Category Archives: Attorneys

Individual attorney profiles and performance metrics

Michael S. Shupe

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Goldschmidt Shupe, PLLC

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Issues
3

Issue Wins
2

Issue Losses
1

Issue Win Rate
66.7%

Associations Represented

• San Ignacio Heights Inc (1 cases)
• Catalina Ridge Community Association Inc (1 cases)
• Quail Creek Villas Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 1

Cases Handled

• 21F-H2120005-REL: Donald S Fern & Judith A. Hedges, Petitioner, vs. San Ignacio Heights, Inc., Respondent.
• 22F-H2222040-REL: Steven J. Schmidt v. Catalina Ridge Community Association, Inc.
• 23F-H042-REL: Quail Creek Villas Association, Inc. vs. Randall & Gisela White

Violations Handled

CC&Rs Article Vi D (1 cases)
Whether The Association Violated CC&Rss Article 7 7 By Incorrectly Applying The Method For Determining The Allowable Square Footage Of An Accessory Structure Detached Garage . (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
CC&Rss 3 J (1 cases)

Bradley R. Jardine

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Jardine, Baker, Hickman, & Houston, PLLC

Side
respondent

Total Issues
4

Issue Wins
3

Issue Losses
1

Issue Win Rate
75.0%

Associations Represented

• The Lakeshore Village Condo Association Inc (2 cases)
• Sandpiper Scottsdale Association Inc (1 cases)
• Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 4
Issues Won: 3
Issues Lost: 1

Cases Handled

• 17F-H1716004-REL-RHG: Brian Sopatyk vs. The Lakeshore Village Condo. Association, Inc.
• 17f-H1716004-REL: Brian Sopatyk vs. The Lakeshore Village Condo. Association, Inc.
• 19F-H1919048-REL: Peter de Scheel vs. Sandpiper Scottsdale Association, Inc.
• 19F-H1919065-REL: Jason West, Petitioner, vs. Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association, Respondent

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1260 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1242 (2 cases)
Article Vi 1 C (1 cases)
Article V 1 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
Bylaw 2.2 (1 cases)
Bylaw 1.5 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

6 Superior Court cases on record for Bradley R. Jardine. Select a case number to view public case details when available or the official court record.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
1 CA-CV 21-0676	2022-12-08	appellate_opinion	Counsel – Co-Counsel for Plaintiffs/Appellants
1 CA-CV 21-0524	2022-08-30	appellate_opinion	Counsel – Co-Counsel for Plaintiffs/Appellants/Cross-Appellees
CV2007-002983	2/16/2007	Civil	Party – Endorsement Case
CV2003-019886	10/17/2003	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV1999-003772	3/3/1999	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV1996-090006	1/3/1996	Civil	Party – Defendant

Auto-compiled from public records, pending verification. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. Always verify against the official court record. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Mark E. Lines

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Shaw & Lines, LLC

Side
respondent

Total Issues
2

Issue Wins
2

Issue Losses
0

Issue Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Bridgewood Nine 30 Property Owners Association Inc Aka Bridgewood Townhomes (1 cases)
• University Shadows Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 2
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 18F-H1818028-REL: Debbie Westerman v. Bridgewood Nine 30 Property Owners Association, Inc. aka Bridgewood Townhomes
• 25F-H099-REL: Ann Galpin v. University Shadows Homeowners Association, Inc.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
CC&Rs 5 G (1 cases)
CC&Rs 5 J (1 cases)
CC&Rs 7 B (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)

Mackenzie Hill

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Brown Law Group

Side
respondent

Total Issues
3

Issue Wins
1

Issue Losses
2

Issue Win Rate
33.3%

Associations Represented

• Olive 66 Condominium Association (1 cases)
• Rancho Del Lago Community Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 1
Issues Lost: 2

Cases Handled

• 21F-H2121059-REL: Jeffrey D Points, Petitioner, vs. Olive 66 Condominium Association, Respondent.
• 22F-H2221019-REL: Brenda C Norman, Petitioner, vs. Rancho Del Lago Community Association, Respondent.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
3.1 D 3 Of The CC&Rss (1 cases)

Beth Mulcahy

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Mulcahy Law Firm, P.C.

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Issues
9

Issue Wins
6

Issue Losses
3

Issue Win Rate
66.7%

Associations Represented

• Eagle Mountain Community Association (2 cases)
• Casa Campa Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Villas On North Mountain Condominium (1 cases)
• Clearwater Farms Estates (1 cases)
• Gainey Ranch Community Association And Pavilions Council Of Co Owners (1 cases)
• Scottsdale Embassy Condominium Association (1 cases)
• Deer Valley Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Wintergardens Co Operative (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 9
Issues Won: 6
Issues Lost: 3

Cases Handled

• 07F-H067010-BFS: Steven Hedden and Paul Ryan v. Eagle Mountain Community Association
• 07F-H067011-BFS: Steven Hedden and Paul Ryan vs. Eagle Mountain Community Association
• 07F-H067024-BFS: Ray Carnes v. Casa Campa Homeowners Association
• 08F-H088001-BFS: LEE DRAPER vs. VILLAS ON NORTH MOUNTAIN CONDOMINIUM
• 08F-H089015-BFS: Carl A. Sawicki vs. Clearwater Farms Estates
• 15F-H1516009-BFS: Gainey Ranch Community Association, and Pavilions Council of Co-Owners vs MS Pavillions 35 LLC
• 21F-H2120028-REL-RHG: Lee & Kim Edwards, PETITIONERS, vs. Scottsdale Embassy Condominium Association, RESPONDENT.
• 23F-H003-REL: Matthew E Thompson vs. Deer Valley Homeowners Association Inc.
• 23F-H059-REL: Charlotte Tande vs. Wintergardens Co-Operative

Violations Handled

CC&Rss 11.2 (2 cases)
CC&Rss 11.4 (2 cases)
Technical Violations Of The Documents Governing The Association (1 cases)
Declaration Of Covenants Conditions And Restrictions (1 cases)
Article Iv Paragraph 5 (1 cases)
Article X Paragraph 3 (1 cases)
Article Viii 5 A (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1255 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Art. Vi Sec. 9 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article Vi 9 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Art. Iv Sec. 1 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 7.3 (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Articles 1.16 6.2 2.3 7.1 7.3 (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1 And 7.2 (1 cases)
Sun City West Dec CC&Rss Article 4.2 F (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.2 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 2.3 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 6.2 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 1.16 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 7.1 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1810 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

7 Superior Court cases on record for Beth Mulcahy. Select a case number to view public case details when available or the official court record.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
CV2025-060700	11/6/2025	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2020-006339	6/1/2020	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2015-053962	9/4/2015	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2013-015763	11/22/2013	Civil	Party – Counter Defendant
1 CA-CV 00-0570	2003-02-18	appellate_opinion	Counsel – Plaintiff-Appellant (Association)
CV1998-011697	6/26/1998	Civil	Party – Third Party Defendant
CV1993-009410	6/14/1993	Civil	Party – Defendant

Auto-compiled from public records, pending verification. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. Always verify against the official court record. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Augustus H. Shaw IV

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Shaw & Lines, LLC

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Issues
4

Issue Wins
2

Issue Losses
2

Issue Win Rate
50.0%

Associations Represented

• Cortina Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Carter Ranch Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Oak Creek Knolls Property Owners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Millett Ranch Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 4
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 2

Cases Handled

• 13F-H1314001-BFS: ALEXANDER WINTER vs CORTINA HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION
• 19F-H1919071-REL-RHG: Thomas J Van Dan Elzen, Petitioner, vs. Carter Ranch Homeowners Association, Respondent.
• 22F-H2222039-REL: Oak Creek Knolls Property Owners Association, Inc. vs Kim M. Grill
• 24F-H035-REL: Jesse Freeman v. Millett Ranch Homeowners’ Association

Violations Handled

A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 44-401 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1808 (1 cases)
Renting Or Leasing Less Than The Entire Residential Property Unit Violation Of ‘residential Use’ Provisions Concerning Single Family Definition. (1 cases)
Title 33 Chapter 16 Article 1 (1 cases)
Bylaws Article Ii 8 As Amended October 18 2000 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

4 Superior Court cases on record for Augustus H. Shaw IV. Select a case number to view public case details when available or the official court record.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
1 CA-CV 17-0543	2018-07-10	appellate_opinion	Counsel – Defendants/Appellees
CV2010-029712	10/28/2010	Civil	Party – Plaintiff
CV2010-017915	6/10/2010	Civil	Party – Defendant
CV2006-007891	5/25/2006	Civil	Party – Defendant

Auto-compiled from public records, pending verification. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. Always verify against the official court record. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Edward D. O’Brien

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
CHDB Law LLP

Side
respondent

Total Issues
4

Issue Wins
4

Issue Losses
0

Issue Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Rancho Madera Condominium Association (2 cases)
• La Barranca II Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Forest Trails Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 4
Issues Won: 4
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 19F-H1918010-REL-RHG: John A. Sellers, vs. Rancho Madera Condominium Association
• 19F-H1919066-REL: John A Sellers vs. Rancho Madera Condominium Association
• 20F-H2019020-REL: Rick and Lisa Holly, Petitioners, vs. La Barranca II Homeowners Association, Respondent.
• 22F-H2221026-REL: Judy Clapp v. Forest Trails Homeowners Association

Violations Handled

CC&Rss 3.10 3.10.2 3.10.4 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1817 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
CC&Rs Article 11.2.5 (1 cases)
CC&Rs Article 12 (1 cases)
CC&Rs Article 4.7 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1811 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Articles 11.3 And 12 (1 cases)
CC&Rs Article 11.3 (1 cases)
Declaration 4.1 (1 cases)
Architectural Guidelines (1 cases)
Declaration 2.2 (1 cases)
Declaration 2.21 (1 cases)
Declaration 3.4 (1 cases)

Timothy D. Butterfield

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
CHDB Law LLP

Side
respondent

Total Issues
3

Issue Wins
2

Issue Losses
1

Issue Win Rate
66.7%

Associations Represented

• Greenlaw Townhouses Unit Two Hoa (1 cases)
• Hidden Valley Association (1 cases)
• Silverbell West Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 1

Cases Handled

• 19F-H1918019-REL-RHG: William P. Lee, Petitioner, vs. Greenlaw Townhouses Unit Two Homeowners Association, Respondent.
• 21F-H2120006-REL: Douglas E Kupel, Petitioner, vs. Hidden Valley Association, Respondent.
• 21F-H2120011-REL: Thomas A & Jade Bossert, Petitioner, vs. Silverbell West Association, Inc., Respondent.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Amendments 1 2 & 3 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1809 (1 cases)
Greenlaw Rules And Regulations (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1243 (1 cases)

Carolyn B. Goldschmidt

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Goldschmidt | Shupe LLC

Side
respondent

Total Issues
10

Issue Wins
10

Issue Losses
0

Issue Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Tucson Estates Property Owners Association Inc (2 cases)
• Champagne Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Sycamore Hills Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Saddlebrooke Home Owners Association 1 Inc (1 cases)
• Colonia Del Rey Hoa Inc (1 cases)
• Ventana Shadows Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Quail Creek Villas Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 10
Issues Won: 10
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 07F-H067021-BFS: CATHERINE CRANDALL vs. CHAMPAGNE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
• 07F-H067022-BFS: Fred T. Neumann vs. Tucson Estates Property Owners Association, Inc.
• 07F-H067028-BFS: LAURA FREY vs. TUCSON ESTATES PROPERTY OWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC.
• 08F-H088008-BFS: John F. and Patricia E. Monahan vs. Sycamore Hills Homeowners Association, Inc.
• 19F-H1918022-REL-RHG: Tom J Martin, Petitioner, vs. SaddleBrooke Home Owners Association #1, Inc., Respondent
• 19F-H1919054-REL: Gregory L. Czekaj v. Colonia Del Rey HOA, Inc.
• 22F-H2222044-REL: David G. Iadevavia vs. Ventana Shadows Homeowners Association, Inc.
• 23F-H004-REL: Randall White, Petitioner, vs. Quail Creek Villas Association Inc., Respondent.

Violations Handled

6 (2 cases)
7 (2 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (2 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)
CC&Rs Article Viii 6 (1 cases)
14 (1 cases)
Article Iv 2 (1 cases)
10 (1 cases)
CC&Rs Article Viii 2 (1 cases)
13 (1 cases)
9 (1 cases)
Fcc Regulations (1 cases)
Article Iv 1 (1 cases)
12 (1 cases)
11 (1 cases)
8 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 10-3801 (1 cases)
Tepoa Bylaws Article V (1 cases)
Neighbor Built Fence Blocking View/value Without Approval (1 cases)
Declarations 8.3.1 (1 cases)
40 (1 cases)
5 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article Ix 6 26 (1 cases)

Superior Court Litigation

1 Superior Court case on record for Carolyn B. Goldschmidt. Select a case number to view public case details when available or the official court record.

Case Number	Filed	Type	Role in Case
2 CA-CV 2012-0129	2013-03-12	appellate_opinion	Counsel – appellee

Auto-compiled from public records, pending verification. Cases are matched to this page by name — different people or organizations may share the same or a similar name, so the matters listed may be incomplete or may not all involve the entity named above. This listing is general information only; it is not legal advice and is not a definitive or official record of any party’s litigation history. Always verify against the official court record. To report an inaccuracy or request removal, contact the site administrator.

Stewart F. Salwin

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
CHDB Law LLP

Side
respondent

Total Issues
3

Issue Wins
3

Issue Losses
0

Issue Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Lakeside Ski Village Hoa (1 cases)
• Blackstone At Vistancia Community Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 3
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 17F-H1716031-REL: Jason West, Petitioner, Vs. Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association, Respondent.
• 17F-H1717027-REL: Mark Virden vs. Lakeside Ski Village HOA
• 18F-H1817002-REL: Brian C. Herbert, Petitioner v. Blackstone at Vistancia Community Association, Respondent

Violations Handled

Bylaw 3.6 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1811 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
The Parties Reached A Settlement Resulting In A Motion To Vacate The Hearing On The Merits. (1 cases)