Question

Who is responsible for proving that a violation occurred in an HOA dispute hearing?

Short Answer

The Petitioner (the person filing the complaint) bears the burden of proof.

Detailed Answer

In an administrative hearing regarding an HOA dispute, the burden is not on the HOA to prove they are innocent. Instead, the homeowner filing the petition must prove that the HOA committed the violation.

Alj Quote

Petitioner bears the burden of proof to establish that Respondent committed the alleged violation by a preponderance of the evidence.

Legal Basis

ARIZ. REV. STAT. section 41-1092.07(G)(2); A.A.C. R2-19-119(A) and (B)(1)

Topic Tags

• Burden of Proof
• Hearing Procedures

Question

What is the legal standard of proof required to win a hearing against an HOA?

Short Answer

Preponderance of the evidence.

Detailed Answer

This standard means that the evidence must show that the claim is more likely true than not true. It is based on the convincing force of the evidence rather than just the number of witnesses.

Alj Quote

“A preponderance of the evidence is such proof as convinces the trier of fact that the contention is more probably true than not.”

Legal Basis

Morris K. Udall, Arizona Law of Evidence § 5 (1960)

Topic Tags

• Legal Standards
• Evidence

Question

If Association Rules conflict with the CC&Rs (Declaration), which document controls?

Short Answer

The Declaration (CC&Rs) prevails.

Detailed Answer

The governing documents usually establish a hierarchy. If the Board adopts rules that are inconsistent with the recorded Declaration, the Declaration is the superior document.

Alj Quote

In the event of any conflict or inconsistency between the provisions of this Declaration and the Association Rules, the provisions of this Declaration shall prevail.

Legal Basis

CC&Rs Article 4 Section 4.3

Topic Tags

• Governing Documents
• Rules vs CC&Rs

Question

Is an HOA obligated to provide a unique gate access code to every individual owner?

Short Answer

Not necessarily, if access is provided to the Lot.

Detailed Answer

If the HOA provides valid methods of access for a Lot (such as a shared code, key fob, or remote), they may not be legally obligated to provide a specific 'personal' code for each individual owner of that Lot.

Alj Quote

Petitioner did not establish that Respondent is obligated to provide her with a “personal” or “individual” access code.

Legal Basis

Findings of Fact / Conclusions of Law 4

Topic Tags

• Access Rights
• Gate Codes
• Security

Question

Can the Administrative Law Judge resolve disputes between co-owners regarding access to the property?

Short Answer

No, disputes between co-owners are personal matters.

Detailed Answer

If one co-owner restricts another co-owner from using a shared access code, the Department of Real Estate views this as a private issue between the owners, not a violation by the HOA.

Alj Quote

Mr. Gribble, as co-owner, has placed restrictions upon Petitioner’s use of the code for the Lot. That is an issue for Petitioner to take up with Mr. Gribble, not the Department.

Legal Basis

Conclusions of Law 4

Topic Tags

• Co-owner Disputes
• Jurisdiction

Question

Are Association Rules as enforceable as the CC&Rs?

Short Answer

Yes, generally rules are enforceable to the same extent as the Declaration.

Detailed Answer

Once validly adopted, Association Rules regarding the management and operation of the community can be enforced just like the recorded covenants.

Alj Quote

The Association Rules shall be enforceable in the same manner and to the same extent as the covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in this Declaration.

Legal Basis

CC&Rs Article 4 Section 4.3

Topic Tags

• Enforcement
• Rules