-client privileged communications, pending litigation, executive session matters).
B. Procedural Motions and Orders
  1. Subpoena Quashing and Reconsideration:
  • On July 10, 2026, the Tribunal issued a subpoena at Petitioner Rainey's request.
  • On July 14, 2026, Respondent objected to the subpoena.
  • On July 15, 2026, ALJ Nicole Robinson issued an Order Quashing the Subpoena.
  • Shortly after, Petitioner filed a Motion for Reconsideration of Order Quashing Subpoenas. On the same day (July 15, 2026), ALJ Robinson issued an Order Upholding the Quash of the Subpoena, preserving Petitioner's right to renew requests during the hearing based on case development.
  1. Continuance Rulings:
  • The hearing was originally scheduled by ALJ Tammy L. Eigenheer for July 31, 2026, at 3:00 p.m.
  • Upon Respondent's request and good cause appearing, ALJ Nicole Robinson granted a continuance via Orders issued July 20, 2026, rescheduling the hearing to August 31, 2026, at 1:00 PM.
  1. Standing Objections:
  • Respondent's counsel argued that Petitioner Chad D. Rainey lacked standing under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 because fee simple title to the property was held by the HN&CR Living Trust, with Heather N. Rainey designated as the trustor/owner.
  • Petitioner countered by submitting an official document (Heather Rainey Designation Form, referenced as 8_07-Heather Rainey designation), establishing Chad Rainey as her authorized designated representative for all non-voting association matters pursuant to community CC&Rs.
C. Analysis of Document Requests at Issue
  • Request #1 (Submitted April 25, 2025):
  • Requested training dates for current board members, the names of training provider companies, preparatory agendas, and certificates/documentation showing successful completion.
  • Request #2 (Submitted October 30, 2025):
  • Referenced circling back to unanswered requests. Explicitly scoped to the preceding 36 months, seeking all communications, notes, records, emails, provider names, invoices, agendas, and certificates regarding board member training.
  • Respondent's Defenses:
  1. Non-Existence of Documents: Respondent contended that beyond public board meeting minutes (which noted past training dates for 2020, 2021, and 2022), no separate agendas, certificates, invoices, or instructional materials exist.
  2. Attorney-Client Privilege: Discussions held during board trainings with association legal counsel (e.g., Carpenter Hazelwood, Ekmark) are protected by attorney-client privilege.
  3. Third-Party Events: A Summer 2025 "Legislative and Case Law Update" presented by attorney Curtis Ekmark at CCMC's office was a broad third-party vendor seminar for all CCMC-managed HOAs, not an official, exclusive Garden Lakes board training session or association record.

3. Timeline of Key Events

“ +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CHRONOLOGICAL CASE TIMELINE | +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Date | Event Description | +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | July 16, 2020 | Board meeting minutes record board setting training date for August 12, 2020.| | May 20, 2021 | Board meeting minutes record board training with Carpenter Hazelwood on June 7| | May 19, 2022 | Board meeting minutes record board setting training date for June 28, 2022. | | April 25, 2025 | Petitioner submits Request #1 for board member training records. | | Summer 2025 | Attorney Curtis Ekmark presents legislative update seminar at CCMC office. | | October 30, 2025 | Petitioner submits Request #2 for board training records over past 36 months. | | November 14, 2025 | Attorney Curtis Ekmark emails Rainey seeking clarification/dates; Rainey | | | replies that the 10-business-day window has already expired. | | April 26, 2026 | Rainey files formal OAH Petition (Docket No. 26F-H114-REL). | | July 7, 2026 | ALJ Eigenheer issues Order setting hearing for July 31, 2026. | | July 10, 2026 | Subpoena issued on behalf of Petitioner. | | July 14, 2026 | Respondent objects to subpoena. | | July 15, 2026 | ALJ Robinson quashes subpoena; Rainey files Motion for Reconsideration; ALJ | | | Robinson issues Order Upholding Quash of Subpoena. | | July 20, 2026 | ALJ Robinson issues Order Granting Continuance to August 31, 2026, at 1:00 PM. | | August 26, 2026 | ALJ Robinson issues Minute Entry noting Respondent's intent to appear in-person| | August 31, 2026 | Formal Administrative Hearing conducted via Google Meet and in-person. | +--------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “


4. Key Entities & Witness Roster

  • Chad D. Rainey: Petitioner appearing pro se; trustee and designated representative for property held under the HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019. Part-time resident (snowbird) living primarily in Colorado Springs, Colorado.
  • Heather N. Rainey: Trustor/Owner of the property within Garden Lakes; spouse of Chad Rainey.
  • Stephanie Ziola (spelled S-T-E-C-H-A-N-I-E Z-I-O-L-A in transcript): Community Manager for CCMC managing Garden Lakes since March 2024 (previously with CCMC for 6 years, left in 2022–2023 to work for AAM, returned in 2024). Testified regarding record searches and portal availability.
  • Wayne Hunt: Resident of Garden Lakes since 1993; Board of Directors member for 10–11 years; Vice President and Chair of Landscape & Lakes Committee; former Board President during 2020–2022.
  • Lauren Elliott Stine, Esq. & Jack Contrera, Esq. (Quarles & Brady LLP): Legal counsel representing Respondent, The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Curtis Ekmark (or Eckmark / Ekmark): General legal counsel for The Garden Lakes Community Association who corresponded with Rainey in November 2025 regarding the scope of his requests.

5. Short-Answer Practice Quiz

Questions
  1. What specific Arizona statute is alleged to have been violated in Docket No. 26F-H114-REL?
  2. What is the statutory deadline specified under A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) for an association to make records available following a written request?
  3. What specific documentation did Petitioner seek in his initial request dated April 25, 2025 (Request #1)?
  4. Who was the presider over the August 31, 2026 hearing, and what administrative office does she represent?
  5. How did Respondent's legal counsel frame the standing objection regarding Chad D. Rainey?
  6. What evidence did Petitioner introduce to counter Respondent's standing objection?
  7. What legal law firm was explicitly named in the May 20, 2021 board meeting minutes as conducting a board training session?
  8. **What was the outcome of Petitioner’s Motion for Reconsideration of Order Quashing Subpoenas issued on July 15, 2026?**
  9. Explain the distinction made by Stephanie Ziola and Wayne Hunt regarding the Summer 2025 CCMC seminar versus official board training.
  10. According to Stephanie Ziola’s testimony, how far back do accessible meeting minutes extend on the community website portal?
  11. Why did Administrative Law Judge Nicole Robinson refuse to admit evidence or transcript excerpts regarding the June 18, 2026 board meeting?
  12. What rule did ALJ Robinson establish regarding the 20-day timeframe for issuing a final decision following the conclusion of the hearing?

Answer Key
  1. A.R.S. § 33-1805(A), which governs member rights to inspect and audit planned community association records.
  2. Ten (10) business days after receipt of a formal written request.
  3. Dates of board member training attendance, names of provider companies, agendas for training sessions, and certificates or other documentation showing successful completion of training for each current board member.
  4. Administrative Law Judge Nicole Robinson of the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).
  5. Respondent argued that under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 and CC&R definitions, legal title to the property is vested in the HN&CR Living Trust whose trustor is Heather N. Rainey, making her the sole legal "owner" rather than Chad D. Rainey.
  6. A executed designation document (8_07-Heather Rainey designation), wherein Heather N. Rainey formally designated Chad D. Rainey as her authorized representative for all non-voting association matters pursuant to CC&Rs Section 6.7 and Article 1 Section DD.
  7. Carpenter Hazelwood.
  8. ALJ Nicole Robinson issued an Order Upholding the Quash of the Subpoena, affirming the July 15, 2026 order quashing the subpoena issued July 10, 2026 (noting Rainey could renew requests at the hearing depending on case development).
  9. They testified that the Summer 2025 event was an informational legislative/case law update hosted by CCMC for all community associations it manages, not an exclusive, official board training session organized for or by The Garden Lakes Community Association board.
  10. To 2017.
  11. ALJ Robinson ruled that events occurring in June 2026 occurred after the filing of the petition on April 26, 2026, placing them outside the tribunal's jurisdiction for this proceeding and rendering them irrelevant to the alleged pre-petition statutory violations.
  12. Under governing administrative procedure, the ALJ must issue a final decision within 20 days after the conclusion of the hearing.

6. Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Prompt 1: Intersection of Statutory Disclosure Mandates and Non-Existent Records

Analyze the legal obligations of a planned community association under A.R.S. § 33-1805 when a member requests documentation (such as training certificates or preparatory agendas) that the association asserts was never created or maintained. In your response, evaluate:

  • The distinction between requesting existing custodial records versus demanding the creation of information.
  • How an association must demonstrate that a thorough, good-faith search was conducted across management files, online portals, and legal communications.
  • The legal effect of providing public meeting minutes that reference an event when no underlying administrative documentation exists.
Prompt 2: Scope of Attorney-Client Privilege in Administrative HOA Disputes

Examine the boundary between statutory record disclosure rights and attorney-client privilege during board member education sessions. Synthesize the hearing testimony of Wayne Hunt and Stephanie Ziola regarding legal advice provided by law firms (e.g., Carpenter Hazelwood, Curtis Ekmark) to board members.

  • Under what circumstances do legal training materials, handouts, or communications become privileged legal advice rather than disclosable association records?
  • Does attendance at a multi-association seminar hosted by a third-party management company (CCMC) waive attorney-client privilege? Explain based on the record.
Prompt 3: Procedural Standing and Representation in Administrative Tribunals

Discuss the procedural requirements governing standing in Arizona Department of Real Estate/OAH dispute resolution proceedings involving real estate held in trust. Evaluate the arguments presented by Respondent regarding fee simple title under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 versus Petitioner’s reliance on explicit spousal designation forms under community CC&Rs. Assess how administrative law judges balance strict statutory definitions of "owner" against practical representative designations.


7. Comprehensive Glossary

“ +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | GLOSSARY OF TERMS | +-------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Term | Definition & Context | +-------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) | The Arizona statute requiring planned communities to make financial | | | and administrative records reasonably available within 10 business days | | | of receiving a written request. | | | | | A.R.S. § 32-2199.01 | The Arizona statute governing the jurisdiction of administrative | | | hearing tribunals over disputes between property owners and HOAs. | | | | | Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)| An independent, neutral adjudicator presiding over contested state | | | regulatory matters within the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH). | | | | | Burden of Proof | The legal obligation of a party to establish a fact or allegation by a | | | specified standard. In this proceeding, the burden lies on Petitioner | | | by a preponderance of the evidence. | | | | | CCMC | Capital Consultant Management Company; the property management firm | | | hired by Garden Lakes to manage day-to-day association operations. | | | | | Continuance | A formal order postponing a scheduled legal proceeding to a later date. | | | Granted on July 20, 2026, moving the hearing to August 31, 2026. | | | | | Designated Representative | An individual formally authorized in writing by a property owner to | | | act on their behalf regarding non-voting association matters. | | | | | Google Meet | The digital video-conferencing platform utilized by OAH for remote and | | | hybrid administrative hearings. | | | | | Minute Entry | An official written record or notice made by the tribunal summarizing a | | | procedural update (e.g., acknowledging Respondent's intent to appear | | | in-person on August 26, 2026). | | | | | Order Quashing Subpoena | A judicial ruling invalidating a previously issued subpoena, determined | | | by ALJ Robinson on July 15, 2026, and upheld upon reconsideration. | | | | | Preponderance of Evidence | The evidentiary standard in civil administrative hearings requiring that | | | a claim be proven more likely true than not. | | | | | Statutory Limitation Period | The legal timeframe within which a cause of action must be filed | | | (raised by Respondent under A.R.S. § 12-541(5) asserting a 1-year limit). | +-------------------------------+-------------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

Behind the Scenes at the Office of Administrative Hearings: Lessons from a Dispute Over HOA Board Training Records

1. Introduction: A Deep Dive into HOA Transparency & Document Requests

Disputes over access to community records remain one of the most volatile friction points in modern homeowners association (HOA) governance. Under Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 33-1805(A), planned community associations are statutorily obligated to make all financial and other records reasonably available for examination by a member or their designated representative within 10 business days of receiving a written request. However, administrative tribunals are routinely called upon to resolve a complex operational tension: What occurs when a homeowner submits a statutory request for records that an association contends were never created or retained in the ordinary course of business?

This pivotal question was tested before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) in Chad D. Rainey / HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019 v. The Garden Lakes Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H114-REL). Petitioner Chad D. Rainey filed a formal administrative petition alleging that Garden Lakes violated A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) by failing to produce comprehensive documentation—including agendas, internal notes, supporting emails, invoices, and completion certificates—related to board member training sessions. The Association maintained that while board training sessions were referenced in official, publicly accessible meeting minutes, no separate standalone documentation, invoices, or certificates were ever generated or retained by the association or its management company.

The administrative proceeding brought together key participants from across Arizona's legal and property management sectors:

  • Administrative Law Judges: ALJ Tammy L. Eigenheer (who issued the initial scheduling order) and ALJ Nicole Robinson (who presided over pre-hearing evidentiary motions, subpoena quashal orders, and the full administrative hearing).
  • Petitioner: Chad D. Rainey, appearing pro se on behalf of himself and the HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019.
  • Respondent: The Garden Lakes Community Association, represented by legal counsel Lauren Elliott Stine, Esq., and Jack Contrera, Esq., of Quarles & Brady LLP, alongside general counsel Curtis Ekmark.
  • Witnesses: Stephanie Ziola (Community Manager with Capital Consultants Management Company / CCMC) and Wayne Hunt (Board Vice President and former President of Garden Lakes).

2. The Procedural Timeline: From Records Request to Virtual Hearing Room

The legal dispute traversed a detailed administrative trajectory marked by statutory inspection demands, discovery motions, subpoena challenges, and scheduling continuances before proceeding to a full evidentiary hearing before the tribunal.

DateProcedural Action / DocumentKey Detail / Ruling
April 25, 2025Initial Written Records RequestPetitioner submits initial written request under A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) for board member training dates, providers, agendas, and completion certificates/documentation.
October 30, 2025Second Written Records RequestPetitioner submits an expanded request covering the preceding 36 months for communications, notes, records, emails, invoices, agendas, and certificates concerning board member training.
July 7, 2026OAH Hearing OrderALJ Tammy L. Eigenheer issues initial Order scheduling the administrative hearing for July 31, 2026, via Google Meet.
July 10, 2026Subpoena IssuedOAH issues a subpoena on behalf of Petitioner targeting witness testimony and associated records.
July 15, 2026Orders Quashing SubpoenaALJ Nicole Robinson issues an Order Quashing the Subpoena following Respondent's objection, and subsequently issues an Order Upholding the Quash after Petitioner files a Motion for Reconsideration.
July 20, 2026Order Granting ContinuanceALJ Robinson grants Respondent's continuance request, rescheduling the Google Meet virtual hearing to August 31, 2026, at 1:00 PM.
August 26, 2026OAH Minute EntryALJ Robinson issues a Minute Entry acknowledging Respondent’s formal notice of intent to appear in-person at 1740 W. Adams Street, Phoenix, AZ.
August 31, 2026Evidentiary Hearing ConvenedFull administrative hearing conducted digitally (via Google Meet) and in-person before ALJ Robinson.

3. Inside the Hearing: Key Arguments & Testimony Breakdown

At the outset of the August 31, 2026 proceeding, ALJ Nicole Robinson addressed critical threshold procedural matters regarding the scope of the administrative petition. Respondent counsel Lauren Elliott Stine objected to the inclusion of Petitioner's Exhibit G (the October 30, 2025 request), arguing that it represented a separate and impermissibly expanded claim beyond the initial April 25, 2025 request. Overruling Respondent’s objection, ALJ Robinson ruled that the October 30 request was an explicit continuation and clarification pointing back to the initial request, consolidating both filings under a single statutory issue under A.R.S. § 33-1805(A).

3.1 Petitioner’s Argument (Chad D. Rainey)

Chad D. Rainey contended that Garden Lakes committed a statutory violation by failing to fulfill his written document requests within the mandatory 10-business-day window mandated by A.R.S. § 33-1805(A). To prove that board training had taken place, Rainey entered into evidence approved association meeting minutes from July 16, 2020, May 20, 2021, and May 19, 2022. The May 20, 2021 minutes explicitly referenced an upcoming board training session with legal counsel Carpenter Hazelwood. Additionally, Rainey highlighted a November 14, 2025 email exchange with HOA counsel Curtis Ekmark, which acknowledged that several Garden Lakes board members had attended a Summer 2025 legislative and case law update session hosted at CCMC's corporate offices.

Rainey argued that because official minutes and legal correspondence confirmed these training events occurred, responsive non-privileged association records—such as preparatory agendas, emails, attendance rosters, seminar slides, or vendor invoices—must exist. He asserted that the management company's failure to furnish these records, combined with an inadequate electronic search across management servers, constituted an improper withholding of association documents under the statute.

3.2 Management & Board Testimony (Stephanie Ziola & Wayne Hunt)
  • Stephanie Ziola (CCMC Community Manager):

Ziola testified regarding CCMC's role as the custodial manager of association records. Upon receiving record requests, Ziola searched official meeting minutes back to 2017—the maximum archive depth available on the homeowner portal. She confirmed that while approved minutes referenced scheduled board training dates, CCMC possessed no standalone agendas, completion certificates, invoices, or separate instructional files for the 2020, 2021, or 2022 sessions. Under cross-examination by Rainey, Ziola made key admissions regarding CCMC's search protocol: she acknowledged that she did not perform any electronic keyword searches across CCMC’s email servers or inbox calendars when processing the October 30, 2025 request. Instead, after verifying the portal meeting minutes, she delegated the formal handling and statutory response entirely to HOA legal counsel Curtis Ekmark.

  • Wayne Hunt (Board Vice President):

Hunt testified regarding the actual nature of association board training. He explained that internal Garden Lakes training sessions consisted of closed legal consultations where general counsel instructed board members on fiduciary obligations, statutory duties, and governance rules. Hunt testified that no separate agendas, vendor invoices, or completion certificates were ever generated or received for these internal legal updates. Addressing the Summer 2025 event referenced in counsel’s email, Hunt clarified that he personally attended this session in person at CCMC's corporate offices alongside approximately 25 to 30 board members representing various HOAs across the region. He confirmed that this was a multi-association seminar hosted generally by CCMC rather than an exclusive, association-specific Garden Lakes board training session, and that no individual board member retained association business records from the event.

3.3 Procedural & Legal Objections

Throughout the proceeding, legal counsel for the Association raised key threshold defenses and evidentiary objections, while the tribunal managed pro se hearing boundaries:

  • Standing & Homeowner Designation: Respondent argued that legal title to the property was held by the HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019, with Heather Rainey designated as trustor/owner, questioning Chad Rainey’s independent standing under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01. Rainey successfully countered this challenge by relying on the formal instrument titled 8_07-Heather Rainey designation executed pursuant to Article 1, Section DD and Section 6.7 of the Garden Lakes CC&Rs. This document formally designated Rainey as the authorized homeowner representative for non-voting association matters, bringing his inspection demand squarely within A.R.S. § 33-1805(A).
  • Statute of Limitations Defense: Respondent argued that claims arising from the April 25, 2025 request were time-barred under A.R.S. § 12-541(5)—which imposes a one-year statute of limitations on actions created by statute—because the petition was filed over one year after the initial request.
  • Attorney-Client Privilege: Respondent asserted strict attorney-client privilege over communications, legal advice, and operational discussions exchanged between board members and association counsel during board updates, objecting to cross-examination inquiries seeking the substance of legal consultations.
  • Pro Se Hearing Dynamics & Evidentiary Boundaries: ALJ Robinson repeatedly instructed the parties on trial management and administrative tribunal jurisdiction. When Rainey sought to introduce post-petition evidence—specifically an transcript excerpt and audio file from a June 18, 2026 board meeting—ALJ Robinson sustained Respondent's objection and struck the evidence, ruling that events occurring after the filing of the petition fell outside the tribunal’s evidentiary jurisdiction.

4. Crucial Takeaways for Homeowners and HOA Boards

The administrative proceedings in Rainey v. The Garden Lakes Community Association provide essential legal clarity for property managers, HOA boards, and community members navigating statutory document disclosures:

  1. Document Requests vs. Information Requests
  • A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) grants members the legal right to inspect and copy existing association business records. It does not impose an affirmative duty on HOAs or management companies to create new documents, draft written responses, compile customized data summaries, or answer interrogatory-style questions regarding dates, vendor identities, or historical facts not embodied in existing records.
  1. The Non-Existence of Records as a Complete Defense
  • An association cannot be adjudicated in statutory violation of disclosure laws for failing to produce records—such as standalone agendas, certificates, or invoices—that were never created, generated, or retained in the ordinary course of business operations.
  1. Publicly Accessible Minutes Fulfill Statutory Transparency
  • Posting approved board meeting minutes on a community web portal satisfies statutory disclosure obligations regarding board governance activities noted within those minutes. When meeting minutes reflect that a legal update occurred, the minutes themselves constitute the official association record of that event.
  1. Multi-HOA Seminars vs. Privileged Legal Consultations
  • Administrative transparency requirements distinguish between third-party educational events and internal legal advice. Broad, management-sponsored seminars (such as CCMC multi-HOA legislative updates attended by directors from numerous communities) are general instructional events that do not yield association-specific business records. Conversely, internal board consultations with association legal counsel constitute executive-level legal advice protected by attorney-client privilege, meaning underlying legal materials cannot be compelled through standard statutory record inspection demands.

5. Conclusion & Summary

The administrative decision-making process in Rainey v. The Garden Lakes Community Association illustrates the boundary separating a homeowner's statutory inspection rights from the legal realities of document creation and custodial retention limits. While A.R.S. § 33-1805(A) provides robust mechanisms for community oversight, administrative tribunals strictly constrain inspection mandates to existing association business records. Where an HOA's official meeting minutes document board legal updates, but secondary materials like certificates or invoices were never generated, the association satisfies its statutory obligations by providing access to the meeting minutes. Both community members and HOA boards benefit when management protocols establish clear, early communication regarding which records physically exist versus requests that seek non-existent or privileged documentation.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Chad Rainey (Petitioner / Designated Representative)
    HN&CR Living Trust
    Homeowner and authorized designated representative for HN&CR Living Trust.
  • Heather Rainey (Trustee / Trustmaker)
    HN&CR Living Trust
    Trustee and trustmaker of the HN&CR Living Trust Dated August 13, 2019.

Respondent Side

  • Lauren Elliott Stine (Attorney for Respondent)
    Quarles & Brady LLP
    Counsel representing The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Jack Contrera (Attorney for Respondent)
    Quarles & Brady LLP
    Counsel representing The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Stephanie Villa (Community Manager / Witness)
    Capital Consultant Management Company
    Association Community Manager employed by CCMC; witness for Respondent.
  • Wayne Hunt (Board Vice President / Witness)
    The Garden Lakes Community Association
    Board Member and Vice President of The Garden Lakes Community Association; witness for Respondent.
  • Curtis Ekmark (Attorney / Legal Counsel)
    Legal counsel for CCMC / Association who responded to records requests.
  • Mike Dropic (Board Member)
    The Garden Lakes Community Association
    Board member of The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Paul Lemon (Board Member)
    The Garden Lakes Community Association
    Board member of The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Bob Gendrich (Board Member)
    The Garden Lakes Community Association
    Board member of The Garden Lakes Community Association.
  • Kevin Bald (Former Community Manager)
    The Garden Lakes Community Association
    Former community manager for Garden Lakes.

Neutral Parties

  • Nicole Robinson (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
    Presiding Administrative Law Judge.
  • Tammy L. Eigenheer (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
    Administrative Law Judge who issued an order setting the hearing date.
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
    Commissioner of the Arizona Department of Real Estate.

Pebblecreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc v.

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H069-REL
AgencyArizona Department of Real Estate
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-10-05
Administrative Law JudgeVelva Moses-Thompson
OutcomePetitioner (PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.)
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties$0.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerPebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.CounselBeth Mulcahy, Esq. (Mulcahy Law Firm, PC)
RespondentChristopher BernardCounselPro Se

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1437523.pdf

(57.6 KB)

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1444665.pdf

(46.9 KB)

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1449299.pdf

(46.8 KB)

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1460747.pdf

(44.3 KB)

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1472904.pdf

(31.8 KB)

26F-H069-REL Case document – 1476316.pdf

(163.9 KB)

Briefing Document: Legal Analysis and Dispute Resolution in PebbleCreek Golf Resort HOA v. Bernard & Wiener

Executive Summary

This briefing document provides an exhaustive analysis of the administrative dispute between PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc. (Petitioner/HOA) and homeowners Christopher Bernard and Deborah Wiener (Respondents) under Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) Docket No. 26F-H069-REL.

The matter originated from a petition filed by the HOA with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) on March 5, 2026, alleging two distinct Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&R) violations on Lot 20 (16078 W. Sheila Lane, Goodyear, AZ 85395):

  1. Installation of an unapproved river rock decorative border.
  2. Installation and maintenance of an unapproved animal structure (dog pen/frame pet cover) visible from neighboring property.

Prior to the evidentiary hearing held on September 11, 2026, the parties settled the river rock border issue, resulting in a partial withdrawal of that claim on September 2, 2026. The evidentiary hearing before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson focused exclusively on whether the Respondents' dog pen violated Article IV, Sections 2(a) and 2(b) of the HOA’s CC&Rs and Section E.8C/E.6 of the Architectural and Landscape Committee (ALC) Guidelines.

On October 5, 2026, ALJ Moses-Thompson issued a final Administrative Law Judge Decision ruling in favor of the HOA. The ALJ concluded that the dog pen was installed without prior written ALC approval and remained visible from neighboring property, violating Article IV, Sections 2(a) and 2(b). The Respondents were ordered to pay the HOA’s $500.00 ADRE filing fee and to abide by the CC&Rs. A civil penalty was denied because Respondent Christopher Bernard genuinely believed—albeit incorrectly—that the structure was non-violative and subject to selective enforcement.


Procedural Timeline and Case Background

The case progressed through multiple administrative orders, continuances, representative changes, and evidentiary submissions:

DateProcedural Event / ActionKey Details & Authorities
June 2024Property AcquisitionRespondents purchase Lot 20 at 16078 W. Sheila Lane, Goodyear, AZ.
October 2024Initial Permit SubmissionRespondents submit landscape permit applications; dog pen is not included.
November 2024Partial Permit ApprovalALC approves landscape permits, excluding a river rock application.
December 2024Structure InstallationRespondents install a black-framed, netted dog pen (~3'x7' or 3'x5') for coyote protection.
January 2025ALC Audit & InspectionsALC conducts yard inspections; identifies multiple issues and mentions the black pet cover.
May 27, 2025Courtesy Violation NoticeALC issues formal courtesy notice citing 9 violations, including unapproved frame pet cover.
June 27, 2025Second Notice / Fine WarningALC issues second notice warning of $100/violation fines if uncured within 21 days.
September 26, 2025Fine AssessmentALC levies an $800.00 fine against Respondents for uncorrected violations.
Nov – Dec 2, 2025Board Appeal & Compliance WalkRespondents appeal to Board; compliance walk on Dec 2 clears all issues except river rock and dog pen.
December 2, 2025After-the-Fact Permit ApplicationRespondents formally apply for dog pen approval following compliance inspection.
December 10, 2025ALC Permit DenialBoard VP John Cohn issues notice denying dog pen permit; suggests block wall with gate as cure. Offer made to reduce fines to $250 upon resolution.
Jan 26 & Feb 10, 2026Legal Demand LettersHOA legal counsel (Mulcahy Law Firm, PC) demands removal, relocation, or approved screening (block wall) of pen after prior permit request.
March 4–5, 2026Board Action & ADRE FilingBoard unanimously consents to legal action; HOA files ADRE petition.
June 19, 2026Initial OAH OrderALJ Adam D. Stone schedules hearing for July 13, 2026.
July 13, 2026Order Granting ContinuanceALJ Stone reschedules hearing to July 24, 2026, upon party agreement.
July 27, 2026Second ContinuanceALJ Stone reschedules hearing to September 11, 2026, at Respondent's request.
August 25, 2026Withdrawal of CounselALJ Stone grants Motion to Withdraw for Respondents' attorneys (Thomas E. Raccuia and Jonathan A. Dessaules of Dessaules Law Group). Respondents proceed pro se.
September 2, 2026Motion for Partial WithdrawalHOA withdraws Claim 1 (river rock border) following homeowner modification.
September 11, 2026Evidentiary HearingHearing convened before ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson. Record held open for post-hearing photo exhibits.
September 14, 2026HOA Response to EvidenceHOA submits response to Respondents' post-hearing photo evidence (Exhibit B / Photos 1653–1662).
September 23, 2026Order Closing RecordALJ Moses-Thompson formally closes the evidentiary record.
October 5, 2026Final Decision & OrderALJ Moses-Thompson issues decision finding Respondents in violation; orders $500 filing fee reimbursement; denies civil penalty.

Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

1. Architectural Control and CC&R Standards

The dispute hinges on two primary provisions of the PebbleCreek Golf Resort CC&Rs (recorded in 1992 with the Maricopa County Recorder) and the 2024 ALC Guidelines:

  • Article IV, Section 2(a) [Architectural Control]: Mandates that no structure, improvement, alteration, landscaping, or exterior work altering the appearance of any lot shall be commenced, erected, or maintained without prior written approval from the ALC.
  • Article IV, Section 2(b) [Animals]: Explicitly provides:

"No structure for the care, housing or confinement of any animal or bird shall be maintained so as to be Visible From Neighboring Property, unless otherwise approved by the Architectural Committee."

  • Definition of "Visible From Neighboring Property": Under Section TT (page 10) of the Declaration, an object is defined as visible if it can be seen by a 6-foot-tall person standing on a neighboring property at the level of the base of the structure being viewed.
Approved Screening vs. Faux Greenery

To attempt compliance without building a permanent wall, Respondents installed green faux foliage, synthetic vines, and lattice material along their open-air view fence.

The HOA presented testimony from General Manager William Barnard and Board President Jack Gregory establishing that:

  1. Faux greenery, artificial plants, or faux fencing materials are never automatically approved and are consistently denied across the community.
  2. Artificial plants are unapproved screening mechanisms because they do not eliminate multi-angle visibility, do not mitigate noise, deteriorate over time, and fail to provide permanent structural enclosure.
  3. Natural vegetation (shrubs, vines) is permitted for general privacy between adjacent patios, but is strictly prohibited as a primary screening mechanism for animal enclosures or trash receptacles, as plants can die or leave gaps.
  4. The HOA’s standard required cure for screening visible animal enclosures or trash containers on golf course lots is a solid cinder/block wall with an integrated gate.

“ [ Neighboring View / Golf Course / Street ] │ ▼ (Unapproved Screening Attempt) [ Faux Greenery / Synthetic Vines / Lattice ] │ <-- Does NOT satisfy CC&Rs ▼ [ Unapproved Dog Pen Structure ] (3'x7' Black-Framed & Netted Box with Pitched Roof) ▲ │ <-- HOA Required Cure [ Solid Cinder Block Wall & Gate ] “


2. HOA Enforcement Integrity vs. Homeowner Defenses
Selective Enforcement and Targeting Allegations

Respondent Christopher Bernard argued that the HOA engaged in harassment, moving goalposts, and selective enforcement, claiming Respondents had accumulated 27 different violation notices across 2025–2026. Bernard asserted that other residents maintained visible dog structures or had shrubbery approved to screen hot tubs.

To refute the selective enforcement defense, the HOA submitted extensive administrative records:

  • Community Compliance Metrics (Jan 1, 2026 – July 14, 2026):
  • 972 courtesy violation letters issued community-wide.
  • 1,035 total violations closed.
  • 136 formal fine warning letters sent.
  • 34 actual fine assessments levied.
  • Comparative Denials (Exhibits 18.1–18.2 & 17.1–17.3): The HOA demonstrated that other applications for pet enclosures without block wall screening were uniformly denied, and citation notices were actively issued to other lot owners attempting to use faux greenery/fencing.
  • Trash Enclosures (Exhibits 25.1–25.3): Requests for trash enclosures were only approved when constructed with an fully enclosing block wall and gate.
Neighbor Dispute and Coyote Protection Context
  • Coyote Protection: Respondents testified the pen was utilized solely between 6:00 a.m. and 7:00 a.m. to protect two 6-pound dogs from coyotes, as community rules prohibit altering open fences or harming wildlife.
  • Neighbor Conflict: The adjacent neighbor submitted formal complaints regarding both the visibility of the pen from her side dining window and unpleasant odors arising from dog feces. Respondent Bernard disputed the smell issue, alleging the neighbor had thrown Drano tablets over the fence and lacked proper boundary fencing, thereby attracting coyotes to the area.
Economic and Aesthetic Impact Arguments

Respondents opposed constructing a block wall based on the following:

  • Estimated construction cost of $8,000.00.
  • Destruction of $1,500.00 worth of recently installed AstroTurf.
  • Negative alteration of the front and rear aesthetics of a lot where they had recently invested $120,000.00 in backyard improvements.
  • Respondents offered to construct the wall if the HOA subsidized 50% of the cost, an offer the HOA declined.

3. Administrative Law Judge Findings and Legal Reasoning

In the final Decision issued on October 5, 2026, ALJ Moses-Thompson systematically evaluated the statutory, contractual, and photographic evidence:

  1. Jurisdiction & Standard of Proof: Under A.R.S. § 32-2199(B) and A.R.S. § 33-1803, the ADRE and OAH have jurisdiction over Planned Community Act disputes. The HOA held the burden to prove violations by a preponderance of the evidence (A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2)).
  2. Unambiguous Restrictive Covenants: Under Arizona case law (Powell v. Washburn, 211 Ariz. 553), unambiguous restrictive covenants must be enforced according to their express language and underlying purpose.
  3. Core Violations Established:
  • Article IV, Section 2(a): Unquestioned violation occurred because Respondents erected the dog pen in December 2024 without seeking or receiving prior written approval from the ALC.
  • Article IV, Section 2(b): The preponderance of evidence—including photographs taken from the street and golf course (Exhibits 16.1–16.5) and Respondents' own post-hearing photos (Exhibit B: Photos 1653, 1655, 1656)—established that the structure was visible to a 6-foot-tall person standing on neighboring property.
  1. Rejection of Civil Penalty: Although the HOA requested penalties for ongoing non-compliance, the ALJ declined to levy a civil penalty under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A). The record demonstrated that Bernard genuinely believed he was not violating the CC&Rs (relying on subjective interpretations of visibility, initial audit communications, and perceived selective enforcement).
  2. Mandatory Statutory Relief: Pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), as the prevailing party, the HOA was statutorily entitled to an order directing Respondents to comply with the CC&Rs and reimburse the HOA's $500.00 filing fee within 30 days.

Important Quotes with Context

Statements by HOA Legal Counsel (Beth Mulcahy, Esq.)
  • On the Binding Contractual Nature of CC&Rs:

"This declaration is a contract that binds the owners within the association to follow the terms of the contract, as well as the association needs to follow the terms of the contract… respondents here today, Mr. Bernard and Ms. Wiener are the owners of lot 20… they are required to follow the declaration, the bylaws, the architectural landscape guidelines, and all other governing documents."

  • Context: Opening statement establishing that lot ownership automatically subjects residents to mandatory architectural review processes.
  • On the Uniformity of Architectural Review:

"This is not selective enforcement. It's ordinary architectural review at 6,000 lot community association… Any selective enforcement or harassment defense is unsupported by the evidence heard today."

  • Context: Closing argument dismantling Respondent's targeting claims by highlighting standard enforcement metrics.

Testimony of HOA Witnesses
  • William Barnard (General Manager) on the Purpose of Fines:

"The bottom line is we're just trying to obtain compliance that's it. We're not trying to make money. It's not a revenue generator for us. And so, you know, the fine is after several notices have been given and no response or no correction."

  • Context: Direct examination explaining why the HOA levied an $800 fine following uncured notices.
  • William Barnard on Why Faux Foliage and Plants are Rejected:

"A pet enclosure or a garbage can, we do not allow plants to be used for situations like that because they don't completely screen and you know they can die and all of that. So in those two specific situations we don't allow shrubs or plants."

  • Context: Cross/redirect examination clarifying the structural rationale behind prohibiting vegetation or artificial foliage as primary screening for animal structures.
  • Jack Gregory (Board President) on the Purpose of Architectural Controls:

"Well, principally, it's to protect property values. It's to maintain the visual quality of the community using the established set of standards. And it also allows homeowners to understand what is acceptable within the community."

  • Context: Direct examination outlining the Board's duty to maintain neighborhood aesthetics.
  • Jack Gregory on Photo Verification:

"Exhibit 16.1, which was taken from the front of the house, was taken using an iPhone 16 camera… used a zoom feature just to make sure that, you know, for clarity, but even to the naked eye from the street… the dog pin was still visible."

  • Context: Rebuttal testimony refuting Respondent's claims that photo evidence was fabricated or manipulated using high-powered binoculars.

Statements by Respondent (Christopher Bernard)
  • On Frustration with Mandatory Wall Construction:

"What I don't want to have to do is tear up my AstroTurf and spend $8,000 to build a wall to enclose two miniature dogs. That's what we're unwilling to do. That's what we're being forced to do with no alternatives and no options presented from the HOA. Zero."

  • Context: Closing argument detailing the financial and practical burden imposed by the HOA's block wall requirement.
  • On Photographic Zooming and Distance:

"My fence is 97 feet from the street. The back fence is 162 feet from the golf course. Those pictures that you took, you were on top of my property in both instances or you zoomed in and took a pair of binoculars. That enclosure cannot be seen from the golf course and it certainly can't be seen from the street."

  • Context: Defense presentation challenging the HOA's visual evidence regarding the visibility of the pen.

Rulings by Administrative Law Judge (Velva Moses-Thompson)
  • On Findings of Fact Regarding Visibility:

"After reviewing the photographs, the Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) finds that the photographs marked as 1653, 1655, and 1656 show that the animal structure is visible to neighboring property. The ALJ finds that remaining photos in Exhibit B do not refute this finding."

  • Context: Finding of Fact No. 35 in the Final Decision analyzing post-hearing evidence submitted by Respondents.
  • On Decision to Decline Civil Penalties:

"Although Mr. Bernard was incorrect in his allegations and assertions, the record shows that Mr. Bernard believed his dog pen was not in violation of the CC&Rs. Based on the foregrounding, the ALJ concludes that a civil penalty is not appropriate at this time."

  • Context: Conclusion of Law No. 9 articulating why monetary penalties beyond fee reimbursement were withheld.

Key Takeaways and Actionable Insights

For Homeowners Association Boards and Management
  1. Maintain Rigorous, Fact-Based Enforcement Logs:
  • The HOA successfully defeated selective enforcement defenses by presenting concrete compliance statistics (972 courtesy notices, 34 fine assessments) and identical denial records for other lots (Exhibits 17, 18, and 25).
  • Action: Continue compiling quantitative enforcement data to validate uniform standard application during administrative hearings.
  1. Provide Clear Structural Specifications in Denial Notices:
  • The ALC’s written denial on December 10, 2025, specifically suggested a "block wall with gate" as an acceptable cure, demonstrating that the HOA was offering constructive compliance pathways rather than outright prohibition.
  • Action: Ensure all architectural denial notices explicitly outline permissible structural remedies and grant standard cure windows (e.g., 21 days).
  1. Document Visibility from Standard Photographic Angles:
  • Although Respondents challenged zoomed-in photos, witness testimony confirming that structures were visible "to the naked eye" from public/common vantage points (street, golf course) proved decisive.
  • Action: When documenting violations, photo inspectors should take wide-angle context shots alongside zoomed detail shots from standard standing height (6 feet) at property boundaries.

For Homeowners in Planned Communities
  1. Prior Written Approval Is Mandatory Before Installation:
  • Installing exterior structures prior to receiving written ALC approval places the homeowner in an immediate, hard-to-defend breach of CC&Rs, eliminating leverage during subsequent negotiations.
  • Action: Always submit detailed architectural applications—and receive explicit written approval—prior to purchasing or erecting exterior structures, regardless of intended usage (e.g., coyote protection).
  1. Self-Help Screening Solutions Do Not Override Rules:
  • Installing unapproved faux greenery, plastic vines, or reed fencing onto view fences often creates secondary violations rather than curing the primary visibility issue.
  • Action: Verify whether non-permanent or synthetic materials are permissible under community guidelines before investing in temporary screening measures.
  1. Distinguish Between Administrative Rules and Subjective Intent:
  • Good faith beliefs, coyote threats, or investments in landscaping ($120,000) do not legalise CC&R non-compliance under Arizona law.
  • Action: Focus administrative hearing defenses on objective CC&R language, precise definitions (such as the 6-foot eye-level standard), and official permit records rather than perceived harassment or cost disputes.

Study Guide: Administrative Law & Planned Community Governance

**Case Focus: PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc. v. Christopher Bernard & Deborah Wiener (Docket No. 26F-H069-REL)**


Section 1: Key Concepts & Case Overview

1. Context and Jurisdiction
  • Forum: Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), acting on behalf of the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).
  • Statutory Framework: Chapter 16 of Title 33, known as the Planned Communities Act (A.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818).
  • Authority: Under A.R.S. § 32-2199(B), homeowners or homeowners associations (HOAs) may petition the ADRE for hearings regarding alleged violations of planned community documents.
  • Presiding Administrative Law Judges (ALJs):
  • ALJ Adam D. Stone: Presided over initial orders, virtual hearing directives, and continuance requests (June–August 2026).
  • ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson: Conducted the evidentiary hearing on September 11, 2026, and issued the final Administrative Law Judge Decision on October 5, 2026.
2. Parties and Representatives
  • Petitioner: PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc. (a 6,000-home planned community in Goodyear, Arizona).
  • Legal Counsel: Beth Mulcahy, Esq. (Mulcahy Law Firm, PC).
  • Witnesses: William "Bill" Barnard (General Manager for ~15 years; 25 total years at PebbleCreek) and Jack Gregory (Board President for 1 year 8 months; Board member for 5 years 6 months).
  • Respondents: Christopher Bernard & Deborah Wiener (Owners of Lot 20, located at 16078 W. Sheila Lane, Goodyear, AZ 85395).
  • Legal Representation: Originally represented by Thomas E. Raccuia, Esq., and Jonathan A. Dessaules, Esq. (Dessaules Law Group). Counsel withdrew without consent via court order on August 25, 2026. Respondents appeared pro se (representing themselves) at the final hearing.

3. Core Legal and Contractual Standards

“ ┌─────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ PebbleCreek Governing Documents │ └────────────────────┬────────────────────┘ │ ┌─────────────────────────────────┴─────────────────────────────────┐ ▼ ▼ ┌─────────────────────────────────┐ ┌─────────────────────────────────┐ │ Article IV, Section 2(a) │ │ Article IV, Section 2(b) │ │ Architectural Control │ │ Animal Structures │ └────────────────┬────────────────┘ └────────────────┬────────────────┘ │ │ ▼ ▼ Requires prior written approval from Prohibits maintaining structures for the Architectural Committee for any exterior care, housing, or confinement of animals improvements, alterations, or structures. that are "Visible From Neighboring Property." “

  • Article IV, Section 2(a) [Architectural Control]: Mandates that no improvements, alterations, landscaping changes, or exterior structures may be erected, maintained, or altered without prior written approval from the Architectural Committee.
  • Article IV, Section 2(b) [Animals]: Explicitly mandates that no structure for the care, housing, or confinement of any animal or bird shall be maintained so as to be Visible From Neighboring Property, unless approved by the Architectural Committee.
  • Definition of "Visible From Neighboring Property" (Declaration Page 10, Section 1.TT): Defined objectively as an object that is visible to a person 6 feet tall standing on neighboring property at the level of the base of the structure being viewed.

4. Dispute Evolution and Procedural History

“ Oct–Dec 2024 May–Sept 2025 Dec 2025 Sept 11, 2026 Oct 5, 2026 ┌──────────────┐ ┌──────────────┐ ┌──────────────┐ ┌─────────────────────┐ ┌──────────────┐ │ Unapproved │ ──> │ Violation │ ──> │ Permit Denied│ ──> │ Evidentiary Hearing │ ──> │ Final Order │ │ Dog Pen │ │ Notices & │ │ & Block Wall │ │ (River Rock Claim │ │ Issued for │ │ Installed │ │ $800 Fine │ │ Solution │ │ Withdrawn) │ │ Association │ └──────────────┘ └──────────────┘ └──────────────┘ └─────────────────────┘ └──────────────┘ “

  1. Initial Violation (Late 2024): Respondents installed a black-framed, netted dog pen (~3'x7' or 3'x5' with a pitched roof line) in December 2024 for coyote protection without seeking or receiving prior Architectural Committee approval.
  2. Enforcement Escalation (2025):
  • May 27 & June 27, 2025: Courtesy Notices issued for unapproved frame pet cover.
  • September 26, 2025: $800 fine levied for uncorrected violations.
  • December 2, 2025: Compliance walkthrough narrowed issues to river rock borders and the dog pen. Respondents formally applied for dog pen approval after the inspection.
  • December 10, 2025: Architectural Committee denied the dog pen application due to visibility, stating a cinder block wall with a gate would resolve the issue.
  1. Attempted Cures & Impasse:
  • Respondents attempted to shield the dog pen using faux greenery, artificial vines, and lattice on their view fence without seeking ALC permits.
  • The HOA consistently rejected faux greenery/fencing as an unapproved screening material across the community.
  • Respondents argued an $8,000 block wall was unreasonable and asserted claims of selective enforcement, harassment, and improper photo manipulation (zooming).
  1. Narrowing Issues: The petition originally included two counts: River Rock border violations and the Dog Pen structure. On September 2, 2026, Petitioner filed a Motion for Partial Withdrawal after Respondents cured the River Rock issue. The September 11, 2026 hearing focused exclusively on the animal structure.

5. Final Findings and Administrative Order
  • Standard of Proof: Preponderance of the evidence (burden borne by Petitioner under A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2)).
  • Violations Proven: The ALJ found that Respondents violated Article IV, Section 2(a) (failure to obtain prior written approval) and Section 2(b) (maintaining an animal structure visible from neighboring property). Post-hearing photographic exhibits (Exhibit B) confirmed visibility to the naked eye from the street and golf course.
  • Relief Granted:
  • Petitioner was declared the prevailing party.
  • Respondents were ordered to abide by Article IV, Section 2(a) and 2(b) of the CC&Rs (requiring removal, compliant relocation, or approved block wall screening).
  • Respondents were ordered to reimburse Petitioner's $500.00 ADRE filing fee within 30 days pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A).
  • Civil Penalty Decision: The ALJ declined to levy civil penalties. Although Respondent Christopher Bernard was legally incorrect, the record established that he held a genuine, subjective good-faith belief that the dog pen did not violate the CC&Rs.

Section 2: Short-Answer Practice Questions

Practice Questions
  1. What state agency transferred the administrative petition to the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), and under what chapter of Arizona revised statutes are planned community disputes governed?
  2. What specific evidentiary burden of proof must a petitioner meet to establish a CC&R violation in an Arizona administrative hearing?
  3. How do the PebbleCreek CC&Rs specifically define the term "Visible From Neighboring Property"?
  4. Why was the issue regarding the "River Rock" border removed from the scope of the September 11, 2026 evidentiary hearing?
  5. What specific physical solution did the Architectural Committee suggest in its December 10, 2025 notice to bring the dog pen into compliance?
  6. Why did the HOA refuse to accept the faux greenery and artificial vines installed by Respondents as a valid cure for the dog pen violation?
  7. Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), what statutory remedy is mandatory if a petitioner prevails in an ADRE administrative hearing?
  8. Why did Administrative Law Judge Velva Moses-Thompson decline to assess a civil penalty against Respondents despite ruling against them?

Answer Key
  1. Answer: The Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) transferred the petition. Planned community disputes are governed by Title 33, Chapter 16 of the Arizona Revised Statutes (the Planned Communities Act, A.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818).
  2. Answer: The petitioner must establish the violation by a preponderance of the evidence (i.e., proving that the contention is more probably true than not / superior evidentiary weight).
  3. Answer: Under Section 1.TT (page 10) of the Declaration, it is defined as visible to a 6-foot tall person standing on a neighboring property at the level of the base of the structure being viewed.
  4. Answer: Petitioner filed a Motion for Partial Withdrawal on September 2, 2026, because Respondents modified the river rock border to the HOA's satisfaction prior to the hearing.
  5. Answer: The Architectural Committee stated that constructing a cinder block wall with a gate surrounding the area would properly screen the structure from all exterior views.
  6. Answer: Faux greenery/fencing is an unapproved screening material under community guidelines. The HOA consistently denies faux greenery across all 6,000 lots because it does not completely eliminate visibility from all angles, can degrade, and does not mitigate noise.
  7. Answer: The Administrative Law Judge must order the losing respondent to reimburse the prevailing petitioner for the ADRE filing fee ($500.00 in this matter).
  8. Answer: The ALJ determined that Respondent Christopher Bernard genuinely believed—though incorrectly—that the dog pen was compliant and that he was not violating CC&Rs, making a punitive civil penalty inappropriate.

Section 3: Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

  1. Subjective Belief vs. Objective Contractual Terms in HOA Governance
  • Prompt: Analyze the conflict between a homeowner's subjective belief of property compliance and the objective standards codified in recorded CC&Rs. Using facts from PebbleCreek v. Bernard & Wiener, discuss how the ALJ balanced contractual enforcement with equitable considerations regarding civil penalties.
  1. Standardized Screening Requirements and Uniform Enforcement
  • Prompt: Evaluate the HOA's rejection of self-help modifications (such as faux greenery and artificial vines) in favor of strict, structural screening rules (such as cinder block walls). Address how uniform enforcement across a large planned community (6,000 lots) impacts claims of selective enforcement and harassment raised by individual homeowners.
  1. Evidentiary Evaluation in Administrative Proceedings
  • Prompt: Discuss the role of visual and photographic evidence in administrative hearings. In this case, Respondents argued that zoomed-in smartphone photos distorted real-world visibility, while HOA witnesses testified to naked-eye visibility from common areas. How should an Administrative Law Judge weigh conflicting technical and testimonial evidence regarding spatial definitions like "Visible From Neighboring Property"?

Section 4: Glossary of Important Terms

TermLegal / Contextual Definition
Administrative Law Judge (ALJ)An independent judicial officer who presides over administrative hearings, evaluates evidence, determines legal conclusions, and issues binding decisions or recommendations.
Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE)The state executive agency statutory authorized under A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq. to receive and adjudicate disputes between HOAs and homeowners.
Architectural Landscape Committee (ALC)A designated committee within an HOA responsible for reviewing permit applications, establishing landscape guidelines, and conducting compliance inspections.
Civil PenaltyA monetary fine levied by a tribunal under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A) against a party found in violation of community documents or statutes.
Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs)Recorded contractual agreements running with the land that establish property use rules, architectural standards, and governance rights for a planned community.
Motion for Partial WithdrawalA formal legal motion filed by a party to remove specific claims or issues from a proceeding prior to or during a hearing, narrowing the court's focus.
Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH)An independent Arizona state agency that conducts administrative evidentiary hearings for state board and agency disputes.
Planned Communities ActChapter 16 of Title 33 of the Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818), regulating the powers, rights, and duties of planned community HOAs and homeowners.
Preponderance of the EvidenceThe administrative burden of proof requiring a party to show that a factual claim is more likely true than not true based on convincing evidentiary weight.
Pro SeA Latin legal term describing a party who represents themselves in a legal proceeding without the assistance of licensed legal counsel.
Unanimous ConsentA board action executed without a formal meeting where all directors unanimously sign a written consent approving a decision (e.g., authorizing legal petitions).
Visible From Neighboring PropertyAn objective contractual visibility standard defined in PebbleCreek CC&Rs as being visible to a 6-foot-tall person standing on an adjacent property at ground level.

Legal Lessons from the Lawn: Inside an Arizona HOA Dispute Over Dog Pens and CC&R Compliance

1. Introduction: The High-Stakes Backyard Battle at PebbleCreek

When homeowners install exterior modifications without advance board authorization, minor property updates can quickly escalate into formal legal proceedings. A dispute at the PebbleCreek Golf Resort community in Goodyear, Arizona—PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc. v. Christopher Bernard and Deborah Wiener (Docket No. 26F-H069-REL)—offers a compelling case study on property modification rules, architectural review enforcement, and association governing standards under the Arizona Planned Communities Act (A.R.S. §§ 33-1801 to 33-1818).

The conflict centered on Lot 20 (16078 W. Sheila Lane), purchased by Christopher Bernard and Deborah Wiener in June 2024. In December 2024, the homeowners installed an unapproved dog pen designed for coyote protection. While HOA inspection photos described the black-framed, netted structure with a pitched roof frame as approximately 3'x7' in size, Mr. Bernard testified during the hearing that the structure was 3'x5' and housed two 6-pound miniature dogs. The HOA asserted that the structure violated community rules because it was installed without prior written architectural approval and remained visible from neighboring properties, including the front street, an adjacent neighbor's window, and the adjacent golf course. The homeowners attempted self-help remediation by adding unapproved faux greenery to screen the pen, leading to formal violation notices, assessed fines, and ultimately an administrative petition filed with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) and heard by the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).

On October 5, 2026, Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson issued a final decision finding the homeowners in continuing violation of the association's Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs). Pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), the judge ordered the homeowners to abide by community rules and reimburse the HOA's $500 ADRE filing fee, but declined to levy discretionary civil penalties after concluding that Mr. Bernard maintained a genuine, good-faith belief that his structure complied with community standards.


2. Case Snapshot: Timeline and Key Parties

Parameter / MilestoneDetails / Facts
PetitionerPebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
RespondentsChristopher Bernard & Deborah Wiener
Property LocationLot 20 / 16078 W. Sheila Lane, Goodyear, AZ 85395
Forum & JurisdictionArizona Office of Administrative Hearings (ADRE Docket No. 26F-H069-REL pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199 et seq.)
Administrative Law JudgeVelva Moses-Thompson (Procedural Orders issued by ALJ Adam D. Stone)
Home PurchaseJune 2024
Dog Pen InstallationDecember 2024
ALC Courtesy Notices IssuedMay 27, 2025 & June 27, 2025
$800 Fine AssessedSeptember 26, 2025
Formal ADRE Petition FiledMarch 4–5, 2026
Withdrawal of Homeowners' CounselAugust 25, 2026 (Dessaules Law Group withdrew via Order No. 1460747)
Partial Withdrawal of ClaimsSeptember 2, 2026 (HOA withdrew River Rock border claim following homeowner compliance)
Evidentiary Hearing DateSeptember 11, 2026
Post-Hearing Record CloseSeptember 23, 2026 (ALJ Order Doc 1472904 closing record after post-hearing exhibit filings)
Final ALJ Decision IssuedOctober 5, 2026 (Doc 1476316)

3. The Rules at Issue: Understanding Article IV, Section 2

The administrative ruling turned on specific provisions within PebbleCreek's recorded CC&Rs and its Architectural Landscape Committee (ALC) guidelines:

  • Article IV, Section 2(a) (Architectural Control): Mandates that no building, fence, exterior wall, residence, improvement, alteration, repair, landscaping, or other structure (whether temporary or permanent) may be commenced, erected, maintained, or altered on a lot without receiving prior written approval from the Architectural Committee. Deviations from approved plans are strictly prohibited without subsequent written authorization.
  • Article IV, Section 2(b) (Animals): Explicitly governs animal enclosures, stating: "No structure for the care, housing or confinement of any animal or bird shall be maintained so as to be Visible From Neighboring Property, unless otherwise approved by the Architectural Committee."
  • Legal Definition of "Visible From Neighboring Property": As set forth in Section TT (page 10) of the CC&Rs, an object or structure is legally defined as "Visible From Neighboring Property" if it is visible to a 6-foot-tall person standing on a neighboring property at the level of the base of the structure being viewed.

4. Hearing Breakdown: The HOA's Arguments vs. The Homeowners' Defense

The September 11, 2026 evidentiary hearing before ALJ Moses-Thompson featured a detailed comparison of evidence. Just prior to the hearing, the HOA filed a motion for partial withdrawal on September 2, 2026, after the homeowners modified their river rock landscaping to meet community standards. This successfully narrowed the scope of the administrative hearing strictly to the dog enclosure dispute.

A pivotal procedural development occurred weeks before the trial: on August 25, 2026, the homeowners' legal counsel (Thomas E. Raccuia and Jonathan A. Dessaules of Dessaules Law Group) withdrew from the case (Order No. 1460747). Forced to proceed pro se, the homeowners struggled with procedural requirements, including navigating the OAH electronic evidence portal and introducing unvetted post-hearing evidence.

The HOA's Position
  • Representation & Witnesses: Represented by Beth Mulcahy, Esq. Witnesses included William Barnard (General Manager of 15 years) and Jack Gregory (Board President).
  • Lack of Prior Permit: The HOA proved that the homeowners installed the dog structure in December 2024 without submitting an ALC application or securing written consent.
  • Objective Visibility & Camera Zoom Refutation: Photographs taken by Board President Jack Gregory (Exhibits 16.1–16.5) showed the structure from the street (3 feet into the roadway) and from the golf course (50 feet away). Gregory testified that while he used an iPhone 16 zoom feature for clarity, the dog pen remained clearly visible to the naked eye from the street, the golf course, and an adjacent neighbor's side window.
  • Neighbor Complaints & Waste Odor: General Manager William Barnard testified that the HOA received formal complaints from the adjacent neighbor regarding the dog pen's visibility from her dining room window and uncollected dog waste odor.
  • Unapproved Visual Cures: The HOA established that attaching faux greenery or artificial vines to view fencing is consistently denied across the 6,000-home community (Exhibits 17.1–17.3). Faux foliage degrades over time, fails to muffle noise, and does not constitute a permanent, approved architectural barrier.
  • Compliant Alternatives Offered: On December 10, 2025, the ALC formally notified the homeowners that constructing an approved cinder block masonry wall with a gate would provide acceptable screening.
  • Objective Enforcement Metrics: To refute allegations of selective enforcement, Jack Gregory introduced summary enforcement statistics for the first half of 2026 (Exhibit 21). Across 6,000 homes, the ALC processed 972 courtesy notices, closed 1,035 violation files, and issued 136 fine letters—but levied actual monetary fines in only 34 instances. This objective data demonstrated uniform, non-arbitrary enforcement.
The Homeowners' Defense
  • Homeowners: Christopher Bernard and Deborah Wiener appeared pro se.
  • Coyote Protection & Usage: Mr. Bernard testified that the enclosure (3'x5') was erected exclusively to protect two 6-pound miniature dogs from coyotes during brief morning outings between 6:00 a.m. and 7:00 a.m.
  • Audit Confusion: The homeowners argued that an initial ALC audit in January 2025 cited a black cover on top of the pen but did not explicitly order the pen's removal, leading them to believe the pen structure itself was acceptable.
  • Neighbor Dispute & Drano Allegations: Mr. Bernard alleged deep personal friction with the adjacent neighbor, testifying that her lack of view fencing attracted coyotes to the property line. He further claimed he had to file police reports with the Goodyear Police Department because the neighbor allegedly threw Drano tablets over the fence to poison his dogs. He argued that the neighbor, standing at 5'2", could not see over the fence under the CC&R's 6-foot eye line standard.
  • Prohibitive Wall Costs & Aesthetic Disruption: The homeowners strongly objected to constructing a masonry block wall, estimating it would cost $8,000, destroy $1,500 of newly installed astroturf, and disrupt the visual balance of their $120,000 backyard renovation.
  • Greenery Coverage & Camera Manipulation: Mr. Bernard contended that artificial vines fully screened the pen and accused the HOA of manipulating camera zoom features from long distances (97 feet from the front street and 162 feet from the golf course) to simulate visibility.

5. The ALJ Decision: Ruling, Financial Remedies, and the "Evidentiary Backfire"

Following the evidentiary hearing, ALJ Moses-Thompson issued an Order Holding Record Open (Doc 1472904) to allow Mr. Bernard to submit additional photo evidence (Respondents' Exhibit B: photos 1653, 1655, 1656, 1660, 1661, and 1662) and allow the HOA to respond. The record officially closed on September 23, 2026.

In a striking procedural turn—and a textbook cautionary lesson for pro se litigants—the post-hearing evidence submitted by the homeowners ultimately doomed their defense. In Findings of Fact #35 and Conclusion of Law #7 of the final ruling dated October 5, 2026 (Doc 1476316), the ALJ specifically noted that the homeowners' own submitted photographs (specifically photos 1653, 1655, and 1656) conclusively proved that the dog pen remained visible from neighboring property despite the faux greenery.

Summary of Administrative Decision (Docket No. 26F-H069-REL) Prevailing Party: PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc. Violations Upheld: The ALJ determined that Petitioner met its burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence. Respondents violated Article IV, Section 2(a) by erecting an exterior structure without advance ALC written approval, and Article IV, Section 2(b) by maintaining an unapproved animal structure that is "Visible From Neighboring Property." Compliance Order: Respondents were formally ordered to abide by Article IV, Sections 2(a) and 2(b) of the CC&Rs by removing, relocating, or properly screening the structure. Mandatory Filing Fee Reimbursement: Pursuant to A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), Respondents were ordered to reimburse the HOA's $500.00 ADRE filing fee within 30 days of the Order. * Civil Penalty Waiver: The ALJ declined to issue civil financial penalties against the homeowners. The court found that while Mr. Bernard was legally mistaken, he held a genuine, good-faith belief that his structure complied with community guidelines, ruling out bad-faith refusal as a factor.


6. Essential Takeaways for Homeowners and HOA Boards

This dispute yields critical risk-mitigation insights for real estate attorneys, community association managers, and homeowners navigating planned community governance:

  1. Prior Written Approval Is Non-Negotiable (and Claim Narrowing Works): Homeowners must secure written permits before making exterior property changes. Informal walkthroughs or late permit applications do not cure initial non-compliance. For HOA boards, narrowing dispute claims prior to trial—such as the HOA's partial withdrawal of the river rock issue—significantly reduces administrative hearing costs and sharpens judicial focus on key violations.
  2. Beware of "Self-Help" Screening and Unvetted Evidence: Adding unauthorized visual barriers (like faux greenery or lattice) often creates secondary CC&R violations rather than curing the original issue. Furthermore, submitting unvetted photographic evidence without understanding objective legal standards can backfire severely; here, the homeowners' post-hearing photos served as the ALJ's primary evidence to prove the HOA's case.
  3. Objective Standards Override Subjective Visual Claims: Statutory tribunals strictly enforce clear CC&R definitions. PebbleCreek's objective definition of "Visible From Neighboring Property" (a 6-foot eye line standing at the base level of the structure) rendered arguments regarding camera zoom, distance, and the neighbor's actual physical height legally irrelevant.
  4. Objective Metrics Defeat Selective Enforcement Allegations: Homeowners frequently allege arbitrary targeting when faced with enforcement action. HOA boards can effectively neutralize selective enforcement defenses by maintaining clear compliance logs. Presenting data showing hundreds of courtesy notices but few actual fines proved that PebbleCreek applied its rules uniformly.
  5. Good Faith Mitigates Punitive Penalties, Not Fee Recovery: Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A), prevailing parties in ADRE proceedings are statutorily entitled to filing fee reimbursement regardless of the opposing party's intent. However, demonstrating sincere efforts to comply and an absence of malice will effectively shield homeowners from punitive civil financial penalties.

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Beth Mulcahy (Attorney for Petitioner)
    Mulcahy Law Firm, PC
  • Emily Bosworth (Law Clerk)
    Mulcahy Law Firm, PC
  • William Barnard (General Manager)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
  • Jack Gregory (Board President)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
  • John Cohn (Vice President, Board of Directors)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
  • Jennifer Sell (Board Administrator)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
  • Rick Watson (Architectural Landscape Committee Inspector)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.
  • Noreen Steckamper (Architectural Landscape Committee Staff)
    PebbleCreek Golf Resort Homeowners Association No. 1, Inc.

Respondent Side

  • Christopher Bernard (Respondent)
  • Deborah Wiener (Respondent)
  • Thomas E. Raccuia (Attorney for Respondents)
    Dessaules Law Group
  • Jonathan A. Dessaules (Attorney for Respondents)
    Dessaules Law Group

Neutral Parties

  • Velva Moses-Thompson (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Adam D. Stone (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Jeremy R. Whittaker v. The Val Vista Lakes Community Association

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H141-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-09-28
Administrative Law JudgeJenna Clark
OutcomePetitioner deemed prevailing party; Final Order issued in favor of Petitioner
Filing Fee Reimbursement$500.00
Civil Penalties$380.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerJeremy R. WhittakerCounsel—
RespondentThe Val Vista Lakes Community AssociationCounsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H141-REL Case document – 1466836.pdf

(38.9 KB)

26F-H141-REL Case document – 1473815.pdf

(52.3 KB)

Briefing Document: Administrative Legal Proceedings in Whittaker v. The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (No. 26F-H141-REL)

Executive Summary

This briefing document provides a detailed account and legal analysis of the administrative proceedings before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) and the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) regarding Docket No. 26F-H141-REL.

The case was initiated by Jeremy R. Whittaker (Petitioner) against The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Respondent) following an alleged single-issue violation of Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 33-1804. Throughout the proceedings, the Respondent consistently failed to submit responses or answers to official state notifications. This pattern of non-responsiveness led to an administrative remand, an Order of Default deeming all allegations admitted, and a final administrative ruling ordering the Respondent to comply with state statute, reimburse the Petitioner’s $500.00 filing fee, and pay a $380.00 civil penalty to the State of Arizona.


Case Directory & Key Parties

Entity / PersonRole in ProceedingsContact / Address Information
Jeremy R. WhittakerPetitioner2103 E. Clipper Ln., Gilbert, AZ 85234
Email: [email protected]
The Val Vista Lakes Community AssociationRespondent1600 E. Lakeside Dr., Gilbert, AZ 85234
Email: [email protected]
Community Asset Management LLCRespondent’s Management / AgentP.O. Box 10000, Prescott, AZ 86304
3205 Lakeside Village, Prescott, AZ 86301
Email: [email protected]
Jenna ClarkAdministrative Law Judge (ALJ)Office of Administrative Hearings
1740 West Adams Street, Lower Level, Phoenix, AZ 85007
Phone: (602) 542-9826
Susan NicolsonCommissioner, Arizona Department of Real Estate – HOA100 N. 15th Ave., Ste. 201, Phoenix, AZ 85007
Emails: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]
CHDB Law, LLPCourtesy Copy Recipient1400 E. Southern Ave., Ste. 400, Tempe, AZ 85282-5691
Emails: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]

Detailed Chronology of Events

“ [May 15, 2026] Petition Filed with ADRE │ [June 06, 2026] Petitioner tenders $500.00 filing fee │ [June 19, 2026] ADRE issues 1st HOA Notice of Petition (20-day response window) -> No Response │ [July 17, 2026] ADRE issues 2nd HOA Notice of Petition (Deadline: Aug 09, 2026) -> No Response │ [August 26, 2026] ADRE issues Notice of Hearing for Sept 30, 2026 before OAH │ [September 08, 2026] Petitioner submits Motion to Vacate / Remand │ [September 09, 2026] ALJ Jenna Clark issues Order Vacating Hearing (Remands to ADRE) │ [September 15, 2026] ADRE issues Order of Default (Petitioner deemed prevailing party) │ [September 25, 2026] Petitioner files Motion for Civil Penalties │ [September 28, 2026] Final Order Issued (Mandates compliance, $500 reimbursement, $380 civil penalty) “

Full Event Breakdown
  • May 15, 2026: Petitioner files a single-issue Homeowners Association Petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate alleging a violation of A.R.S. § 33-1804 and seeking an order in his favor along with civil penalties.
  • June 06, 2026: Petitioner pays the required $500.00 filing fee to the Department.
  • June 19, 2026: The Department sends the initial HOA Notice of Petition to Respondent, giving 20 days to respond and show cause why the petition should be dismissed. Mail is not returned as undeliverable, but Respondent fails to reply.
  • July 17, 2026: The Department issues a second HOA Notice of Petition to Respondent setting a firm response deadline of August 09, 2026. Mail is again not returned as undeliverable, and Respondent fails to reply.
  • August 26, 2026: The Department issues a Notice of Hearing, transferring the matter to the Office of Administrative Hearings for an evidentiary hearing scheduled for September 30, 2026.
  • September 08, 2026: Petitioner files a Motion to Vacate, requesting that the hearing be vacated and remanded back to the Department under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E) due to Respondent's lack of response.
  • September 09, 2026: ALJ Jenna Clark issues an Order Vacating Hearing pursuant to Ariz. Admin. Code R2-19-111(4) and remands the matter back to the Department under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E).
  • September 15, 2026: The Department issues an Order of Default against Respondent, finding that due to failure to file an Answer, all allegations in the Petition are deemed admitted, establishing Petitioner as the prevailing party.
  • September 25, 2026: Petitioner files a Motion for Civil Penalties pursuant to A.R.S. §§ 32-2199.01(E) and 32-21990.02(A), requesting an order mandating compliance with A.R.S. § 33-1804, reimbursement of the $500.00 filing fee, and imposition of civil penalties.
  • September 28, 2026: ALJ Jenna Clark signs the final Order establishing permanent compliance obligations, fee reimbursement, and financial sanctions against the Respondent.

Analysis of Key Legal Themes & Mechanisms

1. Respondent Non-Responsiveness and Administrative Default

A central operational theme of this case is the Respondent’s complete failure to participate in state administrative procedures. Despite two separate notices issued by the Arizona Department of Real Estate (June 19, 2026, and July 17, 2026) sent to multiple addresses (including management firm Community Asset Management LLC), the correspondence was never returned as undeliverable, and no response was ever submitted.

In this case, the Department entered an Order of Default on September 15, 2026 after Respondent failed to answer the notices. The final order records that the allegations were deemed admitted and Whittaker was deemed the prevailing party. That account describes the entered default in this proceeding; it does not establish that every missed deadline automatically and irreversibly forfeits every defense (1473815.pdf, p. 2).

2. Procedural Mechanics of Remand (OAH to ADRE)

Here, Whittaker moved to vacate the scheduled hearing and requested remand. The September 9 order granted that procedural step before the Department entered default.

  • Rule Applied: Arizona Administrative Code R2-19-111(4) governs the vacating of administrative hearings.
  • Basis Cited in This Remand: The September 9 order cites A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E) and remands the matter to the referring agency for further action. It vacates the scheduled hearing, not the later final disposition (1466836.pdf, p. 1).
3. Financial Relief and Statutory Sanctions

The September 28 order mandates three remedies in this case. Its recital of the September 25 motion prints the citation “32-21990.02(A)”; that wording is part of the source recital, not a general statement of legal authority here (1473815.pdf, p. 2):

  1. Injunction/Compliance: Mandatory directive that Respondent must henceforth abide by statutory obligations under A.R.S. § 33-1804.
  2. Fee shifting: Mandatory full reimbursement of the Petitioner’s $500.00 filing fee, specifically ordering payment in certified funds.
  3. State Civil Penalty: Assessment of a $380.00 civil penalty directly levied against Respondent, payable directly to the State of Arizona.

Important Quotes with Context

1. Ruling on Motion to Vacate and Remand

"Pursuant to ARIZ. ADMIN. CODE R2-19-111(4), this matter is hereby vacated from the calendar of the Office of Administrative Hearings and is remanded to the referring agency for further action in accordance with ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 32-2199.01(E)." — ALJ Jenna Clark, Order Vacating Hearing (Sept 09, 2026)

Context: Issued following Petitioner’s September 08, 2026 Motion to Vacate. It stripped the case from the OAH trial docket for September 30, 2026, and routed it back to the Department of Real Estate to process an administrative default due to Respondent's silence.

2. Finding of Default and Entry of Judgment

"On September 15, 2026, the Department issued an ORDER OF DEFAULT against Respondent that held because Respondent failed to submit a timely ANSWER to the HOA NOTICE OF PETITION that all allegations made therein were deemed admitted by Respondent. As such, Petitioner was deemed the prevailing party in the action." — ALJ Jenna Clark, Final Order (Sept 28, 2026)

Context: Details the legal consequences of Respondent's failure to respond to both the June 19 and July 17 notices. Because no Answer was filed, the Department bypassed standard evidentiary burdens, accepting all of Whittaker's claims regarding A.R.S. § 33-1804 as admitted facts.

3. Final Order Mandates

"IT IS ORDERED that Respondent shall henceforth abide by the provisions of ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 33-1804." "IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Respondent shall reimburse Petitioner’s $500.00 filing fee in certified funds." "IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a $380.00 civil penalty be assessed against Respondent that shall be payable to the State of Arizona." — ALJ Jenna Clark, Final Order (Sept 28, 2026)

Context: Operative conclusions of the administrative process signed on September 28, 2026. This translates the default finding into enforceable statutory compliance orders, direct financial restitution to the Petitioner via certified funds, and a punitive financial assessment payable to the state treasury.


What the Orders Establish

  • The procedural sequence: The September 9 order vacated the scheduled hearing and remanded the matter. The Department’s September 15 default is recounted in the later final order; the remand did not end the case in Respondent’s favor.
  • The default in this case: The final order states that Respondent failed to answer the notices, the allegations were deemed admitted, and Whittaker was the prevailing party.
  • The relief actually ordered: Respondent must henceforth abide by A.R.S. § 33-1804, reimburse Whittaker’s $500.00 filing fee in certified funds, and pay a $380.00 civil penalty to the State of Arizona.
  • Award versus payment: These are the obligations imposed by the September 28 order. The order does not establish that either payment was later made, and this report does not treat an award as proof of receipt.

This is the result of these proceedings. The documents do not establish that every default produces the same remedies or a guaranteed reimbursement in certified funds in every other case (1466836.pdf, p. 1; 1473815.pdf, pp. 1–2).

Study Guide: Jeremy R. Whittaker v. The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H141-REL)


1. Executive Summary & Core Concepts

This study guide provides a comprehensive analysis of the administrative legal proceeding Jeremy R. Whittaker v. The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H141-REL), conducted before the State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) and the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).

Key Entities and Roles
  • Petitioner: Jeremy R. Whittaker (Address: 2103 E. Clipper Ln., Gilbert, AZ 85234).
  • Respondent: The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (Address: 1600 E. Lakeside Dr., Gilbert, AZ 85234; also represented via Community Asset Management LLC in Prescott, AZ).
  • Adjudicating Bodies:
  • Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE): Referring state department overseen by Commissioner Susan Nicolson.
  • Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH): Independent state agency handling administrative hearings.
  • Presiding Official: Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Jenna Clark.
  • Courtesy Copy Recipient: CHDB Law, LLP (Tempe, AZ), as identified in the final order’s distribution list.
Legal Basis & Core Dispute
  • Underlying Allegation: Petitioner filed a single-issue Homeowners Association Petition alleging a violation of Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 33-1804 by the Respondent.
  • Procedural Turning Point: Respondent failed to answer two separate official notices issued by the Department of Real Estate. This persistent failure to respond triggered an Order of Default, deeming all allegations admitted and establishing Petitioner as the prevailing party without requiring an evidentiary hearing.
Statutory and Regulatory References
  • A.R.S. § 33-1804: The underlying Arizona statute governing Homeowners Associations that Respondent was alleged to have violated.
  • A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E): The statutory provision governing the remand process and default actions for HOA petitions before the Department.
  • A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A): The statutory authority for assessing civil penalties against a party found in violation.
  • Ariz. Admin. Code R2-19-111(4): Administrative rule granting the OAH authority to vacate a scheduled hearing and remand the matter back to the referring agency.

2. Chronological Procedural History

The following table details the complete procedural timeline of the matter from initial petition filing to the final administrative disposition:

DateEvent / Procedural ActionDescription / Details
May 15, 2026Petition FiledPetitioner files a single-issue Homeowners Association Petition with ADRE alleging a violation of A.R.S. § 33-1804, requesting an order in his favor and civil penalties.
June 06, 2026Filing Fee PaidPetitioner tenders a $500.00 filing fee to ADRE for the petition.
June 19, 2026First Notice IssuedADRE issues the 1st HOA Notice of Petition giving Respondent 20 days to respond and show cause. (Not returned as undeliverable; Respondent does not reply).
July 17, 2026Second Notice IssuedADRE issues a 2nd HOA Notice of Petition setting a response deadline of August 09, 2026. (Not returned as undeliverable; Respondent does not reply).
August 26, 2026Notice of HearingADRE issues Notice of Hearing setting an OAH evidentiary hearing for September 30, 2026.
September 08, 2026Motion to VacatePetitioner submits a Motion to Vacate, requesting OAH remand the case back to ADRE under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E).
September 09, 2026Order Vacating HearingALJ Jenna Clark issues Order Vacating Hearing pursuant to Ariz. Admin. Code R2-19-111(4) and remands matter to ADRE.
September 15, 2026Order of DefaultADRE issues an Order of Default against Respondent due to failure to submit a timely Answer. Allegations are deemed admitted; Petitioner is deemed prevailing party.
September 25, 2026Motion for Civil PenaltiesPetitioner submits a Motion for Civil Penalties under A.R.S. §§ 32-2199.01(E) and 32-2199.02(A), seeking penalties, compliance, and fee reimbursement.
September 28, 2026Final Administrative OrderALJ Jenna Clark issues final Order assessing a $380 penalty, ordering compliance with A.R.S. § 33-1804, and mandating reimbursement of $500 filing fee.

3. Short-Answer Practice Questions

Questions
  1. What state administrative statute did the Petitioner allege that The Val Vista Lakes Community Association violated?
  2. How much was the filing fee paid by the Petitioner on June 06, 2026, and what final disposition was ordered regarding this fee?
  3. How many HOA Notices of Petition were sent by the Department to the Respondent, and what was Respondent's response?
  4. Under what rule of the Arizona Administrative Code did Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark vacate the scheduled September 30, 2026 hearing?
  5. What was the legal consequence of the Department issuing an Order of Default on September 15, 2026?
  6. What were the three specific remedies mandated in the final Order issued on September 28, 2026?
  7. What is the total dollar amount assessed against the Respondent in civil penalties, and to whom is this penalty payable?

Answer Key
  1. A.R.S. § 33-1804.
  2. $500.00. In the final Order, the Respondent was required to reimburse Petitioner's $500.00 filing fee using certified funds.
  3. Two notices were sent (issued on June 19, 2026, and July 17, 2026). Neither notice was returned as undeliverable, but Respondent failed to reply to either one.
  4. Ariz. Admin. Code R2-19-111(4).
  5. Because Respondent failed to submit a timely Answer, all allegations made in the petition were deemed admitted, and the Petitioner was deemed the prevailing party in the action.
  6. The three mandated remedies were:
  • Respondent must henceforth abide by the provisions of A.R.S. § 33-1804.
  • Respondent must reimburse Petitioner's $500.00 filing fee in certified funds.
  • A $380.00 civil penalty was assessed against Respondent payable to the State of Arizona.
  1. $380.00, payable directly to the State of Arizona.

4. Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

  1. Procedural Mechanics of Default in Administrative Proceedings:

Examine how the Department’s default order treated the allegations as admitted after Respondent failed to answer the two notices, and describe the procedural sequence in this case. Analyze the step-by-step procedure starting from the Motion to Vacate to the issuance of the Order of Default, focusing on how A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E) allows an administrative agency to resolve a petition without an evidentiary hearing.

  1. Analysis of Administrative Remedies and Penalties:

Discuss the final Order issued on September 28, 2026, in terms of statutory enforcement and relief. Distinguish between the functions of the non-monetary relief (compelling future adherence to A.R.S. § 33-1804), make-whole relief (reimbursement of the $500.00 filing fee in certified funds), and punitive/regulatory relief ($380.00 civil penalty to the State of Arizona) authorized under A.R.S. § 32-2199.02(A).


5. Glossary of Important Terms

  • Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE / Department): The Arizona administrative state agency tasked with regulating real estate and overseeing administrative petitions involving Homeowners Associations.
  • Certified Funds: The form of payment required for the $500.00 filing-fee reimbursement in this order. The order specifies the obligation; it does not document a completed payment.
  • Civil Penalty: A financial penalty imposed by a government or administrative body as a punishment for a statutory violation, payable in this case to the State of Arizona ($380.00).
  • Motion to Vacate: A formal procedural request submitted by a party (here, the Petitioner on September 08, 2026) asking the tribunal to cancel a scheduled hearing or hearing date.
  • Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH): An independent Arizona state agency that conducts impartial administrative hearings for state regulatory agencies.
  • Order of Default: In this case, the Department’s September 15 order deemed the petition’s allegations admitted after Respondent failed to answer, and deemed Whittaker the prevailing party, as recounted in the September 28 final order.
  • Prevailing Party: The legal party in whose favor a judgment or final administrative order is rendered; established here for the Petitioner following the Respondent's default.
  • Remand: The legal process of sending a case or petition back from a hearing tribunal (OAH) to the referring administrative agency (ADRE) for further administrative action or disposition.

Whittaker v. Val Vista Lakes: Default and September 2026 Order

In OAH case 26F-H141-REL, Jeremy R. Whittaker alleged that The Val Vista Lakes Community Association violated A.R.S. § 33-1804. The matter proceeded through an administrative default after the scheduled hearing was vacated. On September 28, 2026, Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark ordered future compliance, reimbursement of Whittaker’s filing fee, and a civil penalty payable to the state.

Procedural history

The September 28 order records the following sequence:

  • May 15, 2026: Whittaker filed a single-issue petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE), alleging a violation of A.R.S. § 33-1804 and requesting an order in his favor and a civil penalty.
  • June 6: He tendered the $500 filing fee.
  • June 19 and July 17: ADRE issued two notices of petition. The first allowed 20 days to respond; the second set an August 9 response deadline. The order states that neither notice was returned as undeliverable and that the association replied to neither.
  • August 26: ADRE set an OAH hearing for September 30.
  • September 8–9: Whittaker requested that the hearing be vacated and the matter remanded. Judge Clark’s September 9 order vacated the hearing under Arizona Administrative Code R2-19-111(4) and remanded the matter for further action under A.R.S. § 32-2199.01(E).
  • September 15: ADRE entered default because the association had not submitted a timely answer. As recounted in the September 28 order, the petition’s allegations were deemed admitted and Whittaker was deemed the prevailing party.
  • September 25: Whittaker requested civil penalties, an order requiring compliance with A.R.S. § 33-1804, and reimbursement of his filing fee.

The September 28 order

Judge Clark ordered three remedies:

  1. The association must henceforth comply with A.R.S. § 33-1804.
  2. The association must reimburse Whittaker’s $500 filing fee in certified funds.
  3. A $380 civil penalty was assessed against the association, payable to the State of Arizona.

The $500 reimbursement and $380 state penalty are separate obligations with different recipients. The two reviewed orders do not establish whether either amount was paid or whether later proceedings occurred.

Sources: OAH Order Vacating Hearing, September 9, 2026 (document 1466836), and OAH Order, September 28, 2026 (document 1473815).

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Jeremy R. Whittaker (Petitioner)

Neutral Parties

  • Jenna Clark (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Evelyn Keiling, TTE – The Keiling Living Trust v. Lone Mountain

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H116-REL
AgencyArizona Department of Real Estate
TribunalOffice of Administrative Hearings
Decision Date2026-09-21
Administrative Law JudgeNicole Robinson
OutcomePetition denied
Filing Fee Reimbursement$0.00
Civil Penalties—

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerEvelyn Keiling, TTE – The Keiling Living TrustCounselEvelyn Keiling
RespondentLone Mountain Community AssociationCounselMark Sahl, Esq., Jonathan Ebertshauser, Esq.

Alleged Violations

CC&Rs Article 3, Section 3.1; Design Guidelines Sections 1.5 and 5.1.7 (as alleged in the petition)

Outcome Summary

The September 21, 2026 decision denied the petition because Petitioner failed to prove the alleged violations of the governing documents. Respondent was not required to reimburse the filing fee. The tribunal expressly declined to adjudicate challenges to the Association's authority to act under A.R.S. Section 10-3304 or other laws in Title 10, Chapter 26.

Key Issues & Findings

Wall-color requirement: alleged CC&R and Design Guideline violations

The ALJ found that Petitioner failed to prove the alleged governing-document violations by a preponderance of the evidence. Petitioner did not identify a specific violated subsection of CC&Rs Article 3, Section 3.1, and Design Guidelines Section 5.1.7 did not exist. The decision cited CC&Rs Section 5.10.2 and Design Guidelines Section 5.8 in rejecting the pleaded claims. It expressly declined to adjudicate challenges to the Association's authority to act under A.R.S. Section 10-3304 or other laws in Title 10, Chapter 26; it did not decide those excluded claims.

Orders: The petition was denied. Respondent was not required to reimburse Petitioner's filing fee.

Disposition: Petition denied

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Evelyn Keiling (Petitioner)
    The Keiling Living Trust

Respondent Side

  • Mark Sahl (Attorney)
    CHDB Law, LLP
  • Jonathan Ebertshauser (Attorney)
    CHDB Law, LLP
    The appearances paragraph on page 1 spells the surname Ebertshuser; the service block on page 12 identifies Jonathan Ebertshauser.
  • Marcia Hahn (Board President)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
  • Steve Reed (Named in board meeting minutes)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
    Named in the December 16, 2020 board-meeting excerpt on page 5; no hearing appearance is stated.
  • Bob Phillipps (Named in board meeting minutes)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
    Named in the January 13, 2021 board-meeting excerpt on page 5; no hearing appearance is stated.
  • Elaine Parriott (Association Secretary)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
    Identified as Association Secretary who recorded the March 21, 2024 meeting notes on page 5; no hearing appearance is stated.
  • Marc Paquette (Named in architectural-committee report)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
    Named in the April 22, 2025 meeting excerpt on page 6; the decision does not expressly identify a committee membership or hearing appearance.
  • Keith Sutcliffe (Named in board meeting minutes)
    Lone Mountain Community Association
    Named in the November 20, 2025 board-meeting excerpt on page 7; no hearing appearance is stated.

Neutral Parties

  • Nicole Robinson (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Service recipient)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate
    Listed with the Arizona Department of Real Estate – HOA in the service block on page 12; no hearing appearance or specific agency job title is stated.

Case Documents

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1445777.pdf

(45.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1445778.pdf

(5.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1456735.pdf

(56.6 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1456784.pdf

(8.9 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1460822.pdf

(51.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1462275.pdf

(51.0 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1471923.pdf

(53.7 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1471925.pdf

(178.3 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 26F-H116 Notice of Petition – Keiling v Lone Mountain.pdf

(241.7 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 26F-H116 Payment Approved 5-14-26.pdf

(113.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 26F-H116 Respondent Response to NOP.pdf

(377.8 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 26F-H116- Notice of Hearing – ERR.pdf

(2248.5 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – ACC Record – Lone Mountain Community Association.pdf

(324.9 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – ADRE HOA PETITION REQUEST FORM – KEILING.pdf

(601.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – ADRE Response to Petitioner to Submit Additional Hearing Docs to OAH MC 6-22-26.pdf

(112.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 10_EXHIBIT T – LUSTIG CEASE AND DISIST LETTER.pdf

(240.6 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 11_EXHIBIT U – NEXTDOOR.pdf

(625.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 12_EXHIBIT V – BOARD MEMBER SUTCLIFFE CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

(316.3 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 13_TRANSMITTAL LETTER TO THE ADRE – JUNE 9 2026.pdf

(196.5 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 1_EXHIBIT K – 2009 CC&Rs – LONE MOUNTAIN.pdf

(694.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 2_EXHIBIT L – 2009 DESIGN GUIDLINES.pdf

(2092.3 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 3_EXHIBIT M – 2025 DESIGN GUIDELINES – LONE MOUNTAIN – NOVEMBER 2025.pdf

(756.9 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 4_EXHIBIT N – BAINBRIDGE LAW FIRM LETTER MARCH 2026.pdf

(696.8 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 5_EXHIBIT O – HOMEOWNER PETITION SIGNATURES & COMMENTS – JUNE 2026.pdf

(1921.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 6_EXHIBIT P – APPEAL DENIAL ENFORCEMENT CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

(1630.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 7_EXHIBIT Q – FINE LETTERS FROM LMCA MAY THRU JUNE 2026.pdf

(593.8 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 8_EXHIBIT R – SELECTIVE ENFORCEMENT EVIDENCE – TUCKER.pdf

(1144.3 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – 9_EXHIBIT S – CACTUS COLORS PAINT AND STUCCO ESTIMATE .pdf

(60.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – EXHIBIT G – PART 1 OF 2 – CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

(12203.5 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – EXHIBIT G – PART 2 OF 2 – CORRESPONDENCE.pdf

(11431.1 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – EXHIBIT H & I.pdf

(984.9 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – EXHIBIT J – PROFESSIONAL DESIGN EXPERT – OPINION LETTER .pdf

(194.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – EXHIBITS B THRU F.pdf

(9661.4 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – Exhibit A PHOTOGRAPHIC EVIDENCE.pdf

(11814.2 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – LETTER TO ADRE – REQUEST TO EXPEDITE HEARING.pdf

(317.8 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – LETTER TO ADRE – SUBMISSION OF EXHIBIT J.pdf

(241.6 KB)

26F-H116-REL Case document – PETITION FOR ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING – KEILING V LMCA – 04202026.pdf

(1173.6 KB)

Adrianne and Joseph Coates v. The Ocotillo Community Association

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H170-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-09-18
Administrative Law JudgeVelva Moses-Thompson
OutcomeThe Administrative Law Judge ordered that the petition be dismissed because Petitioners failed to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that Ocotillo violated its CC&Rs or failed to enforce them uniformly.
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties$0.00

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerAdrianne CoatesCounsel—
RespondentThe Ocotillo Community AssociationCounselJosh Bolen, Esq. (CHDB Law LLP), Ember Van Vranken, Esq. (CHDB Law LLP)

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H170-REL Case document – 1461133.pdf

(58.0 KB)

26F-H170-REL Case document – 1470453.pdf

(118.7 KB)

Briefing Document: Coates v. The Ocotillo Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H170-REL)


Executive Summary

This briefing document provides a comprehensive analysis of the administrative dispute between petitioners Adrianne and Joseph Coates and respondent The Ocotillo Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H170-REL). The matter was formally set for hearing by the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) on July 27, 2026, and argued before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson at the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) in Phoenix, Arizona, on August 31, 2026.

The central legal issue was whether the Ocotillo Community Association violated Article IV, Section 2(a) and Article XII, Section 2 of its Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) by denying the Coateses' architectural request to install permanent exterior security/eave lighting. The Petitioners alleged that the association denied their request without citing a written rule, applied unpublished standards, and failed to enforce rules uniformly while approving identical lighting on other properties.

Following testimony from the homeowners and Ocotillo board leadership, as well as an evaluation of design standards, photographic comparison evidence, and governing documents, ALJ Moses-Thompson issued a final decision on September 18, 2026. The tribunal found that Ocotillo acted within its legal authority under its CC&Rs and published Design Standards, as the Coateses' stucco home lacked sufficient structural eaves to conceal the light tracking system. Consequently, the tribunal determined that the Petitioners failed to prove non-uniform enforcement or a violation of governing documents, and ordered the petition dismissed.


Key Case Information & Administrative Details

Case ParameterFact / DetailSource Reference
Docket NumberNo. 26F-H170-REL1461133.pdf / 1470453.pdf
TribunalState of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings1461133.pdf
Administrative Law JudgeVelva Moses-Thompson1461133.pdf / 1470453.pdf
PetitionersAdrianne Coates & Joseph Coates (Appeared pro se / on behalf of themselves)1463071.aac / 1470453.pdf
RespondentThe Ocotillo Community Association1461133.pdf / 1470453.pdf
Respondent CounselJosh Bolen, Esq. & Ember Van Vranken, Esq. (CHDB Law LLP)1461133.pdf / 1463071.aac
Respondent WitnessCory Whyte (Vice President of Board of Directors; Chairman of Ocotillo Design Review Board)1463071.aac / 1470453.pdf
Notice of Hearing DateJuly 27, 2026 (Issued by Arizona Department of Real Estate)1463071.aac / 1470453.pdf
Hearing DateAugust 31, 2026 (Conducted via hybrid in-person / Google Meet video appearance)1461133.pdf / 1463071.aac
Final Decision DateSeptember 18, 20261470453.pdf
Final RulingPetition Dismissed in favor of The Ocotillo Community Association1470453.pdf

Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

1. Architectural Control Standards vs. Home Structural Design

A primary point of contention in the proceedings was the application of published community design standards relative to the physical architecture of individual homes within the community.

  • Governing CC&R Authority: Under Article IV, Section 2(a) of Ocotillo’s CC&Rs, the Ocotillo Design Review Board (ODRB) holds authority to establish written architectural guidelines and standards. The provision explicitly grants the ODRB authority to approve or reject proposed alterations or modifications based on engineering, architectural, and aesthetic considerations.
  • Published Design Standards: On January 28, 2025, the ODRB adopted updated Design Standards and Community Rules. Chapter 3 governs permanent exterior lighting and requires written ODRB approval prior to installation. Key specifications for permanent eave lighting include:
  1. The home must have a sufficient amount of eave to install tracks, and tracks must not protrude past the eave.
  2. The preferred method is installing lights and tracks behind the eave or trim plane so they do not extend beyond it.
  3. Alternatively, tracks may be placed at the bottom of the eave/trim, flush with the front face.
  4. Lighting must point downward and cannot create "light trespass" onto adjacent streets or neighboring properties.
  • The Structural Issue: The Coateses submitted their architectural request on January 8, 2026, seeking to install permanent security trim lights on the front and rear rooflines of their home. On January 15, 2026, the ODRB denied the request, stating the home lacked sufficient eave depth to hold the track and that the lights would be positioned at an exposed angle rather than pointing straight down.
  • Architectural Incompatibility: ODRB Chairman Cory Whyte testified that the Coateses' residence features continuous stucco extending up to the roofline without overhangs, exposed wood, or fascia board. Because there is no overhang or recessed fascia, any installed track or bulb system remains fully exposed from the street and driveway rather than hidden or flush mounted as required by Chapter 3.

“ [Standard Eave/Fascia Design] [Coates Stucco Design] +-------------------+ +-------------------+ | Roof Structure | | Roof Structure | +---------+---------+ +---------+---------+ | Wood/Fascia | Stucco Wall | (Recessed Area) | (Extends to Roof) | [Hidden Track/Light] | [Exposed Track] v v Concealed from Street Fully Exposed to Street (Complies with Rules) (Non-Compliant) “


2. Uniformity of Enforcement and Comparative Property Analysis

The Petitioners contended that Ocotillo enforced architectural rules arbitrarily and selectively, alleging that identical permanent lighting systems had been approved on other homes across the community.

  • Petitioners' Comparative Evidence: Mrs. Coates presented photographic evidence of approved properties (Lot 105 / 1270 West Drive and Lot 156) to argue that Ocotillo permitted permanent eave lighting on homes with similar front-facing profiles. She also referenced denied properties (Lot 46 and Lot 118) to demonstrate widespread restrictions.
  • Respondent's Architectural Rebuttal: Cross-examination and witness testimony established critical structural differences between the properties:
  • Approved Homes (Lots 105 & 156): These homes possess recessed wood eaves and deep fascia overhangs. This construction creates a recessed lip above or behind the trim board, allowing lighting tracks to be mounted flush and completely hidden from view.
  • Denied Homes (Lots 46, 118, & Coates Residence): These homes share a common architectural style where stucco extends directly to the roof joinery without wooden fascia or recessed overhangs.
  • Comparable Requests: Finding 13 records that the ODRB had denied lighting requests from owners with homes similar to the Coates home. The ALJ ultimately found that the Coateses had not proved non-uniform enforcement (1470453.pdf, pp. 4, 6).
  • Photographic Testimony: Finding 17 records Mrs. Coates’s difficulty seeing the submitted photographs and expressly finds her testimony about them reliable. Separately, Findings 20–21 and Conclusion 5 address the construction differences and the space available to conceal the track (1470453.pdf, pp. 4–6).

3. Procedural History, Board Appeals, and Demonstration Tracks

The record documents the full sequence of administrative and procedural events leading to the hearing:

“ [Jan 8, 2026] [Jan 15, 2026] [Feb 11, 2026] [Mar 4, 2026] [Apr 29, 2026] [Aug 31, 2026] [Sep 18, 2026] Coateses Submit ODRB Issues Design Manager Coateses File Board of Directors OAH Administrative ALJ Issues Final Design Request Initial Denial Leaves Voicemail Formal Board Denies Appeal Hearing Conducted Order Dismissing For Lighting Letter Re: Sample Track Appeal Letter Letter In Phoenix, AZ Petition “

  • Sample Track Dispute: Following initial discussions, ODRB Design Review Manager left a voicemail (transcribed into evidence as Exhibit 6 Appendix A) indicating that if the contractor mounted a short sample track section, board representatives could review it. The Coateses installed a color-matched sample track on their single-car garage and notified the HOA.
  • Site Inspection Testimony: Mrs. Coates alleged that the ODRB had not reviewed the installed sample. Finding 15 records Mr. Whyte’s explanation that a member may have driven past the home, and that the ODRB would not send two members because that would constitute a meeting that must be public. This is the decision’s account of his testimony, not an independent ruling establishing a general quorum threshold (1470453.pdf, p. 4).
  • Board Appeal Hearing: The Coateses appealed the ODRB's denial to the Association's Board of Directors on March 4, 2026. The Board reviewed the design request, initial denial, physical attributes, and potential for light trespass/visibility. On April 29, 2026, the Board issued a final letter upholding the ODRB's denial.

4. Legal Framework and Administrative Ruling

The hearing was adjudicated under specific Arizona statutory and administrative guidelines:

  • Statutory Jurisdiction: Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 32-2199(B) empowers homeowners in planned communities to petition the Department of Real Estate for administrative hearings regarding CC&R disputes pursuant to A.R.S. § 33-1803. Adjudication is assigned to the Office of Administrative Hearings.
  • Burden of Proof: Under A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2) and A.A.C. R2-19-119, the Petitioners bear the legal burden to establish a CC&R violation by a preponderance of the evidence (showing that the allegation is more probably true than not).
  • Interpretation of Restrictive Covenants: Under Arizona case law (Powell v. Washburn), unambiguous restrictive covenants must be enforced to give effect to the intent of the parties, reading the governing documents as a whole in light of their underlying purpose.
  • ALJ Findings and Legal Conclusions:
  1. Ocotillo's CC&Rs (Article IV, Section 2(a)) and published Design Standards clearly empower the ODRB to deny permanent eave lighting when a home lacks sufficient eave depth to conceal lighting tracks.
  2. The preponderance of the evidence established that the Coates residence lacked adequate eaves or fascia overhangs to mount and hide the track system.
  3. The ODRB appropriately applied its published standards and enforced them consistently among homes with similar structural designs.
  4. The Petitioners failed to sustain their burden of proving non-uniform enforcement or a breach of Article IV, Section 2(a) or Article XII, Section 2.
  • Final Order: On September 18, 2026, ALJ Moses-Thompson officially dismissed the Coateses' petition.

Important Quotes with Context

The following table presents key statements from the hearing transcript and official administrative record, providing context and illustrating the core arguments of each party.

SpeakerExact Quote / Document TextContext & Relevance
Adrianne Coates (Petitioner)"The HOA denied my lighting request based on unwritten criteria such as insufficient ease, angle of lights, and not pointing completely down. None of these appear in the CTNR's design guidelines or any published standard."From Mrs. Coates's opening statement. Outlines the primary contention that the denial was based on subjective, unpublished rules.
Josh Bolen, Esq. (Respondent Counsel)"The design standards unfortunately don't allow the coats to install the lighting that they wanted to because of the design of their home. They don't have a standard eve that would allow the lighting to be shielded…"From Respondent's opening statement. Establishes the defense that structural limitations of the stucco roofline—not selective enforcement—caused the denial.
Cory Whyte (Board VP / ODRB Chair)"There the way that the design of this home is is that it's a it's stucco up to the roof. So there is no wood or fascia that's that's um allowing for anything to be hidden as we like to say… There is no eve or trim."Testimony explaining Exhibit 3 (photo of the Coates residence). Pinpoints the exact architectural feature preventing compliance with Chapter 3.
Written Decision, Finding 15"Mr. Whyte also explained that the ODRB would not send two members to the home because it would have constituted a meeting, and an ODRB meeting must be public."The ALJ’s account of Whyte’s site-inspection testimony (1470453.pdf, p. 4).
Joseph Coates (Petitioner)"The 382 is the best look at it. And as you said, there is nothing in fill in it. No, but the thing's fairly narrow and it's going to be painted the same color as the room… You can [see the track], but you can see the track itself."Testimony during cross-examination. Mr. Coates concedes that the sample track lacks an eave/trim overhang screen and remains visually exposed.
Velva Moses-Thompson (ALJ)"The evidence presented at hearing shows the ODRB may deny a request for permanent eave lighting… if there is insufficient eave on the home to install tracks of light behind the eave. The preponderance of the evidence shows that Coates’s home lacked enough eave…"Conclusion of Law #5 from the ALJ Decision dated Sept 18, 2026. Summarizes the legal basis for upholding Ocotillo's architectural denial.

Actionable Insights & Practical Takeaways

The proceedings and administrative decision in Coates v. The Ocotillo Community Association offer practical lessons for homeowners, HOAs, design review committees, and legal practitioners:

For Homeowners
  • Evaluate Structural Eligibility Before Applying: Published design guidelines often contain specific physical prerequisites (such as recessed overhangs or fascia depth). Homeowners should confirm their home's specific architectural style can physically accommodate the modification before purchasing materials or hiring contractors.
  • Compare the Evidence in This Case: The approved homes had features that allowed their lighting tracks to be concealed, while the Coates home lacked sufficient eave space. The ALJ found that these petitioners had not proved non-uniform enforcement. The decision does not make identical structural conditions a universal prerequisite for a selective-enforcement claim (1470453.pdf, pp. 5–6).
  • Document Sample Installations Clearly: If an HOA permits a sample installation, ensure high-resolution photos are taken from multiple angles (street level, driveway, direct underside) to demonstrate compliance with visibility and screening rules.
For Homeowners Associations & Design Review Boards
  • Identify the Rules Applied: The ALJ applied Ocotillo’s CC&Rs and its adopted Design Standards to this application and found that the ODRB appropriately denied it because the home lacked sufficient eave space to hide the track (1470453.pdf, p. 6).
  • Keep Testimony Separate from Legal Conclusions: The written decision recounts Whyte’s explanation for the site-inspection procedure. Its Conclusions of Law resolve the architectural application and enforcement claim, rather than deciding a general open-meeting rule for site visits (1470453.pdf, pp. 4, 6).
  • Document Architectural Distinctions in Denials: Denial letters should cite specific published guideline sections (e.g., Chapter 3, Permanent Eave Lighting) and detail the exact physical non-compliance observed (e.g., lack of recessed fascia), creating a clear administrative record if challenged.
For Legal Representatives
  • Read the Comparisons in Context: Photographs and testimony about eave space and track visibility mattered to this record. The conclusion was that the Coateses had not proved their alleged violations, not that construction differences automatically defeat every unequal-enforcement claim (1470453.pdf, pp. 5–6).
  • Ensure Exhibit Completeness Early: Complete copies of proposed hearing exhibits should be exchanged with opposing parties prior to administrative proceedings to avoid procedural delays regarding exhibit sharing and foundation objections.

Administrative Law and HOA Governance Study Guide: Adrianne and Joseph Coates v. The Ocotillo Community Association


1. Executive Summary & Case Overview

This study guide examines the administrative law dispute Adrianne and Joseph Coates v. The Ocotillo Community Association (Docket No. 26F-H170-REL), heard before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH).

The case highlights key principles of homeowners association (HOA) governance, architectural authority, administrative burden of proof, statutory enforcement under Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.), and uniform enforcement of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).

Key Case Details
  • Petitioners: Adrianne Coates and Joseph Coates (representing themselves pro se).
  • Respondent: The Ocotillo Community Association ("Ocotillo").
  • Respondent’s Counsel: Josh Bolen, Esq. and Ember Van Vranken, Esq. (CHDB Law LLP).
  • Respondent’s Key Witness: Cory Whyte (Vice President of the Board of Directors; Chairman of the Ocotillo Design Review Board).
  • Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): Velva Moses-Thompson.
  • Forum: Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (Phoenix, AZ), initiated via the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).
  • Primary Issue: Whether Ocotillo violated Article IV, Section 2(a) and Article XII, Section 2 of its CC&Rs by denying the petitioners' architectural application for permanent security eave lighting without a written rule or published standard, and whether the CC&Rs were enforced non-uniformly.
  • Final Outcome: The Administrative Law Judge determined that the Coateses failed to meet their burden of proof. The petition was dismissed on September 18, 2026.

2. Key Concepts & Legal Principles

A. Architectural Control and Discretionary Authority
  • CC&R Article IV, Section 2(a): Grants the Ocotillo Design Review Board (ODRB) express authority to adopt written architectural guidelines and standards. It empowers the ODRB to approve or reject proposed construction, modifications, or alterations based on engineering, architectural, and aesthetic considerations.
  • Scope of Authority: Applies to any exterior modification visible from the street (excluding modifications in backyards that remain below the fence line).
B. Published Design Standards
  • Ocotillo Design Standards and Community Rules: Adopted on January 28, 2025. These rules are part of the association’s governing documents and are made accessible via the owner portal/website and at the HOA management office.
  • Permanent Eave Lighting Requirements (Chapter 3):
  1. The home must have a sufficient amount of eave to install tracks, and tracks must not protrude past the eave.
  2. Preferred installation: Place lights and track systems behind the eave or trim plane so they do not extend beyond it.
  3. Alternative installation: Install track at the bottom of the eave, completely flush with the front of the eave or trim.
  4. Light Direction: Lighting must be directed downward and cannot illuminate, shine onto, or be directed toward adjacent streets or neighboring properties (prohibiting "light trespass").
C. Association Rights of Enforcement
  • CC&R Article XII, Section 2: Authorizes the Association, as agent and representative of the owners, to enforce all covenants, restrictions, servitudes, and conditions set forth in the Declaration.
D. Administrative Procedure & Evidentiary Standards
  • Statutory Framework: Governed by A.R.S. § 32-2199(B) and A.R.S. § 33-1803, allowing planned community property owners to petition the ADRE for administrative hearings before the OAH.
  • Burden of Proof: Under A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2) and A.A.C. R2-19-119, the petitioners bear the burden of proving an HOA violation by a preponderance of the evidence.
  • Preponderance of the Evidence: Proof showing that a contention is "more probably true than not," carrying superior evidentiary weight.
  • Interpretation of Restrictive Covenants: Unambiguous covenants are enforced to give effect to the intent of the parties, construed as a whole in view of their underlying purposes.
E. Open Meeting Requirements & Procedural Rules
  • Site-Inspection Testimony: Finding 15 records Whyte’s explanation that a member may have driven past the home and that the ODRB would not send two members because it would constitute a meeting that must be public. This is his explanation recorded in the decision, not a general quorum rule decided by the ALJ (1470453.pdf, p. 4).

3. Case Timeline

DateEvent / Action
January 28, 2025The Ocotillo Board of Directors adopts the current Ocotillo Design Standards and Community Rules.
January 8, 2026Adrianne and Joseph Coates submit a Design Request to the ODRB for permanent security trim lighting under their roofline.
January 15, 2026ODRB issues a formal letter denying the Coateses' Design Request due to insufficient eave depth and exposed track visibility.
February 11, 2026Design Review Manager leaves a voicemail regarding a sample track demonstration.
March 4, 2026The Coateses submit a formal appeal to the Ocotillo Board of Directors.
April 29, 2026The Board of Directors sends a formal letter upholding the ODRB's denial.
July 27, 2026Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) issues a Notice of Hearing setting the case for trial.
August 26, 2026ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson issues an order granting Ocotillo's motion for a virtual appearance via Google Meet.
August 31, 2026Administrative Hearing conducted at 3:00 PM before ALJ Velva Moses-Thompson.
September 18, 2026ALJ issues Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order dismissing the Coateses' petition.

4. Key Exhibits & Evidence Summary

“ EXHIBIT MATRIX +-------------------------------------------------------------------+ | RESPONDENT (Ocotillo) EXHIBITS | +-------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Exhibit 1 | Ocotillo Declaration of CC&Rs (Art. IV & XII) | | Exhibit 2 | Design Standards & Community Rules (Jan 28, 2025) | | Exhibit 3 | Coates Architectural Application & Home Photo | | Exhibit 4 | ODRB Initial Denial Letter (Jan 15, 2026) | | Exhibit 6 | Approved Home Examples (Recessed Eaves / Wood Fascia)| +-------------------------------------------------------------------+ | PETITIONER (Coates) EXHIBITS | +-------------------------------------------------------------------+ | Ex. 3A1–3A3| Sample Track Demo Photos on Garage | | Ex. 4C1–4C2| Approved Comparison Homes (Lot 105 & Lot 156) | | Ex. 4D1–4D2| Denied Comparison Homes (Lot 46 & Lot 118) | | Ex. 5A1–5A3| Photos of Coates Home Architectural Stucco Profile | | Exhibit 6 | March 4, 2026 Appeal Letter & Voicemail Transcript | +-------------------------------------------------------------------+ “

Analysis of Architectural Evidence
  • Coates Home Profile: Features continuous stucco extended directly up to the roofline without exposed wood fascia, overhangs, or recessed eave cavities. Mounting a track results in an exposed, unscreened fixture visible from the street/driveway.
  • Approved Homes (Lots 105 & 156): Possessed traditional wood fascia boards and recessed roofline cavities, allowing tracking to be installed completely hidden or flush behind the trim plane.
  • Denied Homes (Lots 46 & 118): Shared structural similarities with the Coateses' home (lack of eave depth), resulting in uniform denial by the ODRB.

5. Short-Answer Practice Questions

Question 1

What specific provisions of Ocotillo’s CC&Rs were alleged to have been violated in the petitioners' initial filing?

Answer: Article IV, Section 2(a) (Architectural Control) and Article XII, Section 2 (Enforcement Rights). The petitioners claimed Ocotillo denied their permanent lighting application without citing a written rule, applying a published standard, or enforcing rules uniformly.

Question 2

What architectural feature of the Coateses' home led to the denial of their permanent eave lighting request?

Answer: The home has a continuous stucco exterior extending up to the roofline without exposed wood fascia, trim, or an overhang/eave cavity. Because there was no eave to conceal the light track, any installed track remained exposed and visible rather than hidden or flush.

Question 3

Under Arizona administrative law, what is the legal standard and burden of proof required for a homeowner to prevail against an HOA?

Answer: The petitioner bears the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence (A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2)). They must convince the Administrative Law Judge that it is "more probably true than not" that the HOA violated statutory law or its own governing documents.

Question 4

Why did Ocotillo's board decline to send the full Design Review Board to inspect the sample track installed on the Coateses' home?

Answer: According to Finding 15, Whyte said a member may have driven past the home, but the ODRB would not send two members because that would constitute a meeting that must be public. The written decision records that testimony; its Conclusions of Law do not decide a general rule about site-inspection quorums (1470453.pdf, pp. 4, 6).

Question 5

What distinction does Ocotillo’s published Design Standard make between permanent eave lighting and temporary holiday lighting?

Answer: Holiday lighting is temporary and allowed to produce various colors and project light outward during holiday seasons. Permanent eave lighting must be installed permanently behind/flush with eaves, serve as backlighting, project strictly downward, and prevent light trespass onto neighboring properties or streets.

Question 6

What was the administrative outcome of the dispute, and what recourse is available to an aggrieved party following the decision?

Answer: The petition was dismissed in its entirety. Under A.R.S. § 32-2199.04 and A.R.S. § 41-1092.09, an aggrieved party may request a rehearing by filing an application with the Commissioner of the Department of Real Estate within 30 days of service of the order.


6. Deep-Exploration Essay Prompts

Essay Prompt 1: Aesthetic Discretion vs. Written Guidelines

Prompt: Examine how the ALJ applied Ocotillo’s CC&Rs and published Design Standards to the evidence about this home’s eave and lighting track. Identify the findings supporting the application denial and explain the separate conclusion that the petitioners did not prove non-uniform enforcement (1470453.pdf, pp. 5–6). Key Points to Cover: Contrast general authority under CC&R Article IV, Section 2(a) with the specific guidelines adopted in Chapter 3 of the Ocotillo Design Standards. Examine the petitioners' argument that criteria like "insufficient eave" constituted unwritten, subjective rules. Discuss the ALJ’s finding that the published rule requiring tracks to be placed "behind" or "flush with" the eave implicitly and lawfully restricted homes lacking eaves from installing exposed tracks. Address how written design standards protect community property values while setting boundaries for arbitrary enforcement.

Essay Prompt 2: Evidentiary Requirements in Inconsistent Enforcement Claims

Prompt: Homeowners alleging non-uniform enforcement must prove selective application of rules. Detail the comparative photographic and physical evidence presented by both parties in this case, and discuss why the petitioners failed to establish non-uniform enforcement. Key Points to Cover: Identify the exhibits submitted by Mrs. Coates (Lots 105 and 156) to prove differential treatment. Analyze Ocotillo’s counter-evidence demonstrating structural architectural differences (wood fascia/recessed eaves vs. direct stucco). Discuss the significance of Ocotillo’s evidence showing similar homes (Lots 46 and 118) were consistently denied. Evaluate the impact of testimony admissions (e.g., Mr. Coates admitting on cross-examination that approved homes possessed structural spaces concealing the track, whereas his home did not).


7. Glossary of Important Terms

  • Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): An independent judicial officer who presides over administrative hearings, evaluates evidence, determines findings of fact and conclusions of law, and issues binding decisions or recommendations.
  • Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE): The state administrative agency responsible for regulating real estate matters, including overseeing HOA dispute petition filings under Title 32 and Title 33.
  • Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs): The primary governing document establishing legal ground rules, property rights, architectural restrictions, and association powers for a planned real estate community.
  • Design Review Board (DRB / ODRB): A designated committee within an HOA responsible for reviewing, approving, or denying homeowner applications for exterior architectural modifications.
  • Eave: The lower edge of a roof that overhangs or projects beyond the exterior side wall of a building, often finished with a fascia board or trim soffit.
  • Light Trespass: Unwanted or excessive artificial light falling onto adjacent properties, public streets, or neighboring residences.
  • Master-Planned Community: A large-scale residential development incorporating specialized land-use classifications, shared common areas, unified governance structures, and standardized architectural rules (e.g., Ocotillo's 3,000+ homes).
  • Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH): An independent Arizona state agency designed to provide neutral, administrative adjudication for disputes arising from state regulatory agencies.
  • Preponderance of the Evidence: The standard of proof in civil and administrative cases requiring the party with the burden of proof to demonstrate that their factual claims are more probable than not.
  • Pro Se: A Latin term meaning "for oneself," referring to a party who represents themselves in a legal proceeding without hiring an attorney.
  • Quorum: The minimum number of board or committee members required to be present at a meeting to officially transact association business.
  • Trim Plane: The flat exterior surface or face created by the fascia board or outer edge of an eave, serving as a boundary line beyond which fixtures cannot extend under Ocotillo design rules.

When Permanent Lights Meet HOA Guidelines: Lessons from Coates v. Ocotillo Community Association

1. Introduction: The Eave Lighting Conflict

Adrianne and Joseph Coates challenged the Ocotillo Community Association’s denial of their application for permanent eave lighting. The Office of Administrative Hearings considered that application under Ocotillo’s CC&Rs and Design Standards in Case No. 26F-H170-REL.

The dispute concerned the space available to conceal the lighting track, the written design requirements, and comparisons with approved installations on other homes. The ALJ evaluated those facts and dismissed the petition after concluding that the Coateses had not proved the alleged violations.

Case Result: The ALJ found that the Coates home lacked enough eave space to mount and hide the lighting track under Ocotillo’s CC&Rs and Design Standards. On this record, the petitioners did not prove a violation or non-uniform enforcement, and the petition was dismissed (1470453.pdf, p. 6).

2. Background of the Dispute

Following an official Notice of Hearing issued by the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE) on July 27, 2026, an administrative evidentiary hearing was convened on August 31, 2026. Petitioners Adrianne and Joseph Coates challenged the association's denial of their architectural application submitted on January 8, 2026, which requested permission to install permanent security trim lighting along the front and rear perimeter beneath their roofline.

The Petitioners based their challenge on two principal provisions of Ocotillo's Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, & Restrictions (CC&Rs):

  • Article IV, Section 2(a) (Architectural Control): Authorizes the Design Review Board to adopt written architectural guidelines and standards, granting discretionary authority to approve or reject proposed modifications based on aesthetic, engineering, and architectural considerations.
  • Article XII, Section 2 (Enforcement Rights): Establishes the Association's authority to enforce covenants, restrictions, and conditions across all properties within the development.

In their petition and opening arguments, the Coateses asserted three core allegations against the HOA:

  • Absence of Published Standards: The Petitioners argued that the ODRB rejected their architectural submittal without citing an applicable written rule or enforcing a published, objective standard.
  • Use of Unwritten Subjective Criteria: The Petitioners contended that the board improperly relied on unwritten, subjective requirements, specifically citing criteria regarding "insufficient eave depth," improper light projection angles, and fixtures that failed to point completely downward.
  • Selective and Non-Uniform Enforcement: The Petitioners alleged that the Association enforced architectural rules arbitrarily by denying their submittal while previously approving identical permanent trim lighting installations on other residences in the community.

3. The HOA's Standards and Architectural Reality

The Ocotillo Community Association defended its administrative decision through the testimony of Cory Whyte, Vice President of the Board of Directors and Chairman of the ODRB. Represented by legal counsel Josh Bolen of CHDB Law LLP, the HOA established that its denial was strictly grounded in formal governing rules and structural realities. The Coateses represented themselves pro se.

To contextualize the necessity of strict architectural oversight, testimony revealed that Ocotillo is a large-scale master-planned community encompassing over 3,300 single-family residences and more than 4,000 total unit "doors," including townhomes, condominiums, commercial parcels, and assisted living facilities. Managing architectural uniformity across a development of this magnitude requires rigid adherence to published standards to protect community-wide fair market property values.

On January 28, 2025, the ODRB formally adopted the Ocotillo Design Standards and Community Rules. These rules are maintained in the regular course of business and remain accessible to all residents via the HOA’s online owner portal and management office. Chapter 3 of these standards explicitly governs "Permanent Eave Lighting," establishing four primary mandates:

  1. Properties must possess a sufficient eave depth to accommodate lighting tracks without track protrusion past the eave plane.
  2. The primary installation method requires positioning tracks behind the eave or fascia trim so fixtures do not extend beyond the eave/trim plane.
  3. Alternatively, tracks may be installed along the bottom of the eave or trim, provided they remain completely flush with the front plane.
  4. Illumination must be directed strictly downward, expressly prohibiting light trespass onto adjacent roadways or neighboring lots.

The central obstacle facing the Coateses' submittal was the structural framework of their home. Unlike neighboring residences built with recessed fascia boards or extended wood eaves, the Coates home featured a continuous exterior stucco finish terminating directly at the roofline. This structural design provided no architectural recess or eave lip to screen exterior-mounted light tracks.

HOA Design Standard RequirementCoates Property Condition
Must possess sufficient eave depth to install track systems without protrusion past the eave planeContinuous exterior stucco finish terminating directly at the roofline, providing no wood or fascia eave depth
Tracks must be concealed behind the eave/trim plane or mounted flush along the bottom planeExterior-mounted tracks remain fully exposed to public view without structural recess or screening lip
Lighting must project strictly downward without light trespass or visible exterior track glareLack of structural recess forces exterior track mounting, leaving fixture tracks unshielded along the outer wall

4. Evidentiary Breakdown & Hearing Highlights

During the evidentiary hearing before Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Velva Moses-Thompson, both parties presented photographic exhibits, witness testimony, and structural comparisons. Cross-examination highlighted critical physical differences between the Coates home and surrounding properties.

  1. Presentation of Exhibits & Photographic Evidence
  2. Sample Track Installation (Exhibits 3A1–3A3): Mrs. Coates introduced photographs showing a color-matched, low-profile track segment mounted on their single-car garage wall, arguing that the track was minimally visible from sidewalk distances.
  3. Approved Comparative Properties (Exhibits 4C1–4C2): The Petitioners submitted photographs of approved permanent eave lighting installations on Lot 105 (1270 West Drive) and Lot 156, alleging these properties shared similar rooflines.
  4. Denied Comparative Properties (Exhibit 4D): Evidentiary submissions included records for Lot 118 and Lot 46 (Exhibit 4D), demonstrating that the ODRB consistently denied eave lighting applications for other homes lacking structural eaves, refuting claims of selective enforcement.
  1. Cross-Examination and Key Admissions
  2. Admission of Unshielded Installation: Under cross-examination by association counsel, Mr. Coates acknowledged that their home lacked a physical eave or fascia overhang to block public view of the exterior track system.
  3. Recognition of Structural Distinctions: Mr. Coates conceded that the approved homes on Lot 105 and Lot 156 contained distinct architectural recesses and extended wood fascia boards capable of concealing light tracks, unlike the continuous stucco wall terminating at their own roofline.
  4. Evaluation of Visual Evidence Nuance: During cross-examination, Mrs. Coates disclosed that she suffered from a visual impairment in her right eye that limited her view of the photographic exhibits. In Finding #17 of the decision, ALJ Moses-Thompson formally evaluated this testimony and affirmed that Mrs. Coates's evidentiary submissions and witness statements remained reliable.
  1. ODRB Board Rationale & Open Governance Protocols
  2. Administrative Appeal Review: ODRB Chairman Cory Whyte testified that both the ODRB and the Board of Directors reviewed the Coateses' appeal and confirmed that the proposed track could not be hidden or flush-mounted due to the home's stucco-to-roof construction.
  3. Sample Inspection Testimony: Finding 15 records Whyte’s explanation that a member may have driven past the home and that the ODRB would not send two members because it would constitute a meeting that must be public. The decision reports his explanation; it does not decide a general statutory quorum threshold for all site inspections (1470453.pdf, p. 4).

5. The Ruling and Key Takeaways for Homeowners

On September 18, 2026, Administrative Law Judge Velva Moses-Thompson issued her formal Decision (Docket No. 26F-H170-REL). The decision placed the burden on the petitioners to establish the alleged CC&R violations by a preponderance of the evidence, citing A.R.S. § 41-1092.07(G)(2) and A.A.C. R2-19-119 (1470453.pdf, pp. 5–6).

Conclusion 4 cites Powell v. Washburn for construing restrictive covenants as a whole and giving effect to their provisions and purposes. In Conclusion 5, the ALJ applied Ocotillo’s Article IV, Section 2(a) and Design Standards to the evidence that this home lacked enough eave to mount and hide the track, and concluded that the ODRB appropriately denied this application (1470453.pdf, p. 6).

The decision compared the Coates home with approved homes that had space to conceal the track, and also recorded that similar applications had been denied. Conclusion 6 states that the Coateses failed to prove either the alleged CC&R violations or non-uniform enforcement. The order therefore dismisses their petition (1470453.pdf, pp. 4–6).

The decision turns on Ocotillo’s governing documents and the evidence about this application.

The Home’s Construction Mattered to This Request The ALJ found that the Coates home lacked enough eave space to mount and hide the lighting track as required by Ocotillo’s CC&Rs and Design Standards. That was the basis for upholding the ODRB’s denial.

The Enforcement Comparisons Were Case-Specific The evidence distinguished approved homes with space to conceal the track from the Coates home and other similarly constructed homes whose requests had been denied. On this record, the ALJ found that the Coateses had not proved non-uniform enforcement. The written decision does not establish a universal requirement that comparison properties have identical physical characteristics.

The Site-Inspection Account Was Witness Testimony Whyte’s explanation about sending ODRB members to inspect the sample appears in the findings of fact. The conclusions of law resolve the alleged CC&R violations, not a general legal rule about site-inspection quorums.

The petition was dismissed because the Coateses had not sustained their burden on the alleged violations. These are the bounds of the written ruling (1470453.pdf, pp. 4–6).

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Adrianne Coates (Petitioner)
  • Joseph Coates (Petitioner)

Respondent Side

  • Josh Bolen (Attorney)
    CHDB Law LLP
  • Ember Van Vranken (Attorney)
    CHDB Law LLP
  • Cory Whyte (Vice President and Design Review Board Chairman)
    The Ocotillo Community Association
  • Design Review Manager (Design Review Manager)
    The Ocotillo Community Association
    The written decision does not establish the manager’s name, and machine-transcribed names vary; the person is identified here by role.

Neutral Parties

  • Velva Moses-Thompson (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Representative)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Steven Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.

Case Summary

Case ID26F-H031-REL
Agency—
Tribunal—
Decision Date2026-09-16
Administrative Law JudgeJenna Clark
OutcomePetition Denied and Dismissed with Prejudice
Filing Fee Reimbursement—
Civil Penalties—

Parties & Counsel

PetitionerSteven SchumacherCounselSelf-represented (Pro Se)
RespondentThe Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.Counsel—

Alleged Violations

No violations listed

Video Overview

Audio Overview

Case Documents

26F-H031-REL Case document – 1418035.pdf

(57.9 KB)

26F-H031-REL Case document – 1418059.pdf

(8.8 KB)

26F-H031-REL Case document – 1431541.pdf

(50.4 KB)

26F-H031-REL Case document – 1433527.pdf

(67.3 KB)

26F-H031-REL Case document – 1469008.pdf

(157.0 KB)

Administrative Hearing Briefing Document: Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. (No. 26F-H031-REL)

Executive Summary

This briefing document synthesizes the proceedings, legal arguments, evidentiary disclosures, and final adjudication of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) Docket No. 26F-H031-REL, Steven Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. The dispute centered on whether the homeowners association (HOA) violated its governing Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs)—specifically Article VII, Section 7.2.3—by equally assessing master insurance policy premiums across all 69 property owners rather than assessing structural coverage costs exclusively against attached condominium owners.

Petitioner Steven Schumacher, a detached home owner, argued that because the HOA’s master insurance policy provides guaranteed 100% replacement coverage for 50 attached condominium units (valued at over $20 million) while excluding structural coverage for 19 detached single-family homes, allocating insurance premiums equally (a 1/69th share) forced detached owners to improperly subsidize attached unit coverage. He contended that insurance premiums for attached structures constitute maintenance, repair, or replacement expenses under CC&R Section 7.2.3 and Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.) § 33-1255(C), requiring a 1/50th allocation to attached units only.

Respondent, represented by counsel Daniel Leffler, argued that Article VIII, Section 8.2 specifically governs insurance, designating all association-obtained insurance premiums as common expenses to be shared equally (1/69th) pursuant to Article II, Section 2.6. Respondent further noted that under Section 2.5.1, the outer building shells of attached units are defined as common elements in which all 69 owners hold an undivided equal interest.

Following a formal administrative hearing on September 1, 2026, Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) Jenna Clark issued a decision on September 16, 2026, denying the petition and dismissing the matter with prejudice. The tribunal found that Petitioner had not proved a violation of Article VII, Section 7.2.3 by a preponderance of the evidence. Although both parties agreed that insurance was assessed equally, the written decision rested on insufficient evidence of an improper or unlawful assessment (1469008.pdf, pp. 8–9).


Case Overview and Procedural History

Case Information Summary
ParameterDetails
TribunalOffice of Administrative Hearings (OAH), State of Arizona
Referring AgencyArizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE)
Docket NumberNo. 26F-H031-REL
PetitionerSteven Schumacher (Detached Unit Owner, 56 Ridge Rock Rd., Sedona, AZ 86351)
RespondentThe Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.
Respondent CounselDaniel Leffler, Esq.; Jill J. Ormond, Esq.; Rebecca L. Donsky, Esq. (Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP)
Presiding OfficerAdministrative Law Judge Jenna Clark
Property ProfileHybrid community of 69 units (19 detached single-family lots; 50 attached condominiums in 16 buildings)
Management CompanyAAM LLC
Filing Fee Paid$500.00 tendered by Petitioner
Comprehensive Procedural Timeline

“ [Jan 09, 2026] Petitioner files HOA Dispute Petition with ADRE ($500 fee paid) │ [Feb 03, 2026] ADRE issues Notice of Petition to Respondent │ [Feb 23, 2026] Respondent files Answer denying all complaint items │ [Mar 18, 2026] ADRE issues Notice of Hearing setting OAH trial for April 17, 2026 │ [Apr 21, 2026] ALJ grants Respondent's continuance request; resets hearing to June 11, 2026 │ [Jun 03, 2026] ALJ denies Respondent's motion for continuance for lack of good cause │ [Jun 08, 2026] ALJ grants Respondent's Request for Reconsideration; resets hearing to Sept 01, 2026 │ [Sep 01, 2026] Formal Administrative Hearing conducted via Google Meet (10:47 AM - 12:10 PM) │ [Sep 16, 2026] ALJ Decision issued: Petition DENIED and DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE “


Detailed Analysis of Key Themes

Theme 1: Governing Document Interpretation & Contract Construction Rules

The central legal debate focused on contract interpretation principles applicable to restrictive covenants. In Arizona, CC&Rs operate as an enforceable contract between the association and unit owners.

“ ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ COMPETING ALLOCATION ARGUMENTS │ └──────────────────────────────┬──────────────────────────────┘ │ ┌───────────────────────┴───────────────────────┐ ▼ ▼ Article VIII, Section 8.2 Article VII, Section 7.2.3 Article II, Section 2.6 Article II, Section 2.6 Exception ┌───────────────────────────────┐ ┌───────────────────────────────┐ │ "Premiums for all insurance │ │ "All Common Expenses │ │ obtained... shall be Common │ │ pertaining to maintenance, │ │ Expenses and paid by Assoc." │ │ repair, or replacement of... │ │ Respondent: equal 1/69th │ │ Attached Units... assessed │ └───────────────────────────────┘ │ ONLY against Attached Units" │ │ Petitioner: 1/50th share │ └───────────────────────────────┘ “

  • Specific vs. General Provisions: Respondent’s primary legal argument, supported by witness Donald Schneider (a legal practitioner and former board Vice President), relied on the canon of construction where specific provisions govern general ones. Article VIII specifically addresses "Insurance" and Section 8.2 explicitly classifies all insurance premiums as common expenses. Articles I through VII address broader governance and maintenance duties without referencing insurance premium assessments.
  • The Scope of Section 7.2.3: Petitioner argued that building insurance falls within Section 7.2.3 because insurance ultimately funds the "repair or replacement" of attached buildings. Respondent disputed this, arguing that Section 7.2.3 applies to direct operational maintenance and reserve items—such as exterior painting ($60/month reserve fee assessed solely to attached unit owners)—rather than master risk-mitigation insurance policies.
  • Absence of Cross-References: Article VIII contains no cross-reference back to Article VII or Section 7.2.3. Section 2.6 explicitly enumerates exceptions to equal 1/69th allocation (specifically referencing Sections 7.2.3, 7.2.4, and 7.2.5), but omits Article VIII entirely.
Theme 2: Property Classification, Common Elements, and Risk Allocation

The physical layout of The Ridge at Sedona heavily impacted the legal positions of both parties.

“` THE RIDGE AT SEDONA (69 TOTAL UNITS) │ ┌──────────────────────────┴──────────────────────────┐ ▼ ▼ 19 Detached Units 50 Attached Units (Units 1-12, 63-69) (Units 13-62)

  • Single-family lots – Housed in 16 structures
  • Structures self-insured by owners – Building outer shell = Common Element
  • Pay 1/69th master insurance – Covered by Master Policy ($20M replacement)
  • Pay $286/mo base operational fee – Pay 1/69th master insurance + $60/mo paint fee

“`

  • Undivided Interest in Common Elements: Under Section 2.5.1, the outer structural shell of attached condominium buildings is classified as a "Common Element." Section 2.6 provides that every unit owner holds an undivided 1/69th (or 1/70th per document drafting) interest in all common elements.
  • Insurable Interest: Because detached unit owners hold an undivided fractional ownership interest in the outer shells of the attached structures, Respondent argued that detached owners possess an insurable interest that the master policy protects. When an insured loss occurs, policy payouts go directly to the association to execute repairs, preserving community-wide structural integrity and property values.
  • Petitioner's Counter-Argument on Benefit: Petitioner contended that detached owners receive zero benefit from the $20,049,384 property coverage limit dedicated to attached condo units, pointing to the insurance certificate which expressly states: "There is no residential building coverage for the 19 single family dwellings." He asserted that requiring detached owners to pay for property coverage on structures they cannot inhabit or individually maintain forces an improper cross-subsidization between owner classes.
Theme 3: Statutory Authority vs. Declaration Mandates

The hearing examined the relationship between Arizona state statutes governing condominiums and planned communities and the HOA's internal declaration.

Petitioner invoked A.R.S. § 33-1255(C), arguing that insurance costs benefiting attached units should be charged only to those units. Respondent argued that the petition alleged a violation of Section 7.2.3, not a statutory violation. The written decision records these positions and resolves the pleaded CC&R claim on the evidence (1469008.pdf, pp. 6–8).

  • Application of A.R.S. § 33-1255(C): Petitioner asserted that state law prohibits assessing expenses that benefit fewer than all units against non-benefited units.
  • Respondent’s Argument on Statutory Claims: In closing, Respondent argued that Petitioner had not pleaded violations of A.R.S. § 33-1255(C) or CC&R Section 2.6. The decision records that argument on pages 6–7; its Conclusions of Law find that Petitioner failed to prove the pleaded Section 7.2.3 violation. They do not hold that the CC&Rs override the statute.
Theme 4: Administrative Hearing Dynamics and Burden of Proof
  • Burden of Proof Standard: Pursuant to Arizona Administrative Code (A.A.C.) R2-19-119, the Petitioner carries the burden of proving allegations by a preponderance of the evidence (showing that the allegation is more probably true than not).
  • Pleading Discrepancies and Rebuttal Admissions: In his initial written petition, Schumacher alleged that the "full cost" of insurance was being improperly assessed against detached units. On cross-examination and during rebuttal, Schumacher clarified that he did not mean detached owners paid 100% of the HOA's insurance bill while attached owners paid $0; rather, he meant that detached owners were paying a 1/69th share of the full premium package (including property coverage on attached structures). This clarified the assessment formula. The ALJ ultimately found insufficient evidence of an improper assessment under the pleaded provision; equal assessment itself was undisputed.
  • Procedural Ruling on Directed Verdict: Following Petitioner’s case-in-chief, Respondent’s counsel moved for a Directed Verdict / Judgment as a Matter of Law under Rule 50 of the Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure. ALJ Clark denied the motion, clarifying that civil procedure rules governing directed verdicts do not apply to administrative proceedings where a petitioner has paid a statutory filing fee ($500) to receive a full administrative adjudication.
Theme 5: HOA Governance, Discord, and Democratic Amendment Requirements

Transcripts revealed a long history of community divisiveness regarding common expense allocations.

  • 2022 Allocation Dispute: In early 2022, an owner outcry occurred after the board attempted to reallocate eight categories of common expenses upon receiving an outside legal opinion. Donald Schneider was added to the board specifically to address this discord and liaise with outside counsel (Jason Miller).
  • The CC&R Revision Committee: The HOA formed a committee, chaired by Steven Schumacher, to explore modernizing the 30-year-old declaration. The committee evaluated various proposals, including converting certain common elements into limited common elements (e.g., shifting landscaping responsibility) and altering insurance allocations.
  • Voting Threshold Barriers: Discussions regarding structural changes stalled because converting common elements or reallocating basic assessment formulas requires supermajority owner votes (66 2/3%) or complete approval (100%) under Arizona law and the declaration, particularly if replatting is involved. The committee ultimately abandoned these proposals when owners recognized the voting thresholds were unattainable.

Comprehensive Evidentiary Disclosure Summary

During the September 1, 2026 hearing, the tribunal marked and admitted specific documentary exhibits. Below is the complete record of admitted evidence:

Exhibit IDSource / PresenterDescription & Key ContentsLegal / Evidentiary Significance
Administrative FileOAH / ADREOfficial ADRE File: Petition (Jan 9, 2026), Notice of Petition, Respondent Answer, Notice of Hearing, Continuance Orders.Establishes agency jurisdiction under A.R.S. §§ 32-2199 and 41-1092.
Petitioner Ex. 2Steven SchumacherArdent Insurance Quote & Policy Schedule detail for Policy #N030PK3474-00 (Active Apr 1, 2025 – Apr 1, 2026). Lists 16 buildings; Property value $20,049,384.Used by Petitioner to show breakdown of GL and Property costs between 50 condo units and 19 single-family homes.
Petitioner Ex. 3Steven SchumacherInsurance Breakdown Verification Worksheet from broker Leanne Broom (forwarded by Pam Holloway).Shows broker's premium calculation: $874 total GL/common area for 19 detached homes; $31,925 total GL/Property for 50 attached condos.
Petitioner Ex. 4Steven SchumacherUnofficial Community Newsletter (What's Up on the Ridge, Nov 2025).Mentions a $25,000 insurance deductible for attached unit owners; subject to Respondent's foundation objection.
Respondent Ex. AHOA RespondentSubdivision Plat / Map of The Ridge at Sedona.Confirms physical layout: 69 total units (50 attached, 19 detached).
Respondent Ex. BHOA RespondentAmended & Restated Declaration of CC&Rs (July 26, 1996).Ground truth for CC&R Art. II § 2.5.1, § 2.6; Art. V § 5.1; Art. VII § 7.2.3; Art. VIII § 8.2, § 8.3.
Respondent Ex. DHOA RespondentCertificate of Liability Insurance (Acord, issued June 25, 2025) & Policy Endorsements.Confirms $20,049,384 property limit, $25,000 deductible, single-entity coverage for condos, and 100% guaranteed replacement cost.
Respondent Ex. EHOA RespondentApproved Operating Budget for Fiscal Year 2025–2026.Shows $34,000 total insurance expense included in $286/mo base fee for all 69 units, plus $60/mo attached-only painting reserve.

Important Quotes with Context

1. On Contract Interpretation and Specific vs. General Provisions

Donald F. Schneider (Witness for Respondent): "Article 8 is all about insurance. And Article 8 does not refer back to the first seven articles. There's no reference back to it to tie it in to the more general… and generally my understanding as a lawyer is that typically the more specific provisions govern over the more general provisions when it comes to a particular subject." Context: Delivered during direct examination on September 1, 2026. Schneider explained why Article VIII (Insurance) overrides general assessment language in Article VII, establishing that insurance premiums must be treated as equal common expenses.

2. On Undivided Fractional Ownership of Building Shells

Donald F. Schneider (Witness for Respondent): "My understanding is that the outer shell of the buildings defined as initial cap buildings in the declaration are common elements… Section 2.6 provides that every one of us, every one of the 69 or 70 owners… owns an undivided equal interest in common elements. And so applying it to the buildings for which insurance is obtained, we all have the same interest in the buildings…" Context: Responding to questions regarding CC&R Section 2.5.1 and Section 2.6. Schneider outlined the legal framework establishing that detached owners possess a fractional ownership interest in the physical shells of the condominium structures, justifying an equal 1/69th insurance assessment.

3. On Detached Owners Subsidizing Attached Unit Property Coverage

Steven Schumacher (Petitioner): "Detached units are not benefiting from $20-plus million of property insurance on property we don't own… What we don't own is replacing at guaranteed replacement cost a condominium. And to be paying for that and paying for my own insurance is what I'm contesting… Just follow what's here." Context: Delivered during Petitioner's closing argument on September 1, 2026. Schumacher summarized his core grievance: that detached owners are forced to maintain individual homeowners insurance for their own structures while simultaneously paying a 1/69th share of the master policy covering attached condo structures.

4. On Pleading Inconsistencies and Equal Allocation

Daniel Leffler, Esq. (Counsel for Respondent): "Petitioner needed to establish that the detached unit owners paid for the full cost of insurance for the fiscal year 2025–2026… The notion that insurance was exclusively assessed against attached unit owners is absurd. The claim that section 7.2.3 has been violated by an equal application in assessing insurance equally to all owners is asinine… Section 7.2.3 has nothing to do with insurance." Context: Delivered during Respondent's closing argument. Counsel relied on the equal allocation to argue that Petitioner had not proved his claim. Petitioner clarified that by "full cost" he meant the categories of coverage included in the shared premium, not that detached owners alone paid the entire bill (1469008.pdf, pp. 6–7).

5. On the Tribunal's Final Legal Conclusion

Jenna Clark (Administrative Law Judge): "Both parties are in agreement that all unit owners are assessed equally for insurance, with neither type paying more than the other. There is insufficient evidence in the record to find that the Association unequally or otherwise improperly or unlawfully assessed for common expenses pertaining to the maintenance, repair or replacement of the buildings containing Attached Units to Detached Units… The PETITION must be denied." Context: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law Nos. 7–8 from the formal ALJ Decision issued September 16, 2026. This ruling definitively dismissed all claims against the HOA with prejudice.


What the Written Decision Establishes

  1. The pleaded claim and burden: Petitioner had to prove a violation of CC&R Article VII, Section 7.2.3 by a preponderance of the evidence. The ALJ found that he had not sustained that burden.
  2. The assessment evidence: Both parties agreed that all unit owners were assessed equally for insurance. The ALJ found insufficient evidence of an improper or unlawful assessment for the attached-building maintenance, repair, or replacement expenses addressed by the pleaded provision.
  3. Arguments remain distinct from holdings: Respondent advocated equal insurance allocation under Article VIII and argued that the statutory claim was unpleaded. Those positions should not be recast as an ALJ ruling that insurance provisions always override allocation exceptions or state law.
  4. The result: The petition was denied and dismissed with prejudice. No civil penalties were imposed, and each party was to bear its own preparation and litigation costs.

These conclusions concern this record and the pleaded claim. The decision does not prescribe a universal insurance-allocation formula or an amendment requirement for other disputes (1469008.pdf, pp. 6–9).

Comprehensive Study Guide: Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. (Docket No. 26F-H031-REL)


1. Executive Summary & Key Concepts

Administrative Case Overview

This study guide examines the administrative proceedings before the State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) in the matter of Steven Schumacher (Petitioner) v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. (Respondent), Docket No. 26F-H031-REL.

The dispute centers on whether a homeowners' association (HOA) violated its governing Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) by assessing the premiums for commercial general liability and property building insurance equally across all unit owners (on a 1/69th basis) rather than assessing building property insurance exclusively against attached unit owners (on a 1/50th basis).

“` +———————————————————————–+ | THE RIDGE AT SEDONA HOA | | (69 Units) | +———————————–+———————————–+ | +—————————-+—————————-+ | | v v ATTACHED UNITS DETACHED UNITS

  • 50 Condominiums – 19 Single-Family Residences
  • Housed in 16 Buildings – Independently Owned Lots
  • Outer Shell = Common Element – Self-Insured / Owner Covered
  • Assessed 1/50th for 7.2.3 Expenses – Excluded from 7.2.3 Expenses

“`


Key Entities and Individuals
Entity / PersonRole / Description
Jenna ClarkAdministrative Law Judge (ALJ), Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings.
Steven SchumacherPetitioner; owner of a detached single-family residential property at 56 Ridge Rock Rd., Sedona, AZ 86351.
The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.Respondent; domestic non-profit homeowners' association overseeing a 69-unit hybrid residential development in Sedona, AZ (Hilton Bell Rock subdivision), managed by AAM LLC.
Donald F. SchneiderRespondent's witness; former HOA Board Vice President and Legal Liaison (served early 2022 to mid-2024), former CC&R Revision Committee member, practicing attorney, and owner of 53 Rimtrail Circle (continuously an HOA member since mid-2019).
Daniel Leffler, Esq.Counsel representing Respondent at the September 1, 2026 hearing.
Jill J. Ormond, Esq. & Rebecca L. Donsky, Esq.Counsel of record for Respondent (Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP).
Susan NicolsonCommissioner, Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE).
Tom HazardBoard member / budget witness called by Respondent; excused without testifying after facts were clarified.
Pamela SchumacherObserver present at the hearing.

Governing Legal Framework & Provisions
Arizona Revised Statutes (A.R.S.)
  • A.R.S. § 33-1255(C): Mandates that any common expense or portion thereof benefiting fewer than all units shall be assessed exclusively against the units benefited.
  • A.R.S. § 33-1253: Requires condominium associations to maintain specific property and liability insurance policies.
  • A.R.S. §§ 32-2102 & 32-2199 et seq.: Authorizes the Arizona Department of Real Estate and OAH to receive, hear, and decide dispute petitions between homeowners and HOAs.
CC&Rs of The Ridge at Sedona Association
  • Article II, Section 2.5.1: Defines the outer shell of attached buildings ("initial cap Buildings") as common elements.
  • Article II, Section 2.6 (Allocation of Common Element Interest and Expense Liabilities): Establishes that undivided common element interest and general common expenses are allocated equally among all units (1/69th share, noted historically as 1/70th in text), except for common expenses assessed to less than all units under Sections 7.2.3, 7.2.4, and 7.2.5. Expenses under Section 7.2.3 are allocated equally among attached units at 1/50th each.
  • Article V, Section 5.1 (Duties of the Association): Directs the association to maintain, repair, and replace all common elements as a common expense.
  • Article VII, Section 7.2.3 (Common Expense Assessment): Expressly provides that all common expenses pertaining to the maintenance, repair, or replacement of the buildings containing attached units shall be assessed only against attached units (1/50th share each), and no detached unit shall be assessed for such common expenses.
  • Article VIII, Section 8.2 (Payment of Premiums): Specifies that premiums for all insurance obtained by the association pursuant to Article VIII shall be common expenses and paid for by the association.
  • Article VIII, Section 8.3 (Insurance Obtained by Unit Owners): Clarifies that association insurance does not prevent individual unit owners from obtaining supplemental insurance for their own units and personal liability.

Core Arguments & Legal Interpretations

“ +-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | CENTRAL DISPUTE | +-----------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------+ | PETITIONER'S POSITION (Schumacher) | RESPONDENT'S POSITION (The Ridge HOA) | +-----------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------+ | Insurance covering attached building | Article VIII specifically governs | | structures ($20M+ guaranteed | insurance; Section 8.2 mandates | | replacement cost) benefits attached | premiums are common expenses shared | | units exclusively. | equally (1/69th) by all owners. | | | | | Building repairs/replacements fall | Under Section 2.5.1 & 2.6, building | | under Section 7.2.3; premiums must | outer shells are Common Elements in | | be assessed on a 1/50th basis. | which all 69 owners hold equal | | | undivided ownership interest. | | Assessing detached units (1/69th) | | | violates CC&R 7.2.3 and A.R.S. | Specific provisions (Art. VIII) rule | | § 33-1255(C) by forcing detached | over general provisions; Art. VIII | | owners to subsidize attached owners. | contains no exception for 7.2.3. | +-----------------------------------------+-----------------------------------------+ “


Case Timeline & Procedural History

“ Jan 9, 2026 Feb 3, 2026 Feb 23, 2026 Mar 18, 2026 Apr 21, 2026 Jun 8, 2026 Sep 1, 2026 Sep 16, 2026 +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ | Petition | | Notice of | | Answer | | Notice of | | 1st Order | | Reconsider-| | Cont. OAH | | Final | | Filed by |-->| Petition |->| Filed by |-->| Hearing |-->| Granting |-->| ation/Cont.|-->| Hearing |->| Decision | | Schumacher | | Issued | | HOA | | (Set 4/17) | | Cont. | | Granted | | Conducted | | Issued | | ($500 fee) | | | | (Denial) | | | | (Set 6/11) | | (Set 9/1) | | | | (Dismissed)| +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ +------------+ “

  1. January 9, 2026: Petitioner files an HOA Dispute Process Petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE), tendering a $500 filing fee.
  2. February 3, 2026: ADRE serves Notice of Petition on Respondent.
  3. February 23, 2026: Respondent submits its Answer denying the allegations.
  4. March 18, 2026: ADRE issues a Notice of Hearing scheduling the matter before OAH for April 17, 2026.
  5. April 21, 2026: Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark issues an Order Granting Continuance at Respondent's request, resetting the hearing to June 11, 2026 (Disclosure due June 4, 2026; Subpoena requests due May 27, 2026).
  6. June 3, 2026: ALJ Clark issues an Order Denying Continuance because Respondent failed to identify an unavailable witness, testimony, or emergency.
  7. June 8, 2026: ALJ Clark grants Respondent’s Request for Reconsideration and issues an Order Granting Continuance, resetting the hearing to September 1, 2026 (Disclosure due August 18, 2026; Subpoenas due August 10, 2026).
  8. September 1, 2026: Continued evidentiary hearing held remotely via Google Meet. Evidentiary record closed after witness testimony, exhibit admissions, and closing arguments.
  9. September 16, 2026: ALJ Jenna Clark issues the Administrative Law Judge Decision denying the petition and dismissing it with prejudice.

2. Short-Answer Practice Questions

Question 1

What specific CC&R section was alleged in Steven Schumacher’s petition to have been violated by The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc., and what relief was requested?

Answer: Petitioner alleged a single violation of CC&R Article VII, Section 7.2.3. He alleged that the HOA improperly assessed detached unit owners for insurance premiums protecting attached unit buildings starting in fiscal year 2025–2026. He requested an administrative order directing Respondent to abide by the referenced CC&R provisions when allocating insurance assessments. He did not request civil penalties.


Question 2

How does the composition of units at The Ridge at Sedona affect the allocation of common expenses under CC&R Article II, Section 2.6, and Article VII, Section 7.2.3?

Answer: The community consists of 69 total units: 19 detached units (single-family residential lots) and 50 attached units (condominiums located across 16 buildings). Under Section 2.6, general common expenses are shared equally among all units on a 1/69th share basis. However, expenses governed by Section 7.2.3—which covers maintenance, repair, or replacement of buildings containing attached units—are allocated exclusively to attached units on a 1/50th share basis.


Question 3

What argument did Respondent's witness Donald F. Schneider make regarding contract interpretation when contrasting Article VII and Article VIII of the CC&Rs?

Answer: Schneider testified that under standard legal principles of contract interpretation, specific provisions govern over general provisions. He noted that the first seven articles deal with general community matters without specifying insurance expenses, whereas Article VIII is specifically dedicated to insurance. Because Article VIII, Section 8.2 dictates that all insurance premiums obtained by the association are common expenses and contains no cross-reference or exception tying back to Article VII or Section 7.2.3, insurance must be shared equally among all 69 unit owners.


Question 4

Why did ALJ Clark deny Respondent’s initial Motion for Continuance on June 3, 2026?

Answer: The motion was denied for lack of good cause because Respondent failed to identify the unavailable witness, the nature of their proposed testimony, or the specific nature of the emergency preventing their attendance. (The continuance was subsequently granted on June 8, 2026, upon Respondent's Request for Reconsideration).


Question 5

What evidence did Petitioner introduce regarding the breakdown of insurance premiums from the HOA's insurance broker?

Answer: Petitioner introduced Exhibit 3 (a worksheet verification from insurance broker Leanne Broom provided by Pam Holloway), which broke down the total premium ($32,787). The breakdown allocated $874 across the 19 detached homes for general liability/common areas, $1,752 for condo general liability across 50 units, and $30,171 for property coverage on $19,884,384 of condo building values across the 50 attached units. Petitioner argued this proved the insurance broker explicitly calculated structural building insurance exclusively for attached units.


Question 6

What was the Respondent’s legal argument regarding unit ownership boundaries under CC&R Section 2.5.1 and Section 2.6?

Answer: Respondent argued that under Section 2.5.1, the outer shell of attached buildings is classified as a common element. Section 2.6 provides that all 69 unit owners hold an undivided equal interest in all common elements. Because every detached owner (including Petitioner) holds a 1/69th interest in these common element outer shells, insuring those shells protects a common asset in which all owners share ownership, justifying an equal 1/69th assessment for insurance premiums.


Question 7

What procedural evidentiary rule did ALJ Clark invoke regarding non-party witness appearances during the administrative hearing?

Answer: ALJ Clark ordered that all non-party witnesses were required to appear remotely via Google Meet, and that parties were required to mark proposed exhibits using numbers for Petitioner, letters for Respondent, and employ Bates Stamps on all submitted exhibit pages.


Question 8

Why did Respondent's counsel move for a directed verdict under Rule 50 of the Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure during the September 1, 2026 hearing, and how did the ALJ rule?

Answer: Respondent’s counsel moved for a directed verdict arguing that Petitioner admitted under cross-examination that insurance premiums were assessed equally (1/69th) to all owners, contradicting his written petition's claim that detached owners paid the "full cost." ALJ Clark denied the motion, stating that Rule 50 of the Rules of Civil Procedure is inapplicable to administrative proceedings, particularly where the petitioner paid a statutory fee ($500) to receive a full administrative adjudication on the merits.


Question 9

What role did Exhibit 4 ("What’s Up on the Ridge" newsletter) play in the hearing, and what objection was raised against it?

Answer: Petitioner used Exhibit 4 (a November 2025 community newsletter) to show that attached unit owners were advised of a new $25,000 policy deductible for water leaks and structural repairs, arguing it proved structural coverage applied only to attached units. Respondent’s counsel objected on foundation grounds because the document was an unsanctioned, unofficial publication created by an anonymous volunteer owner rather than an official board document. The ALJ admitted the document over objection, noting it would be given appropriate weight.


Question 10

What was the ultimate ruling of Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark in the Final Order issued September 16, 2026?

Answer: ALJ Clark ruled that Petitioner failed to sustain his burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that Respondent violated CC&R Article VII, Section 7.2.3. She noted that both parties agreed the owners were assessed equally, but found insufficient evidence of an improper or unlawful assessment under the pleaded provision (1469008.pdf, p. 8). The petition was denied and dismissed with prejudice, no civil penalties were levied, and each party was ordered to bear its own litigation costs.


3. Essay Prompts for Deeper Exploration

Essay Prompt 1: Rules of Contract Interpretation in Community Association Governance

Prompt: Analyze the competing principles of contract interpretation presented by Petitioner and Respondent in Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. Compare Petitioner's argument—that specific cost-allocation rules (Article VII, Section 7.2.3) and statutory mandates (A.R.S. § 33-1255(C)) supersede general insurance definitions—against Respondent’s argument that specific subject-matter articles (Article VIII, Section 8.2) govern without implicit exceptions. Distinguish those arguments from the ALJ’s narrower finding that Petitioner had not proved a violation of Section 7.2.3. Identify what the written decision does and does not decide (1469008.pdf, pp. 6–8).


Essay Prompt 2: Harmonizing State Condominium Statutes with Governing Documents

Prompt: A.R.S. § 33-1255(C) provides that common expenses benefiting fewer than all units must be assessed exclusively against the units benefited, while A.R.S. § 33-1253 requires HOAs to maintain master insurance coverage. Discuss how property rights, common element definitions (CC&R Section 2.5.1), and undivided percentage interests (CC&R Section 2.6) intersect with statutory requirements when determining whether property building insurance on multi-family attached units constitutes a general common expense or a restricted common expense.


Essay Prompt 3: Evidentiary Burdens and Procedural Mechanics in Administrative Hearings

Prompt: Examine the procedural lifecycle of an HOA dispute before the Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings as illustrated in this case. Detail the significance of pleading specificity, the burden of proof under Arizona Administrative Code R2-19-119, the inadmissibility of civil procedure motions (such as Rule 50 directed verdicts), and the impact of cross-examination admissions when an administrative tribunal evaluates whether a violation of governing documents occurred.


4. Glossary of Important Terms

  • Administrative Law Judge (ALJ): An independent judicial officer who presides over administrative hearings, evaluates evidence, questions witnesses, and issues binding decisions or recommendations to state agencies (e.g., ALJ Jenna Clark).
  • Arizona Department of Real Estate (ADRE): The state administrative agency authorized under A.R.S. §§ 32-2102 and 32-2199 et seq. to regulate real estate and receive HOA dispute petitions.
  • Attached Units: Condominium residences (units 13 through 62 at The Ridge at Sedona, total 50 units) housed within 16 multi-unit building structures, where outer building shells are defined as common elements.
  • Bates Stamps: A standardized method of numbering legal and evidentiary document pages sequentially (e.g., required for exhibit submissions in OAH proceedings).
  • CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions): The recorded governing declaration that creates an enforceable legal contract between a homeowners' association and property owners, establishing rights, obligations, and assessment structures.
  • Common Elements: Portions of a real estate development owned collectively by all unit owners as undivided percentage interests (e.g., 1/69th interest in building outer shells, gates, and shared grounds under Section 2.5.1 and 2.6).
  • Common Expenses: Operating costs incurred by an HOA to maintain, operate, or insure common elements, allocated among owners as general assessments or special/restricted assessments.
  • Detached Units: Single-family residential lots (units 1 through 12 and 63 through 69 at The Ridge at Sedona, total 19 units) whose owners independently own and insure their entire structural dwellings.
  • Dismissal with Prejudice: A final judicial or administrative determination denying a claim on its merits, prohibiting the petitioner from re-filing the same claim in future proceedings.
  • Limited Common Elements: Common elements reserved for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, unit owners (e.g., specific patios, balconies, or assigned spaces).
  • Preponderance of the Evidence: The standard of proof required in administrative civil proceedings (A.A.C. R2-19-119), defined as evidence proving that a contention is more probably true than not.
  • Replatting: The formal legal process of altering recorded subdivision maps or property boundaries, which under Arizona statute requires a supermajority vote (66 2/3%) of property owners.
  • Single Entity Coverage: Insurance coverage maintained by an HOA covering building structures ("walls-in") excluding tenant/owner improvements and betterments inside individual condominium units.
  • Supermajority Vote: A heightened voting threshold (e.g., two-thirds or 66 2/3% of members) required by CC&Rs or state statute to amend declarations or modify property plats.

HOA Insurance Battles: Understanding CC&R Interpretation and Assessment Allocations in Hybrid Communities

1. Introduction: The High Stakes of HOA Assessment Disputes

Managing assessment allocations in a hybrid homeowners association (HOA)—a community that combines both detached single-family dwellings and attached condominium units—presents one of the most complex governance challenges in real estate law. Because structural footprints, exterior maintenance needs, and property insurance liabilities differ significantly between standalone homes and shared multi-unit buildings, boards and owners frequently clash over what constitutes an association-wide common expense versus a localized expense benefiting only a subset of owners.

"The central conflict in hybrid HOA governance lies in balancing standard equal assessment rules against the equitable allocation of expenses that benefit specific unit types."

This tension reached a legal head in an administrative case heard before Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark of the Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH), operating on behalf of the Arizona Department of Real Estate: Steven Schumacher v. The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. (Case No. 26F-H031-REL). The dispute offers a masterclass in contractual interpretation, statutory application under Arizona HOA law, and the strict evidentiary standards required when challenging community association assessment practices.


2. Breakdown of the Dispute: Detached vs. Attached Units

The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc. is a residential development located in Sedona, Arizona, comprising 69 total units. The community structure is divided into two distinct unit classifications:

  • 19 Detached Units: Independently owned residential lots and standalone single-family dwellings (Units 1–12 and 63–69).
  • 50 Attached Units: Condominiums housed across 16 multi-unit association buildings (Units 13–62).

On January 9, 2026, Petitioner Steven Schumacher, an owner of a detached residential lot at 56 Ridge Rock Road, filed a formal petition with the Arizona Department of Real Estate, paying a $500 filing fee. Schumacher challenged the association’s fiscal year 2025–2026 operating budget, which set total property and casualty insurance expenses at $34,000.

Schumacher alleged that the association improperly assessed the full cost of master property insurance—which specifically provides structural coverage and guaranteed replacement for the 16 attached condominium buildings—equally across all 69 unit owners (a 1/69th split per unit), rather than charging the structural property coverage exclusively to the 50 attached condominium owners (a 1/50th split).

Community Structure & Unit Characteristics
Unit ClassificationKey Attributes & Insurance/Maintenance Allocation Arguments
Detached Units
(19 Single-Family Lots)
• Independently owned lots and standalone structural dwellings.
• Owners carry individual homeowner property insurance for their standalone residential structures.
• Argued that paying a 1/69th share of the master policy forces them to subsidize structural replacement insurance for buildings they do not own and receive no direct structural benefit from.
Attached Condominiums
(50 Units across 16 Buildings)
• Units housed within 16 multi-family building shells.
• Outer building shells are defined as Common Elements under Section 2.5.1 of the CC&Rs.
• Receive direct coverage under the association's master insurance policy (including 100% guaranteed replacement cost). Pay an additional $60/month dedicated reserve fee exclusively for exterior painting.

3. The Legal Tug-of-War: Article VII vs. Article VIII of the CC&Rs

The legal controversy presented during the September 1, 2026 hearing focused on contractual interpretation, specifically contrasting general assessment exceptions against specialized insurance mandates within the association’s Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs).

CC&R Framework Conflict Article VII (Section 7.2.3 – General Assessment Exceptions): Dictates that expenses pertaining to maintenance, repair, or replacement of buildings containing attached units shall be assessed exclusively against attached units on a 1/50th share. VS. * Article VIII (Section 8.2 – Payment of Premiums): States that premiums for insurance obtained under that article are common expenses paid by the association. Section 8.2 itself does not specify equal shares for individual owners; the association advocated that allocation using the governing documents as a whole (1469008.pdf, pp. 4, 6).

Opposing Legal Theories
  • Petitioner's Argument (Section 7.2.3 & Special Assessment): Petitioner Schumacher argued that CC&R Article VII, Section 7.2.3 explicitly commands that all common expenses pertaining to the "maintenance, repair or replacement of the Buildings containing the Attached Units" must be assessed exclusively against attached units on a 1/50th basis. Supporting his argument with A.R.S. § 33-1255(C)—which mandates that any common expense benefiting fewer than all units shall be assessed exclusively against the units benefited—Schumacher contended that detached owners were improperly forced to subsidize a policy carrying $20,049,384 in total insured property value. This figure includes $19,884,384 dedicated strictly to the 50 attached condominium units with 100% guaranteed replacement coverage, while the remaining $165,000 accounts for shared common elements (such as entry gates and common structures) shared across all 69 owners. Schumacher argued that detached owners derive no structural benefit from the condominium building coverage.
  • Respondent's Defense (Article VIII & Specific Governance): Respondent, represented by legal counsel Daniel Leffler and backed by testimony from former board member Donald Schneider, relied on Article VIII, Section 8.2 of the CC&Rs. Section 8.2 explicitly provides that "premiums for all insurance obtained by the Association pursuant to this Article shall be Common Expenses and shall be paid for by the Association." Defense counsel demonstrated that under Section 2.5.1, the outer building shells of the attached structures are defined as common elements, and under Section 2.6, all 69 owners hold an undivided, equal interest in all common elements. Respondent asserted the established legal doctrine that specific contractual provisions (Article VIII governing Insurance) supersede general assessment rules (Article VII), noting that Article VIII contains no language referencing back to Article VII exceptions.

4. Hearing Highlights: Cross-Examination and Budgetary Controversies

During cross-examination, Petitioner Schumacher questioned former Board Vice President Donald Schneider, highlighting a key community budget operational discrepancy: why the association separates exterior painting costs from full building replacement property insurance premiums.

Painting Maintenance (Article V/VII) vs. Property Insurance Premiums (Article VIII)
Governance & Financial CategoryExterior Painting Maintenance (Article V/VII)Property Insurance Premiums (Article VIII)
Governing CC&R ProvisionArticle V (Section 5.1) & Article VII (Section 7.2.3)Article VIII (Sections 8.1 & 8.2)
Budgeted Allocation MethodAssessed exclusively to Attached Units ($60/month reserve fee per attached unit).Assessed equally across all 69 Units (1/69th share embedded in the $286/month base fee).
Petitioner's PositionDemonstrates the HOA recognizes attached outer shells require specialized assessment tracks under Section 7.2.3.Argued replacement insurance falls under "repair and replacement" of building shells, requiring an identical attached-only assessment track.
Respondent's PositionSpecific maintenance/painting operational item governed by general association duties under Article V.Governed strictly and independently by Article VIII, which mandates all insurance premiums are common expenses shared equally.
Tactical Defense Strategy and Procedural Rulings
  1. Respondent's Rule 50 Motion for Directed Verdict: Following Petitioner's testimony, defense counsel Daniel Leffler moved for a directed verdict under Rule 50 of the Arizona Rules of Civil Procedure. Counsel argued that because Schumacher conceded during cross-examination that insurance premiums were allocated equally on a 1/69th basis among all 69 owners, he directly disproved his own petition's literal pleading, which alleged that detached owners paid the "full cost" (100%) of the policy. Defense counsel asserted that Schumacher was using the tribunal to force a contractual reallocation that requires a supermajority membership vote rather than proving an actual CC&R violation. ALJ Jenna Clark denied the motion, explaining as a matter of procedure that Rule 50 directed verdicts are inapplicable to administrative tribunal proceedings where a petitioner has paid the statutory filing fee to receive an adjudication on the merits.
  2. Handling of Evidentiary Issues:
  • Petitioner's Exhibit 3 (Insurance Broker Worksheet): Prepared by insurance broker Leanne Broom, this document detailed the premium calculation ($30,171 for condo property insurance; $1,752 for condo general liability; $874 for home general liability). It was admitted into evidence without objection to establish the premium breakdown.
  • Petitioner's Exhibit 4 (Community Newsletter): An unsanctioned owner newsletter titled What's Up on the Ridge discussing a $25,000 policy deductible for attached units. Respondent raised a foundational objection because the author was anonymous and unverified. ALJ Clark overruled the objection, admitting the document while noting it would only receive appropriate evidentiary weight.

5. The ALJ’s Decision

On September 16, 2026, Administrative Law Judge Jenna Clark denied the petition and dismissed it with prejudice. She found that Schumacher had not proved the alleged violation of CC&R Article VII, Section 7.2.3 by a preponderance of the evidence.

Case ParameterWritten Decision
Final Case OutcomePetition denied and dismissed with prejudice
Pleaded CC&R ViolationArticle VII, Section 7.2.3 — not established by the evidence
Assessment EvidenceBoth parties agreed that all owners were assessed equally for insurance
Reason for DenialInsufficient evidence of an improper or unlawful assessment under the pleaded provision
Civil Penalties & CostsNo civil penalties; each party bears its own preparation and litigation costs
Reading the Result in Context

The parties advanced different interpretations of the declaration. The association relied on Article VIII and common-element ownership to defend equal insurance assessments; Schumacher relied on the allocation exception in Section 7.2.3 and invoked A.R.S. § 33-1255(C). The written decision records Respondent’s unpleaded-claim argument as a closing argument, not as a holding that the declaration overrides the statute.

The ALJ’s stated reason for denial was the failure of proof on this record. The result does not establish that insurance expenses must always be divided equally, that an insurance article always overrides other provisions, or that a formal amendment is the only possible route to a different allocation. The distinction between each party’s argument and the tribunal’s actual findings matters when reading this case (1469008.pdf, pp. 6–9).

Case Participants

Petitioner Side

  • Steven Schumacher (Petitioner)
  • Pamela Schumacher (Observer)

Respondent Side

  • Daniel Leffler (Counsel for Respondent)
  • Donald Schneider (Witness)
    The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.
  • Jill J. Ormond (Counsel for Respondent)
    Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP
  • Rebecca L. Donsky (Counsel for Respondent)
    Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP
  • Tom Hazard (Potential Witness)
    The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.
  • Pam Holloway (Potential Witness)
    The Ridge at Sedona Association of Homeowners, Inc.
  • Jason Miller (Attorney)

Neutral Parties

  • Jenna Clark (Administrative Law Judge)
    Office of Administrative Hearings
  • Susan Nicolson (Commissioner)
    Arizona Department of Real Estate

Other Participants

  • Leanne Broom (Insurance Broker)
  • Larry Cobasol (Insurance Broker)