Question

Can my HOA ban chickens even if I consider them household pets?

Short Answer

Yes. If the CC&Rs explicitly ban 'fowl' or 'poultry,' your subjective belief that they are pets does not override the objective ban.

Detailed Answer

The ALJ determined that even if a homeowner views chickens as pets akin to parakeets, if the CC&Rs explicitly ban 'fowl' or 'poultry,' that ban is enforceable. The specific classification of the animal in the documents overrides the owner's usage of the animal as a pet.

Alj Quote

Petitioner subjectively believes her chickens are pets and therefore qualify for the pet exception of the animal policy; however the CC&Rs plain language objectively bans not only birds but fowl. Chickens are both birds and fowl therefore, homeowners may not have live chickens on their property.

Legal Basis

CC&Rs § 3.3

Topic Tags

• animals
• chickens
• CC&Rs interpretation
• violations

Question

Can my HOA charge me for the cost of sending certified letters regarding a violation?

Short Answer

Not unless the CC&Rs explicitly authorize passing those specific administrative costs to the homeowner.

Detailed Answer

The ALJ ruled that an HOA cannot arbitrarily pass on administrative costs, such as certified mail fees for violation notices, unless the governing documents specifically empower them to do so. In this case, the HOA was ordered to remove the charge.

Alj Quote

Respondent failed to establish their CC&Rs empower them to forward the cost of litigation onto Petitioner prior to the completion of hearing. Therefore, Petitioner established Respondent violated CC&Rs § 5.1 and ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 33-1803

Legal Basis

CC&Rs § 5.1; A.R.S. § 33-1803

Topic Tags

• fines
• fees
• administrative costs
• certified mail

Question

Is my HOA required to go to mediation before enforcing a rule violation?

Short Answer

It depends on the specific language of the dispute resolution clause. Some clauses only apply to disputes with the developer (Declarant), not general homeowner enforcement.

Detailed Answer

The homeowner argued that a 'Dispute Notification and Resolution Procedure' required mediation. However, the ALJ found that the specific section cited applied only to 'Declarant Parties' (the developer/builders) regarding construction or design defects, not to standard enforcement actions between the HOA and a homeowner.

Alj Quote

The CC&Rs § 9.15 restricts its application to disputes involving the Declarant Parties, particularly those arising from or related to construction defects or conditions of the Project and not homeowner disputes. Because Petitioner is not a Declarant Party CC&Rs § 9.15 does not apply.

Legal Basis

CC&Rs § 9.15

Topic Tags

• mediation
• dispute resolution
• procedure
• declarant

Question

Who has the burden of proof when a homeowner challenges an HOA violation?

Short Answer

The homeowner (Petitioner) bears the burden of proving the HOA violated the governing documents or statutes.

Detailed Answer

In an administrative hearing where the homeowner files the petition, the homeowner must prove their case by a 'preponderance of the evidence,' meaning their evidence must be more convincing than the HOA's.

Alj Quote

In this proceeding, Petitioner bears the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that Respondent violated CC&Rs § 3.3, CC&Rs § 9.15, CC&Rs § 5.1 and ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 33-1803.

Legal Basis

Standard of Proof

Topic Tags

• legal standards
• burden of proof
• hearings

Question

If I win part of my case against the HOA, can I get my filing fees reimbursed?

Short Answer

The ALJ may order partial reimbursement of filing fees if the petition is granted in part.

Detailed Answer

In this case, the homeowner lost the argument regarding chickens but won the argument regarding improper fees for certified letters. Consequently, the ALJ ordered the HOA to reimburse $500 of the $1500 filing fee.

Alj Quote

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED Respondent is ordered to pay Petitioner $500.00 of her $1500.00 filing fee within 30 days of the mailing date of the Administrative Law Judge Decision entered in this matter.

Legal Basis

ALJ Order

Topic Tags

• remedies
• filing fees
• penalties

Question

Does an exception for 'household birds' in the CC&Rs allow me to keep chickens?

Short Answer

Likely not, if chickens are also defined as 'fowl' which are otherwise banned.

Detailed Answer

The ALJ rejected the argument that chickens fell under the exception for 'parakeets or similar household birds,' finding instead that they fell under the explicit ban on 'fowl.'

Alj Quote

Notwithstanding Petitioner’s argument that her chickens are akin to parakeets, an exception to the no animal rule in the CC&Rs, birds and fowl are explicitly banned.

Legal Basis

CC&Rs § 3.3

Topic Tags

• animals
• CC&Rs interpretation
• exceptions