Question

What is the burden of proof for a homeowner challenging an HOA's architectural decision?

Short Answer

The homeowner must prove by a 'preponderance of the evidence' that the HOA violated its governing documents.

Detailed Answer

In an administrative hearing regarding an HOA dispute, the petitioner (homeowner) bears the burden of proof. They must demonstrate that it is more probable than not that the Association or its Committee violated specific provisions of the governing documents (such as Design Guidelines).

Alj Quote

Petitioners bear the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that, as alleged, Association through actions of Committee had violated Guidelines Section 1, Items 1 and 32 requirements and Section 5, Item 12 requirements when Committee granted a variance…1

Legal Basis

A.A.C. R2-19-119

Topic Tags

• burden of proof
• legal standards
• evidence

Question

What does 'preponderance of the evidence' mean in an HOA hearing?

Short Answer

It means evidence that is more convincing than the opposing evidence, showing the fact is 'more probable than not.'

Detailed Answer

The ALJ defines this legal standard as evidence that carries greater weight than the evidence offered in opposition. It does not require absolute certainty, but rather that the fact sought to be proved is more probable than not.

Alj Quote

A preponderance of the evidence is “[e]vidence which is of greater weight or more convincing than the evidence which is offered in opposition to it; that is, evidence which as a whole shows that the fact sought to be proved is more probable than not.”2

Legal Basis

Black's Law Dictionary (6th ed. 1990)

Topic Tags

• legal definitions
• standards of evidence

Question

Can my HOA grant a neighbor a variance for construction setbacks?

Short Answer

Yes, if the governing documents grant the Design Review Committee discretion to deviate from requirements in extenuating circumstances.

Detailed Answer

If the Design Guidelines provide the Committee with discretion to deviate from requirements when following them would create an unreasonable hardship or burden, the HOA can validly grant a variance. The ALJ looks for whether the Committee exercised 'reasonable discretion' under this authority.

Alj Quote

The Administrative Law Judge concludes that the hearing record demonstrates that Committee exercised reasonable discretion under its authority to grant… a Section 5, Item 12 deviation, i.e., a variance… to allow the proposed/approved secondary improvements to be placed within the 15’ side-yard setback.3

Legal Basis

Design Guidelines Section 5, Item 12

Topic Tags

• variances
• setbacks
• HOA discretion
• architectural review

Question

Can the HOA treat driveways and landscaping differently than main house structures regarding setbacks?

Short Answer

Yes, governing documents may allow 'modifications' for secondary improvements even if structures have strict setbacks.

Detailed Answer

Governing documents may distinguish between 'building structures' (which must strictly comply with setbacks) and 'secondary improvements' like driveways, grading, or site walls. The documents may allow modifications to setbacks for these secondary items on a case-by-case basis.

Alj Quote

All building Structures shall comply with the above outlined setback distances. Modifications to the above outlined setback distances will be considered on a case-by-case basis for secondary improvements such as grading, landscaping, driveways, site walls, etc.4

Legal Basis

Design Guidelines Section 1, Item 32

Topic Tags

• setbacks
• driveways
• landscaping
• architectural guidelines

Question

What qualifies as an 'unreasonable hardship' that justifies a variance?

Short Answer

Practical necessities, such as needing access to a garage that otherwise complies with setbacks, can be considered an extenuating circumstance.

Detailed Answer

In this case, the Committee determined that needing driveway access to a new garage (which itself was built within the allowable building envelope) constituted an 'extenuating circumstance.' This practical necessity justified granting a variance for the driveway and grading to encroach into the setback area.

Alj Quote

The hearing record demonstrates that… Association supported the Committee’s determination that needing access to the new RV garage which itself was being built within the building envelope… met the criteria of “extenuating” circumstances… for purposes of granting a “variance” for the new driveway to be placed and necessary grading to occur within the 15’ side-yard setback.5

Legal Basis

Design Guidelines Section 5, Item 12

Topic Tags

• hardship
• variances
• construction

Question

If I lose my case against the HOA, do I get my filing fee back?

Short Answer

No, if the petition is dismissed, the homeowner is typically ordered to bear the cost of the filing fee.

Detailed Answer

The ALJ has the authority to order who pays the costs. In this decision, after dismissing the petition because the homeowners failed to prove a violation, the ALJ ordered the homeowners to pay their own filing fee.

Alj Quote

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Petitioners bears their $500.00 filing fee.6

Legal Basis

Administrative Order

Topic Tags

• fees
• penalties
• costs