Arizona HOA Transparency Project

Holding HOA Boards, Attorneys, and Management Companies Accountable

Arizona HOA Transparency Project

Maricopa County Superior Court Case CV2000-012470

Case Header

Maricopa County Superior Court Case CV2000-012470: public docket details, parties, minute entries, documents, and official source links for Palm Valley Community Association.

Case Number
CV2000-012470
County
Maricopa
Caption
Not captured
Filed
7/3/2000
Case Type
Civil
Judge
Whitten, Christopher
Location
Downtown
Official Court Record
Official Court Record

Parties

Party Relationship Attorney
Charolett D Kindred Defendant GERALD SHELLEY
Osei Tutu Defendant Pro Per
Palm Valley Community Association Plaintiff Scott Carpenter

Minute Entries

03/20/2002 — CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 03/20/2002 JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES View Minute Entry ↑ top

Source
Minute Source
SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 03/22/2002
03/20/2002
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES
J. Stobierski
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 049
Page 1
FILED: _________________
PALM VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION
SCOTT CARPENTER
v.
CHAROLETT D KINDRED, et al.
GERALD L SHELLEY
OSEI TUTU
13756 W CAMBRIDGE AVE
GOODYEAR AZ 85338-0000
MINUTE ENTRY
The Court having received and considered Plaintiff’s Motion
to Amend Judgment, no response having been received,
IT IS ORDERED granting same.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED approving and settling the formal
written Amended Judgment and Decree of Foreclosure and Order of
Sale signed by the Court on March 19, 2002 and filed (entered)
by the clerk on March 20, 2002.

04/16/2001 — CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 04/16/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry ↑ top

Source
Minute Source
SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 04/23/2001
04/16/2001
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
HON. PAUL A KATZ
L. Falkenburg
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 020
Page 1
FILED: _________________
PALM VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION
SCOTT CARPENTER
v.
CHAROLETT D KINDRED, et al.
GERALD L SHELLEY
JUDGMENT
AND
UNDER ADVISEMENT
3:08 p.m. This is the time set for oral argument on
Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment (Breach of Contract
and Judicial Lien Foreclosure). Plaintiff is represented by
counsel, Scott Carpenter. Defendants are represented by
counsel, Gerald L. Shelley. Defendant, Charolett D. Kindred is
present.
Court Reporter, Bethany Block, is present.
Oral argument is presented.
THE COURT FINDS the Plaintiff is entitled to judgment, on
Count 2, for $2,338.50, the sum total for assessments, late fees
and fines that are due and owing from the Defendants.
IT IS ORDERED taking the matter of awarding attorneys’ fees
under advisement.

SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 04/23/2001
04/16/2001
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
HON. PAUL A KATZ
L. Falkenburg
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 020
Page 2
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that a proposed form of judgment, in
which the Plaintiff shall delineate the assessments by year,
total amount of late fees and fines, be filed with this Court.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED allowing Plaintiff until 5:00 p.m.
on Friday, April 20, 2001 to file an application for attorneys’
fees, with any supporting affidavits or memoranda.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Defendant shall have until
May 1, 2001 to file any objection to the proposed form of
judgment and any controverting documentation with respect to the
application for attorneys’ fees.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all pleadings and documents
shall be hand-delivered or telefaxed to opposing counsel on the
date they are filed with the court.
3:42 p.m. Matter concludes.

05/16/2002 — CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 05/16/2002 JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES View Minute Entry ↑ top

Source
Minute Source
SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 05/23/2002
05/16/2002
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES
J. Stobierski
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 025
Page 1
FILED: _________________
PALM VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION
SCOTT CARPENTER
v.
CHAROLETT D KINDRED, et al.
GERALD L SHELLEY
OSEI TUTU
13756 W CAMBRIDGE AVE
GOODYEAR AZ 85338-0000
MINUTE ENTRY
Let the record reflect that due to the fact that
Plaintiff’s original “Amended Judgment and Decree of Foreclosure
and Order of Sale” cannot be located by the Clerk’s Office, the
Court has signed a copy of said judgment on May 9, 2002 and same
has been termed a duplicate original and hand-filed by the clerk
on May 10, 2002.
Let the record further reflect that a certified copy of
said judgment has been provided to Plaintiff’s counsel.

06/04/2001 — CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 06/04/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry ↑ top

Source
Minute Source
SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 06/15/2001
06/04/2001
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
HON. PAUL A KATZ
B. Navarro
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 019
Page 1
FILED: _________________
PALM VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION
SCOTT CARPENTER
v.
CHAROLETT D KINDRED, et al.
GERALD L SHELLEY
UNDER ADVISEMENT RULING
The Court having taken Plaintiff's Application in Support of
Attorneys' Fees and Costs under advisement; and good cause
appearing,
IT IS ORDERED awarding Plaintiff costs in an amount of
$370.87 and reasonable attorneys' fees in the amount of
$5,000.00.

08/21/2001 — CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 08/21/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry ↑ top

Source
Minute Source
SUPERIOR COURT OF ARIZONA *** FILED ***
MARICOPA COUNTY 08/28/2001
08/21/2001
CLERK OF THE COURT
FORM V000A
HON. PAUL A KATZ
B. Navarro
Deputy
CV 2000-012470
Docket Code 049
Page 1
FILED: _________________
PALM VALLEY COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION
SCOTT CARPENTER
v.
CHAROLETT D KINDRED, et al.
GERALD L SHELLEY
OSEI TUTU
13756 W CAMBRIDGE AVE
GOODYEAR AZ 85338-0000
JUDGMENT SIGNED
IT IS ORDERED that judgment be entered in favor of Plaintiff
and against the Defendants, Charlotte D. Kindred and Parties-in-
Possession I-V, all in accordance with the formal written Judgment
and Decree of Foreclosure and Order of Sale signed by the Court
August 20, 2001, and filed (entered) by the Clerk August 21, 2001.

Documents

Type Title Content Type Size Source
minute_entry_pdf CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 03/20/2002 JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES View Minute Entry application/pdf 3.2 KB Document Source
minute_entry_pdf CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 04/16/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry application/pdf 6.0 KB Document Source
minute_entry_pdf CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 05/16/2002 JUDGE PENDLETON GAINES View Minute Entry application/pdf 3.3 KB Document Source
minute_entry_pdf CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 06/04/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry application/pdf 4.4 KB Document Source
minute_entry_pdf CV2000012470 KINDRED, CHAROLETT D 08/21/2001 HON. PAUL A KATZ View Minute Entry application/pdf 4.5 KB Document Source

Auto-compiled from public records, pending verification

Review the official court record for the current docket.

To request a correction or removal, contact the site administrator.