Category Archives: Attorneys

Individual attorney profiles and performance metrics

Melissa Doolan

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
The Travis Law Firm, PLC

Side
respondent

Total Cases
2

Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Stetson Valley Owners Association (1 cases)
• The Cliffs Condominium Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 2
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 23F-H008-REL: Amy Hilburn, Petitioner v. Stetson Valley Owners Association, Respondent
• 23F-H010-REL: In the Matter of Richard Busack vs The Cliffs Condominium Association

Violations Handled

A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
Article 6.2 Of The Bylaws (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
Article Iii 3.07 Of The Declaration Of Establishment Of Condominium And Of Declaration Of Covenants Conditions And Restrictions For The Cliffs Condominium (1 cases)
Article Iii 3.07 CC&Rss (1 cases)

Wendy Ehrlich

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm

Side
respondent

Total Cases
2

Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Rancho Reyes II Community Association Inc (1 cases)
• Prince Court Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 2
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 20F-H2019032-REL-RHG: John R Ashley, Petitioner, vs. Rancho Reyes II Community Association, Inc., Respondent.
• 25F-H032-REL: Anne F. Segal, Petitioner, vs. Prince Court Homeowners Association, Inc., Respondent.

Violations Handled

Bylaws Article Iii 4 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article Vii (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1812 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 10-3704 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1817 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)

Michael S. Shupe

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Goldschmidt Shupe, PLLC

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Cases
3

Win Rate
66.7%

Associations Represented

• San Ignacio Heights Inc (1 cases)
• Catalina Ridge Community Association Inc (1 cases)
• Quail Creek Villas Association Inc (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 1

Cases Handled

• 21F-H2120005-REL: Donald S Fern & Judith A. Hedges, Petitioner, vs. San Ignacio Heights, Inc., Respondent.
• 22F-H2222040-REL: Steven Schmidt, Petitioner, vs. Catalina Ridge Community Association, Inc., Respondent.
• 23F-H042-REL: Quail Creek Villas Association, Inc. vs. Randall & Gisela White

Violations Handled

CC&Rs Article Vi D (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article 7.6 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article I 15 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article 7.7 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
CC&Rss 3 J (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)

Mark E. Lines

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Shaw & Lines, LLC

Side
respondent

Total Cases
3

Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Camelback Garden Farms Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Bridgewood Nine 30 Property Owners Association Inc Aka Bridgewood Townhomes (1 cases)
• Bridgewood Nine 30 Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 6
Issues Won: 6
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 16F-H1616009-BFS: Kristi Hillebrand vs Camelback Garden Farms Homeowners Association
• 18F-H1818028-REL: Debbie Westerman v. Bridgewood Nine 30 Property Owners Association, Inc. aka Bridgewood Townhomes
• 25F-H029-REL: Debbie Westerman, Petitioner, v. Bridgewood Nine 30 Homeowners Association, Respondent.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1805 (2 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
CC&Rss (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1812 (1 cases)
CC&Rs 7 B (1 cases)
CC&Rs 5 J (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
CC&Rs 5 G (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)

Bradley R. Jardine

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Jardine, Baker, Hickman, & Houston, PLLC

Side
respondent

Total Cases
4

Win Rate
75.0%

Associations Represented

• The Lakeshore Village Condo Association Inc (2 cases)
• Sandpiper Scottsdale Association Inc (1 cases)
• Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 4
Issues Won: 3
Issues Lost: 1

Cases Handled

• 17F-H1716004-REL-RHG: Brian Sopatyk vs. The Lakeshore Village Condo. Association, Inc.
• 17f-H1716004-REL: Brian Sopatyk vs. The Lakeshore Village Condo. Association, Inc.
• 19F-H1919048-REL: Peter de Scheel vs. Sandpiper Scottsdale Association, Inc.
• 19F-H1919065-REL: Jason West, Petitioner, vs. Desert Sage Two Homeowners Association, Respondent

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1242 (2 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1260 (2 cases)
Article Vi 1 C (1 cases)
Article V 1 (1 cases)
Bylaw 2.2 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
Bylaw 1.5 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)

James Robles

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Perry, Childers, Hanlon & Hudson, PLC

Side
respondent

Total Cases
3

Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• Green Valley Country Club Vistas II Poa (3 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 17F-H1716018-REL: Thomas Satterlee, Petitioner, vs. Green Valley Country Club Vistas II Property Owners Association Respondent.
• 17F-H1716022-REL-RHG: Thomas Satterlee v. Green Valley Country Club Vistas II Property Owners’ Association
• 18F-H1817022-REL-RHG: Thomas P. Satterlee vs. Green Valley Country Club Vistas II Property Owner's Association

Violations Handled

N/a – Jurisdictional Dismissal (1 cases)
N/A (1 cases)
Whether Respondent Met The Definition Of A ‘planned Community’ By Having A ‘covenant To Maintain Roadways’ That Would Grant Jurisdiction To The Adre. (1 cases)

Mackenzie Hill

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Brown Law Group

Side
respondent

Total Cases
2

Win Rate
33.3%

Associations Represented

• Olive 66 Condominium Association (1 cases)
• Rancho Del Lago Community Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 3
Issues Won: 1
Issues Lost: 2

Cases Handled

• 21F-H2121059-REL: Jeffrey D Points, Petitioner, vs. Olive 66 Condominium Association, Respondent.
• 22F-H2221019-REL: Brenda C Norman, Petitioner, vs. Rancho Del Lago Community Association, Respondent.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1258 (1 cases)
3.1 D 3 Of The CC&Rss (1 cases)

Beth Mulcahy

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Mulcahy Law Firm, PC

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Cases
9

Win Rate
70.0%

Associations Represented

• Eagle Mountain Community Association (2 cases)
• Casa Campa Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Villas On North Mountain Condominium (1 cases)
• Clearwater Farms Estates (1 cases)
• Gainey Ranch Community Association And Pavilions Council Of Co Owners (1 cases)
• Scottsdale Embassy Condominium Association (1 cases)
• Deer Valley Homeowners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Wintergardens Co Operative (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 10
Issues Won: 7
Issues Lost: 3

Cases Handled

• 07F-H067010-BFS: Steven Hedden and Paul Ryan v. Eagle Mountain Community Association
• 07F-H067011-BFS: Steven Hedden and Paul Ryan vs. Eagle Mountain Community Association
• 07F-H067024-BFS: Ray Carnes v. Casa Campa Homeowners Association
• 08F-H088001-BFS: LEE DRAPER vs. VILLAS ON NORTH MOUNTAIN CONDOMINIUM
• 08F-H089015-BFS: Carl A. Sawicki vs. Clearwater Farms Estates
• 15F-H1516009-BFS: Gainey Ranch Community Association, and Pavilions Council of Co-Owners vs MS Pavillions 35 LLC
• 21F-H2120028-REL-RHG: Lee & Kim Edwards, PETITIONERS, vs. Scottsdale Embassy Condominium Association, RESPONDENT.
• 23F-H003-REL: Matthew E Thompson vs. Deer Valley Homeowners Association Inc.
• 23F-H059-REL: Charlotte Tande vs. Wintergardens Co-Operative

Violations Handled

CC&Rss 11.2 (2 cases)
CC&Rss 11.4 (2 cases)
Technical Violations Of The Documents Governing The Association (1 cases)
Declaration Of Covenants Conditions And Restrictions (1 cases)
Article X Paragraph 3 (1 cases)
Article Iv Paragraph 5 (1 cases)
Article Viii 5 A (1 cases)
CC&Rss Article Vi 9 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1255 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Art. Iv Sec. 1 (1 cases)
CC&Rss Art. Vi Sec. 9 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 7.3 (1 cases)
Sun City West Dec CC&Rss Article 4.2 F (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 6.2 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Articles 1.16 6.2 2.3 7.1 7.3 (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 2.3 (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.2 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 7.1 (1 cases)
Deer Valley CC&Rss Article 1.16 (1 cases)
Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1 And 7.2 (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1810 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)

Augustus H. Shaw IV

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Shaw & Lines, LLC

Side
petitioner, respondent

Total Cases
4

Win Rate
50.0%

Associations Represented

• Cortina Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Carter Ranch Homeowners Association (1 cases)
• Oak Creek Knolls Property Owners Association Inc (1 cases)
• Millett Ranch Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 4
Issues Won: 2
Issues Lost: 2

Cases Handled

• 13F-H1314001-BFS: ALEXANDER WINTER vs CORTINA HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION
• 19F-H1919071-REL-RHG: Thomas J Van Dan Elzen, Petitioner, vs. Carter Ranch Homeowners Association, Respondent.
• 22F-H2222039-REL: Oak Creek Knolls Property Owners Association, Inc. vs Kim M. Grill
• 24F-H035-REL: Jesse Freeman v. Millett Ranch Homeowners’ Association

Violations Handled

A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 44-401 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1805 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1808 (1 cases)
Renting Or Leasing Less Than The Entire Residential Property Unit Violation Of ‘residential Use’ Provisions Concerning Single Family Definition. (1 cases)
Title 33 Chapter 16 Article 1 (1 cases)
Bylaws Article Ii 8 As Amended October 18 2000 (1 cases)

Clint Goodman

Posted on October 9, 2025 by [email protected]

Law Firm
Goodman Law Group

Side
respondent

Total Cases
2

Win Rate
100.0%

Associations Represented

• The Val Vista Lakes Community Association (1 cases)
• Circle G Ranches 4 Homeowners Association (1 cases)

Issues Breakdown

All Issues: 5
Issues Won: 5
Issues Lost: 0

Cases Handled

• 19F-H1918029-REL: Nathan Brown, Petitioner, vs. Val Vista Lakes Community Association, Respondent.
• 21F-H2120022-REL: Darryl Jacobson-Barnes & Robert Barnes, Petitioner, vs. Circle G Ranches 4 Homeowners Association, Respondent.

Violations Handled

A.R.S. § 33-1803 (2 cases)
Article Iv 4.6 CC&Rss (1 cases)
Article Iii 3.10 CC&Rss (1 cases)
A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
A.R.S. § 33-1811 (1 cases)