Author Archives: AZ HOA Watch

SHAW & LINES LLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side petitioner

Total Cases 1

Total Issues 1

Win Rate 0.0%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with SHAW & LINES LLC

• Augustus H. Shaw IV

Associations Represented

• Oak Creek Knolls Property Owners Association Inc (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

Renting Or Leasing Less Than The Entire Residential Property Unit Violation Of 'residential Use' Provisions Concerning Single Family Definition. (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

3 Superior Court cases on record for Shaw & Lines, LLC. Select a linked case number to view the first-party public-record detail page when available.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
CV2011-001892	1/21/2011	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2010-029712	10/28/2010	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV2009-030859	10/1/2009	Civil	Party – Defendant

Compiled from public records. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Goldschmidt, Shupe, PLLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 1

Total Issues 1

Win Rate 100.0%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Goldschmidt, Shupe, PLLC

• Carolyn B. Goldschmidt

Associations Represented

• Saddlebrooke Home Owners Association 1 Inc (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

Violation Of Website And Policy Manual Policy Bc-3 (1 cases)

Phillips, Maceyko & Battock, PLLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 3

Total Issues 4

Win Rate 75.0%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Phillips, Maceyko & Battock, PLLC

• Emily H. Mann

Associations Represented

• Fulton Ranch Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Hilton Casitas Council Of Homeowners (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1250 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)Article Iii 3 Of The Bylaws Of Hilton Casitas Council Of Co-owners (1 cases)Whether The Board's Adoption Of The Rules And Regulations In August 2016 Violated 23.9 Of The Declaration CC&Rss . (1 cases)Whether The Petitioner's Breach Of Contract Claim Is Barred By The Six-year Statute Of Limitations. (1 cases)

Childers Hanlon & Hudson, PLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 4

Total Issues 4

Win Rate 75.0%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Childers Hanlon & Hudson, PLC

• Christopher Hanlon
• Michael S. Mcleran

Associations Represented

• Cimmarron Superstition Hoa (1 cases)
• Los Reyes Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• The Village At Elk Run Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Rovey Farm Estates Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1819 (1 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)Article 4 4.1 Of The Community's CC&Rss (1 cases)Burke Versus Voiceream Wireless Corporation 2 2007 Arizona 393 Quarter Of Appeal 2004 (1 cases)CC&Rss Article 2 3.2 3.3 And 3.11 (1 cases)CC&Rss Article 6.2 (1 cases)CC&Rss Article 9.4 (1 cases)CC&Rss Article Viii 8.8 (1 cases)Failure To Meet Required Burden Of Proof (1 cases)Pal Versus Washburn 211 Arizona 553 2006 (1 cases)

Stratman Law Firm, PLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 6

Total Issues 6

Win Rate 100.0%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Stratman Law Firm, PLC

• Troy B. Stratman

Associations Represented

• Cottonfields Community Association (2 cases)
• Silverton II Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Whisper Mountain Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Montelena Master Community Association (1 cases)
• Desert Oasis Of Surprise Master Association (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1806 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-442 (1 cases)CC&Rss 14.2 (1 cases)CC&Rss 3.2 And 7.7 (1 cases)CC&Rss 4.1.1 (1 cases)Declaration 12.1 (1 cases)Declaration 14.2 (1 cases)Design Guidelines (1 cases)Rema Article 12 (1 cases)Rema Article 5 5.1 Article 12 (1 cases)Tierra Ranchos Homeowners Ass'n V Kitchukov 216 Ariz. 173 165 P.3d 173 App. 2007 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

1 Superior Court case on record for Stratman Law Firm, PLC. Select a linked case number to view the first-party public-record detail page when available.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
CV2021-012606	8/10/2021	Civil	Party – Defendant

Compiled from public records. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Dessaules Law Group

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side petitioner, respondent

Total Cases 7

Total Issues 9

Win Rate 88.9%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Dessaules Law Group

• Jacob A. Kubert
• Jake Kubert
• Jonathan A. Dessaules

Associations Represented

• Cortez Canyon Unit Owners Association (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 12-548 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1243 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)Article Iv 3 (1 cases)Article Vii Paragraph 2 (1 cases)Association Bylaws Article Iii (1 cases)Association Bylaws Article Iii 3 & 4 (1 cases)Association Bylaws Article Viii 1 (1 cases)CC&Rs Article 2 3 A 2 (1 cases)CC&Rs Article 3 3 D 1 (1 cases)CC&Rs Article 6 2 A (1 cases)CC&Rs Article 6 5 (1 cases)CC&Rs Article 7 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 12.2 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 14.2 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 15.2b (1 cases)

Smith & Wamsley, PLLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 6

Total Issues 9

Win Rate 55.6%

Penalties Against $500

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Smith & Wamsley, PLLC

• Jason E. Smith
• Sean K. Moynihan

Associations Represented

• Moonrise At Starr Pass Community Association (1 cases)
• High Lonesome Ranch Estates Property Owners Association (1 cases)
• Verde Meadows Crest Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• The Foothills Homeowners Association 1 (1 cases)
• Tucson Estate No Two Owners Association (1 cases)
• Agua Dulce Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 10-11601 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1202 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1243 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1250 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1813 (1 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)ARIZ. REV. STAT. §32- 2199.02(A) (1 cases)Bylaws Article 10 (1 cases)CC&Rs 5.4 (1 cases)Declaration 12.b (1 cases)Finance Committee Rules (1 cases)Hlr Ccr 6.2.1 (1 cases)Hlr Ccr 6.2.1 And Hlr Association Rules Nominating And Election Committee Mission And Procedures Approved 19 July 2021 (1 cases)Nominating And Elections Committee Mission And Procedures (1 cases)Whether The Notice Should Be Considered 'sent' On The Date It Was Stamped By A Private Meter June 23 Or The Date It Was Postmarked By The Usps June 24 . (1 cases)

Farley Choate Law

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 5

Total Issues 8

Win Rate 87.5%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Farley Choate Law

• John T. Crotty
• Jonathan Crotty
• Kelsey Dressen
• Maria R. Kupillas

Associations Represented

• Saguaro Crest Homeowners Association Inc (2 cases)
• Will Rogers Equestrian Ranch (1 cases)
• Lakeshore At Andersen Springs Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• The Boulders At La Reserve Condominium Association (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 10-3821 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1242 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1804 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1243 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1260.01 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)Architectural Design Guidelines 4.0 (1 cases)CC&Rs 6.2 A (1 cases)CC&Rs 7.2 (1 cases)CC&Rss 5 (1 cases)CC&Rss 7.21 (1 cases)CC&Rss 7.3 (1 cases)

Jones, Skelton & Hochuli, PLC

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side respondent

Total Cases 11

Total Issues 12

Win Rate 50.0%

Penalties Against $200

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Jones, Skelton & Hochuli, PLC

• David Onuschak
• Diana J. Elston
• Erik J. Stone
• Gary Linder
• J. Gary Linder
• Keith D. Collett
• Matthew G. Hayes
• Samuel E. Arrowsmith
• Steven D. Leach

Associations Represented

• Crossings At Willow Creek Property Owners Association (1 cases)
• Greenfield Village Rv Resort Association Inc (1 cases)
• Carriage Manor Rv Resort Association Inc (1 cases)
• Camelback Country Club Estates I And II Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Cedar Ridge Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Civano 1 Neighborhood 1 Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• La Vida Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• The Villages At Aviano Condominium Association (1 cases)
• Casas Arroyo Association Inc (1 cases)
• Pinecrest Lake Property Owners Association Inc (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

20 (2 cases)4 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)12 (1 cases)15 (1 cases)16 (1 cases)17 (1 cases)18 (1 cases)19 (1 cases)21 (1 cases)22 (1 cases)24 (1 cases)3 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1812 (1 cases)Bylaws 6.4 (1 cases)Bylaws 6.4 10.2 (1 cases)Bylaws Article Iv 5 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 12.2 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 14.2 (1 cases)CC&Rs's 15.2b (1 cases)CC&Rss 12 (1 cases)CC&Rss 3.25 6.4 B (1 cases)CC&Rss 6.4 6.5 (1 cases)CC&Rss 8 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

29 Superior Court cases on record for Jones, Skelton & Hochuli, PLC. Select a linked case number to view the first-party public-record detail page when available.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
CV2024-037171	12/20/2024	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2024-033800	11/22/2024	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2021-001280	1/25/2021	Civil	Party
CV2019-094307	11/27/2018	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2013-000741	1/22/2013	Civil	Party
CV2011-055131	12/30/2011	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2010-091813	7/29/2010	Civil	Party – Defendant
TJ2009-013008	8/13/2009	Transcript Judgment	Party
CV2009-032282	10/23/2009	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2008-027176	10/29/2008	Civil	Party
TJ2007-008625	10/17/2007	Transcript Judgment	Party
CV2004-007697	4/19/2004	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2002-012315	6/26/2002	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2001-018143	10/17/2001	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2000-018975	10/18/2000	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1999-017944	10/6/1999	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1999-010992	6/18/1999	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1998-093152	12/30/1998	Civil	Party
CV1997-014865	8/11/1997	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV1996-017794	10/3/1996	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1996-015270	8/27/1996	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1995-021414	12/27/1995	Civil	Party – Counter Defendent
CV1995-012995	8/10/1995	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV1995-001447	1/26/1995	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1995-000082	1/5/1995	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV1994-001764	2/7/1994	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
TJ1993-000134	1/13/1993	Transcript Judgment	Party – Plaintiff
CV1993-025220	11/23/1993	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV1993-016199	7/16/1993	Civil	Party – Defendant

Compiled from public records. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Goodman Law Group

Posted on October 10, 2025 by AZ HOA Watch

Side petitioner, respondent

Total Cases 16

Total Issues 16

Win Rate 81.2%

Penalties Against None

Attorney Count 0

Attorneys Affiliated with Goodman Law Group

• Ashley N. Turner
• Clint G. Goodman
• Daniel S. Francom
• Danny M. Ford
• Erica L. Mortenson
• Jason E. Smith

Associations Represented

• Paradise Park Condominiums Phase II Homeowners Association (3 cases)
• Long Meadow Ranch East Property Owners Association Inc (1 cases)
• The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (1 cases)
• Rancho Del Lago Community Association (1 cases)
• Circle G Ranches 4 Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Tempe Villages Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Foothills Townhomes Association Inc (1 cases)
• The Camelview Greens Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Tonto Forest Estates Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Artesian Ranch Community Association (1 cases)
• Coronado Ranch Community Association (1 cases)
• The Concorde Condominium Home Owners Association (1 cases)
• Keystone Owners Association (1 cases)
• Tatum Highlands Community Association Inc (1 cases)

Cases Handled

All Cases Issue Wins Issue Losses Cases with Penalties

Violations Involved

A.R.S. § 33-1803 (5 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (5 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1804 (4 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1801 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1243 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1248 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1261 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1810 (1 cases)A.R.S. § 33-1811 (1 cases)Article Ii 3 Of Respondent's Bylaws (1 cases)Article Iii 3.10 CC&Rss (1 cases)Article Iv 4.6 CC&Rss (1 cases)Board Meeting Held On 9/22/2022 Organized By The HOA Manager Who Was Allegedly Not Authorized To Call A Board Meeting. (1 cases)Bylaws Article 4 1 (1 cases)CC&Rs 4.32 (1 cases)CC&Rss 3.11 D 1 / Common Project Guidelines 3.11 D 1 (1 cases)Community Bylaws 3.03 (1 cases)Failure To Elect Officers In An Exclusively And Timely Scheduled Organizational Meeting. (1 cases)Keystone CC&Rss Art. V Sec. 5.19 (1 cases)Mountain Park Association CC&Rss Art. Iv Sec. 2 (1 cases)Muting The Opposing Side During The Zoom Open Board Meeting On October 24 2022. (1 cases)Prohibiting The Recording Of The Open Session On October 24 2022. (1 cases)Violation Of Bylaws Article Ii Paragraph 2.3 For Failing To Hold The Annual Meeting As Required In April 2022. (1 cases)